An anticipative scheduling approach with controllable processing times

In practice, machine schedules are usually subject to disruptions which have to be repaired by reactive scheduling decisions. The most popular predictive approach in project management and machine scheduling literature is to leave idle times (time buffers) in schedules in coping with disruptions, i.e. the resources will be under-utilized. Therefore, preparing initial schedules by considering possible disruption times along with rescheduling objectives is critical for the performance of rescheduling decisions. In this paper, we show that if the processing times are controllable then an anticipative approach can be used to form an initial schedule so that the limited capacity of the production resources are utilized more effectively. To illustrate the anticipative scheduling idea, we consider a non-identical parallel machining environment, where processing times can be controlled at a certain compression cost. When there is a disruption during the execution of the initial schedule, a match-up time strategy is utilized such that a repaired schedule has to catch-up initial schedule at some point in future. This requires changing machine–job assignments and processing times for the rest of the schedule which implies increased manufacturing costs. We show that making anticipative job sequencing decisions, based on failure and repair time distributions and flexibility of jobs, one can repair schedules by incurring less manufacturing cost. Our computational results show that the match-up time strategy is very sensitive to initial schedule and the proposed anticipative scheduling algorithm can be very helpful to reduce rescheduling costs.     

Robust scheduling on a single machine to minimize total flow time

In a real-world manufacturing environment featuring a variety of uncertainties, production schedules for manufacturing systems often cannot be executed exactly as they are developed. In these environments, schedule robustness that guarantees the best worst-case performance is a more appropriate criterion in developing schedules, although most existing studies have developed optimal schedules with respect to a deterministic or stochastic scheduling model. This study concerns robust single machine scheduling with uncertain job processing times and sequence-dependent family setup times explicitly represented by interval data. The objective is to obtain robust sequences of job families and jobs within each family that minimize the absolute deviation of total flow time from the optimal solution under the worst-case scenario. We prove that the robust single machine scheduling problem of interest is NP-hard. This problem is reformulated as a robust constrained shortest path problem and solved by a simulated annealing-based algorithmic framework that embeds a generalized label correcting method. The results of numerical experiments demonstrate that the proposed heuristic is effective and efficient for determining robust schedules. In addition, we explore the impact of degree of uncertainty on the performance measures and examine the tradeoff between robustness and optimality.     

On the identical parallel-machine rescheduling with job rework disruption

This paper investigates an issue of rescheduling on identical parallel machines where the original jobs have already been scheduled to minimize the total completion time, when a single set of jobs to be reworked re-arrives and creates a job rework disruption. Two conflicting rescheduling criteria are considered: the total completion time, as the measure of scheduling cost (efficiency); and the number of jobs assigned to different machines in the original schedule and newly generated schedule, as the measure of disruption cost (stability). Further, the rescheduling problem is defined as a bi-criteria scheduling problem. Two polynomial time algorithms are proposed to lexicographically optimize the two criteria. Besides, the set of all efficient schedules with respect to the two criteria can be also generated in polynomial time.     

Rescheduling Manufacturing Systems: A Framework of Strategies, Policies, and Methods

Many manufacturing facilities generate and update production schedules, which are plans that state when certain controllable activities (e.g., processing of jobs by resources) should take place. Production schedules help managers and supervisors coordinate activities to increase productivity and reduce operating costs. Because a manufacturing system is dynamic and unexpected events occur, rescheduling is necessary to update a production schedule when the state of the manufacturing system makes it infeasible. Rescheduling updates an existing production schedule in response to disruptions or other changes. Though many studies discuss rescheduling, there are no standard definitions or classification of the strategies, policies, and methods presented in the rescheduling literature. This paper presents definitions appropriate for most applications of rescheduling manufacturing systems and describes a framework for understanding rescheduling strategies, policies, and methods. This framework is based on a wide variety of experimental and practical approaches that have been described in the rescheduling literature. The paper also discusses studies that show how rescheduling affects the performance of a manufacturing system, and it concludes with a discussion of how understanding rescheduling can bring closer some aspects of scheduling theory and practice.     

Single-machine scheduling with workload-dependent tool change durations and equal processing time jobs to minimize total completion time

We consider a single-machine tool change scheduling problem where tool change durations are workload-dependent. The processing times of all the jobs are the same. The objective is to determine the number of tool change activities, the start time and the completion time of each tool change activity jointly and schedule all the jobs to the machine such that the total completion time of the jobs is minimized. For the case where the tool change duration function is concave, we present a linear time optimal algorithm. For the case where the tool change duration function is convex, we convert it into a convex integer quadratic programming problem with fixed dimension and then propose two polynomial time algorithms for it. We also study some special cases for which optimal schedules can be obtained directly. For the case where the tool change duration function is linear, we present all the optimal schedules.     

Decision support for unrelated parallel machine scheduling with discrete controllable processing times

In a manufacturing or service system, the actual processing time of a job can be controlled by the amount of an indivisible resource allocated, such as workers or auxiliary facilities. In this paper, we consider unrelated parallel-machine scheduling problems with discrete controllable processing times. The processing time of a job is discretely controllable by the allocation of indivisible resources. The planner must make decisions on whether or how to allocate resources to jobs during the scheduling horizon to optimize the performance measures. The objective is to minimize the total cost including the cost measured by a standard criterion and the total processing cost. We first consider three scheduling criterions: the total completion time, the total machine load, and the total earliness and tardiness penalties. If the number of machines and the number of possible processing times are fixed, we develop polynomial time algorithms for the considered problems. We then consider the minimization problem of the makespan cost plus the total processing cost and present an integer programming method and a heuristic method to solve the studied problem.     

Fast reactive scheduling to minimize tardiness penalty and energy cost under power consumption uncertainties

Motivated by the need to deal with uncertainties in energy optimization of flexible manufacturing systems, this paper considers a dynamic scheduling problem which minimizes the sum of energy cost and tardiness penalty under power consumption uncertainties. An integrated control and scheduling framework is proposed including two modules, namely, an augmented discrete event control (ADEC) and a max-throughput-min-energy reactive scheduling model (MTME). The ADEC is in charge of inhibiting jobs which may lead to deadlocks, and sequencing active jobs and resources. The MTME ensures the fulfillment of the innate constraints and decides the local optimal schedule of active jobs and resources. Our proposed framework is applied to an industrial stamping system with power consumption uncertainties formulated using three different probability distributions. The obtained schedules are compared with three dispatching rules and two rescheduling approaches. Our experiment results verify that MTME outperforms three dispatching rules in terms of deviation from Pareto optimality and reduces interrupted time significantly as compared to rescheduling approaches. In addition, ADEC and MTME are programmed using the same matrix language, providing easy implementation for industrial practitioners.     

Genetic algorithms for match-up rescheduling of the flexible manufacturing systems

Scheduling plays a vital role in ensuring the effectiveness of the production control of a flexible manufacturing system (FMS). The scheduling problem in FMS is considered to be dynamic in its nature as new orders may arrive every day. The new orders need to be integrated with the existing production schedule immediately without disturbing the performance and the stability of existing schedule. Most FMS scheduling methods reported in the literature address the static FMS scheduling problems. In this paper, rescheduling methods based on genetic algorithms are described to address arrivals of new orders. This study proposes genetic algorithms for match-up rescheduling with non-reshuffle and reshuffle strategies which accommodate new orders by manipulating the available idle times on machines and by resequencing operations, respectively. The basic idea of the match-up approach is to modify only a part of the initial schedule and to develop genetic algorithms (GAs) to generate a solution within the rescheduling horizon in such a way that both the stability and performance of the shop floor are kept. The proposed non-reshuffle and reshuffle strategies have been evaluated and the results have been compared with the total-rescheduling method.     

Single-machine scheduling with trade-off between number of tardy jobs and compression cost

We consider a single-machine scheduling problem, in which the job processing times are controllable or compressible. The performance criteria are the compression cost and the number of tardy jobs. For the problem, where no tardy jobs are allowed and the objective is to minimize the total compression cost, we present a strongly polynomial time algorithm. For the problem to construct the trade-off curve between the number of tardy jobs and the maximum compression cost, we present a polynomial time algorithm. Furthermore, we extend the problem to the case of discrete controllable processing times, where the processing time of a job can only take one of several given discrete values. We show that even some special cases of the discrete controllable version with the objective of minimizing the total compression cost are NP-hard, but the general case is solvable in pseudo-polynomial time. Moreover, we present a strongly polynomial time algorithm to construct the trade-off curve between the number of tardy jobs and the maximum compression cost for the discrete controllable version. This research was supported by the Teaching and Research Award Program for Outstanding Young Teachers in Higher Education Institutions of the MOE, China, and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (10271110). The third author was supported in part by The Hong Kong Polytechnic University under a grant from the ASD in China Business Services.     

Single-machine rescheduling with deterioration and learning effects against the maximum sequence disruption

In this paper, we study the issue of single-machine rescheduling with linear deteriorating jobs and position-based learning effects simultaneously in response to an unexpected arrival of new jobs. The scheduling efficiency is measured in terms of the makespan, while the cost of disruption is measured in terms of the maximum difference in processing orders of the original jobs before and after disruption. By introducing the effects of deterioration and learning, the job actual processing time is defined by an increasing function of its starting time, meanwhile a decreasing function of its position. Two types of problems are considered. For the first one, the makespan is minimised subject to a limit on the maximum sequence disruption; while in the second one, a linear combination of the makespan and the maximum sequence disruption is minimised. For each problem, the polynomial solvability is demonstrated, and an efficient algorithm is then developed. Finally, extensive computational experiments are conducted to show the efficiency and running behaviours of the proposed algorithms.     

Bicriteria robotic cell scheduling

This paper considers the scheduling problems arising in two- and three-machine manufacturing cells configured in a flowshop which repeatedly produces one type of product and where transportation of the parts between the machines is performed by a robot. The cycle time of the cell is affected by the robot move sequence as well as the processing times of the parts on the machines. For highly flexible CNC machines, the processing times can be changed by altering the machining conditions at the expense of increasing the manufacturing cost. As a result, we try to find the robot move sequence as well as the processing times of the parts on each machine that not only minimize the cycle time but, for the first time in robotic cell scheduling literature, also minimize the manufacturing cost. For each 1-unit cycle in two- and three-machine cells, we determine the efficient set of processing time vectors such that no other processing time vector gives both a smaller cycle time and a smaller cost value. We also compare these cycles with each other to determine the sufficient conditions under which each of the cycles dominates the rest. Finally, we show how different assumptions on cost structures affect the results.     

Single machine scheduling with controllable processing times to minimize total tardiness and earliness

In most deterministic scheduling problems job processing times are considered as invariable and known in advance. Single machine scheduling problem with controllable processing times with no inserted idle time is presented in this study. Job processing times are controllable to some extent that they can be reduced or increased, up to a certain limit, at a cost proportional to the reduction or increase. In this study, our objective is determining a set of compression/expansion of processing times in addition to a sequence of jobs simultaneously, so that total tardiness and earliness are minimized. A mathematical model is proposed firstly and afterward a net benefit compression–net benefit expansion (NBC–NBE) heuristic is presented so as to acquire a set of amounts of compression and expansion of jobs processing times in a given sequence. Three heuristic techniques in small problems and in medium-to-large instances two meta-heuristic approaches, as effective local search methods, as well as these heuristics are employed to solve test examples. The single machine total tardiness problem (SMTTP) is already NP-hard, so the considered problem is NP-hard obviously. The computational experiments demonstrate that our proposed heuristic is efficient approach for such just-in-time (JIT) problem, especially equipped with competent heuristics.     

A bi‐objective approach to reschedule new jobs in a one machine model

We consider a one machine scheduling model, minimizing a classical objective function—either the total completion time or the maximum tardiness—and with two sets of jobs: one with initial jobs already scheduled and one with new jobs that must be inserted in the schedule. As such rescheduling can create a modification of the schedule of the initial jobs, a disruption objective is considered in addition to the original objective. This additional objective can be formulated in four different ways. Such model has been introduced by Hall and Potts, minimizing either a linear aggregation of the two objectives or the initial objective under a constraint giving an upper limit of the disruption objective. In this paper, the aim is to obtain the set of efficient schedules in regard to the two objectives. Algorithms are provided for the eight possible bi‐objective problems and illustrated by some didactic examples.     

A hybrid scheduling approach for a two-stage flexible flow shop with batch processing machines

In this paper, we discuss a flexible flow shop scheduling problem with batch processing machines at each stage and with jobs that have unequal ready times. Scheduling problems of this type can be found in semiconductor wafer fabrication facilities (wafer fabs). We are interested in minimizing the total weighted tardiness of the jobs. We present a mixed integer programming formulation. The batch scheduling problem is NP-hard. Therefore, an iterative stage-based decomposition approach is proposed that is hybridized with neighborhood search techniques. The decomposition scheme provides internal due dates and ready times for the jobs on the first and second stage, respectively. Each of the resulting parallel machine batch scheduling problems is solved by variable neighborhood search in each iteration. Based on the schedules of the subproblems, the internal due dates and ready times are updated. We present the results of designed computational experiments that also consider the number of machines assigned to each stage as a design factor. It turns out that the proposed hybrid approach outperforms an iterative decomposition scheme where a fairly simple heuristic based on time window decomposition and the apparent tardiness cost dispatching rule is used to solve the subproblems. Recommendations for the design of the two stages with respect to the number of parallel machines on each stage are given.     

Minimizing total tardiness and earliness on unrelated parallel machines with controllable processing times

Job scheduling has always been a challenging task in modern manufacturing and the most real life scheduling problems which involves multi-criteria and multi-machine environments. In this research our direction is largely motivated by the adoption of the Just-In-Time (JIT) philosophy in parallel machines system, where processing times of jobs are controllable. The goal of this paper is to minimize total weighted tardiness and earliness besides jobs compressing and expanding costs, depending on the amount of compression/expansion as well as maximum completion time called makespan simultaneously. Jobs due dates are distinct and no inserted idle time is allowed after starting machine processing. Also each machine is capable of processing only some predetermined jobs and operations with probably different speeds. A Mixed Integer Programming (MIP) model is proposed to formulate such a problem and is solved optimally in small size instances. A Parallel Net Benefit Compression-Net Benefit Expansion (PNBC–NBE) heuristic is then presented to acquire the optimal jobs set amount of compression and expansion processing times in a given sequence. To solve medium-to-large size cases, a proposed heuristic, two meta-heuristics and a hybrid technique are also employed. Experimental results demonstrate that our hybrid procedure is a proficient method and could efficiently solve such complicated problems.     

Real-time integrated production-scheduling and maintenance-planning in a flexible job shop with machine deterioration and condition-based maintenance

The introduction of modern technologies in manufacturing is contributing to the emergence of smart (and data-driven) manufacturing systems, known as Industry 4.0. The benefits of adopting such technologies can be fully utilized by presenting optimization models in every step of the decision-making process. This includes the optimization of maintenance plans and production schedules, which are two essential aspects of any manufacturing process. In this paper, we consider the real-time joint optimization of maintenance planning and production scheduling in smart manufacturing systems. We have considered a flexible job shop production layout and addressed several issues that usually take place in practice. The addressed issues are: new job arrivals, unexpected due date changes, machine degradation, random breakdowns, minimal repairs, and condition-based maintenance (CBM). We have proposed a real-time optimization-based system that utilizes a modified hybrid genetic algorithm, an integrated proactive-reactive optimization model, and hybrid rescheduling policies. A set of modified benchmark problems is used to test the proposed system by comparing its performance to several other optimization algorithms and methods used in practice. The results show the superiority of the proposed system for solving the problem under study. The results also emphasize the importance of the quality of the generated baseline plans (i.e., initial integrated plans), the use of hybrid rescheduling policies, and the importance of rescheduling times (i.e., reaction times) for cost savings.     

Minimizing makespan subject to minimum flowtime on two identical parallel machines

We consider the problem of scheduling jobs on two parallel identical machines where an optimal schedule is defined as one that gives the smallest makespan (the completion time of the last job) among the set of schedules with optimal total flowtime (the sum of the completion times of all jobs). We propose an algorithm to determine optimal schedules for the problem, and describe a modified multifit algorithm to find an approximate solution to the problem in polynomial computational time. Results of a computational study to compare the performance of the proposed algorithms with a known heuristic shows that the proposed heuristic and optimization algorithms are quite effective and efficient in solving the problem.Scope and purposeMultiple objective optimization problems are quite common in practice. However, while solving scheduling problems, optimization algorithms often consider only a single objective function. Consideration of multiple objectives makes even the simplest multi-machine scheduling problems NP-hard. Therefore, enumerative optimization techniques and heuristic solution procedures are required to solve multi-objective scheduling problems. This paper illustrates the development of an optimization algorithm and polynomially bounded heuristic solution procedures for the scheduling jobs on two identical parallel machines to hierarchically minimize the makespan subject to the optimality of the total flowtime.     

Hybrid Evolutionary Algorithm for job scheduling under machine maintenance

The job scheduling problem (JSP) belongs to the well-known combinatorial optimization domain. After scheduling, if a machine maintenance issue affects the scheduled processing of jobs, the delivery of jobs must be delayed. In this paper, we have first proposed a Hybrid Evolutionary Algorithm (HyEA) for solving JSPs. We have then analyzed the effect of machine maintenance, whether preventive or breakdown, on the job scheduling. For the breakdown maintenance case, it is required to revise the algorithm to incorporate a rescheduling option after the breakdown occurs. The algorithm has been tested by solving a number of benchmark problems and thence comparing them with the existing algorithms. The experimental results provide a better understanding of job scheduling and the necessary rescheduling operations under process interruption.     

Single CNC machine scheduling with controllable processing times to minimize total weighted tardiness

Advanced manufacturing technologies, such as CNC machines, require significant investments, but also offer new capabilities to the manufacturers. One of the important capabilities of a CNC machine is the controllable processing times. By using this capability, the due date requirements of customers can be satisfied much more effectively. Processing times of the jobs on a CNC machine can be easily controlled via machining conditions such that they can be increased or decreased at the expense of tooling cost. Since scheduling decisions are very sensitive to the processing times, we solve the process planning and scheduling problems simultaneously. In this study, we consider the problem of scheduling a set of jobs on a single CNC machine to minimize the sum of total weighted tardiness, tooling and machining costs. We formulated the joint problem, which is NP-hard since the total weighted tardiness problem (with fixed processing times) is strongly NP-hard alone, as a nonlinear mixed integer program. We proposed a DP-based heuristic to solve the problem for a given sequence and designed a local search algorithm that uses it as a base heuristic.     

Series production in a basic re-entrant shop to minimize makespan or total flow time

This paper addresses a real life shop scheduling problem in a manufacturing company. In this problem, a set of n identical jobs are to be processed on two machines. Every job visits one of the machines more than once. This is therefore a re-entrant shop. Due to the fact that the jobs are identical, the decision version of this problem is even not in the class NP. We give an optimal schedule to minimize the makespan. Since the total flow time depends on the relations between the processing times, we decompose this problem into sub-problems according to the relations between the processing times. We prove various properties of optimal solutions and, based on these properties, we provide an optimal solution for all the sub-problems except one of them. For the sole remaining sub-problem, we prove a dominance property which allows to consider a part of schedules to find an optimal one.