Heat-integrated reactive distillation process for synthesis of fatty esters

Catalytic reactive distillation (RD) offers novel opportunities for manufacturing fatty acid alkyl esters involved in specialty chemicals and at a larger scale in biodiesel. The integration of reaction and separation into one RD unit, corroborated with the use of a heterogeneous catalyst, provides major benefits such as low capital investment and operating costs. This work presents a novel heat-integrated process based on reactive distillation that aims to reduce furthermore the energy requirements for biodiesel production, leading to competitive operating costs. Despite the high degree of integration, the process is well controllable using an efficient control structure proposed in this work. Rigorous simulations embedding experimental results were performed using computer aided process engineering tools, such as AspenTech Aspen Plus and Aspen Dynamics. The RD column was simulated using the rigorous RADFRAC unit with RateSep (rate-based) model, and explicitly considering three phase balances. Steady-state and dynamic simulation results are given for a plant producing 10 ktpy fatty acid methyl esters (FAME) from methanol and waste vegetable oil with high free fatty acids (FFA) content, using sulfated zirconia as green catalyst. The heat-integrated RD process eliminates all conventional catalyst related operations, efficiently uses the raw materials and the reactor volume offering complete conversion of the fatty acids and allowing significant energy savings. Remarkably, compared to previously reported RD processes, the energy requirements of this process are about 45% lower - only 108.8 kW h/ton biodiesel - while the capital investment cost remains the same as no additional equipment is required.     

Production of Methyl Oleate in Reactive‐Separation Systems

The esterification of oleic acid and methanol using sulfuric acid as a homogeneous catalyst is studied in reactive‐separation systems. The conversion of the free fatty acid was investigated in two different experiments with the molar ratio of methanol/oleic acid, amount of catalyst, temperature, and reaction time as variables. The conversion of the free fatty acid was found to depend strongly on the molar ratio of methanol/oleic acid. The reaction time had a direct effect on the conversion of the free fatty acid, and this conversion decreased with higher temperature. These results were valuable for a preliminary study on biodiesel production, using an acid homogeneous catalyst in a reactive dividing‐wall distillation column.     

Reactive distillation for biodiesel production from soybean oil

Biodiesel, which is regarded as a promising alternative to a conventional petroleum-based diesel fuel, can be produced from transesterification of vegetable oils and alcohol in conventional batch and continuous reactors. Since the transesterification is an equilibrium-limited reaction, a large excess of reactants is usually used to increase the production of biodiesel, thereby requiring more expensive separation of unreacted raw materials. This study proposed the use of a reactive distillation for transesterification of soybean oil and methanol catalyzed by sodium hydroxide to produce biodiesel. The simulation results showed that a suitable configuration of the reactive distillation column consists of three reactive stages. The optimal conditions for the reactive distillation operation are at the molar feed ratio of methanol and oil at 4.5: 1, reflux ratio of 3, and reboiler duty of 1.6×10⁷ kJ h⁻¹. Methanol and soybean oil should be fed into the column at the first stage. The effect of important operating and design parameters on the performance of reactive distillation was also presented.     

Novel process for biodiesel by reactive absorption

Process integration and intensification is increasingly applied also in the biodiesel production, as shown by recent research papers. This study takes previous work on reactive separation processes for biodiesel production to a new level by proposing an innovative technology based on reactive absorption using solid acid catalysts. This is a major step forward since reactive absorption offers significant benefits over reactive distillation, such as: reduced capital investment and operating costs due to the absence of the reboiler and condenser, higher conversion and selectivity as no products are recycled in the form of reflux or boil-up vapors, as well as no occurrence of thermal degradation of the products due to a lower temperature profile in the column. Rigorous simulations embedding experimental results were performed in AspenTech AspenONE engineering suite to design this novel reactive absorption process and evaluate the technical and economical feasibility. The main results are given for a plant producing 10 ktpy biodiesel from waste vegetable oil with high free fatty acids content, using solid acids as green catalysts. This innovative process eliminates all conventional catalyst-related operations, and efficiently uses the raw materials and the reactor volume in an integrated setup that allows significant savings in CapEx and OpEx of the plant.     

酯化-酯交换两步法制备生物柴油的动力学

以潲水油（WCO）为原料,探讨了酯化-酯交换两步法制备生物柴油的反应动力学。以活性炭负载硫酸铁［Fe₂(SO₄)₃/AC］为负载型催化剂,通过测定不同反应温度、不同甲醇/脂肪酸（FFA）摩尔比条件下WCO中游离脂肪酸的转化率,以此确定酯化反应的动力学控制步骤及动力学方程中的待定参数,从而建立了在实验温度范围内酯化反应的动力学方程,并根据碱催化酯交换反应机理,在简化的动力学模型基础上,推导出了WCO中甘油三酯（TG）与甲醇发生酯交换反应的宏观动力学方程。结果表明,酯化反应和酯交换反应的动力学方程在实验条件范围内都能较好地描述各自的反应过程。     

Transesterification of palm oil with methanol in a reactive distillation column

The higher feedstock and processing costs for biodiesel production can be reduced by applying reactive distillation (RD) in transesterification process. The effects of reboiler temperature, amount of KOH catalyst, methanol to oil molar ratio and residence time on the methyl ester purity were determined by using a simple laboratory-scale RD packed column. The results indicated that from the empty column, the system reached the steady state in 8 h. Too high reboiler temperature and the amount of catalyst introduce more soap from saponification in the process. The optimal operating condition is at a reboiler temperature 90 °C, a methanol to oil molar ratio of 4.5:1.0, KOH of 1 wt.% respect to oil and 5 min of residence time in the column. This condition requires the fresh feed methanol 25% lower than in the conventional process and produces 92.27% methyl ester purity. Therefore this RD column can be applied in small or medium biodiesel enterprise.     

固体催化剂催化高酸值鱼油的甲酯化研究

以高酸值鱼油为原料,利用Amberlyst15固体酸催化剂在温和条件下进行酯化反应降低酸值,再由氧化钙固体碱催化剂催化转酯化得到鱼油脂肪酸甲酯。采用正交设计优化反应条件,预酯化：催化剂用量15%,反应温度75℃,n（醇）/n（油）14,反应时间1.5 h,酸值降为3.35 mg/g,二次预酯化酸值降至1.24 mg/g;酯交换：催化剂用量为10%,反应温度65℃,n（醇）/n（油）为6,反应时间为3 h,鱼油甲酯收率为93.7%。     

Biodiesel synthesis via homogeneous Lewis acid-catalyzed transesterification

Lewis acids (AlCl₃ or ZnCl₂) were used to catalyze the transesterification of canola oil with methanol in the presence of terahydrofuran (THF) as co-solvent. The conversion of canola oil into fatty acid methyl esters was monitored by ¹H NMR. NMR analysis demonstrated that AlCl₃ catalyzes both the esterification of long chain fatty acid and the transesterification of vegetable oil with methanol suggesting that the catalyst is suitable for the preparation of biodiesel from vegetable oil containing high amounts of free fatty acids. Optimization by statistical analysis showed that the conversion of triglycerides into fatty acid methyl esters using AlCl₃ as catalyst was affected by reaction time, methanol to oil molar ratio, temperature and the presence of THF as co-solvent. The optimum conditions with AlCl₃ that achieved 98% conversion were 24:1 molar ratio at 110 °C and 18 h reaction time with THF as co-solvent. The presence of THF minimized the mass transfer problem normally encountered in heterogeneous systems. ZnCl₂ was far less effective as a catalyst compared to AlCl₃, which was attributed to its lesser acidity. Nevertheless, statistical analysis showed that the conversion with the use of ZnCl₂ differs only with reaction time but not with molar ratio.     

Reactive distillation in the intensification of oleic acid esterification with methanol – A simulation case-study

Process intensification through reactive distillation (RD) could be successfully applied to the esterification of long-chain fatty acids, which is a crucial step in the biodiesel synthesis. While previous literature reports are mainly focused on the esterification of short- to medium- fatty acids, oleic acid has been chosen as an example of a long chain one and different RD configurations were simulated and compared. The configuration with top external recycle proved to be the best solution since it allows the reaction to be conducted under a large methanol excess, even though the column is fed with stoichiometric reactants.     

酯交换法合成碳酸二甲酯研究

通过酯交换法，以甲醇和碳酸丙烯酯（ＰＣ）为原料，反应精馏合成碳酸二甲酯，筛选出最佳催化剂，确定了其用量，考察了原料配比等对反应转化率的影响，研究结果表明，催化剂ＣＨＳ－１和ＣＨＳ－２催化效果较好，其较佳用量为０．４％～０．５％（相对于甲醇的质量）甲醇与ＰＣ的质量比为８～１０，反应停留时间为４０ｍｉｎ～６０ｍｉｎ本文报道的酯交换工艺具有一定的工业应用价值。     

Reactive Distillation for Solvent Regeneration after Biphasic Carboxylic Acid Esterification

Emulsion-enhanced biphasic esterification has proven to be applicable for carboxylic acid recovery from dilute aqueous process streams. The carboxylic acid is esterified with 1-octanol in an emulsified regime with 4-dodecylbenzenesulfonic acid (4-DBSA) or Ni(DBSA)₂ as catalyst. After phase separation, the laden solvent phase must be regenerated. This study presents a regeneration concept based on reactive distillation with transesterification of the octyl ester-laden solvent with methanol. The regenerated solvent is reused in the extraction step.     

Rate-based analysis of reactive distillation sequences with different degrees of integration

In this work, reactive distillation sequences with different degrees of integration are investigated with the aim to identify the optimal configuration. Such integration includes the combination of both unit operations, reaction and distillation, as well as the combination of distillation columns within one unit. For rapid determination of required design parameters, a special two-step approach based on the decomposition method is developed.As a test system, the transesterification of carbonates is chosen, and three promising configurations with increasing integration degree are identified. These configurations comprise two different combinations of single non-reactive and reactive distillation columns as well as a highly integrated reactive dividing wall column. Their analysis shows that the unit integration leads to significant savings in energy consumption and production costs.     

Design and control of transesterification reactive distillation with thermal coupling

In the study, the design and control strategies of a reactive distillation process with partially thermal coupling for the production of methanol and n-butyl acetate by transesterification reaction of methyl acetate and n-butanol are investigated. Since methanol and methyl acetate formed an azeotrope, the products of a reactive distillation column include n-butyl acetate and the mixture of methanol and methyl acetate, which must be separated by an additional column. Partially thermal coupling can be used to eliminate the condenser of the second column. Not only energy reduction but also better operability and controllability can be obtained for the thermally coupled reactive distillation process. Proper selection and pairing of controlled and manipulated variables chosen for three control objectives were determined by using steady-state analysis. A simple control scheme with three temperature control loops is sufficient to maintain product purities and stoichiometric balance between the reactant feeds.     

Heterogeneously Catalyzed Esterification of FFAs in Vegetable Oils

The production of methyl esters (biodiesel) from free fatty acids (FFAs) contained in vegetable oils was studied using a heterogeneous acid catalyst. The feedstock was a by‐product of a vegetable oil refinery. The experiments were performed in a batch reactor, in a temperature range of 363.15–393.15 K, with an initial molar ratio of methanol to FFAs of 6.6/1, while the catalyst mass was fixed at 2 wt % of the total vegetable oil mass. A technical kinetic model has been developed which accounts for the reversible esterification reaction. Kinetic parameters were determined by fitting experimental data to the model.     

Enzymatic production of fatty acid alkyl esters with a lipase preparation from Candida sp. 99‐125

A lipase preparation developed from Candida sp. 99‐125 was used for fatty acid alkyl ester synthesis by both enzymatic esterification of fatty acids, and transesterification of oils and fats. The lipase preparation was chosen based on screening of lipases from commercial sources as well as those produced in the laboratory. The effects of enzyme dosage, solvent types, water absorbent additions, inhibition of short‐chain alcohols, alcohol and acid types, molar ratio of substrates, and reusability of the lipase preparation in esterification were studied. Degree of esterification between oleic acid and methanol under optimal conditions reached 92%. Purity of the methyl ester after washing with water and distillation was 98%. Half‐life of the lipase preparation was calculated to be approximately 340 h. For transesterification of rapeseed oil with the same lipase preparation, the amount of methanol and mode of methanol addition to the reaction were also conducted. Transesterification of the oil with stepwise methanol addition reached 83% after 36 h reaction time.     

侧反应器反应精馏方法生产醋酸甲酯的模拟

采用强酸性阳离子交换树脂催化醋酸与甲醇反应精馏生成醋酸甲酯,可避免硫酸作为催化剂的不足。但该非均相催化反应受平衡限制,且达到平衡时间较长,采用传统反应精馏塔难以提供足够反应空间。文中设计侧反应器与精馏塔耦合新工艺,采用Aspen Plus软件模拟研究了侧反应器数量、位置,原料进料位置,回流比,醇酸比等对反应精馏过程的影响。结果表明,当装置具有7个侧反应器,反应器间隔4块板,在优化的操作条件下,醋酸甲酯质量分数可达99.1%。     

Base/acid-catalyzed FAEE production from hydroxylated vegetable oils

In this study was developed a new methodology to produce fatty acid ethyl esters from castor oil. The base-catalyzed transesterification step was followed by on pot addition of sulfuric acid. That addition implicated the successful separation of FAEEs/glycerin phases due to soap breaking. The study was carried out through an experimental design where the variables studied in the first step were the molar ratio alcohol:oil and the catalyst amount in the transesterification process. As expected, the on pot addition of concentrated sulfuric acid yields FFAs that increase the acid value in the FAEEs phase. A second step esterification of these free fatty acids from FAEE raw mixture was investigated. The esterification of FFA was carried out in 60:1 and 80:1 M ratios (alcohol:free fatty acids) and concentrated sulfuric acid 5% and 10% w/w (based on free fatty acids). Consequently, these two steps yielded more fatty ethyl esters and assure that the following important requirements in the FAEEs production process from castor oil are satisfied: complete reaction, best separation of FAEEs/glycerin phases, removal of catalyst, limpid glycerin, and absence of free fatty acids.     

In situ transesterification of coconut oil using mixtures of methanol and tetrahydrofuran

The conventional biodiesel production method requires oil extraction followed by transesterification with methanol. The solubility of vegetable oils in methanol is low which decreases the overall rate of reaction. To eliminate the oil extraction step and improve the overall reaction rate, simultaneous extraction, esterification and transesterification were conducted by directly mixing methanol and tetrahydrofuran (THF) co-solvent and sulfuric acid catalyst with ground, desiccated coconut meat (copra) in a batch process and continuing the reaction until the system reached steady state. After separation of the mixture, yield was obtained by measuring the content of triglycerides, diglycerides and monoglycerides in the biodiesel phase. The yield increases with THF:methanol ratio, methanol:oil molar ratio and temperature. Within the range of conditions tested, the highest yield achieved was 96.7% at 60 °C, THF:methanol volume ratio of 0.4 and methanol:oil molar ratio of 60:1. The methanol:oil molar ratio is necessarily high in order to completely wet the copra mass, but is still lower than in previous studies by other researchers on in situ transesterification. Product assays show that the resulting biodiesel product is similar to conventionally produced coconut biodiesel. The results indicate that the in situ transesterification of copra using methanol/THF mixtures merits further study.     

Optimal design of mixed acid esterification and isopropanol dehydration systems via incorporation of dividing-wall columns

This study explores the design of a reactive distillation system and that of a heterogeneous azeotropic system by incorporating dividing-wall column (DWC). The first system involves the esterification of mixed acid (acetic acid and propionic acid) with methanol. Simulation studies are carried out for conventional reactive distillation sequence as well as for reactive dividing-wall distillation system. Both systems are optimized by an iterative optimization procedure. Optimal design results show that the reactive dividing-wall system saves steam consumption by 45.2% and reduces total annual costs (TAC) by 34.5%. The second case investigated is a heterogeneous azeotropic distillation system involving dehydration of crude isopropyl alcohol with cyclohexane as entrainer. Two optimal separation systems are generated, including one with a single-dividing wall column and one with a double-dividing wall column. In comparison with an energy-efficient azeotropic distillation sequence containing two stripping columns by Chang et al. (2012) [1], simulation results show that the former two systems can cut steam usage further by 6.0%. The two systems save about 5.4–6.1% in terms of TAC. DWCs prove to be superior to the convention distillation systems with respect to both cost and energy efficiency.     

Gas chromatographic determination of free fatty acids in vegetable oils by a modified esterification procedure

Free fatty acids in small vegetable oil samples were determined by gas liquid chromatography after a modified BCl₃ or BF₃/methanol esterification procedure with methylurea. This compound was found to sufficiently reduce triacylglyceride transesterification during free fatty acid esterification with BC1₃ or BF₃ methanol. Good results were obtained using this new procedure on neutral lipid oils containing known amounts of free fatty acids. Good agreement between the new method and the A.O.C.S. titration method was also demonstrated on commercial and laboratory-extracted crude oils. Because very small oil samples (200 mg) can be analyzed, the new method could be applicable for oilseed physiological studies.