Fracture through the physeal scar of the femoral head in the setting of osteonecrosis in an adult: a case report

Slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) in the skeletally mature patient is rare. We present a rare case of a fracture through the physeal scar of a skeletally mature patient after a trivial injury, with pre-existing osteonecrosis of the femoral neck and metadiaphysis with sparing of the femoral head.     

Transphyseal osseous bridges in experimental osteonecrosis of the femoral head of the rat. Histologic study of the bony bridges connecting the epiphyseal with the metaphyseal bony trabeculae through gaps in the physeal cartilage

In view of the lifelong persistence of the physis, the femoral head of rats may serve to model Perthes disease and slipped capital femoral epiphysis. To produce osteonecrosis, the blood supply of one femoral head of 133, 6-month-old animals was severed by circumferentially incising the periosteum of the neck and cutting the ligamentum teres. The rats were killed 7 days to 90 days postoperatively. Associated with resorption of the necrotic bone and marrow, remodeling of the epiphysis was characterized by an ingrowth of vascularized fibrous tissue, formation of new bone and some cartilage, architectural deformation and flattening of the head. In 22 of 83 rats killed 30 days or more postoperatively, gaps in the continuity of the physeal cartilage were occupied by osseous bridges, connecting newly formed epiphyseal bony trabeculae with either the preexisting or newly formed metaphyseal osseous trabeculae. This healing mode may follow ischemic death of physeal chondrocytes or be owing to another mechanism, e.g., release of mediatory substances of inflammation. These findings raise the possibility that fixation of the healing epiphysis of a child's previously necrotic femoral head to the metaphysis occurs by transphyseal osseous growth in cases in which the physis is involved in the necrotic process.     

Subkapitale Korrekturosteotomie bei der Epiphyseolysis capitis femoris mittels chirurgischer Hüftluxation

OBJECTIVE: The aim of treatment of slipped capital femoral epiphysis is an anatomically aligned epiphysis with normal blood supply. This result can be achieved by open subcapital reorientation of the epiphysis or by a wedge osteotomy of the femoral neck. Other procedures have, so far, not gained optimal control over the risk of avascular necrosis. INDICATIONS: Acute epiphyseolysis. Chronic epiphyseolysis for which trimming of the metaphyseal overhang to permit free flexion and internal rotation without impingement would leave less than two thirds of the femoral neck diameter intact. CONTRAINDICATIONS: Ankylosis of the hip joint at an advanced stage. Destruction of the femoral head. SURGICAL TECHNIQUE: The blood supply to the epiphysis from the medial femoral circumflex artery can be preserved by surgical hip dislocation and a soft-tissue flap derived subperiosteally from the retinaculum and external rotators. This soft-tissue flap permits not only the detachment of the epiphysis, but also complete callus resection from the femoral neck without causing tension in the retinaculum. Dislocation of the femoral head ensures its manual protection during curettage of the epiphyseal plate and, ultimately, allows anatomic reduction under visual control of the retinaculum. With the head dislocated there is less risk to the integrity of the retinaculum due to unintentional manipulation of the leg than there would be, if the head remained in the socket. RESULTS: From 1996 to 2005, 30 hips with a diagnosis of slipped capital femoral epiphysis were treated according to the technique described. The average follow-up time was 55 months (24-96 months). Femoral head necrosis did not occur. Distribution across sexes was well balanced. Girls were 12 years old at the time of the operation and boys were 14 years old on average. Posterior displacement was measured at 30-70 degrees. In six hips there was a so-called acute on chronic slip. Two hips required revision due to screw failure, a difficulty that was addressed by the introduction of fully threaded wires. One hip had to be revised because the fully threaded wire bent. After reoperation, shortening of maximum 1 cm was seen in these three cases. In one patient with ectopic bone formation at the anteroinferior femoral neck, internal rotation in flexion is reduced by half.     

Ischemic necrosis of the femoral head: An experimental rabbit model

To describe the morphology of the proximal femoral epiphysis in a rabbit model from the ischemic insult to the end of the revascularization process. Ischemia of the femoral head was induced in 32 rabbits at the 8th day of life, by sectioning the joint capsule and the ligamentum teres and dislocating the femoral head. Rabbits were sacrificed at 4, 8, 12, 18, 21, 26, 34, and 48 days after surgery and femoral heads were observed histologically. During the first days following the ischemic injury, large areas underwent necrotic changes. Both epiphyseal and physeal cartilage were thicker than normal and less trabecular bone formation was evident. Bone marrow was also diffusely necrotic within the secondary center of ossification. After day 12th, reparative process started with formation of extensive areas of fibrocartilage and several secondary centers of ossifications. At that stage femoral head deformity was already evident. In the following days the secondary centers of ossification cohalesced and epiphyseal and physeal cartilage resumed a normal appearance, but the femur showed a permanent deformity. In newborn rabbits, the ischemic injury to the femoral head blocked the ossification of the epiphyseal and physeal cartilage associated to necrotic bone marrow within the secondary center of ossification of the femoral head as well as to extensive areas of necrosis of epiphyseal and physeal cartilage. Extensive areas of fibrocartilage and small newly formed ossification centers within the femoral epiphysis were the results of the revascularization process, and femoral head deformity became stable afterward. © 2015 Orthopaedic Research Society. Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Orthop Res 33:535–541, 2015.     

A histopathological study on the femoral head necrosis in spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR)]

The histopathological study was conducted in the femoral head of spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR), which had frequently manifested osteonecrosis and a delay in the ossification at the femoral epiphysis. In order to elucidate the course of necrosis and its repair process, the bone dynamic of the femoral head was investigated with bone fluorochrome labelling technique. Femoral epiphyses in the SHR were classified into five groups, according to their histopathological changes in relation to osteonecrosis, its repair process and the delay in ossification. Changes in the growing rate of the growth plate at the femoral head and neck were measured quantitatively. As a result, the articular cartilage remained viable and overgrowing, while the epiphyseal plates were affected by the necrosis and there was early physeal maturation occurred. It is concluded that SHR appear to be a useful experimental model for Perthes' disease.     

Radiological evaluation of unstable (acute) slipped capital femoral epiphysis treated by pinning with Kirschner wires

Treatment of slipped capital femoral epiphysis is still controversial with regard to the implants used for stabilization and the need for prophylactic treatment of the contralateral, unaffected, side. The objective of this study was to ascertain whether prophylactic transfixation of the epiphysis with Kirschner wires in patients with unstable slipped capital femoral epiphysis resulted in significant disturbance of the growth plate and impairment of further growth of the femoral neck and head. Between 1990 and 1999, 29 patients with unstable slipped capital femoral epiphysis were simultaneously treated with internal fixation of the epiphysis and metaphysis with 3-4 Kirschner wires on the affected and the not (yet) affected side. After a mean follow-up of 3.5 years, we evaluated the hip joints radiologically, analysing different roentgenological parameters (CCD angle, femoral head diameter, length of the femoral neck and sphericity of the femoral head). CCD angle, femoral head diameter and length of the femoral neck showed statistically significant (P<0.001, Student's t-test) differences between the affected and unaffected, but prophylactically pinned, sides. Asphericity of the femoral head was found in six cases only on the affected side, whereas all hips, which were operated prophylactically, showed spherical femoral heads at follow-up (P<0.02, Pearson's chi test). These results indicate that the slip itself may cause impairment of the femoral growth plate in patients with unstable slipped capital femoral epiphysis and not stabilization with Kirschner wires. Compared with other series from the literature using different implants (screws, nails), prophylactic transfixation of the epiphysis and metaphysis with Kirschner wires is less compromising to the growth plate on the not (yet) affected side.     

Physeal remodeling after internal fixation of slipped capital femoral epiphyses

Rounding off the femoral neck metaphysis helps improve hip function in slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE). Remodeling by physeal growth, not previously reported, may also contribute. By studing the changes in physeal-shaft angle after internal fixation (IF), we found evidence of physeal remodeling in one of 21 mild, five of 23 moderate, and in all of 11 severe slips. Although the amount of remodeling averaged 11.7 degrees, it occurred in 100% of severe slips (p less than 0.001). This support the use of initial pin fixation and a wait of at least 2 years before realignment femoral neck osteotomies are considered.     

Shear stress in epiphyseal growth plate is a risk factor for slipped capital femoral epiphysis

BACKGROUND: Slipping of the capital femoral epiphysis is an important orthopaedic problem of early adolescence. Many hypotheses about its etiology have been examined, yet the underlying mechanisms have not yet been fully elucidated. We examined elevated shear stress in the epiphyseal growth plate and elevated contact hip stress exerted on the femoral head as risk factors for slipping of the capital femoral epiphysis. METHODS: Two groups of hips were compared: a group of 100 hips contralateral to the slipped ones and a group of 70 age- and gender-matched healthy hips. The characteristics of individual hips were incorporated by means of geometrical parameters determined from standard anteroposterior radiographs. Shear stress was calculated by using a mathematical model where the femoral neck was considered to function as an elastic rod. Contact hip stress was calculated by the HIPSTRESS method. RESULTS: Hips contralateral to the slipped ones had higher average shear stress (0.81 vs 0.51 MPa; P < 0.001) and more vertically inclined physeal angle (55.4 vs 63.2 degrees.; P < 0.001) in comparison to healthy hips. Shear stress in the contralateral hips to the slipped ones remained significantly higher even when normalized to the body weight (1400 vs 1060 Pa/N; P < 0.001). There was no significant difference in the average contact hip stress (1.86 vs 1.74 MPa; P = 0.145). CONCLUSIONS: Elevated shear stress, but not elevated contact stress, is a risk factor for slipping of the capital femoral epiphysis. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III (prognostic study, case-control study).     

Shear strength of the physis varies with anatomic location and is a function of modulus, inclination, and thickness.

Slipped capital femoral epiphysis involves the gradual displacement of the femoral head relative to the neck. Many theories have arisen to explain this slip. Frequently cited etiological factors include increases in physeal thickness and inclination. Slipped epiphysis has been postulated to result from shear overload that causes separation through the hypertrophic cellular zone. We sought to answer the following questions: (a) Do significant regional differences in strength and stiffness exist within a given physis? (b) Are regional differences in resistance to shear related to thickness and inclination of the physis? (c) Does physeal compression cause mammillary interdigitation to begin sooner and increase the resistance to shear before, during, and after failure? (d) Does shear failure occur at displacements detectable by radiography? and (e) Does cleavage occur throughout the entire columnar zone, and do the chondrocyte columns remain intact on both sides of the cleavage plane? We prepared beam-shaped microstructural samples from different sites of the bovine proximal tibial physis. We determined thickness, inclination, ultimate stress and strain, modulus, and strain energy density at ultimate stress as a function of location. Using scanning electron microscopy, we also examined the entire failed surface of several samples. Forty-eight samples were tested by displacing the epiphysis end anteriorly, without axial (across the thickness) constraint; 41 were sheared while an average axial compressive stress of 0.3 MPa was applied to the physis. The posterior region had the greatest strength and stiffness, lowest physeal thickness, and steepest inclination. Compressing the plate did not increase the shear strength or tangent modulus. Ultimate strength varied inversely with thickness and increased when shearing up steeper inclinations; however, it was more strongly associated with the modulus, implying that additional factors control both strength and modulus. Scanning electron microscopy revealed that the plane of fracture differed widely between and within samples, involving all zones of the growth plate. On either side of the fracture, individual chondrocyte columns remained intact, although separated from neighboring columns.     

Slipped capital femoral epiphysis in skeletally immature patients

Fixation by a single screw is considered the current treatment of choice for a slipped capital femoral epiphysis. This approach promotes premature physeal closure. The use of a modified, standard, single, cannulated screw designed to maintain epiphyseal fixation without causing premature closure of the physis was reviewed in ten patients. The nine boys and one girl aged between 10.6 and 12.6 years with unilateral slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE), were markedly skeletally immature (Tanner stage I, bone age 10 to 12.6 years). Clinical and radiological review at a mean follow-up of 44.3 months (36 to 76) showed no difference in the time to physeal closure between the involved and uninvolved side. Measurement of epiphyseal and physeal development showed continued growth and remodelling in all patients. Use of this device provided epiphyseal stability and maintained the capacity for physeal recovery and growth following treatment for both unstable and stable slipped capital femoral epiphysis.     

Open bone graft epiphyseodesis for slipped capital femoral epiphysis

Seventeen patients underwent open bone graft epiphyseodesis for slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE); physeal fusion was achieved in 12 patients. Eight grafts either resorbed, moved, or fractured postoperatively (graft insufficiency). Graft insufficiency was statistically associated with failure of physeal fusion, (p = 0.009). Radiographic examination, using three different measurements, corroborated postoperative changes in femoral head position. One case of joint space narrowing and three cases of significant myositis ossificans occurred. Ten patients had anterolateral thigh hypesthesia. We conclude that fracture, movement, or resorption of a single bone graft is common, leading to an increase in slip severity and failure of physeal fusion.     

Pathogenesis of metaphyseal radiolucent changes following ischemic necrosis of the capital femoral epiphysis in immature pigs. A preliminary report

BACKGROUND: Although metaphyseal radiolucent changes are often seen in patients with Legg-Calvé-Perthes disease, the pathogenesis of these changes remains controversial. The purpose of the present study was to determine the prevalence and histopathological characteristics of these metaphyseal radiolucent changes in a piglet model of ischemic necrosis of the capital femoral epiphysis. METHODS: Ischemic necrosis of the right femoral head was produced in fifty piglets by surgically placing a ligature tightly around the femoral neck. The contralateral, left hip of each animal was used as a control. Radiographs and histological sections of the femoral heads were examined at two, four, and eight weeks. The radiographs were used to measure the femoral neck length in order to assess growth disturbance. RESULTS: Thirteen of the fifty animals were found to have radiolucent changes in the proximal femoral metaphysis on the side of the infarcted femoral head. These changes were observed in none of the twelve animals that were evaluated at two weeks, in one of the fourteen animals that were evaluated at four weeks, and in twelve of the twenty-four animals that were evaluated at eight weeks. The radiolucent changes ranged from a focal cystic lesion to a diffuse area of radiolucency around the proximal femoral physis. Three distinct types of histological changes were observed in the metaphysis. Type-I changes were characterized by focal thickening of the physeal cartilage extending down into the metaphysis. Some of these lesions demonstrated cystic degeneration of the thickened cartilage. Type-II changes were characterized by central disruption of the physis and resorption and replacement of the metaphyseal bone in the region by fibrovascular tissue. Type-III changes were characterized by diffuse resorption of the physeal cartilage and resorption of the adjacent metaphyseal and epiphyseal bone. The mean femoral neck length on the infarcted side in animals with metaphyseal radiolucent changes was significantly shorter than that in animals without metaphyseal radiolucent changes (p = 0.02). CONCLUSIONS: Metaphyseal radiolucent changes frequently were observed in this piglet model at eight weeks after the induction of ischemia. The metaphyseal radiolucent changes were associated with histopathological lesions of the physis. The present study suggests that the presence of metaphyseal lesions can result in a greater growth disturbance of the proximal femoral physis than is seen in the absence of metaphyseal lesions. Clinical Relevance: The present study supports the clinical observation that the presence of diffuse metaphyseal radiolucent changes may be associated with substantial growth disturbance of the proximal part of the femur in patients with Legg-Calvé-Perthes disease. The study provides a histopathological basis for proximal femoral physeal growth disturbance that has not been clearly demonstrated in the past. These findings also may provide a histopathological basis for the fluidfilled metaphyseal cysts that sometimes are observed on the magnetic resonance imaging scans of these patients.     

Acetabular development in developmental dysplasia of the hip complicated by lateral growth disturbance of the capital femoral epiphysis

BACKGROUND: Lateral growth disturbance of the capital femoral epiphysis is the most common type of physeal arrest complicating the treatment of developmental hip dysplasia. Although this type of physeal damage has been assumed to result in poor acetabular development, the natural history of dysplastic hips affected by this pattern of growth disturbance is still unclear. To investigate this issue, we evaluated acetabular development in a retrospective study of fifty-eight hips in forty-eight patients who had lateral physeal arrest after management of developmental hip dysplasia. METHODS: Of the fifty-eight hips, thirty-six were reduced closed and twenty-two were reduced open. The average age of the patients was twenty-two months (range, three to ninety-seven months) at the time of the reduction and twenty-one years (range, ten to fifty-five years) at the time of the latest follow-up evaluation. Hips rated as Severin class I (an excellent result) or II (a good result) were defined as having a satisfactory result, and those rated as Severin class III (a fair result) or IV (a poor result) were considered to have an unsatisfactory result. Specific femoral head changes were sought in the complete radiographic files on all hips. Various radiographic parameters of hip integrity, including the degree of lateral tilt of the capital femoral epiphysis, were measured over time, and comparisons were made between hips classified as satisfactory and those classified as unsatisfactory at four time-points: before the reduction, at two years after the reduction, at six to eight years of age, and at the time of the final follow-up. RESULTS: Lateral growth disturbance of the capital femoral epiphysis was first evident by an average of ten years of age (range, four to fourteen years of age). There was no consistent early pattern of changes in the epiphysis, physis, or metaphysis related to later development of valgus tilt of the epiphysis. Thirty-four hips (59 percent) were rated as satisfactory and twenty-four were rated as unsatisfactory at the latest follow-up evaluation. Hips classified as unsatisfactory exhibited poor acetabular development by an average age of seven years. The inclination of the epiphyseal plate became progressively more horizontal or even reversed over time; however, serial measurements of inclination were not significant predictors of Severin classification. CONCLUSIONS: Lateral growth disturbance of the capital femoral epiphysis is not necessarily associated with poor acetabular development, as when dysplasia does occur it is generally evident prior to the identification of the physeal arrest. It is important to monitor acetabular development after reduction rather than search for radiographic changes of physeal arrest, which are difficult to detect in young children.     

Slipped capital femoral epiphysis: physeal histologic features before and after fixation

Physeal histopathologic changes following slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) are usually considered permanent. This assumption may not be correct, since radiographic signs of proximal femoral neck growth and remodeling are commonly seen after fixation. This work analyzed the physeal histologic features of chondroepiphyseal biopsies before and after SCFE surgical fixation but before complete physiologic epiphysiodesis. Eighteen patients, nine with unstable and nine with stable SCFE of varying severity, had pretreatment biopsies. Three patients had postfixation biopsies prior to total physiologic proximal femoral epiphysiodesis. Pretreatment biopsies showed varied degrees of histoarchitectural changes ranging from almost normal arrangement to markedly deranged physeal morphology. Postfixation biopsies showed improved physeal organization in a case of moderate unstable SCFE. In one severe unstable case and one severe stable case, nearly normal physeal architecture was seen. Physeal histopathologic changes appear to improve after fixation. Progressive modulation of the recovering physis after fixation helps explain the remodeling and growth changes seen radiographically after chondroepiphyseal fixation.     

Abnormal extension of the femoral head epiphysis as a cause of cam impingement

The etiology of an insufficient femoral head-neck offset has not been identified yet. It was investigated whether a decreased head-neck offset might be correlated with an unusual orientation of the physeal capital scar. Therefore, the femoral head-neck offset and the extension of the physeal scar onto the femoral neck were measured with specific magnetic resonance imaging arthrography. The measurements were done in 15 patients with anterior femoroacetabular impingement attributable to a nonspherical head and were compared with 15 age- and gender-matched control subjects. Eight serial magnetic resonance imaging sections perpendicular to the femoral neck axis were used in each hip to measure the head-neck offset and the epiphyseal extension toward the femoral neck at 16 measurement points. In both groups there was an inverse correlation between the amount of head-neck offset and the relative extension of the capital physeal scar in the cranial hemisphere of the head. Within the anterosuperior head quadrant, there was statistically significant different decrease of the head-neck offset and increase of the lateral epiphyseal extension in the patients compared with the control subjects. These findings suggest a growth abnormality of the capital physis as one probable underlying cause for a nonspherical head.     

Diagnosis and treatment of slipped capital femoral epiphysis: Recent trends to note

Slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) is not frequently encountered during routine practice and diagnosis and treatment are often delayed. It is important to understand symptoms and imaging features to avoid delayed diagnosis. After the diagnosis is made correct classification of the disease is required. The classification should be based on the physeal stability in order to choose safe and effective treatment. However, surgeons should bear in mind that the assessment is challenging and actual physeal stability is not always consistent with the stability predicted by a clinical classification method.

Growth disturbance of the proximal part of the femur after treatment for congenital dislocation of the hip

The radiographs of ninety patients in whom treatment of unilateral congenital dislocation of the hip was complicated by disturbance of growth of the proximal part of the femur were studied retrospectively. All patients were followed until closure of the affected proximal femoral physis. We divided the patients into three groups, according to the degree of vascular insufficiency: patients who had mild vascular insufficiency of the hip, which had little effect on growth; those who had moderate vascular insufficiency, which produces partial arrest of growth; and those who had severe vascular insufficiency, which causes complete arrest of growth. Good correlation was found between the initial degree of vascular insufficiency and the radiographic results at the most recent follow-up. The radiographic signs that were used to predict the extent of physeal involvement were a crescent-shaped epiphysis, medial bowing of the femoral neck (a shorter and more concave curve between the lesser trochanter and the proximal femoral metaphysis [the lateral portion of the Shenton line]), lateral tilting of the capital epiphysis, and premature physeal closure. Signs that were diagnostic of existing physeal involvement were elevation of the greater trochanter and shortening of the affected extremity. The presence and severity of these signs correlated well with the degree of vascular insufficiency. Medial bowing was the most reliable prognostic factor for the determination of the fate of the hip joint at maturity.     

Anterior physeal separation. A sign indicating a high risk for avascular necrosis after slipped capital femoral epiphysis

A study of 78 children (110 hips) was undertaken in an attempt to assess the risk of avascular necrosis (AVN) after slipped capital femoral epiphysis based on the radiological appearances of the hip at the time of presentation. Physeal separation, which was defined as the amount of separation of the anterior lip of the epiphysis from the metaphysis on the frog lateral view, was assessed. Of the eight hips which developed AVN, seven had anterior physeal separation. We conclude that anterior physeal separation is associated with a high incidence of subsequent AVN after slipped capital femoral epiphysis and that screw fixation may not be appropriate in these patients.     

Delayed separation of the capital femoral epiphysis after an ipsilateral transcervical fracture of the femoral neck

A displaced transcervical fracture of the femoral neck in a three-year-eight-month-old boy was fixed with two screws, which did not cross the growth plate. When he resumed walking five weeks after the injury, a delayed separation of the capital femoral epiphysis occurred. The displaced epiphysis was reduced and fixed with three unthreaded pins. In spite of disruption of the femoral neck at two sites, avascular necrosis of the femoral head did not occur. This was confirmed by two sequential isotope scans. Delayed epiphyseal separation after the femoral neck fracture and the preservation of the vascularity of the epiphysis in this case are both very unusual.     

Ultrasonography in slipped capital femoral epiphysis. Diagnosis and assessment of severity

We used ultrasonography to study 26 hips with slipped capital femoral epiphyses. In recently slipped epiphyses the ultrasound image revealed a step at the anterior physeal outline (mean 6.4 mm), diminished distance between the anterior acetabular rim and the femoral metaphysis (mean 4.3 mm) and an effusion. As metaphyseal remodelling progressed the physeal step decreased. The femoral neck appeared straighter in hips which had been symptomatic for longer than three weeks. It was possible to measure posterior epiphyseal displacement without projectional errors and the method was accurate in diagnosing minimal slip and in staging displacement. The suggested criteria are, less than 7 mm for a mild slip, 7 to 11 mm for a moderate slip and more than 11 mm for a severe slip. We recommend ultrasonography for the diagnosis, staging and follow-up management of slipped upper femoral epiphysis.