Hepatic Considerations in the Use of Antiepileptic Drugs

Summary: Virtually all of the major antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) can cause hepatotoxicity, although fatal hepatic reactions are rare. The mechanisms, incidences, and risk profiles for such reactions differ from drug to drug. With carbamazepine and phenytoin, hepatotoxicity may be due to drug hypersensitivity. Although the profiles of patients at risk have not been well-defined for these two antiepileptic drugs, it would appear from reports in the literature that older adolescents and adults are at higher risk than children of developing serious or fatal hepatotoxicity. Once hepatotoxicity develops, mortality rates are 10–38% with phenytoin and 25% for carbamazepine. The risk profile for valproate fatal hepatotoxicity has been more clearly defined. Those at primary risk of fatal hepatic dysfunction are children under the age of 2 years who are receiving multiple anticonvulsants and also have significant medical problems in addition to severe epilepsy. The risk is considerably lower for patients over the age of 2 years on valproate monotherapy. In contrast to the risk profile with other AEDs, adults receiving valproate as monotherapy have the lowest risk of hepatotoxicity. Fatal hepatic dysfunction coincident with valproate may be the result of aberrant drug metabolism. Concomitant use of AEDs that induce microsomal P450 enzymes (e.g., phenytoin and phenobarbital) may enhance the production of a toxic metabolite, and hence the greater risk of hepatotoxicity with polypharmacy.     

Treatment Considerations in Anticonvulsant Monotherapy

Summary: The long-standing practice of polypharmacy in treating epilepsy is giving way to use of monotherapy. Monotherapy can improve seizure control as well as reduce the risk of serious idiosyncratic reactions, dose-related side effects, and complex drug interactions. Monotherapy also offers improved compliance and cost-effectiveness. The basis of monotherapy is accurate diagnosis and assessment of the patient's seizure type(s), followed by selection of a single appropriate anticonvulsant drug. Many patients currently treated with multiple anticonvulsants can be successfully converted to monotherapy with a carefully monitored program in which troublesome and redundant drugs are gradually withdrawn from the therapeutic regimen.     

Anticonvulsant Drugs and Cognitive Function: A Review of the Literature

Summary: Alterations of cognitive function are separate from disturbances of behavior seen in association with epilepsy. The nature of the cognitive disability may to a certain extent depend on the seizure type. Partial seizures, mainly derived from a temporal lobe focus, impair memory tasks, while generalized seizures seem to have more effect on attentional abilities. A number of studies, reviewed in this paper, suggest that anticonvulsant drugs further impair cognitive function. Maximal impairments are seen in patients receiving polytherapy: rationalization of polytherapy improves cognitive abilities. Studies in children and adults have allowed differentiation of the effects of various commonly used antiepileptic agents. Maximal cognitive deficits are seen with. phenytoin, while phenobarbital and sodium valproate induce moderate disturbances, and carbamazepine seems relatively free from such toxicity. Further research is needed on the interrelationship between types of seizure disorders, types of anticonvulsant medications, and cognitive function.     

Pharmacology of Antiepileptic Drugs

Summary: Several different types of chemical compounds are useful as antiepileptic drugs. Their mechanisms of action, as well as their physical structures, differ. Compounds such as carbamazepine, phenytoin, and probably valproate act by modifying ionic conductances, particularly sodium and calcium, in excitable membranes, thus limiting sustained high-frequency neuronal discharges. In contrast, barbiturates and benzodiazepines tend to affect 7-aminobutyric acid (GABA) mediation of the chloride channel opening. Knowledge of drug mechanisms is important for choosing the proper drug for various seizure types. In addition, an understanding of antiepileptic drug pharamcokinetics, nonther-apeutic effects, and interactions is essential for optimal therapy. The lack of uniform pharmacokinetics among patients and among different formulations of a drug can make it difficult to arrive at uniform criteria for both seizure control and determinations of toxicity. Both pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic interactions can occur between antiepileptic medications and other drugs. Three major types of side effects with anticonvulsants can be identified: dose-related alterations of neurologic function, idiosyncratic reactions, and nonidiosyncratic direct actions on other organ systems. These effects often compromise treatment.     

Carbamazepine Efficacy in Adults With Partial and Generalized Tonic-Clonic Seizures

Summary: Carbamazepine and phenytoin are drugs of choice in initial monotherapy for adult partial and secondarily generalized tonic-clonic seizures. These designations reflect the results of the Veterans Administration Epilepsy Cooperative Study Group of 1985. An earlier comparative study of carbamazepine and phenytoin by Ramsay and associates found both drugs equally effective in controlling new-onset seizures. Among the advantages of carbamazepine is that it causes relatively few cognitive and dysmorphic side effects. Its disadvantages are its unavailability in parenteral formulation and its metabolic autoinduction. The latter must be compensated for by planned dosage increases to maintain therapeutic plasma steady-state levels during the first 2 or 3 months of treatment. Carbamazepine is judged a drug of choice in the treatment of these secondarily generalized tonic-clonic seizures, and the drug of choice in children, adolescents, and women susceptible to the dysmorphic side effects associated with other anticonvulsant agents.     

Carbamazepine Efficacy and Utilization in Children

Summary: Carbamazepine is effective for preventing partial and generalized tonic-clonic seizures in children. Although absence epilepsies are more common in children than adults, an estimated 80% of children with epilepsy have seizure types or epilepsies that are potentially responsive to carbamazepine. The differential diagnosis of ictal staring is an especially important issue in children because absence and atypical absence seizures are more prevalent in children than adults. Age-related pharmacokinetic differences and drug interactions are major considerations in children. On average, children have higher clearance rates of carbamazepine, shorter half-lives, and higher ratios of carbamazepine-10, 11-epoxide to carbamazepine than adults. In addition, children with severe epilepsy are more likely to require multiple-drug therapy, which can lead to complex drug interactions. When carbamazepine is administered along with valproate, drug protein binding interactions can cause intermittent side effects.     

Efficacy and Safety of Antiepileptic Drugs: A Review of Controlled Trials

Summary: Twenty randomized, double-blind, controlled clinical trials of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) in mostly adult patients with mostly partial onset and/or generalized tonic-clonic seizures have been reported, with a total of 1,336 patients. None of these studies has demonstrated significant differences in antiepileptic efficacy between available antiepileptic drugs, but the results show that there are considerable individual differences between patients' responses to the same drug. While side effects are common with all of the antiepileptic drugs currently available, these are usually mild and reversible. Although some toxic effects may occur more frequently with certain drugs, there is sufficient overlap between the effects of various antiepileptic drugs that most side effects cannot be attributed with certainty to any one drug. Since side effects are generally dose-related, they can frequently be avoided or minimized by careful dosage titration and individualization of therapy.     

Cognitive Function and Time-of-Day Variation in Serum Carbamazepine Concentration in Epileptic Patients Treated with Monotherapy

Different parameters of antiepileptic drug (AED) treatment have been shown to affect cognitive function. The drug, dose, and duration of treatment have been studied. The present study assessed cognitive function in relation to time-of-day variation in serum carbamazepine (CBZ) concentration in epileptic patients treated with monotherapy. We studied 10 males and 12 females with a mean age of 36 years and a mean duration of CBZ-therapy of 4.4 years. Patients had been seizure-free for at least 1 month and took two daily CBZ doses. The test battery included tests of motor speed, reaction time, attention, and memory. In the experimental design, the subjects were tested twice at times close to expected daily maximum and minimum serum CBZ concentration. They were studied in two balanced blocks (block 1 tested at 8 a.m. and noon, block 2 tested at noon and 8 p.m.). Blood samples were collected every 2 hr from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. The subjects showed significant differences in serum CBZ concentration between testing times, with suggested maximum concentration between 10 a.m. and noon. The test battery showed no consistent differences between performance at times of high versus low serum concentration. A supplementary analysis of correlations between mean performance level on cognitive tests and variables related to CBZ treatment did not show consistent trends.     

Neuropsychological Abilities Before and After 5 Years of Stable Antiepileptic Drug Therapy

Detailed neuropsychological evaluations were conducted on 198 adults with epilepsy before and after a 5-year study period. Of these, three groups of 11 persons each were formed in which the patients did not change their medication: (a) phenytoin (PHT) monotherapy; (b) PHT and other drug(s); (c) drug regimens exclusive of PHT. The typical patient had few seizures during the study period. Examination of data from 20 neuropsychological and intellectual variables obtained at the beginning and end of the 5-year study period revealed few statistically significant changes in mental abilities and no losses. Thus, we were unable to find evidence for insidious cognitive losses with PHT and other drugs over time with normal therapeutic serum levels and in the absence of active seizure disorders.     

Valproate Monotherapy in the Management of Generalized and Partial Seizures

Summary: For decades, therapeutic tradition has promoted the concept of polypharmacy in the management of epilepsy. In recent years, however, studies have shown that, for most patients, monotherapy can provide comparable or better seizure control than administration of multiple anticonvulsants, while diminishing the potential for adverse reactions, drug interactions, and poor compliance. Valproate is an important monotherapeutic agent that is highly effective in the control of idiopathic primary and secondarily generalized epilepsies, and partial seizures that do not generalize. Comparative studies have found that valproate is at least as effective as phenytoin and carbamazepine in the treatment of generalized and partial seizures. Given the similar efficacy, other factors such as pharmacokinetics and side effects may therefore determine anticonvulsant selection for monotherapy.     

Clinically Significant Carbamazepine Drug Interactions: An Overview

Summary: Knowledge of the principles of drug action and distribution contributes to an understanding of the occurrence of drug interactions. The pharmacologic action of most drugs is postulated to occur by the formation of a drug-receptor complex at the site of action that is capable of altering the physiologic response of the target system. The therapeutic response observed depends on the sum of the numerous factors that can affect the disposition pattern of a drug. In an individual, the response to a given drug dose remains relatively constant, but in a large population, a fixed dose can produce a range of plasma concentrations and therefore varied clinical responses. For most drugs, there is a linear relationship between the total dose and the plasma concentration achieved at steady state. Saturation, or zero-order, kinetics accounts for nonlinear increases in drug concentration with dosage increase. Drug-drug interactions with carbamazepine include several types. (1) Autoinduction of carbamazepine metabolism increases the carbamazepine clearance rate, decreases the half-life, and decreases serum concentrations; the clinician must reevaluate a patient's serum levels at 4 to 6 weeks after initiation of therapy. (2) Carbamazepine induces the metabolism of other antiepileptic drugs, enhancing the clearance of phenytoin, primidone, valproic acid, clonazepam, and ethosuximide. (3) Other drugs added to the epileptic patient's drug regimen may induce the metabolism of carbamazepine, causing increased serum concentrations. (4) Inhibition of carbamazepine metabolism by other drugs can also occur; symptoms of drug intoxication rapidly follow. Interactions occur between carbamazepine and macrolide antibiotics, cimetidine, propoxyphene, and isoniazid. Drug-drug interactions are preventable. It is the responsibility of every physician to be alert to the potential for their occurrence whenever a change in the epileptic patient's drug regimen is made.     

Cognitive Effects of Antiepileptic Drugs

Antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) can adversely affect cognitive function by suppressing neuronal excitability or enhancing inhibitory neurotransmission. The main cognitive effects of AEDs are impaired attention, vigilance, and psychomotor speed, but secondary effects can manifest on other cognitive functions. Although the long-term use of AEDs can obviously elicit cognitive dysfunction in epilepsy patients, their cognitive effects over short periods of up to a year are inconclusive due to methodological problems. In general, the effects on cognition are worse for older AEDs (e.g., phenobarbital) than for placebo, nondrug condition, and newer AEDs. However, topiramate is the newer AED that has the greatest risk cognitive impairment irrespective of the comparator group. Since the cognitive impact of AEDs can be serious, clinicians should be alert to adverse events by evaluating cognitive function using screening tests. Adverse cognitive events of AEDs can be avoided by slow titration to the lowest effective dosage and by avoiding polytherapy.     

How to Initiate and Maintain Carbamazepine Therapy in Children and Adults

Summary: Appropriate use of carbamazepine for the treatment of epilepsy is based on correct identification of the patient's seizure type. Carbamazepine is effective against partial seizures and against generalized tonic-clonic seizures. Therapy should begin gradually, with initial doses increased slowly over 1 or 2 weeks, as tolerated. Side effects include fatigue, dizziness, ataxia, double vision, nausea, and vomiting. Most practitioners agree that, because of carbamazepine's relatively short half-life, the total dosage should be administered in at least two divided doses. This avoids too high a peak blood level that would occur with a single dose. Carbamazepine therapy is associated with the development of two hematologic conditions. Leukopenia, which may be transient or persistent, requires careful monitoring but is not cause for immediate discontinuation of therapy. Aplastic anemia occurs rarely but is potentially fatal, and therefore diligent monitoring of hematologic function is indicated. Aplastic anemia is an idiosyncratic, non-dose-related side effect that is most likely to occur within the first 3 or 4 months of initiating therapy. Once seizures are controlled, plasma levels of carbamazepine should be measured to establish optimum levels for individual patients being treated with this drug.     

Effects of Vigabatrin on Cognitive Function and Mood When Used as Add-on Therapy in Patients with Intractable Epilepsy

Cognitive function and mood of patients with epilepsy who received 2 g/day vigabatrin (GVG) in addition to their usual antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) was assessed on two occasions: before start of treatment (baseline) and 4 weeks after start of treatment. A battery of selected psychological tasks measuring attention, mental speed, motor speed, central cognitive processing, and perceptuomotor performance was used, along with standardized, objective mood assessments. A comparison group (n = 15) of patients receiving stable medication was also tested to evaluate practice effects of the psychometric tests. Administration of 2 g/day GVG significantly decreased response time on a test of central cognitive processing ability (arithmetic). No adverse effect was noted on any other test of cognitive function or mood.     

Valproate Metabolites in Serum and Urine During Antiepileptic Therapy in Children with Infantile Spasms: Abnormal Metabolite Pattern Associated with Reversible Hepatotoxicity

The purpose of this study was to identify abnormal metabolite patterns of valproate (VPA) as possible early indicators of VPA-induced liver toxicity. In a prospective study, we determined serum and urine levels of VPA metabolites by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) during the course of therapy in 25 children treated for infantile spasms with high VPA doses (less than or equal to 100 mg/kg body weight/day). Most patients had similar metabolite profiles: The main metabolites in serum were the beta-oxidation products (2-en-VPA and 3-keto-VPA) and the major diunsaturated metabolite 2,3'-dien-VPA. Glucuronide conjugates and the oxidation products represent the most abundant metabolites in urine. Other metabolites, including the potential hepatotoxin 4-en-VPA, were detected only in low concentrations. Two children had transiently aberrant metabolite profiles, indicating altered beta-oxidation, (levels of 2-en-VPA, 2,3'-dien-VPA, and 3-en-VPA were markedly increased) in connection with hepatomegaly and increased liver enzyme activities at a time when both had febrile infections and were receiving dexamethasone comedication. At no time were increased levels of 4-en-VPA or its derivatives detected. Establishing the VPA metabolite profile may aid in evaluation of patients who show signs and symptoms of liver dysfunction during VPA therapy. The present study shows that initial stages of hepatotoxicity reactions to VPA may be accompanied by characteristic changes in VPA metabolism; early detection of such abnormal metabolite patterns might decrease the risk of severe hepatic injury.     

Polytherapy, Monotherapy, and Carbamazepine

Summary: Despite the widespread and traditional use of polytherapy in the treatment of epilepsy, there is little evidence of its advantages over monotherapy. Among other undesirable effects, it can produce subtle cognitive and behavioral changes and sometimes even exacerbate the epilepsy. Recent studies provide evidence that in many patients seizures can be controlled by carefully monitored monotherapy: Approximately 75% of newly diagnosed, previously untreated epileptic patients will enter a 2-year remission with this form of treatment. The theory has even been advanced that early control of seizures may help prevent the evolution of drug-resistant, chronic epilepsy. In some patients with chronic epilepsy, multiple-drug therapy can be reduced to single-drug treatment, usually with an improvement in cognitive function and without increase in seizures. Trials conducted to date have shown no evidence of superiority of any one major antiepileptic drug over another in control of a particular seizure type. The choice of antiepileptic drug for monotherapy may therefore be influenced by differences in toxic effects associated with individual agents. On the basis of clinical and psychometric evidence, carbamazepine has been shown to cause fewer adverse effects than other antiepileptic drugs on cognitive function, mood, and behavior.     

Hepatotoxic Reactions Associated with Carbamazepine Therapy

Hepatotoxic reactions in patients receiving carbamazepine (CBZ) therapy have been reported, and some have been considered fatal. We present two patients with hepatic dysfunction secondary to CBZ therapy. Liver biopsies were compatible with hepatotoxic damage, and the symptoms were reversible with medication withdrawal. Our patients are representative of those in the literature, most of whom have granulomatous hepatitis and sometimes have associated cholangitis. The patients with fatal reactions differed clinically and pathologically from the others, and may represent a different entity. The clinical syndrome resembles a viral hepatitis. Elderly patients seem to be particularly susceptible and their hepatic function should be monitored closely when CBZ therapy is initiated.