Comparative study of the interaction of meso-tetrakis (N-para-trimethyl-anilium) porphyrin (TMAP) in its free base and Fe derivative form with oligo(dA.dT)15 and oligo(dG.dC)15

Interaction between a cationic porphyrin and its ferric derivative with oligo(dA.dT)₁₅ and oligo(dG.dC)₁₅ was studied by UV–vis spectroscopy, resonance light scattering (RLS), and circular dichroism (CD) at different ionic strengths; molecular docking and molecular dynamics simulation were also used for completion. Followings are the observed changes in the spectral properties of meso-tetrakis (N-para-trimethyl-anilium) porphyrin (TMAP), as a free-base porphyrin with no axial ligand, and its Fe derivative (FeTMAP) upon interaction with oligo(dA.dT)₁₅ and oligo(dG.dC)₁₅: (1) the substantial red shift and hypochromicity at the Soret maximum in the UV–vis spectra; (2) the increased RLS intensity by increasing the ionic strength; and (3) an intense bisignate excitonic CD signal. All of them are the reasons for TMAP and FeTMAP binding to oligo(dA.dT)₁₅ and oligo(dG.dC)₁₅ with the outside binding mode, accompanied by the self-stacking of the ligands along the oligonucleotide helix. The CD results demonstrated a drastic change from excitonic in monomeric behavior at higher ionic strengths, which indicates the groove binding of the ligands with oligonucleotides. Molecular docking also confirmed the groove binding mode of the ligands and estimated the binding constants and energies of the interactions. Their interaction trend was further confirmed by molecular dynamics technique and structure parameters obtained from simulation. It showed that TMAP reduced the number of intermolecular hydrogen bonds and increased the solvent accessible surface area in the oligonucleotide. The self-aggregation of ligands at lower concentrations was also confirmed.     

Vibrational and electronic circular dichroism study of the interactions of cationic porphyrins with (dG-dC)10 and (dA-dT)10

The interactions of two different porphyrins, without axial ligands-5,10,15,20-tetrakis(1-methylpyridinium-4-yl)porphyrin-Cu(II) tetrachloride (Cu(II)TMPyP) and with bulky meso substituents-5,10,15,20-tetrakis(N,N,N-trimethylanilinium-4-yl)porphyrin tetrachloride (TMAP), with (dG-dC)10 and (dA-dT)10 were studied by combination of vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) and electronic circular dichroism (ECD) spectroscopy at different [oligonucleotide]/[porphyrin] ratios, where [oligonucleotide] and [porphyrin] are the concentrations of oligonucleotide per base-pair and porphyrin, respectively. The combination of VCD and ECD spectroscopy enables us to identify the types of interactions, and to specify the sites of interactions: The intercalative binding mode of Cu(II)TMPyP with (dG-dC)(10), which has been well described, was characterized by a new VCD "marker" and it was shown that the interaction of Cu(II)TMPyP with (dA-dT)10 via external binding to the phosphate backbone and major groove binding caused transition from the B to the non-B conformer. TMAP interacted with the major groove of (dG-dC)10, was semi-intercalated into (dA-dT)10, and caused significant variation in the structure of both oligonucleotides at the higher concentration of porphyrin. The spectroscopic techniques used in this study revealed that porphyrin binding with AT sequences caused substantial variation of the DNA structure. It was shown that VCD spectroscopy is an effective tool for the conformational studies of nucleic acid-porphyrin complexes in solution.     

Thermodynamics of interactions of TAlPyP4 and AgTAlPyP4 porphyrins with poly(rA)poly(rU) and poly(rI)poly(rC) duplexes

We employed UV light absorption and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopic measurements to study the binding of novel water-soluble porphyrins meso-tetra-(4N-allylpyridyl)porphyrin [TAlPyP4], and its Ag containing derivative to the poly(rA)poly(rU) and poly(rI)poly(rC) RNA duplexes. Our results suggest that TAlPyP4 associate with the duplexes via intercalation, whereas the conservative CD spectra indicates that AgTAlPyP4 preferably binds via outside self-stacking mode. We used our determined binding isotherms for each ligand-RNA binding event to calculate the binding constant, Kb, and binding free energy, DeltaGb = -RTlnKb. By performing these experiments as a function of temperature, we evaluated the van't Hoff binding enthalpies, DeltaH. The binding entropies, DeltaSb, were calculated as DeltaSb = (DeltaHb - DeltaGb)/T. We interpret our data in terms of specific interactions that stabilize/destabilize each ligand-RNA complex studied in this work. Taken together, our data provide important new information about the thermodynamics of interactions of porphyrins with nucleic acids.     

Interactions of DNA with a new electron-deficient tentacle porphyrin: meso-Tetrakis[2,3,5,6-tetrafluoro-4-(2-trimethylammoniumethylamine)phenyl]porphyrin

A new electron-deficient tentacle porphyrin meso-tetrakis[2,3,5,6-tetrafluoro-4-(2-trimethylammoniumethylamine)phenyl]porphyrin (TθF₄TAP) has been synthesized. The binding interactions of TθF₄TAP with DNA polymers were studied for comparison to those of an electron-deficient tentacle porphyrin and an electron-rich tentacle porphyrin; these previously studied porphyrins bind to DNA primarily by intercalative and outside-binding modes, respectively. The three tentacle porphyrins have similar size and shape. The basicity of TθF₄TAP indicated that it has electronic characteristics similar to those of the intercalating electron-deficient tentacle porphyrin. However, TθF₄TAP binds to calf thymus DNA, [poly(dA-dT)]₂, and [poly(dG-dC)]₂ in a self-stacking, outside-binding manner under all conditions. Evidence for this binding mode included a significant hypochromicity of the Soret band, a conservative induced CD spectrum, and the absence of an increase in DNA solution viscosity. As found previously for the electron-rich porphyrin, the results suggest that combinations of closely related self-stacked forms coexist. The mix of forms depended on the DNA and the solution conditions. There are probably differences in the detailed features of the self-stacking adducts for the two types of tentacle porphyrins, especially at high R (ratio of porphyrin to DNA). At low R values, the induced CD signal of TθF₄TAP/CT DNA resembled that of TθF₄TAP/[poly(dA-dT)]₂, suggesting that TθF₄TAP binds preferentially at AT regions. Competitive binding experiments gave evidence that TθF₄TAP binds preferentially to [poly(dA-dT)]₂ over [poly(dG-dC)]₂. Thus, despite the long, positively charged, flexible substituents on the porphyrin, the binding of TθF₄TAP is significantly affected by base-pair composition. Similar characteristics were found previously for the electron-rich tentacle porphyrin. Thus, significant changes in electron richness have relatively minor effects on this outside binding selectivity for AT regions. TθF₄TAP is the first porphyrin with electron deficiency and shape similar to intercalating porphyrins that does not appear to intercalate. All porphyrins reported to intercalate have had pyridinium substituents. Thus, the electronic distribution in the porphyrin ring, not just the overall electron richness, may play a role in facilitating intercalation. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biopoly 42: 203–217, 1997     

Cationic porphyrins bearing diazolium rings: synthesis and their interaction with calf thymus DNA

Two novel cationic porphyrins bearing five-membered rings at the meso-positions, meso-tetrakis(1,3-dimethylimidazolium-2-yl)porphyrin (H2TDMImP) and meso-tetrakis(1,2-dimethylpyrazolium-4-yl)porphyrin (H2TDMPzP), have been synthesized. These two compounds interact with calf thymus DNA (CTDNA) in different binding modes from that of mesotetrakis(N-methylpyridinium-4-yl)porphyrin (H2TMPyP). H2TDMImP outside binds to the minor groove of CTDNA while H2TDMPzP intercalates into CTDNA. These two novel cationic porphyrins strongly bind to CTDNA even at high ionic strength and the binding constant of H2TDMPzP to CTDNA is comparable to that of H2TMPyP. The binding of H2TDMImP to CTDNA is enthalpically driven. The favorable free energy changes in binding of H2TDMPzP to CTDNA come from the large negative enthalpy changes accompanied by small positive entropy changes.     

Two binding modes of netropsin are involved in the complex formation with poly(dA-dT).poly(dA-dT) and other alternating DNA duplex polymers

Using CD measurements we show that the interaction of netropsin to poly(dA-dT).poly(dA-dT) involves two binding modes at low ionic strength. The first and second binding modes are distinguished by a defined shift of the CD maximum and the presence of characteristic isodichroic points in the long wavelength range from 313 nm to 325 nm. The first binding mode is independent of ionic strength and is primarily determined by specific interaction to dA.dT base pairs. Employing a netropsin derivative and different salt conditions it is demonstrated that ionic contacts are essential for the second binding mode. Other alternating duplexes and natural DNA also exhibit more or less a second step in the interaction with netropsin observable at high ratio of ligand per nucleotide. The second binding mode is absent for poly(dA).poly(dT). The presence of a two-step binding mechanism is also demonstrated in the complex formation of poly(dA-dT).poly(dA-dT) with the distamycin analog consisting of pentamethylpyrrolecarboxamide. While the binding mode I of netropsin is identical with its localization in the minor groove, for binding mode II we consider two alternative interpretations.     

Interaction of Fe(III)- and Zn(II)-tetra(4-sulfonatophenyl) porphyrins with ionic and nonionic surfactants: aggregation and binding

Interactions of the water soluble Fe(III)- and Zn(II)-tetra(4-sulfonatophenyl) porphyrins, FeTPPS(4) and ZnTPPS(4), with ionic and nonionic micelles in aqueous solutions have been studied by optical absorption, fluorescence, resonance light-scattering (RLS), and 1H NMR spectroscopies. The presence of three different species of both Fe(III)- and Zn(II)TPPS(4) in cationic cetyltrimethylammonium chloride (CTAC) solution has been unequivocally demonstrated: free metalloporphyrin monomers or dimers (pH 9), metalloporphyrin monomers or aggregates (possibly micro-oxo dimers) bound to the micelles, and nonmicellar metalloporphyrin/surfactant aggregates. The surfactant:metalloporphyrin ratio for the maximum nonmicellar aggregate formation is around 5-8 for Fe(III)TPPS(4) both at pH 4.0 and 9.0; for Zn(II)TPPS(4) this ratio is 8, and the spectral changes are practically independent of pH. In the case of zwitterionic N-hexadecyl-N,N-dimethyl-3-ammonio-1-propanesulfonate (HPS) and non-ionic polyoxyethylene lauryl ether (Brij-35) and t-octylphenoxypolyethoxyetanol (Triton X-100), the nonmicellar aggregates were not observed in the pH range from 2.0 to 12.0. Binding constants were calculated from optical absorption data and are of the order of 10(4) M(-1) for both CTAC and HPS, values which are similar to those previously obtained for the porphyrin in the free base form. For Brij-35 and Triton X-100 the binding constant for ZnTPPS(4) at pH 4.0 is a factor of 3-5 lower than those for CTAC and HPS, while in the case of FeTPPS(4) they are two orders of magnitude lower. Our data show that solubilization of ZnTPPS(4) within nonpolar regions of micelles is determined, in general, by nonspecific hydrophobic interactions, yet it is modulated by electrostatic factors. In the case of FeTPPS(4), the electrostatic factor seems to be more relevant. NMR data indicated that Fe(III)TPPS(4) is bound to the micelles predominantly as a monomer at pH 4.0, and at pH 9.0 the bound aggregated form (possibly micro-oxo dimers) remains. The metalloporphyrins were incorporated into the micelles near the terminal part of their hydrocarbon chains, as evidenced by a strong upfield shift of the corresponding peaks of the surfactants.     

Classification of CD and absorption spectra in the Soret band of H(2)TMPyP bound to various synthetic polynucleotides

The binding mode of porphyrins, namely meso-tetrakis(N-methyl pyridinium-4-yl)porphyrin (H(2)TMPyP), was classified in this work by absorption and circular dichroism(CD) spectroscopy. The three binding modes of intercalation, minor groove binding and external stacking exhibit their own characteristic absorption and CD spectra. Intercalation occurs for this porphyrin when bound to GC-rich polynucleotides at a low mixing ratio, as expected. This binding mode produces hypochromism and a red shift in the absorption band and a negative CD band in the Soret absorption region. When it is complexed with AT-rich polynucleotides at a low mixing ratio, hypochromism and a red shift in the absorption band and a positive CD peak is apparent, and this species can easily be assigned to the minor groove-binding mode. For both AT- and GC-rich polynucleotides at a high binding ratio, an excitonic CD was apparent. The sign of excitonic CD depends on the order of the DNA bases; the CD spectra of H(2)TMPyP complexed with non-alternating homopolymer (disregarding the nature of base pairs, i.e. AT or GC) are characterized by a positive band at short wavelengths followed by a negative band at long wavelengths. In contrast, those complexed with alternating polynucleotide were opposite to those of non-alternating homopolymers.     

Interaction of metallopyrazoliumylporphyrins with calf thymus DNA.

The interaction of transition metal complexes of cationic porphyrins bearing five membered rings, meso-tetrakis(1,2-dimethylpyrazolium-4-yl)porphyrin (MPzP, M=Mn(III), Ni(II), Cu(II) or Zn(II)), with calf thymus DNA (ctDNA) has been studied. Metalloporphyrins NiPzP and CuPzP are intercalated into the 5'GC3' step of ctDNA. MnPzP is bound edge-on at the 5'TA3' step of the minor groove of ctDNA, while ZnPzP is bound face-on at the 5'TA3' step of the major groove of ctDNA. The binding constants of the metalloporphyrins to ctDNA range from 1.05x10(5) to 2.66x10(6) M(-1) and are comparable to those of other reported cationic porphyrins. The binding process of the metallopyrazoliumylporphyrins to ctDNA is endothermic and entropically driven. These results have revealed that the kind of central metal ions of metalloporphyrins influences the binding characteristics of the porphyrin to DNA.     

Circular dichroism and the interactions of water soluble porphyrins with DNA

The size, sign, and profile of induced circular dichroism (CD) features in the Soret region are reliable indicators of the binding modes of porphyrins and metalloporphyrins to DNA. Porphyrins shown (using such CD criteria) to be intercalators in monodispersed DNA duplexes prove extremely useful for the detection and characterization of organized, condensed forms of nucleic acids (psi-condensates). In addition, certain select porphyrin derivatives can form extended assemblies on nonaggregated DNA templates. A combination of CD and resonance light scattering (RLS) measurements allows for sensitive detection and characterization of these porphyrin arrays.     

Rotation of periphery methylpyridine of meso-tetrakis(n-N-methylpyridiniumyl)porphyrin (n = 2, 3, 4) and its selective binding to native and synthetic DNAs

By utilizing circular and linear dichroism, the binding mode of meso-tetrakis(n-N-methylpyridiniumyl)porphyrin (n = 2, 3, 4) to various DNAs was studied in this work. 2-N-(methylpyridiniumyl)porphyrin(o-TMPyP), in which rotation of the periphery pyridinium ring is prevented, exhibits similar spectral properties when bound to DNA, poly[d(G-C)(2)] and poly[d(A-T)(2)], suggesting a similar binding mode. Close analysis of the spectral properties led us to conclude that o-TMPyP sits in the major groove. However, both 3-N- and 4-N-(methylpyridiniumyl)porphyrin (m- and p-TMPyP), of which the periphery pyridinium ring is free to rotate, intercalate between the basepairs of DNA and poly[d(G-C)(2)]. In the presence of poly[d(A-T)(2)], m-TMPyP exhibits a typical bisignate excitonic CD spectrum in the Soret band, while p-TMPyP shows two positive CD bands. The excitonic CD spectrum of the m-TMPyP-poly[d(A-T)(2)] complex and the positive CD band of the o-TMPyP-poly[d(A-T)(2)] complex were not affected by the presence of the minor groove binding drug, 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI), indicating that this porphyrin is bound in the major groove. In contrast, two positive CD bands of the p-TMPyP-poly[d(A-T)(2)] complex altered in the presence of DAPI. From the changes in CD spectrum and other spectral properties, a few possible binding modes for p-TMPyP to poly[d(A-T)(2)] are suggested.     

Copper insertion facilitates water-soluble porphyrin binding to rA.rU and rA.dT base pairs in duplex RNA and RNA.DNA hybrids

The binding of the copper(II) complex of water-soluble meso-tetrakis(N-methylpyridinium-4-yl)porphyrin (TMPyP) to double-helical polynucleotides has been studied by optical absorption, circular dichroism (CD), and resonance Raman spectroscopic methods. The target polymers were RNA and RNA.DNA hybrids consisting of rA.rU, rI.rC, rA.dT, and rI.dC base pairs. Relative to the metal-free H(2)TMPyP [Uno, T., Hamasaki, K., Tanigawa, M., and Shimabayashi, S. (1997) Inorg. Chem. 36, 1676-1683], CuTMPyP binds to poly(rA).poly(dT) and poly(rA).poly(rU) with a greatly increased binding constant. The external self-stacking of the porphyrin on the surface of the polymers was evident from the strong conservative-type induced CD signals. The signal intensity correlated almost linearly with the number of stacking sites on the polymer except for poly(rA).poly(dT), which showed extraordinarily strong CD signals. Thus, the bound porphyrin may impose an ordered architecture on the polymer surface, the stacking being facilitated by the more planar nature of the CuTMPyP than the nonmetal counterpart. Resonance Raman spectra of the stacked CuTMPyP were indistinguishable from those of the intercalated one with positive delta(Cbeta-H) and negative delta(Cm-Py) bending shifts, and hence the stacked porphyrins are suggested to adopt a similar structure to that of intercalated ones. Porphyrin flattening by copper insertion opens a new avenue for medical applications of porphyrins, blocking biological events related to RNA and hybrids in malignant cells.     

Porphyrin-nucleic acid interactions: a review

Research involving three important interactions of synthetic cationic porphyrins with nucleic acids: DNA binding, oxidative-reductive strand scission and photosensitized strand scission, is examined retrospectively. The observation that these porphyrins as a class can associate with DNA by intercalative binding, outside binding and outside binding with self-stacking, i.e., the "three-mode binding model", is evaluated with regard to supporting data from several studies including recent evidence from NMR spectroscopy. Results from investigations into the "nuclease-like" activity of the metallo-derivatives of this class of porphyrins are surveyed for demonstrations of base specificity and the mechanism of the chemical interaction. The ability of cationic porphyrins to induce photosensitized damage in DNA is also reviewed with an emphasis on their strand scission activity via a singlet oxygen intermediate.     

Syntheses and DNA binding of new cationic porphyrin-tetrapeptide conjugates

Recently cationic porphyrin-peptide conjugates were synthesized to enhance the cellular uptake of porphyrins or deliver the peptide moiety to the close vicinity of nucleic acids. DNA binding of such compounds was not systematically studied yet.We synthesized two new porphyrin-tetrapeptide conjugates which can be considered as a typical monomer unit corresponding to the branches of porphyrin-polymeric branched chain polypeptide conjugates. Tetra-peptides were linked to the tri-cationic meso-tri(4-N-methylpyridyl)-mono-(4-carboxyphenyl)porphyrin and bi-cationic meso-5,10-bis(4-N-methylpyridyl)-15,20-di-(4-carboxyphenyl)porphyrin. DNA binding of porphyrin derivatives, and their peptide conjugates was investigated with comprehensive spectroscopic methods. Titration of porphyrin conjugates with DNA showed changes in Soret bands with bathocromic shifts and hypochromicities. Decomposition of absorption spectra suggested the formation of two populations of bound porphyrins.Evidence provided by the decomposition of absorption spectra, fluorescence decay components, fluorescence energy transfer and induced CD signals reveals that peptide conjugates of di- and tricationic porphyrins bind to DNA by two distinct binding modes which can be identified as intercalation and external binding. Tri-cationic structure and elimination of negative charges in the peptide conjugates are preferable for the binding. Our findings provide essential information for the design of DNA-targeted porphyrin-peptide conjugates.     

Binding and photocleavage of cationic porphyrin-phenylpiperazine hybrids to DNA

The binding properties of cationic porphyrin-phenylpiperazine hybrids to calf thymus (CT) DNA were investigated by using absorption, fluorescence and circular dichroism (CD) spectra, and the apparent affinity binding constants (K(app)) of the porphyrins for CT DNA were determined by using a competition method with ethidium bromide (EB). Intercalation of porphyrin into CT DNA occurred when two phenylpiperazines were introduced at cis position onto the periphery of cationic porphyrin. The photocleavages of pBR322 plasmid DNA by the porphyrins were consistent with the values of K(app). With [porphyrin]/[DNA base pairs] ratio increased, the binding mode tended to be outside binding, and the cleavage abilities of the porphyrins varied. In the presence of sodium azide, a quencher of 1O2, the cleavage of DNA by the porphyrin of intercalation was less inhibited.     

Binding of porphyrin to human serum albumin. Structure-activity relationships.

The equilibrium binding of hydroxyethyl vinyl deuteroporphyrin (HVD) and of irreversible porphyrin aggregates to human serum albumin was studied at the molecular level. This protein may function as an endogenous drug carrier for porphyrins in photodynamic therapy of tumours. HVD-protein binding studies revealed two types of binding sites, which are attributed to the two HVD isomers. The binding constant for the high-affinity isomer, 2.1 (+/- 0.3) x 10(8) M-1, is similar to that previously determined for protoporphyrin. At the same time the binding constant for the lower-affinity HVD isomer, 1.8(+/- 0.3) x 10(6) M-1, is similar to that previously determined for haematoporphyrin. Irreversible porphyrin aggregates were purified from the haematoporphyrin derivative and from Photofrin and are defined by spectral and chromatographic data. Gel-exclusion studies indicate that the dominant size of these aggregates is ten porphyrin monomeric units. The protein-binding constant of these aggregates is 1.7(+/- 0.2) x 10(5) M-1, with four binding sites per protein molecule. The distinction between the HVD isomers along the porphyrin-protein affinity sequence gives insight into the relationship of porphyrin structure to porphyrin-albumin binding. On the basis of this study an evaluation of human serum albumin as an endogenous carrier for porphyrins (at various aggregation states) in photodynamic therapy of tumours is presented.     

Binding of tetrakis(pyrazoliumyl)porphyrin and its copper(II) and zinc(II) complexes to poly(dG-dC)2 and poly(dA-dT)2

Interactions of cationic porphyrins bearing five-membered rings at the meso position, meso-tetrakis(1,2-dimethylpyrazolium-4-yl)porphyrin (MPzP; M is H₂, Cu^II or Zn^II), with synthetic polynucleotides poly(dG-dC)₂ and poly(dA-dT)₂ have been characterized by viscometric, visible absorption, circular dichroisim and magnetic circular dichroism spectroscopic and melting temperature measurements. Both H₂PzP and CuPzP are intercalated into poly(dG-dC)₂ and are outside-bound to the major groove of poly(dA-dT)₂, while ZnPzP is outside-bound to the minor groove of poly(dA-dT)₂ and surprisingly is intercalated into poly(dG-dC)₂. The binding constants of the porphyrin and poly(dG-dC)₂ and poly(dA-dT)₂ are on the order of 10⁶ M⁻¹ and are comparable to those of other cationic porphyrins so far reported. The process of the binding of the porphyrin to poly(dG-dC)₂ and poly(dA-dT)₂ is exothermic and enthalpically driven for H₂PzP, whereas it is endothermic and entropically driven for CuPzP and ZnPzP. These results have revealed that the kind of the central metal ion of metalloporphyrins influences the characteristics of the binding of the porphyrins to DNA.Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available for this article at and is accessible for authorized users.     

Binding mode of porphyrins to poly[d(A-T)(2)] and poly[d(G-C)(2)

We examined the binding geometry of Co-meso-tetrakis (N-methyl pyridinium-4-yl)porphyrin, Co-meso-tetrakis (N-n-butyl pyridinium-4-yl)porphyrin and their metal-free ligands to poly[d(A-T)(2)] and poly[d(G-C)(2)] by optical spectroscopic methods including absorption, circular and linear dichroism spectroscopy, and fluorescence energy transfer technique. Signs of an induced CD spectrum in the Soret band depend only on the nature of the DNA sequence; all porphyrins exhibit negative CD when bound to poly[d(G-C)(2)] and positive when bound to poly[d(A-T)(2)]. Close analysis of the linear dichroism result reveals that all porphyrins exhibit outside binding when complexed with poly[d(A-T)(2)], regardless of the existence of a central metal and side chain. However, in the case of poly[d(G-C)(2)], we observed intercalative binding mode for two nonmetalloporphyrins and an outside binding mode for metalloporphyrins. The nature of the outside binding modes of the porphyrins, when complexed with poly[d(A-T)(2)] and poly[d(G-C)(2)], are quite different. We also demonstrate that an energy transfer from the excited nucleo-bases to porphyrins can occur for metalloporphyrins.