Metrological role of neutron activation analysis. IA. Inherent characteristics of relative INAA as a primary ratio method of measurement

In a series of three papers, the inherent characteristics of relative instrumental neutron activation analysis (INAA) as a primary ratio method of measurement, the unique functions of parametric INAA as an ideal back-up method of the relative INAA, and the valuable role of INAA in characterization of sampling behavior of individual elements in certified reference materials (CRMs) will be discussed. In this paper, the first of the series, the uncertainty evaluation and the traceability of values measured by neutron activation analysis (NAA), especially instrumental NAA (INAA), will be described to demonstrate the method at its ”the state-of-the-art” level can meet CCQM criteria for a primary ratio method. The scope and examples will be given. Received: 19 March 2001 Accepted: 2 October 2001     

Nuclear analytical methods in quality control of microanalysis

Quantitative calibration and quality control have been a major bottleneck in microanalysis due to the lack of natural-matrix CRMs certified at sample sizes compatible with those of unknown samples. In this paper, a solution is described to characterize sampling behavior for individual elements, so as to identify elements homogeneous enough at stated sample size levels in given CRMs/RMs. By using a combination of several nuclear analytical techniques, INAA-EDXRF-μPIXE, sampling behavior for individual elements can be characterized at sample size levels from grams down to pg. Natural-matrix CRMs specifically for QC of microanalysis may thus be created. Additional information in certificates of these new generation CRMs is imagined. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Estimating the uncertainty of stability for matrix CRMs

The new version of ISO Guide 34 requires producers of certified reference materials (CRMs) to include contributions of possible instability to the overall CRM uncertainty, to obtain a value for the uncertainty in compliance with the Guide to the Expression of the Uncertainty in Measurement (GUM). A pragmatic approach to estimating the uncertainty of stability is presented. It relies on regression analysis of stability data with subsequent testing of the slope of the regression line for significance. If the slope is found to be statistically insignificant, a shelf life is chosen and the uncertainty connected with this time is estimated via the standard deviation of the slope. This uncertainty is included in the overall uncertainty of the CRM. This approach is explained with examples showing its applicability to matrix CRMs. Received: 12 October 2000 / Revised: 2 January 2001 / Accepted: 3 January 2001     

Implementing the GUM in the certification of reference materials: the revision of ISO Guide 35

The availability of certified reference materials, certified in accordance to the GUM is an important tool for the proper estimation of measurement uncertainty in routine analysis. Many CRMs may suffer from incomplete or wrongly estimated uncertainties, mainly due to lack of guidance on how to implement the GUM in the production of CRMs. In particular the inclusion of the impact of inhomogeneity and instability in the uncertainty budget is often missing. The ongoing revision of ISO Guide 35 aims to fill this gap in providing guidance how (batch) inhomogeneity and instability can be translated into measurement uncertainty. The structure of the current ISO Guide 35 has been maintained as far as possible, but major parts underwent revision to become better aligned with GUM and ISO Guide 34 (2000). Received: 9 April 2001 Accepted: 22 October 2001     

Certified reference materials as a quality tool in food control: much used—often misused—sometimes abused

Certified reference materials (CRMs) are important tools in the quality control of food analyses. There are, however, many ways in which CRMs can be abused and misused. It can be due to ignorance, as well as to overuse of expensive materials. The major drawback of CRMs is probably that the analyst knows the level of the analyte. The statistical evaluation of CRM results in reports and publications is often limited to a comparison between the found and the certified levels, which yields little, and sometimes erroneous, information. Recoveries based on CRMs often give a picture that is far too bright, with little consideration of uncertainties. The way the use of CRMs is described in most scientific journals is often very crude and shows that CRMs are seldom used to their full capacity. The objective of this paper is to try to summarise the ways in which a CRM can be misused and thereby put into focus how to make better use of such materials. It also gives examples on how to evaluate CRMs, using a procedure that was recently introduced by the Nordic Committee on Food Analysis.     

Role of NAA in the characterization of sampling behaviors of multiple elements in CRMs

Taking the advantage of the high precision and accuracy of neutron activation analysis (NAA), sampling constants have been determined for multielements in several international and Chinese reference materials. The suggested technique may be used for finding elements in existing CRMs qualified for quality control (QC) of small size samples (several mg or less), and characterizing sampling behaviors of multielements in new CRMs specifically made for QC of microanalysis.     

Matrix certified reference materials for environmental monitoring from the National Metrology Institute of Japan (NMIJ)

Matrix certified reference materials (CRMs) are playing an increasingly important role in environmental monitoring in Japan. The National Metrology Institute of Japan (NMIJ)/National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST) has been developing matrix CRMs for environmental monitoring since 2001, and has issued nine kinds of CRMs as NMIJ CRMs. The development of the CRMs was conducted in NMIJ in cooperation with candidate material producers. The isotope dilution mass spectrometry (IDMS) was principally adopted to give reliable certified values. Meanwhile, two or more analytical methods, whose levels of accuracy were well evaluated, were applied to avoid any possible analytical bias. Two typical certification processes, the certification of river water CRMs for trace element analysis and that of marine sediment CRMs for PCB and organochlorine pesticide analysis, are outlined as examples. Presented at -- “BERM-10” -- April 2006, Charleston, SC, USA.     

Synthesis of no-carrier-added 6-[11C]methyl-l-DOPA

Taking advantages of nuclear analytical techniques (NATs) with non-destruction, multielement capability, small and estimable uncertainties over a wide range of sample sizes, the sampling behavior of multielements for a home-made natural matrix material was studied with sample sizes ranging from several hundred mg down to tenths ng, namely nine orders of magnitude, by a combination of three NATs, neutron activation analysis (NAA), proton induced X-ray emission (PIXE) and synchrotron radiation X-ray flurescence (SR-XRF), in an effort to explore a procedure for the development of certified reference materials (CRMs) suitable for quality control of microanalysis. For accurately weighable sample sizes (>1?mg), sampling uncertainties for 13 elements were found to be less than 1% by INAA. For sample sizes unable to be accurately weighed (<1?mg), PIXE and SR-XRF were used, respectively. Sampling uncertainties were found to be less than 1% at sample sizes of tenth mg level for seven elements, and less than 10% on ng levels for three elements. Considering these three elements have satisfied homogeneity (sampling uncertainty less than 10%) at ng sample size level, any one of them can be served as a ??relative balance?? in sampling behavior characterization of multielements on sample size levels larger than ng (e.g., ??g level). On this basis, sampling uncertainties for nine elements were found to be less than 10% on ??g sample size level by INAA. The results indicate that the matrix is eligible as a candidate of CRMs suitable for quality control of solid sampling microanalysis.     

The deplorable state of the description of the use of certified reference materials in the literature.

A detailed survey of 26 scientific journals showed that journal editors and a majority of authors of the re- c viewed papers seem unconcerned by the importance of correctly reporting their use of certified reference materials (CRMs). Only around 55% of the abstracts surveyed mention the use of CRMs described in these papers. This, however, is of key importance as the abstract of a paper is most widely available in electronic media. Many authors mentioned the use of CRMs in passing, often in incomplete form and without giving any details of the results obtained. Some are confused about the source of the reference material used, as they fail to report the type or the producer of CRMs applied. Others use materials that do not match the samples analyzed or do not see the need to use any CRM, despite the availability of suitable materials. Even in cases where correct data were given for type and producer of the CRMs, frequently the proper use and statistical evaluation are questionable. To improve this situation it is necessary that publishers should give recommendations where and how the use of CRMs should be described.     

Proficiency test on the determination of mineral oil from polluted soils

Mineral oil products are abundant sources of environmental contamination. A Finnishproficiency test was carried out to investigate the quality of data provided in an analysis of mineral oil in polluted soils. The homogeneity and stability of the samples were tested. The calculated concentration or the median value of the results was used as the assigned value because of the unavailability of certified reference materials (CRMs). The samples were analysed using an infrared spectroscopy (IR) or gas chromatography (GC) procedure. Even if the participating laboratories had little experience with GC, the results were promising. Hence, the GC procedure will replace IR as the new ISO standard (ISO/DIS 16703) in the near future in many Finnish environmental laboratories. There is a need for CRMs for the determination of mineral oil using the GC method due to common contamination problems caused by mineral oil. Received: 9 December 2001 Accepted: 14 February 2002     

Trends in certified reference materials for the speciation of trace elements.

The measurement of the chemical species of elements (instead of the total element concentration) has become an irreversible trend in analytical chemistry. The motivation lies in the fact that the biochemical and geochemical behaviour of an element is governed by its species. Quality assurance of the analytical procedures used for speciation analysis requires the analysis of representative reference materials, certified for the relevant species. Up to now the number of existing certified reference materials for trace element species is very limited. The most important ones are environmental CRMs certified for trialkyltin compounds, methylmercury, Cr(III)/Cr(VI) and food CRMs certified for arsenic species and methylmercury. Major developments are to be expected in CRMs focussed on environmental problems, including waste treatment, on bioavailability of trace elements in food and on bio-monitoring in occupational health and hygiene. It is, however, unlikely that the producers of CRMs will ever be able to cover all needs. Add to this that many, very active species are notoriously unstable and/or short living and require in-situ analysis. This will lead to different analytical developments, such as analyses in-situ, where the classical concept of CRMs may not stand firm anymore.     

Harmonized protocol and certified reference material for the determination of extractable contents of phosphorus in freshwater sediments – A synthesis of recent works

An analytical protocol for the determination of the extractable phosphorus contents in freshwater sediments has been harmonized through interlaboratory studies in the frame of the Standards Measurements and Testing Program of the European Commission. A homogeneous and stable sediment reference material has been prepared and certified on the basis of this protocol named SMT protocol, and will be available in spring of 2001. The SMT protocol, together with the reference material, are useful tools in the field of water management, especially at a time when quality assurance and data comparability are of paramount importance in laboratory analysis. The knowledge of the bioavailable forms of phosphorus is important not only for sediments but also for sludge and soils. Therefore, the SMT protocol could be extended to these materials and new CRMs could be prepared. The SMT protocol was used in a study of a reservoir, which allowed to calculate the P stock, therefore helping to predict the restoration delay of the lake. The paper describes the protocol and the CRM, and gives a brief outline of the case study. Received: 14 November 2000 / Revised: 25 January 2001 / Accepted: 31 January 2001     

A new certified reference material for benzene measurement in air on a sorbent tube: development and proficiency testing

A certified matrix reference material (CRM) for the measurement of benzene in ambient air has been developed at Laboratoire National de Métrologie et d’Essais. The production of these CRMs was conducted using a gravimetric method fully traceable to the International System of Units. The CRMs were prepared by sampling an accurate mass of a gaseous primary reference material of benzene, using a high-precision laminar flowmeter and a mass flow controller, with a PerkinElmer sampler filled with Carbopack™ X sorbent. The relative standard deviations obtained for the preparation of a batch of 20 tubes loaded with 500 ng of benzene were below 0.2%. Each CRM is considered independent from the others and with its own certified value and an expanded uncertainty estimated to be within 0.5%, lower than the uncertainties of benzene CRMs already available worldwide. The stability of these materials was also established up to 12 months. These CRMs were implemented during proficiency testing, to evaluate the analytical performances of seven French laboratories involved in benzene air monitoring.     

Validation of mercury determination by solid sampling Zeeman atomic absorption spectrometry and a specially designed furnace

Certified reference materials (CRMs) of different origin were used to validate the direct determination of total mercury by solid sampling Zeeman atomic absorption spectrometry (SS-ZAAS) and a specially designed furnace. The temperature program provides only for one step. Atomisation of mercury and pyrolysis of the matrix is performed at a constant temperature in the range of 900–1000 °C. Calibration points achieved by CRMs and aqueous solutions are covered by one calibration line, indicating the absence of matrix effects. Relatively high amounts of chlorine, known for causing problems in mercury determination do not influence analytical results. The excellent accuracy of the method results in a very good agreement with the certified values. The precision of SS-ZAAS measurements in a range from 0.5 to 50 ng Hg does not exceed 3% R.S.D. A limit of quantification of 0.008 μg g⁻¹ Hg was achieved.     

Certified reference materials for inorganic and organic contaminants in environmental matrices

Chemical measurements often constitute the basis for informed decision-making at different levels in society; sound decision-making is possible only if the quality of the data used is uncompromised. To guarantee the reliability and comparability of analytical data an intricate system of quality-assurance measures has to be put into effect in a laboratory. Reference materials and, in particular, certified reference materials (CRMs) are essential for achieving traceability and comparability of measurement results between laboratories and over time. As in any other domain of analytical chemistry, techniques used to monitor the levels and fate of contaminants in the environment must be calibrated using appropriate calibration materials, and the methods must be properly validated using fit-for-purpose matrix-matched CRMs, to ensure confidence in the data produced. A sufficiently large number of matrix CRMs are available for analysis of most elements, and the group of chemicals known as persistent organic pollutants, in environmental compartments and biota. The wide variety of analyte/level/matrix/matrix property combinations available from several suppliers enables analysts to select CRMs which sufficiently match the properties of the samples they analyse routinely. Materials value-assigned for the so-called emerging pollutants are scarce at the moment, though an objective of current development programmes of CRM suppliers is to overcome this problem.     

NAA Study on Homogeneity of Reference Materials and their Suitability for Microanalytical Techniques

Homogeneity of the existing (Virginia Tobacco Leaves CTA-VTL-2 (ICHTJ), Apatite Concentrate CTA-AC-1 (ICHTJ), Fine Fly Ash CTA-FFA-1 (ICHTJ) and candidate certified reference materials (CRMs) (IAEA-338 Lichen, IAEA-413 Algae, Spruce Shoots RMF II (Germany)) was studied by neutron activation analysis (NAA). Several samples of small mass (ca. 1 or 10 mg) taken from various containers were analyzed by instrumental NAA and the results for several elements were compared by Fisher's test and t-test with analogous series of results for samples taken from one container. In the second approach, sampling variance was estimated for some elements from overall variance and the components of analytical variance. The results were interpreted with the aid of Ingamells' sampling constant. Particle size distribution of the reference materials was also measured by several techniques. In addition quantitative determinations for some elements were performed and results compared with the certified values. The results of the present study were discussed with reference to suitability of CRMs to microanalytical techniques. It was pointed out that the term "microanalysis" itself is not always unequivocally understood and used.     

Certified reference materials for the quality control of environmental analysis within the standards,measurements and testing programme (formerly BCR)

A great number of analyses is performed every year, the results of which are used for many purposes, e.g. the quality of goods and food, the status of quality of the environment or the health of patients. The accuracy of these results is a prerequisite for a good interpretation of the data obtained. One of the most powerful tool for achieving quality control of chemical analysis is to use reference materials (RMs) and certified reference materials (CRMs). These materials are necessary for one or more of the following items: method validation (CRMs), monitoring of the state of statistical control (RMs), samples in inter-comparisons (RMs), etc. The requirements and use of RMs and CRMs in chemical analysis are described, with special emphasis on environmental analysis, and some examples of environmental materials currently in production within the Standards, Measurements and Testing Programme (formerly BCR) of the European Commission are given.     

Production of certified reference materials for the detection of genetically modified organisms

Certified reference materials (CRMs) are an essenIial tool in the quality assurance of analytical measurements. They are produced, certified, and used in accordance with relevant ISO (International Organization for Standardization) and BCR (Community Bureau of Reference) guidelines. The Institute for Reference Materials and Measurements (IRMM; Geel, Belgium) has produced the first powdery genetically modified organism (GMO) CRMs in cooperation with the Institute for Health and Consumer Protection (Ispra, Italy). Until now, different weight percentages in the range of 0-5% for 4 GMOs in Europe were produced and certified: Bt (Bacillus thuringiensis)-11 and Bt-176 maize, Roundup Ready soybean, and MON810 maize. Bt-11 and Bt-176 maize and Roundup Ready soybean were produced by IRMM on behalf of Fluka Chemie AG (Buchs, Switzerland). Characterization of used base material is the first step in production and is especially important for GMO CRMs. The production of powdery GMO CRMs and methods used for production control are described. Thorough control of homogeneity and stability are essential for certification of reference materials and ensure validity of the certificate for each bottle of a batch throughout a defined shelf-life. Because production of reference materials and their maintenance are very labor- and cost-intensive tasks, the usefulness of new types of GMO CRMs must be estimated carefully.     

A mussel tissue certified reference material for multiple phycotoxins. Part 1: design and preparation

The development of multi-analyte methods for lipophilic shellfish toxins based on liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry permits rapid screening and analysis of samples for a wide variety of toxins in a single run. Validated methods and appropriate certified reference materials (CRMs) are required to ensure accuracy of results. CRMs are essential for accurate instrument calibration, for assessing the complete analytical method from sample extraction to data analysis and for verifying trueness. However, CRMs have hitherto only been available for single toxin groups. Production of a CRM containing six major toxin groups was achieved through an international collaboration. Preparation of this material, CRM-FDMT1, drew on information from earlier studies as well as improved methods for isolation of toxins, handling bulk tissues and production of reference materials. Previous investigations of stabilisation techniques indicated freeze-drying to be a suitable procedure for preparation of shellfish toxin reference materials and applicable to a wide range of toxins. CRM-FDMT1 was initially prepared as a bulk wet tissue homogenate containing domoic acid, okadaic acid, dinophysistoxins, azaspiracids, pectenotoxin-2, yessotoxin and 13-desmethylspirolide C. The homogenate was then freeze-dried, milled and bottled in aliquots suitable for distribution and analysis. The moisture content and particle size distribution were measured, and determined to be appropriate. A preliminary toxin analysis of the final material showed a comprehensive toxin profile.     

Intercomparison and certification of some Chinese and international food and biological matrix CRMs for several uncertified ultratrace elements by NAA

Radiochemical neutron activation analysis was used for determinationsof 8 rare earth elements (La, Ce, Nd, Sm, Eu, Tb, Yb and Lu) in two ChineseCRMs, GBW 08503 (wheat) and GBW 09101 (hair), and Cs, Sr, Th and U in fiveNIST SRMs, 1548 (Total Diet), 1486 (Bone Meal), 8414 (Bovine Muscle), 1566a(Oyster Powder) and 1575 (Pine Needles). These determinations are for eventualcertification of above ultratrace elements so far not certified. The radiochemicalseparation scheme used in RNAA of NIST SRMs is an anion exchange followedby the co-precipitation by (REE)F 3 for U and Th, and a SrSO 4 precipitationfor Sr and Cs. For RNAA of the two Chinese CRMs, a one step (REE)F 3 precipitationwas used. Chemical yields were determined for all relevant elements by tracerexperiments. All these materials were also analyzed by ICPMS, that offeredan opportunity to compare the two major trace analytical techniques on theirmerits and drawbacks for these particular cases. RNAA is proven to be oneof the important techniques in ultratrace analysis, especially in certificationof some ultratrace elements. Determination of elements in sub-ng/g level isstill an area to be further investigated because: (1) some such elements areimportant in food and health related environmental studies, (2) many of theseelements have no (or very few) certified values in existing biological CRMs,(3) reliable techniques qualified for ultratrace analysis are needed to beestablished, and (4) sampling behavior of elements at these levels is stillnot very well known (recommended minimum sample size may not be adequate).