Variation of cardinal growth parameters and growth limits according to phylogenetic affiliation in the Bacillus cereus Group. Consequences for risk assessment

The growth rates of strains covering the seven major phylogenetic groups of Bacillus cereus sensu lato (as defined by Guinebretiere et al., 2008) at a range of temperature (7 °C–55 °C), pH (4.6–7.5) and a_w (0.929–0.996, with 0.5%–10% NaCl as humectant) were determined. Growth rates were fitted by non-linear regression to determine the cardinal parameters T_min, T_opt, T_max, pH_min, pH_opt, a_wmin and μ_opt. We showed that cardinal parameters reflected the differences in the temperature adaptation observed between B. cereus phylogenetic groups I to VII. The ability of growing at low pH (up to 4.3) or low a_w (from a_w 0.929 and up to 10% NaCl) varied among strains. The strains of groups III and VII, the most tolerant to heat, were also the most adapted to high NaCl (all strains growing at 8% NaCl) and the ones of groups I and VI the least adapted (no growth at 7% NaCl). All strains of groups II and VII were able to grow at pH 4.6, and only a few strains of group VI. Phenotypic differences between the two psychrotrophic groups II and VI were revealed by contrasted acid and salt tolerance. The cardinal values determined in this work were validated by comparing with cardinal parameters of a panel of strains published elsewhere and with predictions of growth in a range of foods.