Comparison of ligand-based and receptor-based virtual screening of HIV entry inhibitors for the CXCR4 and CCR5 receptors using 3D ligand shape matching and ligand-receptor docking

HIV infection is initiated by fusion of the virus with the target cell through binding of the viral gp120 protein with the CD4 cell surface receptor protein and the CXCR4 or CCR5 co-receptors. There is currently considerable interest in developing novel ligands that can modulate the conformations of these co-receptors and, hence, ultimately block virus-cell fusion. This article describes a detailed comparison of the performance of receptor-based and ligand-based virtual screening approaches to find CXCR4 and CCR5 antagonists that could potentially serve as HIV entry inhibitors. Because no crystal structures for these proteins are available, homology models of CXCR4 and CCR5 have been built, using bovine rhodopsin as the template. For ligand-based virtual screening, several shape-based and property-based molecular comparison approaches have been compared, using high-affinity ligands as query molecules. These methods were compared by virtually screening a library assembled by us, consisting of 602 known CXCR4 and CCR5 inhibitors and some 4700 similar presumed inactive molecules. For each receptor, the library was queried using known binders, and the enrichment factors and diversity of the resulting virtual hit lists were analyzed. Overall, ligand-based shape-matching searches yielded higher enrichments than receptor-based docking, especially for CXCR4. The results obtained for CCR5 suggest the possibility that different active scaffolds bind in different ways within the CCR5 pocket.     

Pharmacophore modeling coupled with molecular dynamic simulation approach to identify new leads for meprin-β metalloprotease

Human meprin beta metalloprotease, a small subgroup of the astacin family, is a potent drug target for the treatment of several disorders such as fibrosis, neurodegenerative disease in particular Alzheimer and inflammatory bowel diseases. In this study, a ligand-based pharmacophore approach has been used for the selection of potentially active compounds to understand the inhibitory activities of meprin-β by using the sulfonamide scaffold based inhibitors. Using this dataset, a pharmacophore model (Hypo1) was selected on the basis of a highest correlation coefficient (0.959), lowest total cost (105.89) and lowest root mean square deviation (1.31 Å) values. All the pharmacophore hypotheses generated from the candidate inhibitors comprised four features: two hydrogen-bond acceptor, one hydrogen-bond donor and one zinc binder feature. The best validated pharmacophore model (Hypo1) was used for virtual screening of compounds from several databases. The selective hit compounds were filtered by drug likeness property, acceptable ADMET profile, molecular docking and DFT study. Molecular dynamic simulations with the final 10 hit compounds revealed that a large number of non-covalent interactions were formed with the active site and specificity sub-pockets of the meprin beta metalloprotease. This study assists in the development of the new lead molecules as well as gives a better understanding of their interaction with meprin-β.     

Pharmacophore identification, in silico screening, and virtual library design for inhibitors of the human factor Xa

Factor Xa inhibitors are innovative anticoagulant agents that provide a better safety/efficacy profile compared to other anticoagulative drugs. A chemical feature-based modeling approach was applied to identify crucial pharmacophore patterns from 3D crystal structures of inhibitors bound to human factor Xa (Pdb entries 1fjs, 1kns, 1eqz) using the software LIGANDSCOUT and CATALYST. The complex structures were selected regarding the criteria of high inhibitory potency (i.e. all ligands show K(i) values against factor Xa in the subnanomolar range) and good resolution (i.e. at least 2.2 A) in order to generate selective and high quality pharmacophore models. The resulting chemical-feature based hypotheses were used for virtual screening of commercial molecular databases such as the WDI database. Furthermore, a ligand-based molecular modeling approach was performed to obtain common-feature hypotheses that represent the relevant chemical interactions between 10 bioactive factor Xa inhibitors and the protein, respectively. In a next step a virtual combinatorial library was designed in order to generate new compounds with similar chemical and spatial properties as known inhibitors. The software tool ILIB DIVERSE was used for this procedure in order to provide new scaffolds of this group of anticoagulants. Finally we present the combination of these two techniques, hence virtual screening was performed with selective pharmacophore models in a focused virtual combinatorial database. De novo derived molecular scaffolds that were able to adequately satisfy the pharmacophore criteria are revealed and are promising templates for candidates for further development.     

PhAST: pharmacophore alignment search tool

We present a ligand-based virtual screening technique (PhAST) for rapid hit and lead structure searching in large compound databases. Molecules are represented as strings encoding the distribution of pharmacophoric features on the molecular graph. In contrast to other text-based methods using SMILES strings, we introduce a new form of text representation that describes the pharmacophore of molecules. This string representation opens the opportunity for revealing functional similarity between molecules by sequence alignment techniques in analogy to homology searching in protein or nucleic acid sequence databases. We favorably compared PhAST with other current ligand-based virtual screening methods in a retrospective analysis using the BEDROC metric. In a prospective application, PhAST identified two novel inhibitors of 5-lipoxygenase product formation with minimal experimental effort. This outcome demonstrates the applicability of PhAST to drug discovery projects and provides an innovative concept of sequence-based compound screening with substantial scaffold hopping potential.     

Site-Identification by Ligand Competitive Saturation (SILCS) assisted pharmacophore modeling

Database screening using receptor-based pharmacophores is a computer-aided drug design technique that uses the structure of the target molecule (i.e. protein) to identify novel ligands that may bind to the target. Typically receptor-based pharmacophore modeling methods only consider a single or limited number of receptor conformations and map out the favorable binding patterns in vacuum or with a limited representation of the aqueous solvent environment, such that they may suffer from neglect of protein flexibility and desolvation effects. Site-Identification by Ligand Competitive Saturation (SILCS) is an approach that takes into account these, as well as other, properties to determine 3-dimensional maps of the functional group-binding patterns on a target receptor (i.e. FragMaps). In this study, a method to use the FragMaps to automatically generate receptor-based pharmacophore models is presented. It converts the FragMaps into SILCS pharmacophore features including aromatic, aliphatic, hydrogen-bond donor and acceptor chemical functionalities. The method generates multiple pharmacophore hypotheses that are then quantitatively ranked using SILCS grid free energies. The pharmacophore model generation protocol is validated using three different protein targets, including using the resulting models in virtual screening. Improved performance and efficiency of the SILCS derived pharmacophore models as compared to published docking studies, as well as a recently developed receptor-based pharmacophore modeling method is shown, indicating the potential utility of the approach in rational drug design.     

On the value of homology models for virtual screening: discovering hCXCR3 antagonists by pharmacophore-based and structure-based approaches

Human chemokine receptor CXCR3 (hCXCR3) antagonists have potential therapeutic applications as antivirus, antitumor, and anti-inflammatory agents. A novel virtual screening protocol, which combines pharmacophore-based and structure-based approaches, was proposed. A three-dimensional QSAR pharmacophore model and a structure-based docking model were built to virtually screen for hCXCR3 antagonists. The hCXCR3 antagonist binding site was constructed by homology modeling and molecular dynamics (MD) simulation. By combining the structure-based and ligand-based screenings results, 95% of the compounds satisfied either pharmacophore or docking score criteria and would be chosen as hits if the union of the two searches was taken. The false negative rates were 15% for the pharmacophore model, 14% for the homology model, and 5% for the combined model. Therefore, the consistency of the pharmacophore model and the structural binding model is 219/273 = 80%. The hit rate for the virtual screening protocol is 273/286 = 95%. This work demonstrated that the quality of both the pharmacophore model and homology model can be measured by the consistency of the two models, and the false negatives in virtual screening can be reduced by combining two virtual screening approaches.     

Machine learning-, rule- and pharmacophore-based classification on the inhibition of P-glycoprotein and NorA

The efflux pumps P-glycoprotein (P-gp) in humans and NorA in Staphylococcus aureus are of great interest for medicinal chemists because of their important roles in multidrug resistance (MDR). The high polyspecificity as well as the unavailability of high-resolution X-ray crystal structures of these transmembrane proteins lead us to combining ligand-based approaches, which in the case of this study were machine learning, perceptual mapping and pharmacophore modelling. For P-gp inhibitory activity, individual models were developed using different machine learning algorithms and subsequently combined into an ensemble model which showed a good discrimination between inhibitors and noninhibitors (acc_{train-diverse} = 84%; acc_{internal-test} = 92% and acc_{external-test} = 100%). For ligand promiscuity between P-gp and NorA, perceptual maps and pharmacophore models were generated for the detection of rules and features. Based on these in silico tools, hit compounds for reversing MDR were discovered from the in-house and DrugBank databases through virtual screening in an attempt to restore drug sensitivity in cancer cells and bacteria.     

Development of purely structure-based pharmacophores for the topoisomerase I-DNA-ligand binding pocket

Purely structure-based pharmacophores (SBPs) are an alternative method to ligand-based approaches and have the advantage of describing the entire interaction capability of a binding pocket. Here, we present the development of SBPs for topoisomerase I, an anticancer target with an unusual ligand binding pocket consisting of protein and DNA atoms. Different approaches to cluster and select pharmacophore features are investigated, including hierarchical clustering and energy calculations. In addition, the performance of SBPs is evaluated retrospectively and compared to the performance of ligand- and complex-based pharmacophores. SBPs emerge as a valid method in virtual screening and a complementary approach to ligand-focussed methods. The study further reveals that the choice of pharmacophore feature clustering and selection methods has a large impact on the virtual screening hit lists. A prospective application of the SBPs in virtual screening reveals that they can be used successfully to identify novel topoisomerase inhibitors.     

Discovery of novel cathepsin S inhibitors by pharmacophore-based virtual high-throughput screening

The cysteine protease cathepsin S (CatS) is involved in the pathogenesis of autoimmune disorders, atherosclerosis, and obesity. Therefore, it represents a promising pharmacological target for drug development. We generated ligand-based and structure-based pharmacophore models for noncovalent and covalent CatS inhibitors to perform virtual high-throughput screening of chemical databases in order to discover novel scaffolds for CatS inhibitors. An in vitro evaluation of the resulting 15 structures revealed seven CatS inhibitors with kinetic constants in the low micromolar range. These compounds can be subjected to further chemical modifications to obtain drugs for the treatment of autoimmune disorders and atherosclerosis.     

Evaluation of potential inhibitors of squalene synthase based on virtual screening and in vitro studies

Squalene synthase (SQS) is a potential target for hyperlipidemia treatment. To identify novel chemical scaffolds of SQS inhibitors, we generated 3D-QSAR pharmacophore models using HypoGen. The best quantitative pharmacophore model, Hypo 1, was selected for virtual screening using two chemical databases, Specs and Traditional Chinese Medicine database (TCM). The best-mapped hit compounds were then subjected to filtering by Lipinski^’s rule of five and docking studies to refine the hits. Finally, five compounds were selected from the top-ranked hit compounds for SQS inhibitory assay in vitro. Three of these compounds could inhibit SQS in vitro, and should be further evaluated pre-clinically as a treatment for hyperlipidemia.     

SHAFTS: a hybrid approach for 3D molecular similarity calculation. 1. Method and assessment of virtual screening

We developed a novel approach called SHAFTS (SHApe-FeaTure Similarity) for 3D molecular similarity calculation and ligand-based virtual screening. SHAFTS adopts a hybrid similarity metric combined with molecular shape and colored (labeled) chemistry groups annotated by pharmacophore features for 3D similarity calculation and ranking, which is designed to integrate the strength of pharmacophore matching and volumetric overlay approaches. A feature triplet hashing method is used for fast molecular alignment poses enumeration, and the optimal superposition between the target and the query molecules can be prioritized by calculating corresponding "hybrid similarities". SHAFTS is suitable for large-scale virtual screening with single or multiple bioactive compounds as the query "templates" regardless of whether corresponding experimentally determined conformations are available. Two public test sets (DUD and Jain's sets) including active and decoy molecules from a panel of useful drug targets were adopted to evaluate the virtual screening performance. SHAFTS outperformed several other widely used virtual screening methods in terms of enrichment of known active compounds as well as novel chemotypes, thereby indicating its robustness in hit compounds identification and potential of scaffold hopping in virtual screening.     

Identification of potential Tpx inhibitors against pathogen-host interactions

Yersinia organisms cause many infectious diseases by invading human cells and delivering their virulence factors via the type three secretion system (T3SS). One alternative strategy in the fight against these pathogenic organisms is to interfere with their T3SS. Previous studies demonstrated that thiol peroxidase, Tpx is functional in the assembly of T3SS and its inhibition by salicylidene acylhydrazides prevents the secretion of pathogenic effectors. In this study, the aim was to identify potential inhibitors of Tpx using an integrated approach starting with high throughput virtual screening and ending with molecular dynamics simulations of selected ligands. Virtual screening of ZINC database of 500,000 compounds via ligand-based and structure-based pharmacophore models retrieved 10,000 hits. The structure-based pharmacophore model was validated using high-throughput virtual screening (HTVS). After multistep docking (SP and XP), common scaffolds were used to find common substructures and the ligand binding poses were optimized using induced fit docking. The stability of the protein–ligand complex was examined with molecular dynamics simulations and the binding free energy of the complex was calculated. As a final outcome eight compounds with different chemotypes were proposed as potential inhibitors for Tpx. The eight ligands identified by a detailed virtual screening protocol can serve as leads in future drug design efforts against the destructive actions of pathogenic bacteria.     

Influenza virus neuraminidase inhibitors: generation and comparison of structure-based and common feature pharmacophore hypotheses and their application in virtual screening

X-ray crystallographic data of the influenza virus neuraminidase in complex with different inhibitors were used to generate chemical feature-based pharmacophore models of the binding site of this enzyme. The models were built using the software package Catalyst. Pharmacophore hypotheses derived from the 3-D structure of ligands cocrystallized with the enzyme were then compared with automatically generated common feature pharmacophore hypotheses for neuraminidase inhibitors. The latter models were found to contain fewer features and exhibited lower selectivity in virtual screening experiments. Some functions of the inhibitors obviously participate in more than one mode of interaction with the enzyme (charge-charge interaction and hydrogen bond) or form hydrogen bonds to several amino acids. Since such multiple interactions of one chemical function cannot be included into the Catalyst data format, strategies are presented to overcome these limitations. Finally, the results of 3-D database searching experiments using these hypotheses are described.     

基于虚拟筛选策略发现新型潜在JAK3小分子抑制剂

利用已知活性的分子采用基于配体的策略构建药效团模型,通过基于类药规则、药效团模型、多种精度的分子对接算法、MM/GBSA结合能预测以及ADMET筛选手段对含约250万个分子的数据库进行虚拟筛选。发现5种JAK3抑制剂的新型骨架,其中6个以1-苯基咪唑烷-2-酮为骨架的分子在与JAK3激酶的结合能以及分子的ADMET性质评价方面均表现优异,具备高JAK3抑制剂潜力,被认为是虚拟筛选的命中分子。     

Pharmacophore Modeling and in Silico Screening Studies to Design Potential KDR Kinase Inhibitors

A novel ligand‐based pharmacophore model for KDR kinase was generated on the basis of chemical features of 30 KDR kinase inhibitors. This pharmacophore model consists of one hydrogen‐bond acceptor, one hydrogen‐bond donor and two hydrophobic groups. Several methods have been used to validate the model, suggesting that it can serve as a reliable tool for virtual screening to facilitate the discovery of novel KDR inhibitors. The model was then used as database search query from the National Cancer Institute (NCI) database for the rational design to identify new hit compound.     

Identification of new dual spleen tyrosine kinase (Syk) and phosphoionositide-3-kinase δ (PI3Kδ) inhibitors using ligand and structure-based integrated ideal pharmacophore models

Owing to the complex pathophysiology of autoimmune disorders, it is very challenging to develop successful treatment strategies. Single-target agents are not desired therapeutics for such multi-factorial disorders. Considering the current need for the treatment of complex autoimmune disorders, dual inhibitors of Syk and PI3Kδ have been designed using ligand and structure-based molecular modelling strategies. In the present work, structure and ligand-based pharmacophore modelling was implemented for a varied set of Syk and PI3Kδ inhibitors. Ligand-based pharmacophore models (LBPMs) were developed for two kinases: ADPR.14 (r²_train = 0.809) for Syk, comprising one hydrogen bond acceptor, one hydrogen bond donor, one positive ionisable and one ring aromatic feature, and for PI3Kδ: AAARR.45 (r²_train = 0.942) consisting of three hydrogen bond acceptor and two ring aromatic features. The generated e-pharmacophore models revealed an additional ring aromatic and hydrophobic feature important for Syk and PI3Kδ inhibition, respectively. Subsequently, LBPMs were modified resulting in APDRR.14 hypothesis for Syk inhibitors and AAAHRR.45 hypothesis for PI3Kδ inhibitors employed for virtual screening. Thus, the combination of ligand and structure-based pharmacophore modelling helped in developing ideal pharmacophore models that may be an efficient tool for the designing of novel dual inhibitors of Syk and PI3Kδ.     

New serotonin 5-HT(6) ligands from common feature pharmacophore hypotheses

Serotonin 5-HT6 receptor antagonists are thought to play an important role in the treatment of psychiatry, Alzheimer's disease, and probably obesity. To find novel and potent 5-HT6 antagonists and to provide a new idea for drug design, we used a ligand-based pharmacophore to perform the virtual screening of a commercially available database. A three-dimensional common feature pharmacophore model was developed by using the HipHop program provided in Catalyst software and was used as a query for screening the database. A recursive partitioning (RP) model which can separate active and inactive compounds was used as a filtering system. Finally a sequential virtual screening procedure (SQSP) was conducted, wherein both the common feature pharmacophore and the RP model were used in succession to improve the results. Some of the hits were selected based on druglikeness, ADME properties, structural diversity, and synthetic accessibility for real biological evaluation. The best hit compound showed a significant IC50 value of 9.6 nM and can be used as a lead for further drug development.     

Automated pharmacophore query optimization with genetic algorithms - a case study using the MC4R system

Due to the recent availability of high quality small molecule databases, such as ZINC and PubChem,1,2 virtual screening is playing an even more important role in identifying biologically relevant molecules in drug discovery campaigns. The success of pharmacophore-based virtual screening (PBVS) relies largely on the accuracy and specificity of the pharmacophore query employed. Deriving a pharmacophore query from a single structure inevitably introduces uncertainty, and the derived query is unlikely to be optimal against every collection of input compounds, especially when it is desired to discriminate among compounds with similar chemical structures. In this study, we present an optimization approach empowered by genetic algorithms (GA) to enhance the accuracy and specificity of a primary pharmacophore query. The example utilized is the human melanocortin type 4 receptor (hMC4R), for which the pharmacophore query was built on the basis of the structure of a rigid cyclic peptide agonist.(3) The optimized query is shown to be capable of identifying 37 positive hMC4R agonists with no false positives from a training set containing 55 agonists and 51 nonagonists. This represents a significant improvement from the initial query which exhibited a 37/32 hit rate. The final, optimized query is challenged with a testing set comprising of 55 hMC4R agonists and 50 nonagonists and achieves a hit rate of 33/8, that improved from 40/31. The impact of GA controlling parameters, including mutation rate, crossover rate, fitness function, population size, and convergence criterion, on performance of optimization are examined and discussed.