A note on the truck and trailer routing problem

This study considers the relaxed truck and trailer routing problem (RTTRP), a relaxation of the truck and trailer routing problem (TTRP). TTRP is a variant of the well studied vehicle routing problem (VRP). In TTRP, a fleet of trucks and trailers are used to service a set of customers with known demands. Some customers may be serviced by a truck pulling a trailer, while the others may only be serviced by a single truck. This is the main difference between TTRP and VRP. The number of available trucks and available trailers is limited in the original TTRP but there are no fixed costs associated with the use of trucks or trailers. Therefore, it is reasonable to relax this fleet size constraint to see if it is possible to further reduce the total routing cost (distance). In addition, the resulting RTTRP can also be used to determine a better fleet mix. We developed a simulated annealing heuristic for solving RTTRP and tested it on 21 existing TTRP benchmark problems and 36 newly generated TTRP instances. Computational results indicate that the solutions for RTTRP are generally better than the best solutions in the literature for TTRP. The proposed SA heuristic is able to find better solutions to 18 of the 21 existing benchmark TTRP instances. The solutions for the remaining three problems are tied with the best so far solutions in the literature. For the 36 newly generated problems, the average percentage improvement of RTTRP solutions over TTRP solutions is about 5%. Considering the ever rising crude oil price, even small reduction in the route length is significant.     

A tabu search heuristic for the truck and trailer routing problem

Two new construction heuristics and a tabu search heuristic are presented for the truck and trailer routing problem, a variant of the vehicle routing problem. Computational results indicate that the heuristics are competitive to the existing approaches. The tabu search algorithm obtained better solutions for each of 21 benchmark problems.     

A simulated annealing heuristic for the truck and trailer routing problem with time windows

European firms have been using a combination of trucks and trailers in the delivery/collection of food products for years. Thus, some previous studies had been devoted to improving the efficiency of the resulting truck and trailer routing problem (TTRP). Since time window constraints are present in many real-world routing applications, in this study, we introduce the truck and trailer routing problem with time windows (TTRPTW) to bring the TTRP model closer to the reality. A simulated annealing (SA) heuristic is proposed for solving the TTRPTW. Two computational experiments are conducted to test the performance of the proposed SA heuristic. The results indicate that the proposed SA heuristic is capable of consistently producing quality solutions to the TTRPTW within a reasonable time.     

Truck and trailer routing—Problems,heuristics and computational experience

In the truck and trailer routing problem (TTRP) the vehicle fleet consists of truck units and trailer units with some customers only accessible by truck. For that purpose trailers can be uncoupled en-route at customers where truck sub-tours are built. We discuss several variants of this specific rich vehicle routing problem (RVRP): the TTRP with and without the option of load transfer between truck and trailer as well as the requirement of time windows for delivery. We present computational experience with a simple and flexible hybrid approach which is based on local search and large neighborhood search as well as standard metaheuristic control strategies. This approach which has shown to be rather effective on several other RVRP-classes before can compete with complex state-of-the-art approaches with respect to speed and accuracy on the TTRP too.     

A GRASP with evolutionary path relinking for the truck and trailer routing problem

In the truck and trailer routing problem (TTRP) a heterogeneous fleet composed of trucks and trailers has to serve a set of customers, some only accessible by truck and others accessible with a truck pulling a trailer. This problem is solved using a route-first, cluster-second procedure embedded within a hybrid metaheuristic based on a greedy randomized adaptive search procedure (GRASP), a variable neighborhood search (VNS) and a path relinking (PR). We test PR as a post-optimization procedure, as an intensification mechanism, and within evolutionary path relinking (EvPR). Numerical experiments show that all the variants of the proposed GRASP with path relinking outperform all previously published methods. Remarkably, GRASP with EvPR obtains average gaps to best-known solutions of less than 1% and provides several new best solutions.     

A variable neighborhood search for the multi-depot vehicle routing problem with loading cost

The purpose of this paper is to propose a variable neighbourhood search (VNS) for solving the multi-depot vehicle routing problem with loading cost (MDVRPLC). The MDVRPLC is the combination of multi-depot vehicle routing problem (MDVRP) and vehicle routing problem with loading cost (VRPLC) which are both variations of the vehicle routing problem (VRP) and occur only rarely in the literature. In fact, an extensive literature search failed to find any literature related specifically to the MDVRPLC. The proposed VNS comprises three phases. First, a stochastic method is used for initial solution generation. Second, four operators are randomly selected to search neighbourhood solutions. Third, a criterion similar to simulated annealing (SA) is used for neighbourhood solution acceptance. The proposed VNS has been test on 23 MDVRP benchmark problems. The experimental results show that the proposed method provides an average 23.77% improvement in total transportation cost over the best known results based on minimizing transportation distance. The results show that the proposed method is efficient and effective in solving problems.     

Selection of Vehicle Routing Heuristic Using Neural Networks

Due to its combinatorial structure, the vehicle routing problem has been attacked by many heuristic solution approaches. Given the large number of available heuristics, selecting the best heuristic for a particular problem poses its own kind of difficulty. This study uses a simple neural network approach to select the best heuristic for a VRP instance according to its basic characterstics. The approach has been trained and tested on a large test bed which covers problems with a wide variety of characterstics. It was also tested on a set of benchmark problems from the literature. For these problems, a simple procedure was used to extract the problem characterstics from the problem data. Statistical analysis reveals that the performance of each heuristic is affected differently by the problem characterstics. Neural network results for both test sets show that our approach is capable of selecting the best algorithm for a given VRP instance.     

A hybrid discrete particle swarm optimization for vehicle routing problem with simultaneous pickup and delivery

Vehicle routing problem (VRP) is an important and well-known combinatorial optimization problem encountered in many transport logistics and distribution systems. The VRP has several variants depending on tasks performed and on some restrictions, such as time windows, multiple vehicles, backhauls, simultaneous delivery and pick-up, etc. In this paper, we consider vehicle routing problem with simultaneous pickup and delivery (VRPSPD). The VRPSPD deals with optimally integrating goods distribution and collection when there are no precedence restrictions on the order in which the operations must be performed. Since the VRPSPD is an NP-hard problem, we present a heuristic solution approach based on particle swarm optimization (PSO) in which a local search is performed by variable neighborhood descent algorithm (VND). Moreover, it implements an annealing-like strategy to preserve the swarm diversity. The effectiveness of the proposed PSO is investigated by an experiment conducted on benchmark problem instances available in the literature. The computational results indicate that the proposed algorithm competes with the heuristic approaches in the literature and improves several best known solutions.     

A two-stage heuristic method for vehicle routing problem with split deliveries and pickups

The vehicle routing problem （VRP） is a well-known combinatorial optimization issue in transportation and logistics network systems. There exist several limitations associated with the traditional VRP. Releasing the restricted conditions of traditional VRP has become a research focus in the past few decades. The vehicle routing problem with split deliveries and pickups （VRPSPDP） is particularly proposed to release the constraints on the visiting times per customer and vehicle capacity, that is, to allow the deliveries and pickups for each customer to be simultaneously split more than once. Few studies have focused on the VRPSPDP problem. In this paper we propose a two-stage heuristic method integrating the initial heuristic algorithm and hybrid heuristic algorithm to study the VRPSPDP problem. To validate the proposed algorithm, Solomon benchmark datasets and extended Solomon benchmark datasets were modified to compare with three other popular algorithms. A total of 18 datasets were used to evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed method. The computational results indicated that the proposed algorithm is superior to these three algorithms for VRPSPDP in terms of total travel cost and average loading rate.     

Heuristics for tactical time slot management: a periodic vehicle routing problem view

In this study, we consider a tactical problem where a time slot schedule for delivery service over a given planning horizon must be selected in each zone of a geographical area. A heuristic search evaluates each schedule selection by constructing a corresponding tactical routing plan of minimum cost based on demand and service time estimates. At the end, the schedule selection leading to the best tactical routing plan is selected. The latter can then be used as a blueprint when addressing the operational problem (i.e., when real customer orders are received and operational routes are constructed). We propose two heuristics to address the tactical problem. The first heuristic is a three‐phase approach: a periodic vehicle routing problem (PVRP) is first solved, followed by a repair phase and a final improvement phase where a vehicle routing problem (VRP) with time windows is solved for each period of the planning horizon. The second heuristic tackles the problem as a whole by directly solving a PVRP with time windows. Computational results compare the two heuristics under various settings, based on instances derived from benchmark instances for the VRP with time windows.     

Network service scheduling and routing

Real‐life vehicle routing problems generally have both routing and scheduling aspects to consider. Although this fact is well acknowledged, few heuristic methods exist that address both these complicated aspects simultaneously. We present a graph theoretic heuristic to determine an efficient service route for a single service vehicle through a transportation network that requires a subset of its edges to be serviced, each a specified (potentially different) number of times. The times at which each of these edges are to be serviced should additionally be as evenly spaced over the scheduling time window as possible, thus introducing a scheduling consideration to the problem. Our heuristic is based on the tabu search method, used in conjunction with various well‐known graph theoretic algorithms, such as those of Floyd (for determining shortest routes) and Frederickson (for solving the rural postman problem). This heuristic forms the backbone of a decision support system that prompts the user for certain parameters from the physical situation (such as the service frequencies and travel times for each network link as well as bounds in terms of acceptability of results) after which a service routing schedule is suggested as output. The decision support system is applied to a special case study, where a service routing schedule is sought for the South African national railway system by Spoornet (the semi‐privatised South African national railways authority and service provider) as part of their rationalisation effort, in order to remain a lucrative company.     

基于启发式蚁群算法的VRP问题研究

针对蚁群算法求解VRP问题时收敛速度慢,求解质量不高的缺点,把城市和仓库间的距离矩阵和路径节约矩阵信息融入到初始信息素矩阵中作为启发式信息引入到蚁群算法中用于求解有容量限制的车辆路径规划问题（CVRP）,在三个基准数据集上的实验研究表明,基于启发式信息的蚁群算法与基本蚁群算法相比能够以较快的速度收敛到较好的解。     

A deterministic tabu search algorithm for the capacitated arc routing problem

The capacitated arc routing problem (CARP) is a difficult optimisation problem in vehicle routing with applications where a service must be provided by a set of vehicles on specified roads. A heuristic algorithm based on tabu search is proposed and tested on various sets of benchmark instances. The computational results show that the proposed algorithm produces high quality results within a reasonable computing time. Some new best solutions are reported for a set of test problems used in the literature.     

A simple and effective evolutionary algorithm for the vehicle routing problem

The vehicle routing problem (VRP) plays a central role in the optimization of distribution networks. Since some classical instances with 75 nodes resist the best exact solution methods, most researchers concentrate on metaheuristics for solving real-life problems. Contrary to the VRP with time windows, no genetic algorithm (GA) can compete with the powerful tabu search (TS) methods designed for the VRP. This paper bridges the gap by presenting a relatively simple but effective hybrid GA. In terms of average solution cost, this algorithm outperforms most published TS heuristics on the 14 classical Christofides instances and becomes the best solution method for the 20 large-scale instances generated by Golden et al.Scope and purposeThe framework of this research is the development of effective metaheuristics for hard combinatorial optimization problems met in vehicle routing. It is surprising to notice in the literature the absence of effective genetic algorithms (GA) for the vehicle routing problem (VRP, the main capacitated node routing problem), contrary to node routing problems with time windows or arc routing problems. Earlier attempts were based on chromosomes with trip delimiters and needed a repair procedure to get feasible children after each crossover. Such procedures are known to weaken the genetic transmission of information from parents to children. This paper proposes a GA without trip delimiters, hybridized with a local search procedure. At any time, a chromosome can be converted into an optimal VRP solution (subject to chromosome sequence), thanks to a special splitting procedure. This design choice avoids repair procedures and enables the use of classical crossovers like OX. The resulting algorithm is flexible, relatively simple, and very effective when applied to two sets of standard benchmark instances ranging from 50 to 483 customers.     

Testing local search move operators on the vehicle routing problem with split deliveries and time windows

The vehicle routing problem (VRP) is an important transportation problem. The literature addresses several extensions of this problem, including variants having delivery time windows associated with customers and variants allowing split deliveries to customers. The problem extension including both of these variations has received less attention in the literature. This research effort sheds further light on this problem. Specifically, this paper analyzes the effects of combinations of local search (LS) move operators commonly used on the VRP and its variants. We find when paired with a MAX-MIN Ant System constructive heuristic, Or-opt or 2-opt⁎ appear to be the ideal LS operators to employ on the VRP with split deliveries and time windows with Or-opt finding higher quality solutions and 2-opt⁎ requiring less run time.     

GRASP/VND and multi-start evolutionary local search for the single truck and trailer routing problem with satellite depots

In the single truck and trailer routing problem with satellite depots (STTRPSD) a vehicle composed of a truck with a detachable trailer serves the demand of a set of customers reachable only by the truck without the trailer. This accessibility constraint implies the selection of locations to park the trailer before performing the trips to the customers. We propose two metaheuristics based on greedy randomized adaptive search procedures (GRASP), variable neighborhood descent (VND) and evolutionary local search (ELS) to solve this problem. To evaluate these metaheuristics we test them on a set of 32 randomly generated problems. The computational experiment shows that a multi-start evolutionary local search outperforms a GRASP/VND. Moreover, it obtains competitive results when applied to the multi-depot vehicle routing problem (MDVRP), that can be seen as a special case of the STTRPSD.     

求解卸装一体化的车辆路径问题的混合启发式算法

提出一种结合蚁群系统(Ant Colony System,ACS)和变邻域下降搜索(Variable Neighborhood Descent,VND)的混合启发式算法ACS_VND,求解卸装一体化车辆路径问题.利用基于插入的ACS解构造方法产生多个弱可行解,再逐个转换成强可行解,并选择其中最好的作为VND的初始解.在VND过程中使用三种不同的邻域结构:插入、交换和2-opt依次对解进行迭代优化.对55个规模为22~199的benchmark算例的求解结果表明,算法ACS_VND能在较短时间内获得52个算例的已知最好解,并且更新了其中44个算例的已知最好解,求解性能优于现有算法.     

Heuristic methods for vehicle routing problem with time windows

This paper documents our investigation into various heuristic methods to solve the vehicle routing problem with time windows (VRPTW) to near optimal solutions. The objective of the VRPTW is to serve a number of customers within predefined time windows at minimum cost (in terms of distance travelled), without violating the capacity and total trip time constraints for each vehicle. Combinatorial optimisation problems of this kind are non-polynomial-hard (NP-hard) and are best solved by heuristics. The heuristics we are exploring here are mainly third-generation artificial intelligent (AI) algorithms, namely simulated annealing (SA), Tabu search (TS) and genetic algorithm (GA). Based on the original SA theory proposed by Kirkpatrick and the work by Thangiah, we update the cooling scheme and develop a fast and efficient SA heuristic. One of the variants of Glover's TS, strict Tabu, is evaluated and first used for VRPTW, with the help of both recency and frequency measures. Our GA implementation, unlike Thangiah's genetic sectoring heuristic, uses intuitive integer string representation and incorporates several new crossover operations and other advanced techniques such as hybrid hill-climbing and adaptive mutation scheme. We applied each of the heuristics developed to Solomon's 56 VRPTW 100-customer instances, and yielded 18 solutions better than or equivalent to the best solution ever published for these problems. This paper is also among the first to document the implementation of all the three advanced AI methods for VRPTW, together with their comprehensive results.     

An evolutionary approach for multi-objective vehicle routing problems with backhauls

The vehicle routing problem (VRP) is an important aspect of transportation logistics with many variants. This paper studies the VRP with backhauls (VRPB) in which the set of customers is partitioned into two subsets: linehaul customers requiring a quantity of product to be delivered, and backhaul customers with a quantity to be picked up. The basic VRPB involves finding a collection of routes with minimum cost, such that all linehaul and backhaul customers are serviced. A common variant is the VRP with selective backhauls (VRPSB), where the collection from backhaul customers is optional. For most real world applications, the number of vehicles, the total travel cost, and the uncollected backhauls are all important objectives to be minimized, so the VRPB needs to be tackled as a multi-objective problem. In this paper, a similarity-based selection evolutionary algorithm approach is proposed for finding improved multi-objective solutions for VRPB, VRPSB, and two further generalizations of them, with fully multi-objective performance evaluation.     

基于划分的蚁群算法求解货物权重车辆路径问题

考虑单产品分销网络中的车辆路径问题(VRP:vehicle routing problem).与以往诸多研究不同的是,建立了一种带货物载重量的VRP模型(weighted VRP),即车辆在两个顾客之间行驶时的载重量也作为影响运输费用的一个因素考虑.因此,需求量较大的顾客拥有较高的车辆运输优先权.在分析了问题性质的基础上,提出一种基于划分策略的蚁群算法PMMAS求解货物权重车辆路径问题,并与其他常用的启发式算法进行比较分析,表明了算法的有效性.