A review on RF ESD protection design

Radio frequency (RF) electrostatic discharge (ESD) protection design emerges as a new challenge to RF integrated circuits (IC) design, where the main problem is associated with the complex interactions between the ESD protection network and the core RFIC circuit being protected. This paper reviews recent development in RF ESD protection circuit design, including mis-triggering of RF ESD protection structures, ESD-induced parasitic effects on RFIC performance, RF ESD protection solutions, as well as characterization of RF ESD protection circuits.     

ESD–RF co-design methodology for the state of the art RF-CMOS blocks

This paper describes an approach to design ESD protection for integrated low noise amplifier (LNA) circuits used in narrowband transceiver front-ends. The RF constraints on the implementation of ESD protection devices are relaxed by co-designing the RF and the ESD blocks, considering them as one single circuit to optimise. The method is applied for the design of 0.25 μm CMOS LNA. Circuit protection levels higher than 3 kV HBM stress are achieved using conventional highly capacitive ggNMOS snapback devices. The methodology can be extended to other RF-CMOS circuits requiring ESD protection by merging the ESD devices in the functionality of the corresponding matching blocks.     

CMOS射频集成电路ESD保护的挑战

随着集成电路(IC)T艺进入深亚微米水平,以及射频(Radi0.Frequency,RF)IC工作频率向数千兆赫兹频段迈进,片上防静电泄放(ESD)保护设计越来越成为RF IC设计的挑战.产生这一挑战的关键原因在于ESD保护电路和被保护的RF IC核电路之间存在着不可避免的复杂交互影响效应.本文讨论了RF ESD保护的研究和设计领域的最新动态,总结了所出现的新挑战、新的设计方法和最新的RF ESD保护解决方案.     

Characteristics analysis and optimization design of a new ESD power clamp circuit

As CMOS technology scales down, the design of ESD protection circuits becomes more challenging. There are some disadvantages for the actual power clamp circuit. In this paper, an optimization ESD power clamp circuit is proposed. The new clamp circuit adopts the edge triggering True Single Phase Clocked Logic (TSPCL) D flip-flop to turn on and time delay, it has the advantage of dynamic transmission structure. By adding a leakage transistor of small size, the clamp circuit can turn off effectively. By changing the W/L ratio, the clamp can safely protect the gate of ESD power clamp devices from thermoelectric breakdown. The results show that the circuit can reduce the false triggering and power supply noise more effectively, it can be widely used in high-speed integrated circuits. The proposed structure has the advantages of low power and low cost, and can be used to the system-level ESD protection.     

CMOS射频集成电路ESD保护的挑战

随着集成电路(IC)T艺进入深亚微米水平,以及射频(Radi0.Frequency,RF)IC工作频率向数千兆赫兹频段迈进,片上防静电泄放(ESD)保护设计越来越成为RF IC设计的挑战.产生这一挑战的关键原因在于ESD保护电路和被保护的RF IC核电路之间存在着不可避免的复杂交互影响效应.本文讨论了RF ESD保护的研究和设计领域的最新动态,总结了所出现的新挑战、新的设计方法和最新的RF ESD保护解决方案.     

Design of 2.4-GHz T/R switch with embedded ESD protection devices in CMOS process

As CMOS processes advanced, the integration of radio-frequency (RF) integrated circuits was increasing. In order to protect the fully-integrated RF transceiver from electrostatic discharge (ESD) damage, the transmit/receive (T/R) switch of transceiver frond-end should be carefully designed to bypass the ESD current. This work presented a technique of embedded ESD protection device to enhance the ESD capability of T/R switch. The embedded ESD protection devices of diodes and silicon-controlled rectifier (SCR) are generated between the transistors in T/R switch without using additional ESD protection device. The design procedure of RF circuits without ESD protection device can be simplified. The test circuits of 2.4-GHz transceiver frond-end with T/R switch, PA, and LNA have been integrated and implemented in nanoscale CMOS process to test their performances during RF operations and ESD stresses. The test results confirm that the embedded ESD protection devices can provide sufficient ESD protection capability and it is free from degrading circuit performances.     

Low-capacitance ESD protection design for high-speed I/O interfaces in a 130-nm CMOS process

Electrostatic discharge (ESD) protection design for high-speed input/output (I/O) interface circuits in a 130-nm CMOS process is presented in this paper. First, the ESD protection diodes with different dimensions were designed and fabricated to evaluate their ESD levels and parasitic effects in gigahertz frequency band. With the knowledge of the dependence of device dimensions on ESD robustness and the parasitic capacitance, whole-chip ESD protection scheme were designed for the general receiver and transmitter interface circuits. Besides, an ESD protection scheme is proposed to improve the ESD robustness under the positive-to-V_SS (PS-mode) ESD test, which is the most critical ESD-test pin combination. With a silicon-controlled rectifier (SCR) between the I/O pad and V_SS, the clamping voltage along the PS-mode ESD current path can be reduced, so the PS-mode ESD level can be improved. Besides, the parasitic P-well/N-well diode in the SCR can provide the NS-mode ESD current path. Thus, SCR is the most promising ESD protection device in ESD protection design with low-capacitance consideration. The ESD protection scheme presented in this paper has been practically applied to an IC product with 2.5-Gb/s high-speed front-end interface.     

ESD protection design for CMOS RF integrated circuits using polysilicon diodes

ESD protection design for CMOS RF integrated circuits is proposed in this paper by using the stacked polysilicon diodes as the input ESD protection devices to reduce the total input capacitance and to avoid the noise coupling from the common substrate. The ESD level of the stacked polysilicon diodes on the I/O pad is restored by using the turn-on efficient power-rail ESD clamp circuit, which is constructed by substrate-triggered technique. This polysilicon diode is fully process compatible to general sub-quarter-micron CMOS processes.     

Evaluation of RF electrostatic discharge (ESD) protection in 0.18-μm CMOS technology

Electrostatic discharge (ESD) protection design is challenging for RF integrated circuits (ICs) because of the trade-off between the ESD robustness and parasitic capacitance. ESD protection devices are fabricated using the 0.18-μm RF CMOS process and their RF ESD characteristics are investigated by the transmission line pulsing (TLP) tester. The results suggest that the silicon controlled rectifier (SCR) is superior to the diode and NMOS from the perspective of ESD robustness and parasitic, but the SCR nevertheless possesses a longer turn-on time.     

A 0.8-dB NF ESD-Protected 9-mW CMOS LNA operating at 1.23 GHz [forGPS receiver]

In recent years, much research has been carried out on the possibility of using pure CMOS, rather than bipolar or BiCMOS technologies, for radio-frequency (RF) applications. An example of such an application is the Global Positioning System (GPS). One of the important bottlenecks to make the transition to pure CMOS is the immunity of the circuits against electrostatic discharge (ESD). This paper shows that it is possible to design a low-noise amplifier (LNA) with very good RF performance and sufficient ESD immunity by carefully co-designing both the LNA and ESD protection. This is demonstrated with a 0.8-dB noise figure LNA with an ESD protection of -1.4-0.6 kV human body model (HBM) with a power consumption of 9 mW. The circuit was designed as a standalone LNA for a 1.2276-GHz GPS receiver. It is implemented in a standard 0.25-μm 4M1P CMOS process     

Implementation of plug-and-play ESD protection in 5.5 GHz 90 nm RF CMOS LNAs—Concepts, constraints and solutions

Design and implementation of ESD protection for a 5.5 GHz low noise amplifier (LNA) fabricated in a 90 nm RF CMOS technology is presented. An on-chip inductor, added as “plug-and-play”, is used as ESD protection for the RF pins. The consequences of design and process, as well as, the limited freedom on the ESD protection implementation for all pins to be protected are presented in detail. Enhancement in the ESD robustness using additional core-clamp diodes is proposed.     

Investigation and application of vertical NPN devices for RF ESD protection in BiCMOS technology

BiCMOS technologies have been used to implement the radio-frequency (RF) integrated circuits (ICs) due to the advantages of low noise, low power consumption, high drive, and high speed. The electrostatic discharge (ESD) is one of the important reliability issues of IC. When the ESD events happen, the ESD protection devices must be turned on immediately to protect the ICs, including the RF ICs in BiCMOS technologies. In this work, the vertical NPN (VNPN) devices in 0.18 μm silicon-germanium (SiGe) BiCMOS technology with base-emitter shorted and resistor trigger approaches are investigated. In component-level, using transmission-line-pulsing (TLP) and ESD simulator test the IV characteristics and human-body-model (HBM) robustness of the VNPN devices, respectively. In system-level, using ESD gun tests the system-level ESD robustness. The ESD protection of VNPN devices are further applied to a 2.4 GHz low-noise amplifier (LNA). After attaching the VNPN devices to LNA, the RF characteristics are not degraded while the ESD robustness can be much improved.     

Analysis and design of distributed ESD protection circuits for high-speed mixed-signal and RF ICs

Electrostatic discharge (ESD) protection devices can have an adverse effect on the performance of high-speed mixed-signal and RF circuits. This paper presents quantitative methodologies to analyze the performance degradation of these circuits due to ESD protection. A detailed S-parameter-based analysis of these high-frequency systems illustrates the utility of the distributed ESD protection scheme and the impact of the parasitics associated with the protection devices. It is shown that a four-stage distributed ESD protection can be beneficial for frequencies up to 10 GHz. In addition, two generalized design optimization methodologies incorporating coplanar waveguides are developed for the distributed structure to achieve a better impedance match over a broad frequency range (0-10 GHz). By using this optimized design, an ESD device with a parasitic capacitance of 200 fF attenuates the RF signal power by only 0.27 dB at 10 GHz. Furthermore, termination schemes are proposed to allow this analysis to be applicable to high-speed digital and mixed-signal systems.     

Decreasing-size distributed ESD protection scheme for broad-band RF circuits

The capacitive load, from the large electrostatic discharge (ESD) protection device for high ESD robustness, has an adverse effect on the performance of broad-band RF circuits due to impedance mismatch and bandwidth degradation. The conventional distributed ESD protection scheme using equal four-stage ESD protection can achieve a better impedance match, but degrade the ESD performance. A new distributed ESD protection structure is proposed to achieve both good ESD robustness and RF performance. The proposed ESD protection circuit is constructed by arranging ESD protection stages with decreasing device size, called as decreasing-size distributed electrostatic discharge (DS-DESD) protection scheme, which is beneficial to the ESD level. The new proposed DS-DESD protection scheme with a total capacitance of 200 fF from the ESD diodes has been successfully verified in a 0.25-mum CMOS process to sustain a human-body-model ESD level of greater than 8 kV     

Built-in ESD Protection for RFID Tag ICs

The built-in Electro-Static discharge (ESD) protection circuits for Radio frequency identification (RFID) tag ICs are proposed.The ESD protection function is built into the rectifier and amplitude limiter.The rectifier and limiter are connected directly to the RF interface,and some transistors can discharge the larger current.These transistors can be used to build ESD protection circuits,through the redesign and optimization.The built-in ESD protection circuits can improve the ESD protection level and reduce the layout area.The circuits have been fabricated in 0.18μm CMOS process.The test results show that the built-in ESD protection circuits work well under 4kV ESD pressure and save as much as 72％ of the layout area compare with foundry standard ESD protection cells.     

A Fully Integrated 7.3 kV HBM ESD-Protected Transformer-Based 4.5–6 GHz CMOS LNA

The increasing mask costs of modern scaled CMOS makes silicon area precious. Meanwhile, the lowering oxide thickness seriously toughens ESD protection of RF circuits, pushing towards area-demanding inductor-based ESD protection techniques. This paper presents a transformer-based ESD protection technique for inductor-based LNAs. With no area penalty, an ESD protection level of 4.5 kV HBM is achieved. Introducing two-stage protection increases the robustness up to 7.3 kV, maintaining excellent RF performance. Further it extends the TLP protection level from 3.2 to 5 A. A noise figure of 2.6 dB is achieved with a power gain of 14.8 dB, while consuming 6.5 mW. The technique serves as a solution for low-area highly protected LNAs in deep-submicron CMOS.      

2.4GHz低噪声放大器的全芯片ESD保护设计

设计并流片验证了一种0.18μmRFCMOS工艺的2.4GHz低噪声放大器的全芯片静电放电(ESD)保护方案。对于射频(RF)I/O口的ESD防护,主要对比了二极管、可控硅(SCR)以及不同版图的互补型SCR,经流片与测试,发现岛屿状互补型SCR对I/O端口具有很好的ESD防护综合性能。对于电源口的ESD防护,主要研究了不同触发方式的ESD保护结构,结果表明,RCMOS触发SCR结构(RCMOS-SCR)具有良好的ESD鲁棒性和开启速度。基于上述结构的全芯片ESD保护设计,RF I/O口采用岛屿状布局的互补SCR结构的ESD防护设计,该ESD防护电路引入0.16dB的噪声系数和176fF的寄生电容,在人体模型(HBM)下防护能力可达6kV;电源口采用了RCMOS-SCR,实现了5kV HBM的ESD保护能力,该设计方案已经在有关企业得到应用。     

CMOS on-chip electrostatic discharge protection circuit using four-SCR structures with low ESD-trigger voltage

A robust CMOS on-chip ESD protection circuit is proposed, which consists of four parasitic lateral SCR devices with low ESD trigger voltages to protect NMOS and PMOS devices of the internal circuits against the ESD pulses with both positive and negative polarities with respect to either VDD or VSS(GND) nodes. For each ESD stress with positive or negative polarity, there is an efficient and direct shunt path generated by the SCR low-impedance latching state to quickly bypass the ESD current. Thus, this four-SCR ESD protection circuit can perform very efficient protection in a small layout area. Since there is no diffusion or polysilicon resistor in the proposed ESD protection circuit, the RC delay between each I/O pad and its internal circuits is very low and high-speed applications are feasible. The experimental results show that this four-SCR protection circuit can successfully perform very effective protection against ESD damage. Moreover, the proposed ESD protection circuit is fully process-compatible with n-well or p-well CMOS and BiCMOS technologies.     

Selecting an appropriate ESD protection for discrete RF power LDMOSTs

For ESD protections of RF Power MOSTs, V_t1 lowering by the RF signal - due to the dV/dt effect - can seriously degrade the RF performance. The use of a cascoded protection solves this problem. A new failure mechanism, related to the discharge of on-chip RF matching capacitors is presented. Adding a current limiting resistor in the protection solves this issue. Combining these solutions yields an appropriate protection for discrete RF power LDMOSTs.     

A 5-GHz fully integrated ESD-protected low-noise amplifier in 90-nm RF CMOS

A fully integrated 5-GHz low-power ESD-protected low-noise amplifier (LNA), designed and fabricated in a 90-nm RF CMOS technology, is presented. This 9.7-mW LNA features a 13.3-dB power gain at 5.5 GHz with a noise figure of 2.9 dB, while maintaining an input return loss of -14 dB. An on-chip inductor, added as "plug-and-play," i.e., without altering the original LNA design, is used as ESD protection for the RF pins to achieve sufficient ESD protection. The LNA has an ESD protection level up to 1.4 A transmission line pulse (TLP) current, corresponding to 2-kV Human Body Model (HBM) stress. Experimental results show that only minor RF performance degradation is observed by adding the inductor as a bi-directional ESD protection device to the reference LNA.