Fragment‐Based Lead Discovery: Screening and Optimizing Fragments for Thermolysin Inhibition

Fragment‐based drug discovery has gained a foothold in today's lead identification processes. We present the application of in silico fragment‐based screening for the discovery of novel lead compounds for the metalloendoproteinase thermolysin. We have chosen thermolysin to validate our screening approach as it is a well‐studied enzyme and serves as a model system for other proteases. A protein‐targeted virtual library was designed and screening was carried out using the program AutoDock. Two fragment hits could be identified. For one of them, the crystal structure in complex with thermolysin is presented. This compound was selected for structure‐based optimization of binding affinity and improvement of ligand efficiency, while concomitantly keeping the fragment‐like properties of the initial hit. Redesigning the zinc coordination group revealed a novel class of fragments possessing K_i values as low as 128 μM , thus they provide a good starting point for further hit evolution in a tailored lead design.     

Using a Fragment‐Based Approach To Target Protein–Protein Interactions

The ability to identify inhibitors of protein–protein interactions represents a major challenge in modern drug discovery and in the development of tools for chemical biology. In recent years, fragment‐based approaches have emerged as a new methodology in drug discovery; however, few examples of small molecules that are active against chemotherapeutic targets have been published. Herein, we describe the fragment‐based approach of targeting the interaction between the tumour suppressor BRCA2 and the recombination enzyme RAD51; it makes use of a screening pipeline of biophysical techniques that we expect to be more generally applicable to similar targets. Disruption of this interaction in vivo is hypothesised to give rise to cellular hypersensitivity to radiation and genotoxic drugs. We have used protein engineering to create a monomeric form of RAD51 by humanising a thermostable archaeal orthologue, RadA, and used this protein for fragment screening. The initial fragment hits were thoroughly validated biophysically by isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) and NMR techniques and observed by X‐ray crystallography to bind in a shallow surface pocket that is occupied in the native complex by the side chain of a phenylalanine from the conserved FxxA interaction motif found in BRCA2. This represents the first report of fragments or any small molecule binding at this protein–protein interaction site.     

Development of Fragment‐Based n‐FABS NMR Screening Applied to the Membrane Enzyme FAAH

Despite the recognized importance of membrane proteins as pharmaceutical targets, the reliable identification of fragment hits that are able to bind these proteins is still a major challenge. Among different ¹⁹F NMR spectroscopic methods, n‐fluorine atoms for biochemical screening (n‐FABS) is a highly sensitive technique that has been used efficiently for fragment screening, but its application for membrane enzymes has not been reported yet. Herein, we present the first successful application of n‐FABS to the discovery of novel fragment hits, targeting the membrane‐bound enzyme fatty acid amide hydrolase (FAAH), using a library of fluorinated fragments generated based on the different local environment of fluorine concept. The use of the recombinant fusion protein MBP‐FAAH and the design of compound 11 as a suitable novel fluorinated substrate analogue allowed n‐FABS screening to be efficiently performed using a very small amount of enzyme. Notably, we have identified 19 novel fragment hits that inhibit FAAH with a median effective concentration (IC₅₀) in the low mM –μM range. To the best of our knowledge, these results represent the first application of a ¹⁹F NMR fragment‐based functional assay to a membrane protein.     

Fragment‐Based Phenotypic Lead Discovery: Cell‐Based Assay to Target Leishmaniasis

A rapid and practical approach for the discovery of new chemical matter for targeting pathogens and diseases is described. Fragment‐based phenotypic lead discovery (FPLD) combines aspects of traditional fragment‐based lead discovery (FBLD), which involves the screening of small‐molecule fragment libraries to target specific proteins, with phenotypic lead discovery (PLD), which typically involves the screening of drug‐like compounds in cell‐based assays. To enable FPLD, a diverse library of fragments was first designed, assembled, and curated. This library of soluble, low‐molecular‐weight compounds was then pooled to expedite screening. Axenic cultures of Leishmania promastigotes were screened, and single hits were then tested for leishmanicidal activity against intracellular amastigote forms in infected murine bone‐marrow‐derived macrophages without evidence of toxicity toward mammalian cells. These studies demonstrate that FPLD can be a rapid and effective means to discover hits that can serve as leads for further medicinal chemistry purposes or as tool compounds for identifying known or novel targets.     

One Question,Multiple Answers: Biochemical and Biophysical Screening Methods Retrieve Deviating Fragment Hit Lists

Fragment‐based lead discovery is gaining momentum in drug development. Typically, a hierarchical cascade of several screening techniques is consulted to identify fragment hits which are then analyzed by crystallography. Because crystal structures with bound fragments are essential for the subsequent hit‐to‐lead‐to‐drug optimization, the screening process should distinguish reliably between binders and non‐binders. We therefore investigated whether different screening methods would reveal similar collections of putative binders. First we used a biochemical assay to identify fragments that bind to endothiapepsin, a surrogate for disease‐relevant aspartic proteases. In a comprehensive screening approach, we then evaluated our 361‐entry library by using a reporter‐displacement assay, saturation‐transfer difference NMR, native mass spectrometry, thermophoresis, and a thermal shift assay. While the combined results of these screening methods retrieve 10 of the 11 crystal structures originally predicted by the biochemical assay, the mutual overlap of individual hit lists is surprisingly low, highlighting that each technique operates on different biophysical principles and conditions.     

Perspectives on Inhibiting β‐Amyloid Aggregation through Structure‐Based Drug Design

Targeting β‐amyloid (Aβ) remains the most desired strategy in Alzheimer’s disease (AD) drug discovery research. Many peptides that specifically target Aβ aggregates are known, encompassing efforts from both industrial and academic research settings. However, in clinical terms, not much success has been gained with peptide research; in turn, small drug‐like molecules are already globally recognized as showing promise as an alternate approach. Aβ aggregation inhibitors are the most important part of the multifunctional drug design regimen for treating AD. Unfortunately, rational drug design approaches with small molecules are still in the initial stages. Herein we highlight, update, and elaborate on the structural anatomy of Aβ and known Aβ aggregation inhibitors in hopes of helping to optimize their use in structure‐based drug design approaches toward inhibitors with greater specificity. Furthermore, we present the first review of efforts to target a previously uncharacterized region of acetylcholinesterase: the N‐terminal 7–20 sub‐region, which was experimentally elucidated to participate in Aβ aggregation and deposition.     

Fueling Open‐Source Drug Discovery: 177 Small‐Molecule Leads against Tuberculosis

With the aim of fuelling open‐source, translational, early‐stage drug discovery activities, the results of the recently completed antimycobacterial phenotypic screening campaign against Mycobacterium bovis BCG with hit confirmation in M. tuberculosis H37Rv were made publicly accessible. A set of 177 potent non‐cytotoxic H37Rv hits was identified and will be made available to maximize the potential impact of the compounds toward a chemical genetics/proteomics exercise, while at the same time providing a plethora of potential starting points for new synthetic lead‐generation activities. Two additional drug‐discovery‐relevant datasets are included: a) a drug‐like property analysis reflecting the latest lead‐like guidelines and b) an early lead‐generation package of the most promising hits within the clusters identified.     

Alzheimer’s Disease: Identification and Development of β‐Secretase (BACE‐1) Binding Fragments and Inhibitors by Dynamic Ligation Screening (DLS)

The application of dynamic ligation screening (DLS), a methodology for fragment‐based drug discovery (FBDD), to the aspartic protease β‐secretase (BACE‐1) is reported. For this purpose, three new fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) substrates were designed and synthesized. Their kinetic parameters (V_max, K_M, and k_cat) were determined and compared with a commercial substrate. Secondly, a peptide aldehyde was designed as a chemically reactive inhibitor (CRI) based on the Swedish mutation substrate sequence. Incubation of this CRI with the protease, a FRET substrate, and one amine per well taken from an amine library, which was assembled by a maximum common substructure (MCS) approach, revealed the fragment 3‐(3‐aminophenyl)‐2H‐chromen‐2‐one ( 1 ) to be a competitive BACE‐1 inhibitor that enhanced the activity of the CRI. Irreversibly formed fragment combination products of 1 with the initial peptide sequence were active and confirmed the targeting of the active site through the ethane‐1,2‐diamine isostere. Finally, structure‐assisted combination of fragment 1 with secondary fragments that target the S1 site in hit optimization yielded novel, entirely fragment‐based BACE‐1 inhibitors with up to 30‐fold improved binding affinity. Interactions with the protein were explained by molecular modeling studies, which indicate that the new fragment combinations interact with the catalytic aspartic acid dyad, as well as with the adjacent binding sites required for potency.     

Discovery of Plasmepsin Inhibitors by Fragment‐Based Docking and Consensus Scoring

Plasmepsins (PMs) are essential proteases of the plasmodia parasites and are therefore promising targets for developing drugs against malaria. We have discovered six inhibitors of PM II by high‐throughput fragment‐based docking of a diversity set of ～40 000 molecules, and consensus scoring with force field energy functions. Using the common scaffold of the three most active inhibitors (IC₅₀=2–5 μM ), another seven inhibitors were identified by substructure search. Furthermore, these 13 inhibitors belong to at least three different classes of compounds. The in silico approach was very effective since a total of 13 active compounds were discovered by testing only 59 molecules in an enzymatic assay. This hit rate is about one to two orders of magnitude higher than those reported for medium‐ and high‐throughput screening techniques in vitro. Interestingly, one of the inhibitors identified by docking was halofantrine, an antimalarial drug of unknown mechanism. Explicit water molecular dynamics simulations were used to discriminate between two putative binding modes of halofantrine in PM II.     

Pharmacology of Free Fatty Acid Receptors and Their Allosteric Modulators

The physiological function of free fatty acids (FFAs) has long been regarded as indirect in terms of their activities as educts and products in metabolic pathways. The observation that FFAs can also act as signaling molecules at FFA receptors (FFARs), a family of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs), has changed the understanding of the interplay of metabolites and host responses. Free fatty acids of different chain lengths and saturation statuses activate FFARs as endogenous agonists via binding at the orthosteric receptor site. After FFAR deorphanization, researchers from the pharmaceutical industry as well as academia have identified several ligands targeting allosteric sites of FFARs with the aim of developing drugs to treat various diseases such as metabolic, (auto)inflammatory, infectious, endocrinological, cardiovascular, and renal disorders. GPCRs are the largest group of transmembrane proteins and constitute the most successful drug targets in medical history. To leverage the rich biology of this target class, the drug industry seeks alternative approaches to address GPCR signaling. Allosteric GPCR ligands are recognized as attractive modalities because of their auspicious pharmacological profiles compared to orthosteric ligands. While the majority of marketed GPCR drugs interact exclusively with the orthosteric binding site, allosteric mechanisms in GPCR biology stay medically underexploited, with only several allosteric ligands currently approved. This review summarizes the current knowledge on the biology of FFAR1 (GPR40), FFAR2 (GPR43), FFAR3 (GPR41), FFAR4 (GPR120), and GPR84, including structural aspects of FFAR1, and discusses the molecular pharmacology of FFAR allosteric ligands as well as the opportunities and challenges in research from the perspective of drug discovery.     

Design and Generation of Highly Diverse Fluorinated Fragment Libraries and their Efficient Screening with Improved 19F NMR Methodology

Fragment screening performed with ¹⁹F NMR spectroscopy is becoming increasingly popular in drug discovery projects. With this approach, libraries of fluorinated fragments are first screened using the direct‐mode format of the assay. The choice of fluorinated motifs present in the library is fundamental in order to ensure a large coverage of chemical space and local environment of fluorine (LEF). Mono‐ and poly‐fluorinated fragments to be included in the libraries for screening are selected from both in‐house and commercial collections, and those that are ad hoc designed and synthesized. Additional fluorinated motifs to be included in the libraries derive from the fragmentation of compounds in development and launched on the market, and compounds contained in other databases (such as Integrity, PDB and ChEMBL). Complex mixtures of highly diverse fluorine motifs can be rapidly screened and deconvoluted in the same NMR tube with a novel on the fly combined procedure for the identification of the active molecule(s). Issues and problems encountered in the design, generation and screening of diverse fragment libraries of fluorinated compounds with ¹⁹F NMR spectroscopy are analyzed and technical solutions are provided to overcome them. The versatile screening methodology described here can be efficiently applied in laboratories with limited NMR setup and could potentially lead to the increasing role of ¹⁹F NMR in the hit identification and lead optimization phases of drug discovery projects.     

A Detailed Study of Antibacterial 3‐Acyltetramic Acids and 3‐Acylpiperidine‐2,4‐diones

Inspired by the core fragment of antibacterial natural products such as streptolydigin, 3‐acyltetramic acids and 3‐acylpiperidine‐2,4‐diones have been synthesised from the core heterocycle by direct acylation with the substituted carboxylic acids using a strategy which permits ready access to a structurally diverse compound library. The antibacterial activity of these systems has been established against a panel of Gram‐positive and Gram‐negative bacteria, with activity mostly against the former, which in some cases is very potent. Data consistent with modes of action against undecaprenylpyrophosphate synthase (UPPS) and/or RNA polymerase (RNAP) for a small subset of the library has been obtained. The most active compounds have been shown to exhibit binding at known binding sites of streptolydigin and myxopyronin at UPPS and RNAP. These systems offer potential for their antibacterial activity, and further demonstrate the use of natural products as biologically validated starting points for drug discovery.     

Repositioning the Substrate Activity Screening (SAS) Approach as a Fragment‐Based Method for Identification of Weak Binders

Fragment‐based drug discovery (FBDD) has evolved into an established approach for “hit” identification. Typically, most applications of FBDD depend on specialised cost‐ and time‐intensive biophysical techniques. The substrate activity screening (SAS) approach has been proposed as a relatively cheap and straightforward alternative for identification of fragments for enzyme inhibitors. We have investigated SAS for the discovery of inhibitors of oncology target urokinase (uPA). Although our results support the key hypotheses of SAS, we also encountered a number of unreported limitations. In response, we propose an efficient modified methodology: “MSAS” (modified substrate activity screening). MSAS circumvents the limitations of SAS and broadens its scope by providing additional fragments and more coherent SAR data. As well as presenting and validating MSAS, this study expands existing SAR knowledge for the S1 pocket of uPA and reports new reversible and irreversible uPA inhibitor scaffolds.     

A Fragment‐Based Approach to Probing Adenosine Recognition Sites by Using Dynamic Combinatorial Chemistry

A new strategy that combines the concepts of fragment‐based drug design and dynamic combinatorial chemistry (DCC) for targeting adenosine recognition sites on enzymes is reported. We demonstrate the use of 5′‐deoxy‐5′‐thioadenosine as a noncovalent anchor fragment in dynamic combinatorial libraries templated by Mycobacterium tuberculosis pantothenate synthetase. A benzyl disulfide derivative was identified upon library analysis by HPLC. Structural and binding studies of protein–ligand complexes by X‐ray crystallography and isothermal titration calorimetry informed the subsequent optimisation of the DCC hit into a disulfide containing the novel meta‐nitrobenzyl fragment that targets the pantoate binding site of pantothenate synthetase. Given the prevalence of adenosine‐recognition motifs in enzymes, our results provide a proof‐of‐concept for using this strategy to probe adjacent pockets for a range of adenosine binding enzymes, including other related adenylate‐forming ligases, kinases, and ATPases, as well as NAD(P)(H), CoA and FAD(H₂) binding proteins.     

The Cell Surface Receptor CD44: NMR‐Based Characterization of Putative Ligands

The cell surface receptor CD44 is a glycoprotein belonging to the hyaluronan‐binding proteins, termed hyaladherins. CD44 is expressed in a wide variety of isoforms in many cells and, in particular, is present on the surface of malignant cells where it is involved in the onset and progression of cancer. In a first attempt to identify novel CD44‐binding agents, we first characterized, with NMR spectroscopic techniques, several agents that were reported to bind to human CD44 (hCD44). To our surprise, however, none of these putative CD44‐binding agents, including a peptide that is in phase 2 clinical trials (A6 peptide) and a recently reported fragment hit, were found to interact significantly with recombinant hCD44(21–178). Nonetheless, we further report that a fragment‐screening campaign, with solution NMR spectroscopy as the detection method, identified a viable fragment hit that bound in a potentially functional pocket on the surface of CD44, opposite to the hyaluronic acid binding site. We hypothesize that this pocket could be indirectly associated with the cellular and in vivo activity of the A6 peptide, which would provide a novel framework for the possible development of therapeutically viable CD44 antagonists.     

Activity‐Based Protein Profiling: Recent Advances in Probe Development and Applications

The completion of the human genome sequencing project has provided a wealth of new information regarding the genomic blueprint of the cell. Although, to date, there are roughly 20 000 genes in the human genome, the functions of only a handful of proteins are clear. The major challenge lies in translating genomic information into an understanding of their cellular functions. The recently developed activity‐based protein profiling (ABPP) is an unconventional approach that is complementary for gene expression analysis and an ideal utensil in decoding this overflow of genomic information. This approach makes use of synthetic small molecules that covalently modify a set of related proteins and subsequently facilitates identification of the target protein, enabling rapid biochemical analysis and inhibitor discovery. This tutorial review introduces recent advances in the field of ABPP and its applications.     

Merging Allosteric and Active Site Binding Motifs: De novo Generation of Target Selectivity and Potency via Natural‐Product‐Derived Fragments

The de novo design of molecules from scratch with tailored biological activity is still the major intellectual challenge in chemical biology and drug discovery. Herein we validate natural‐product‐derived fragments (NPDFs) as excellent molecular seeds for the targeted de novo discovery of lead structures for the modulation of therapeutically relevant proteins. The application of this de novo approach delivered, in synergy with the combination of allosteric and active site binding motifs, highly selective and ligand‐efficient non‐zinc‐binding ( 3 : 4‐{[5‐(2‐{[(3‐methoxyphenyl)methyl]carbamoyl}eth‐1‐yn‐1‐yl)‐2,4‐dioxo‐1,2,3,4‐tetrahydropyrimidin‐1‐yl]methyl}benzoic acid) as well as zinc‐binding ( 4 : 4‐({5‐[2‐({[3‐(3‐carboxypropoxy)phenyl]methyl}carbamoyl)eth‐1‐yn‐1‐yl]‐2,4‐dioxo‐1,2,3,4‐tetrahydropyrimidin‐1‐yl}methyl)benzoic acid) uracil‐based MMP‐13 inhibitors presenting IC₅₀ values of 11 nM ( 3 : LE=0.35) and 6 nM ( 4 : LE=0.31).     

A Cactus‐Derived Toxin‐Like Cystine Knot Peptide with Selective Antimicrobial Activity

Naturally occurring cystine knot peptides show a wide range of biological activity, and as they have inherent stability they represent potential scaffolds for peptide‐based drug design and biomolecular engineering. Here we report the discovery, sequencing, chemical synthesis, three‐dimensional solution structure determination and bioactivity of the first cystine knot peptide from Cactaceae (cactus) family: Ep‐AMP1 from Echinopsis pachanoi. The structure of Ep‐AMP1 (35 amino acids) conforms to that of the inhibitor cystine knot (or knottin) family but represents a novel diverse sequence; its activity was more than 500 times higher against bacterial than against eukaryotic cells. Rapid bactericidal action and liposome leakage implicate membrane permeabilisation as the mechanism of action. Sequence homology places Ec‐AMP1 in the plant C6‐type of antimicrobial peptides, but the three dimensional structure is highly similar to that of a spider neurotoxin.     

Fragment-Based Drug Discovery for RNA Targets

Rapid development within the fields of both fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) and medicinal targeting of RNA provides possibilities for combining technologies and methods in novel ways. This review provides an overview of fragment-based screening (FBS) against RNA targets, including a discussion of the most recently used screening and hit validation methods such as NMR spectroscopy, X-ray crystallography, and virtual screening methods. A discussion of fragment library design based on research from small-molecule RNA binders provides an overview on both the currently limited guidelines within RNA-targeting fragment library design, and future possibilities. Finally, future perspectives are provided on screening and hit validation methods not yet used in combination with both fragment screening and RNA targets.