Preference mapping of salmon–sauce combinations: The influence of temporal properties

Food–food combinations are complex stimuli where the dynamic nature of sensory interactions plays an important role for perception and acceptance. The aim of this study was to investigate if TDS provides additional insight about drivers of liking compared to DA in a preference mapping context. A trained sensory panel performed DA and TDS on six different samples (combinations of salmon and culinary sauces), and sixty-one consumers rated acceptance for the same samples. In addition to TDS SCORES, this study introduces the use of extracted parameters based on dominance information from TDS; the area of dominance based on the integrated area under the dominance curves and the number of dominant sensations and blends within a specified time period. Results from preference mappings showed that the TDS approaches generally provided similar but less detailed information regarding drivers of liking and disliking compared to DA. Moreover, with the use of the extracted TDS parameters, it was possible to identify the time of dominance of certain attributes and the number of perceived sensations and blends in specific time periods as potential drivers of liking and disliking. The results also showed that TDS has a potential to provide complementary information about the dynamic nature of sensory interactions in food–food combinations compared to DA.     

Linking oral processing behavior to bolus properties and dynamic sensory perception of processed cheeses with bell pepper pieces

The addition of food particles to food matrices is a convenient approach that allows to steer oral behavior, sensory perception and satiation. The aim of this study was to determine the influence of physical-chemical properties of heterogenous foods on oral processing behavior, bolus properties and dynamic sensory perception. Bell pepper gel pieces varying in fracture stress and concentration were added to processed cream cheese matrices differing in texture. Addition of bell pepper gel pieces to processed cheeses increased consumption time, decreased eating rate and led to harder and less adhesive bolus with more saliva incorporated. Addition of bell pepper gel pieces to processed cheeses decreased dominance rate and duration of creaminess, smoothness, melting and dairy flavor and increased graininess and bell pepper flavor. Increasing fracture stress of bell pepper gel pieces from 100 to 300 kPa resulted in longer consumption time and lower eating rate. For hard/non-adhesive processed cheese matrices increasing gel pieces fracture stress lead to a boli with larger particles and more saliva. These changes were accompanied by decreased dominance perception of creaminess and bell pepper flavor and increased dominance of graininess. Increasing the concentration of bell pepper gel pieces from 15 to 30% did not affect oral behavior but led to the formation of harder and less adhesive bolus with larger particles and less saliva that were perceived with reduced dominance of creaminess, meltiness and dairy flavor while dominance of graininess and bell pepper flavor increased. Changing the texture of the cheese matrix from soft/adhesive to hard/non-adhesive decreased consumption time, increased eating rate, did not influence bolus properties and decreased dominance rate of creaminess, smoothness and melting sensations. Number of chews and total consumption time were positively correlated with saliva content of the bolus, number of bolus particles, bolus hardness, dominance of firmness, chewiness and graininess. We conclude that the modification of physical-chemical properties of processed cheeses and embedded bell pepper gel pieces can be a strategy to steer oral behavior and bolus properties which consequently determine dynamic sensory perception.     

Impact of Almond Form and Moisture Content on Texture Attributes and Acceptability

The objectives of this study were to measure sensory texture attributes of 5 types of almonds (blanched slivered, natural sliced, whole blanched, whole dry roasted, and natural whole) conditioned at 4 different moisture levels, to measure liking of a subset of these products, and to compare the sensory texture measurements with consumer liking ratings. Thirteen panelists trained to evaluate almond texture rated the texture attributes of the 20 almond samples. A panel of 113 almond consumers rated their liking of a subset of 8 of these almonds. Compared with the whole almonds, sliced and slivered almonds had less hardness, less crunchiness, less cohesiveness, less tooth packing, and required fewer chews and swallows to consume. Compared with slivered almonds, sliced almonds were more powdery, had more surface roughness, more loose particles, and were crisper. Compared with slivered almonds, sliced almonds were less hard, broke into fewer pieces, had less moistness and cohesiveness of mass, less fatty film, and required fewer chews and fewer swallows to consume. Dry roasted almonds were generally harder, more crisp, more crunchy, and produced more loose particles than natural almonds, which were, in turn, more hard, crisp, and crunchy than blanched almonds. As moisture content increased, moistness of mass and cohesiveness of mass increased. Crispness, number of pieces, hardness, crunchiness, persistence of crunch, and particulate mass decreased with increasing moisture content. Consumer texture liking ratings were highly positively correlated with the attributes crispness, crunchiness, and persistence of crunch.     

STUDY OF THE PHENOMENON OF AGGLOMERATION IN THE YEAST SACCHAROMYCES CEREVISIAE

Agglomeration or “grittiness” is detrimental to bakers' yeast quality. Gritty yeast only partially resuspends when mixed in water, most of it remaining as macroscopic cell aggregates. A macroscopic sedimentation test was developed for measuring agglomeration intensity. Expression of the gritty phenotype was investigated in two strains (N176 and GB1) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae grown on a 14-liter scale by varying fermentation conditions of agitation and aeration. Results show that yeast agglomeration is different from yeast flocculation, and is determined by both strain genetic background and environmental factors. The gritty phenotype was expressed in the strain prone to agglomeration (N176) when dissolved oxygen was limiting in the fermenter. Gritty cells had a lower phosphorus and lipid concentration and a higher protein concentration at the surface of the cell, and a higher amount of whole cell and cell wall proteins and calcium than non-gritty cells. Some proteins were also extracted from gritty cells with sodium hydroxide or mercaptoethanol, that were not present in non-gritty cells. Agglomeration did not result in major differences in the structure or composition of the structural cell wall mannoprotein (CWMP). A model for agglomeration is proposed: proteins (cognors) activated by Ca²⁺ (cofactors) to increase their binding capacity bind the mannans (cognons) of adjoining cells; binding is facilitated by the lower phosphorus and lipid concentration at the surface of gritty cells.     

Relating dynamic perception of reformulated cheese pies to consumers' expectations of satiating ability

Designing satiating food is not an easy task. Food reformulation is normally done by altering the proportion of basic ingredients or by adding new minor ingredients. In general, the texture varies concomitantly with these changes, altering the way the food is processed orally and the complete eating experience. This highlights the interest of discovering how variations in minor ingredients influence texture and how this affects the dynamics of the oral trajectory. Six cheese pie formulations were prepared: basic recipe (Base), no egg (− Egg), no corn starch (− Corn starch) no sugar (− Sugar), added diary cream (+ Cream) and extra skimmed milk powder (+ Milk powder). Temporal dominance of sensations was used to show that the appearance and disappearance of each texture sensation dominance experienced in the mouth during the eating process differed among the six pies, as did their relation to the consumers' expectation of satiating capacity scores and to the changes in composition. Two extreme behaviors were found: suppression of egg/addition of extra milk powder made the pies initially drier and harder, while suppression of corn starch/addition of cream gave the samples a soft, moist early sensation. The former elicited higher expectations of satiating capacity. In addition, overall liking, liking evolving with time (dynamic liking) and the level of several key texture attributes' divergence from those of an “ideal” cheese pie were evaluated on bipolar just-about-right scales and through penalty analysis to gain insights into potential directions for reformulating acceptable pies.     

Reducing the stiffness of concentrated whey protein isolate (WPI) gels by using WPI microparticles

Concentrated protein gels were prepared using native whey protein isolate (WPI) and WPI based microparticles. WPI microparticles were produced by making gel pieces from a concentrated WPI suspension (40% w/w), which were dried and milled. The protein within the microparticles was denatured and the protein concentration after drying was similar to the native WPI powder. WPI microparticles had irregular shape with an average size of about 70 μm. They absorbed water when dispersed in water, but the dispersion did not gel upon heating. Replacing part of the native WPI powder with WPI microparticles in the protein gel resulted in lower gel stiffness compared with a gel with the same overall protein concentration but without microparticles. However, microparticles also strengthened the continuous phase because they take up water from this phase. This might increase gel stiffness more than would be expected from an inert particle/filler. There was also good bonding between the microparticles and the WPI continuous phase in the gel, which contributed to gel stiffness.     

Characterization of particles in cream cheese

Cream cheese is used as a spread and as an ingredient in many food applications. A gritty or grainy mouthfeel is an undesirable textural defect that occurs in cream cheese. However, the factors that cause the textural defect are not well understood. The objectives of this study were to isolate and characterize particles from cream cheese and to study the effect of particles on cheese texture. Particles were isolated by washing cream cheese with water first at 25 degrees C and then at 50 degrees C repeatedly 4 to 5 times. The size of these particles was determined using a particle size analyzer. The particles as well as the original cheeses were analyzed for moisture, fat, protein, ash, and lactose. The particle size ranged of 0.04 to 850 microm. It was found that isolated particles were significantly higher in protein content as compared with the whole cheese. To study the effect on the cheese texture, particles were added at 5, 15, and 25% (wt/wt) levels to smooth cream cheese, and a sensory ranking test was done on the samples. Isolated particles were further separated into 2 size classes of 2.5 to 150 microm and > or =150 microm. These particles were then mixed with smooth cream cheese at 16 and 29% (wt/wt), and a sensory test was conducted on these samples. Smooth cream cheese with only 5% (wt/wt) added particles was perceived as significantly grittier than the control sample. This experiment also revealed that the perceived grittiness increased with increase in amount and size of particles.     

Development of a questionnaire to assay recalled liking for salt,sweet and fat

Liking for a sweet, salty or fatty diet may induce overconsumption of simple carbohydrates, sodium or lipids. Measuring overall liking of the corresponding sensory sensations contributes to understanding the determinants of dietary behaviours. However, no standardized validated questionnaire assaying these sensations is currently available. In the present study, we developed a web-based questionnaire, “PrefQuest”, which measures recalled liking for the following four sensations: salt, fat and salt, sweet, fat and sweet. PrefQuest included four types of items: (1) liking for sweet, fatty-sweet and fatty-salty foods, (2) preferences in the level of seasoning by adding salt, sweeteners, or fat, (3) preferences for types of dishes in a restaurant menu and (4) overall questions about sweet-, salt- and fat-related behaviours. A development study (n = 198) demonstrated that PrefQuest was feasible, well-perceived, only lasted about 20 min and that items were repeatable (overall mean intra-class correlation coefficient: 0.77, SD 0.08). Construct validity was then evaluated on a larger population sample (n = 47 803). The underlying structure within each of the four sensations was determined by exploratory factor analysis and then internally validated by confirmatory factor analysis. After a selection of the most relevant items, the salt, fat-and-salt, sweet, and fat-and-sweet scales exhibited a theoretically meaningful factor structure, unidimensional for the salt scale and with interrelated sub-dimensions for the sweet, fat-and-salt, and fat-and-sweet scales. Based on the fat-and-sweet and fat-and-salt scales, a fat model was also unveiled. For each factor, internal consistency as well as convergent and divergent validities were demonstrated. Overall, PrefQuest is an internally valid and original tool that can be used to assay recalled liking for sweet, salt, and fat considered altogether or separately as fat and salt or fat and sweet, and can be applied to large population surveys.     

Texture concepts for consumers: a better understanding of crispy–crunchy sensory perception

Differences in the definitions and terms used by consumers to describe their sensory sensations of crispness/crunchiness were studied, highlighting the relevance of using well-defined terms in consumer studies. A questionnaire was presented to consumers from two different Spanish-speaking countries (Spain and Uruguay, n = 200). The answers showed that the terms crispy and crunchy had different meanings or evoked different perceptions depending on the country. The crispy/crunchy food items most frequently mentioned by consumers were dry-crisp, processed products; vegetables or other wet-crisp products were not often mentioned by the consumers interviewed. The main difference between the two countries was that 38% of Spanish consumers did not know the Spanish term for “crunchy” and 17% thought that “crispy” and “crunchy” had the same meaning. The results contribute to a greater knowledge of the terminology used by the consumers to describe oral sensations related to crispness and crunchiness.     

INSTRUMENTAL AND SENSORY MEASUREMENT OF BEEF PATTY AND SAUSAGE TEXTURE

Beef sausages and beef patties of different texture were produced by varying the fat content in the raw mix over the range 5–30%. Batter shear stress and strain increased linearly with increased fat level (P<0.09 and 0.001, respectively). Although batter shear stress was not related to sensory scores, shear strain was directly related to moistness and inversely related to grittiness scores (P<0.05). Batter sensory moistness increased and firmness and grittiness deceased linearly with fat content (P<0.001). Changes in fat content did not affect the peak force of cooked patties, and there were poor correlations between patty peak force and sensory scores. Patty juiciness and softness increased and patty cohesiveness and chewiness decreased with fat content (P<0.001). Batter cook yield increased and patty cook yield decreased with increasing fat level (P<0.001). Sensory scores, using trained panelists, were more sensitive to the effect of fat content on patty and sausage texture than instrumental measurements.     

Dynamic texture perception in plant-based yogurt alternatives: Identifying temporal drivers of liking by TDS

As texture properties in novel food categories have a crucial role in consumer acceptance, mouthfeel profile of different plant-based yogurt-like semi-solid products were studied and compared to dairy yogurts. Mouthfeel properties of five plant-based yogurt-like products and two dairy yogurts were analyzed using temporal dominance of sensations (TDS) with consumers (n = 87). The attributes evaluated were thick, thin, creamy, watery, sticky, and foamy. Following TDS, overall liking and mouthfeel liking were evaluated using a 7-point hedonic scale. Temporal drivers of mouthfeel liking were studied using correspondence analysis and penalty-lift analysis with different time points during mastication. For penalty-lift analysis TDS data was analyzed as check-all-that-apply (CATA) data. Results from the present work show that mouthfeel perception in non-dairy yogurt alternatives is a dynamic process. Attributes typically used to describe dairy yogurts are also relevant for describing non-dairy yogurt alternatives. Yogurt alternatives and dairy yogurts can be similar and equally liked by their mouthfeel profile. Temporal drivers of liking in plant-based products are thickness and creaminess and temporal drivers of disliking are thinness and wateriness. In this study, the first dominant attributes were found to have a stronger impact on mouthfeel liking than the dominant attributes perceived later during mastication.     

Yogurts with an increased protein content and physically modified starch: rheological,structural, oral digestion and sensory properties related to enhanced satiating capacity

Protein is the most effective food macronutrient providing a satiating effect. Thus, formulating dairy foods with increased protein contents can help to modulate food intake. Oral perception cues also contribute an increased perception of satiating capacity when the oral residence time and handling are longer and more laborious. In the present work, yogurts were prepared with double skimmed milk powder (MP) and whey protein (WP), as well as a control (C) without extra protein. Three more samples were prepared by adding 2% of a physically modified starch to each (CS, MPS and WPS, respectively), in order to increase the consistency and impart creaminess. Rheological tests were used to characterize the flow and viscoelastic properties of the samples before and after saliva treatment, and their microstructure was observed. Finally the differences in sensory perceptions elicited by the samples were related to consumers' expected satiating capacity and liking scores. Before in vitro oral digestion, MP showed denser areas than C; in WP, two protein networks could be distinguished. In the samples with added starch, starch granules were embedded in the protein networks. After in vitro oral digestion the protein tended to aggregate; the starch granules maintained their structure indicating that they were not broken down by the saliva. These observations were related to the samples' rheological behavior. The sensory graininess, lumpiness and grittiness detected in the WP samples could be linked to the aggregation of whey protein and the formation of two different protein networks. All the added-starch samples elicited creamier and denser sensations than their counterparts without starch. MP with starch was scored as the most satiating and best-liked yogurt sample.     

Assessment of Important Sensory Attributes of Millet Based Snacks and Biscuits

There is an increasing push by consumers for new food products that can provide health benefits. To develop these products, sometimes it is necessary to look to alternative crops, 1 of which is millet. For millet to be successfully adopted by consumers, it is necessary to identify and develop product types that are acceptable to North Americans. Biscuits and extruded snacks were produced using varying amounts of refined proso millet flour (0%, 25%, 75%, and 100%). Sensory analysis was conducted on 8 products (4 types of biscuits and 4 types of extruded snack) in 2 separate tests (1 for biscuits and 1 for snacks). Preferred Attribute Elicitation (PAE), a relatively new sensory method, was used to determine attributes affecting liking of the products. Results indicated that as the amount of millet in the biscuits and extruded snacks increased, the liking of the flavor, texture and overall liking decreased. Millet contributed to a bitter taste and bitter aftertaste, and resulted in gritty and dry food products. Further work is required to refine the products tested as well as to identify further products that can be added to the diet in order to take advantage of the health benefits that millet provides.     

Comparison of methods to monitor liking of food during consumption

The measure of the liking of a product remains mainly accomplished through a single integrated response. Whether liking exhibits dynamic changes during the consumption of a food remains largely unexplored. Besides, studying the temporal aspects of perceptions during eating is a growing research topic in sensory science. Different tools are available to measure the time course of one or more perceptions during food consumption, such as time intensity or temporal dominance of sensations. The studies using these tools have shown that panellists can provide information on the temporality of their perceptions and monitor their perceptions from onset through extinction. The aim of our study was to adapt the latter approach to investigate the temporal aspects of hedonic assessment. As such, we proposed, tested and compared two methods to measure the liking throughout the consumption of a food. Forty-nine consumers participated in the tasting of three different cereals. One method consisted of eliciting any liking change during consumption, whereas the other method consisted of scoring liking at four predefined time-points during consumption. We also proposed a new method to analyse the data and graphically represent the dynamics of liking. At a panel level, the two methods showed similar dynamics of liking for two of the three products. However, the changes of liking during consumption were quite low partly due to a poor consensus among subjects. Yet, the individual responses showed many different patterns of dynamic liking. K-means analyses resulted in a two-cluster partition for each method. Although not similar, the two partitions showed large overlap. Finally, correlation coefficients calculated per subject between overall liking scores and dynamic liking data suggested the importance of the beginning of the consumption event in the overall liking (i.e., the time averaged response).     

The Influence of Herbs,Spices, and Regular Sausage and Chicken Consumption on Liking of Reduced Fat Breakfast and Lunch Items

Adults often consume more fat than is recommended. We examined factors that may improve liking of reduced fat and reduced saturated fat foods, including the addition of herbs and spices and habitual consumption of different high‐fat and low‐fat food items. We randomized adults to taste 3 different conditions: full fat (FF), reduced fat with no added spice (RF), and reduced fat plus spice (RFS). Subjects rated their liking of French toast, sausage and the overall meal, or chicken, vegetables, pasta, and the overall meal on a 9‐point hedonic Likert scale. Overall liking of the RF breakfast and lunch meals were lower than the FF and RFS versions (breakfast: 6.50 RF compared with 6.84 FF, P = 0.0061; 6.50 RF compared with 6.82 RFS, P = 0.0030; lunch: 6.35 RF compared with 6.94 FF, P < 0.0001; 6.35 RF compared with 6.71 RFS, P = 0.0061). RFS and FF breakfast and lunch meals, French toast, chicken, and vegetable likings were similar. FF and RFS conditions were liked more than RF for the breakfast and lunch meals, French toast, chicken entrée, and vegetables. Liking of all 3 sausage conditions was similar. FF pasta was liked more than RFS and RF (7.47 FF compared with 6.42 RFS, P < 0.0001; 7.47 FF compared with 6.47 RF, P < 0.0001). Habitual consumption of roasted chicken was associated with reduced liking of FF chicken (r = ?0.23, P = 0.004) and FF pasta (r = ?0.23, P = 0.005). Herbs and spices may be useful for improving the liking of lower fat foods and helping Americans maintain a diet consistent with the U.S. Dietary Guidelines.     

Viscosity drives texture perception of protein beverages more than hydrocolloid type

Hydrocolloids are added to alter rheological properties of beverages but have other properties that can contribute to overall taste and texture perception. In this study, tapioca starch and λ-carrageenan were used to determine how hydrocolloid type, viscosity level (4–6 mPa·s, 25–30 mPa·s, and 50–60 mPa·s at 50 s⁻¹), and complexity of the system (aqueous, skim milk, or whole milk) influence sensory taste and texture of fluids. All fluids were shear thinning; however, skim milk and whole milk solutions that contained carrageenan had much higher low shear viscosity and lower high shear viscosity than those with starch. There was a significant effect of viscosity level on sensory perception of consistency, creamy/oily, mouthcoating, and residual mouthcoating in aqueous, skim milk, and whole milk beverages, and a weak effect of hydrocolloid type. However, normalizing creamy/oily, paste, and mouthcoating against sensory consistency removed the effect of hydrocolloid type. Flavors (cream, cooked, cardboard, and melon/cardboard) were associated with the type of hydrocolloid and milk protein ingredient. Temporal dominance of sensations showed that samples exhibit similar temporal sensory profiles, although the addition of hydrocolloids enhanced dominance of creaminess even in samples without fat. Hydrocolloid type did not significantly influence mouthcoating or the persistence of astringency. Additionally, increasing viscosity from 3 to 74 mPa·s at 50 s⁻¹ did not suppress perceived sweet or salty taste. The results suggest that in fluid systems with viscosity levels typically found in beverages, textural properties are determined by viscosity and independent of the type of hydrocolloid.