Resistant cabbage cultivars change the susceptibility of Plutella xylostella to Bacillus thuringiensis

1 Laboratory studies demonstrated that the susceptibility of larvae of the lepidopteran crucifer pest Plutella xylostella to the insect pathogen Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) was influenced by the host plant. 2 Larvae reared on the resistant cabbage cultivars Minicole F₁ and Red Drumhead were significantly more susceptible to Bt (the LC₅₀ fell to one half) than larvae fed leaves of susceptible cultivars. 3 However, a third resistant cultivar, Aquarius F₁, had no synergistic effect on Bt‐related mortality. 4 Actual uptake of Bt was monitored in the bioassays, as a preliminary experiment showed that the plant resistance reduced consumption of Bt‐treated leaf discs. However, differences in feeding rate did not explain the observed differences in mortality.     

Transgenic broccoli expressing aBacillus thuringiensis insecticidal crystal protein: Implications for pest resistance management strategies

We usedAgrobacterium tumefaciens to transform flowering stalk explants of five genotypes of broccoli with a construct containing the neomycin phosphotransferase gene and aBacillus thuringiensis (Bt) gene [CryIA(c) type] optimized for plant expression. Overall transformation efficiency was 6.4%; 181 kanamycin-resistant plants were recovered. Of the 162 kanamycin-resistant plants tested, 112 (69%) caused 100% morality of 1st-instar larvae of aBt-susceptible diamondback moth strain. Southern blots of some resistant transformants confirmed presence of theBt gene. Selected plants that gave 100% mortality of susceptible larvae allowed survival of a strain of diamondback moth that had evolved resistance toBt in the field. F₁ hybrids between resistant and susceptible insects did not survive. Analysis of progeny from 26 resistant transgenic lines showed 16 that gave segregation ratios consistent with a single T-DNA integration. Southern analysis was used to verify those plants possessing a single T-DNA integration. Because these transgenic plants kill susceptible larvae and F₁ larvae, but serve as a suitable host for resistant ones, they provide an excellent model for tests ofBt resistance management strategies.     

Strategy for orchard use of Bacillus thuringiensis while minimizing impact on Choristoneura rosaceana parasitoids

Trials were conducted to study how spring Bacillus thuringiensis Berliner subsp. kurstaki treatments on apple may be timed to maximize the survival of parasitoids of the obliquebanded leafroller, Choristoneura rosaceana (Harris) (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae), found in the southern interior of British Columbia, Canada. Orchard collections verified that second through fourth instar obliquebanded leafrollers were found in varying proportions from pink through the petal fall stage of apple development when spring B. thuringiensis treatments are applied vs. lepidopteran pests. Laboratory‐reared second through fourth instar obliquebanded leafrollers, unparasitized and parasitized by one of three native parasitoid species, were fed untreated apple leaves or leaves treated with B. thuringiensis. The highest mortality of unparasitized obliquebanded leafrollers occurred when fourth instars were exposed to B. thuringiensis‐treated leaves; B. thuringiensis‐induced mortality in the unparasitized second and third instars was less than 50%. The consumption of B. thuringiensis‐treated leaves by host larvae significantly increased the percentage of dead host larvae in all parasitized and unparasitized treatments. However, because of the low susceptibility of this leafroller species to B. thuringiensis, relatively high numbers (38–43%) of three obliquebanded leafroller parasitoid species were able to survive the consumption of B. thuringiensis by second and third instar host larvae. Fourth instar obliquebanded leafrollers were found at the full bloom and petal fall stage of apple development in the orchard, at which time B. thuringiensis treatments are recommended for optimal leafroller control. The highest parasitoid mortality due to host mortality was recorded in Apophua simplicipes Cresson (Hymenoptera: Ichneumonidae) and Macrocentrus linearis (Nees) (Hymenoptera: Braconidae), when the hosts were treated as fourth instars. Both of these parasitoids emerge from fifth and sixth instar obliquebanded leafrollers. Bacillus thuringiensis did not have as negative an impact on Apanteles polychrosidis Viereck (Hymenoptera: Braconidae), which emerges when the host is in the fourth instar. When leafroller mortality and parasitism were combined, the B. thuringiensis treatment did not significantly increase host elimination above that of parasitism alone, except for larvae parasitized by A. simplicipes that were in the fourth instar. The consumption of B. thuringiensis by unparasitized larvae was shown to slow larval development.     

Contribution of Bacillus thuringiensis Spores to Toxicity of Purified Cry Proteins Towards Indianmeal Moth Larvae

The influence of Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki HD-1 spores upon the toxicity of purified Cry1Ab and Cry1C crystal proteins toward susceptible and BT-resistant Indianmeal moth (IMM, Plodia interpunctella) larvae was investigated. With susceptible larvae, HD-1 spores were toxic in the absence of crystal protein and highly synergistic (approximately 35- to 50-fold) with either Cry1Ab or Cry1C protein. With BT-resistant IMM larvae, HD-1 spores were synergistic with Cry1Ab and Cry1C protein in all three resistant strains examined. Synergism was highest (approximately 25- to 44-fold) in insects with primary resistance toward Cry1C (IMM larvae with resistance to B. thuringiensis subsp. aizawai or entomocidus). However, HD-1 spores also synergized either Cry1Ab or Cry1C toxicity toward larvae resistant to B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki at a lower level (approximately five- to sixfold). With susceptible larvae, the presence of spores reduced the time of death when combined with each of the purified Cry proteins. Without spores, the speed of intoxication and eventual death for larvae treated with Cry1C and Cry1Ab proteins was much slower than for the HD-1 preparation containing both spores and crystals together. Neither spores nor toxin dose affected the mean time of death of resistant larvae treated with either Cry1Ab or Cry1C toxins. Both Cry1Ab and Cry1C toxins appeared to reduce feeding and consequently toxin consumption. Received: 1 December 1995 / Accepted: 3 January 1996     

Larval feeding behavior of Dipel-resistant and susceptible Ostrinia nubilalis on diet containing Bacillus thuringiensis (Dipel ESTM)

Diet choice tests were conducted to examine the effects of Bacillus thuringiensis Berliner on larval feeding behavior of Dipel-resistant and susceptible strains of European corn borer, Ostrinia nubilalis (Hübner). Larvae (first through fourth instars) were presented an untreated standard diet and three diets incorporating different concentrations of a commercial formulation of B. thuringiensis, Dipel ES^TM. Significantly higher proportions of susceptible and resistant larvae were found on the control diet compared to the proportions recorded on any of the Dipel-treated diets. Soon after release (0.5 to 3 h), the occurrence of larvae on each of the diets was similar across different instars. The number of first and second instars on the control diet increased steadily over 72 h after release, when 43 to 75% of larvae were found on the control diet. The proportion of third and fourth instars on the control diet also increased initially, with an equilibrium occurring 12 to 24 h later when 30 to 40% of larvae were found on the control diet. Both strains appeared to avoid the Dipel-treated diets and their responses were similar over different Dipel concentrations. The Dipel-resistant strain showed higher ability to avoid the treated diets than the susceptible strain.     

Characterization of cultured insect cells selected by <Emphasis Type="Italic">Bacillus thuringiensis</Emphasis> crystal toxin

Summary Selection for resistance against Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) Cry1Ac10 in the Trichoplusia ni (Hübner) cell line BTI-TN-5B1-4 (TnH5) was tested, and the development of resistance in the selected cells was like a S-form curve. Monitoring at the Cry1Ac10 50th challenge, the resistance ratio was 1, 294-fold as many as that of initial cells. But the resistance to Cry1Ac10 declined gradually when the selection was relaxed. The resistance declined rapidly at the low level of resistance and slowly at the high level of resistance. This resistant cell had high resistance to all the tested solubilized trypsin-treated mixture of crystal multitoxins of B. thuringiensis subsp. aizawai GC-91, an engineering bacterium of Bt, B. thuringiensis subsp. aizawai HD-133 and B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki HD-1, and low cross-resistance (19.7-fold) to activated Cry1C. Both N-acetyl-d-galactosamine (GalNAc) and tunicamycin did not inhibit the toxicity of Cry1Ac10 to the susceptible TnH5 cells. Comparison of the total proteins of the selected resistant cells with that of the nonselected susceptible cells by two-dimensional electrophoresis analysis showed that were obvious differences among the 11 protein expression. These results strongly suggest that there exists an unknown mechanism of resistance in the cell line that was different from the reported mechanisms in insects.     

Synergism between Bacillus thuringiensis Spores and Toxins against Resistant and Susceptible Diamondback Moths (Plutella xylostella)

We studied the effects of combinations of Bacillus thuringiensis spores and toxins on the mortality of diamondback moth (Plutella xylostella) larvae in leaf residue bioassays. Spores of B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki increased the toxicity of crystals of B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki to both resistant and susceptible larvae. For B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki, resistance ratios were 1,200 for a spore-crystal mixture and 56,000 for crystals without spores. Treatment of a spore-crystal formulation of B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki with the antibiotic streptomycin to inhibit spore germination reduced toxicity to resistant larvae but not to susceptible larvae. In contrast, analogous experiments with B. thuringiensis subsp. aizawai revealed no significant effects of adding spores to crystals or of treating a spore-crystal formulation with streptomycin. Synergism occurred between Cry2A and B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki spores against susceptible larvae and between Cry1C and B. thuringiensis subsp. aizawai spores against resistant and susceptible larvae. The results show that B. thuringiensis toxins combined with spores can be toxic even though the toxins and spores have little or no independent toxicity. Results reported here and previously suggest that, for diamondback moth larvae, the extent of synergism between spores and toxins of B. thuringiensis depends on the strain of insect, the type of spore, the set of toxins, the presence of other materials such as formulation ingredients, and the concentrations of spores and toxins.     

Plant-mediated vulnerability of an insect herbivore to Bacillus thuringiensis in a plant-herbivore-pathogen system

Laboratory studies were performed to explore the effects of host-plant quality on the vulnerability of Plutella xylostella to Bacillus thuringiensis. P. xylostella were kept on different host plants, including Brassica pekinensis (Chinese cabbage) cv. Hero, Brassica oleracea var. botrytis (cauliflower) cv. Royal, and B. oleracea var. capitata (common cabbage) cv. Globe Master (white cabbage) and cv. Red Dynasty (red cabbage) for at least two generations. These host plants are considered as the high (Chinese cabbage), intermediate (cauliflower and white cabbage) and low-quality (red cabbage) hosts for P. xylostella. The vulnerability of the pest larvae was then tested using two formulation of B. thuringiensis var. kurstaki, including Biolarv^® and Biolep^®. The results demonstrated that the susceptibility of P. xylostella to B. thuringiensis was influenced by host-plant quality. Indeed, B. thuringiensis acted better on the pest fed on the low-quality host plant compared with that on the high-quality host plant. The interaction between the pathogen and plant quality/resistance resulted in more mortality of the pest larvae, implying a synergistic effect. From a pest management viewpoint, these findings may be promising for the integration of the pathogen and the low-quality/partially resistant host plants against P. xylostella in field studies.     

Larval survival and development of susceptible and resistant Ostrinia nubilalis (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) on diet containing Bacillus thuringiensis

Abstract 1 Larval survival and development of Dipel‐susceptible and ‐resistant strains of European corn borer, Ostrinia nubilalis (Hübner), were assayed using diets incorporating low doses of a commercial formulation of Bacillus thuringiensis var. kurstaki Berliner (Dipel ES). 2 Larval mortality, growth and development, pupation rate and pupal weight were not significantly different between Dipel‐susceptible and ‐resistant strains when larvae were reared on a nontoxic control diet. 3 Larval mortality of Dipel‐resistant larvae did not significantly change as Dipel concentration increased at the tested concentrations, whereas mortality of Dipel‐susceptible larvae increased dramatically as Dipel concentration increased. 4 Larval development was significantly delayed when larvae were fed diets containing low doses of Dipel. 5 Pupation rate and pupal body weight declined as Dipel concentration increased but it decreased faster for the susceptible strain than for the resistant strain.     

Resistance to Toxins from Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki Causes Minimal Cross-Resistance to B. thuringiensis subsp. aizawai in the Diamondback Moth (Lepidoptera: Plutellidae)

Repeated exposure in the field followed by laboratory selection produced 1,800- to >6,800-fold resistance to formulations of Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki in larvae of the diamondback moth, Plutella xylostella. Four toxins from B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki [CryIA(a), CryIA(b), CryIA(c), and CryIIA] caused significantly less mortality in resistant larvae than in susceptible larvae. Resistance to B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki formulations and toxins did not affect the response to CryIC toxin from B. thuringiensis subsp. aizawai. Larvae resistant to B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki showed threefold cross-resistance to formulations of B. thuringiensis subsp. aizawai containing CryIC and CryIA toxins. This minimal cross-resistance may be caused by resistance to CryIA toxins shared by B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki and B. thuringiensis subsp. aizawai.     

Effect of CryIC toxin from Bacillus thuringiensis on larval feeding behavior of Spodoptera exigua

The lack of data on the effect of Bacillus thuringiensis (B.t.) toxins on larval feeding behavior of the pest Spodoptera exigua (Hübner) (Noctuidae: Amphypyrini) prompted us to investigate the effect of three delivery systems of CryIC, a commercial formulation, inclusion bodies, and the activated CryIC toxin. The commercial formulation was the least and CryIC toxin the most lethal form to neonates of susceptible colonies. All but two of the treatments in choice tests with neonates and third instars showed significant avoidance of B.t. treated diet, with greater proportion of larvae from susceptible (UCR-S and AUBURN-S) and resistant (AUBURN-R) colonies on untreated diet than on diet treated with any of the CryIC forms and concentrations tested. Furthermore, third instars consumed significantly more control than treated diet for all CryIC forms, colonies and concentrations. The avoidance of CryIC toxin by neonates and third instars strongly suggests that CryIC, which also is present in the commercial formulation and in the inclusion bodies, is responsible for eliciting avoidance behavior by S. exigua larvae. Behavioral observations of third instars in a no-choice test on either treated or control diet indicated that questing behavior in susceptible larvae appears to be positively related with presence of CryIC toxin in the diet. Furthermore, resistant third instars were on the whole more active than susceptible thirds on both treated and control diet. Resistant thirds raised on CryIC treated diet (AUBURN-RC) spent more time eating treated diet than resistant larvae raised on control diet (AUBURN-R), suggesting that diet conditioning plays an important role on feeding behavior of S. exigua. The implications of these results are discussed.     

Contrary effects of jasmonate treatment of two closely related plant species on attraction of and oviposition by a specialist herbivore

Elevated jasmonic acid (JA) concentrations in response to herbivory can induce wounded plants to produce defences against herbivores. In laboratory and field experiments we compared the effects of exogenous JA treatment to two closely related cabbage species on the host‐searching and oviposition preference of the diamondback moth (DBM), Plutella xylostella. JA‐treated Chinese cabbage (Brassica campestris) was less attractive than untreated Chinese cabbage to ovipositing DBM, while JA‐treatment of common cabbage (B. oleracea) made plants more attractive than untreated controls for oviposition by this insect. Similar effects were observed when plants of the two species were damaged by DBM larvae. In the absence of insect‐feeding, or JA application, Chinese cabbage is much more attractive to DBM than common cabbage. Inducible resistance therefore appears to occur in a more susceptible plant and induced susceptibility appears to occur in a more resistant plant, suggesting a possible balance mechanism between constitutive and inducible defences to a specialist herbivore.     

Video-tracking and On-plant Tests Show Cry1Ab Resistance Influences Behavior and Survival of Neonate <Emphasis Type="Italic">Ostrinia nubilalis</Emphasis> Following Exposure to Bt Maize

To examine how resistance to Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) toxins influences movement and survival of European corn borer (Ostrinia nubilalis [Hübner]) neonates, the responses of Cry1Ab-resistant , -susceptible, and hybrid (F1) larvae were examined using two different techniques. First, using an automated video-tracking system, aspects of O. nubilalis movement were quantified in the presence of artificial diet incorporating 50% non-Bt or insect-resistant Cry1Ab maize tissue. Second, O. nubilalis dispersal and survival were measured 48–72 h after hatching on a Cry1Ab maize plant surrounded by two non-Bt maize plants. Video tracking indicated the presence of Cry1Ab tissue increased the total distance moved (m), time moving (%), and time away from the diet (%) for O. nubilalis while decreasing meander (degrees/cm). However, resistant larvae showed reduced movement and increased meander (≈localized searching) relative to susceptible or hybrid larvae on diet incorporating Cry1Ab tissue. Conversely, when placed onto Cry1Ab maize plants, resistant larvae were more likely than susceptible O. nubilalis to disperse onto adjacent non-Bt plants. The difference in on-plant dispersal seems to reflect greater survival after toxin exposure for resistant larvae rather than increased activity. These results suggest that simplified ‘Petri dish’ tests may not be predictive of larval movement among non-Bt and insect-resistant Bt maize plants. Because models of O. nubilalis resistance evolution incorporate various movement and survival parameters, improved data for on-plant behavior and survival of Bt- resistant , -susceptible, and hybrid larvae should help preserve the efficacy of transgenic insect-resistant maize.     

Physiological resistance and behavioral avoidance responses to residues of four pesticides by six spider mite populations

Six twospotted spider mite populations were assayed for their levels of physiological resistance and behavioral avoidance to residues of four synthetic pesticides. Mortality could not be estimated for bifenthrin and fenvalerate (synthetic pyrethroids) as mites effectively avoided treated surfaces, however significant between-population differences in mortality were detected for chlordimeform and cyhexatin. Considerable variation in walkoff and spindown behavioral response to sub-lethal doses of pesticides was observed among populations within compounds, and within populations among compounds. Within-compound walkoff and spindown behavioral response varied among all mite populations. Few significant between-compound correlations were significant, indicating that spider mites responded differently to the four pesticides. The hypothesis that physiological resistance is negatively correlated with behavioral avoidance was tested. Of the four possible negative correlations between physiological resistance and behavioral avoidance for chlordimeform and cyhexatin, only the correlation between cyhexatin-induced mortality and spindown response was significant. Comparisons of physiological resistance and behavioral avoidance of chlordimeform and cyhexatin by specific pairs of populations did not consistently find these two characters to be related. In a related experiment, the magnitude and direction of the correlation between physiological resistance and behavioral avoidance following selection for increased physiological tolerance to cyhexatin was compared in a highly resistant and a susceptible population of the twospotted spider mite. Mortality in the susceptible population at 2 ppm cyhexatin was similar to mortality in the resistant population at 250 ppm after 72h exposure (ca. 12%). However, at these concentrations, the resistant population exhibited much higher avoidance of the compound through walkoff response.     

Combining genetic engineering and traditional breeding to provide elevated resistance in potatoes to Colorado potato beetle

The sustainable deployment of resistant crop varieties is a critical issue for the implementation of biotechnology in crop pest management. Feeding, biomass accumulation, and mortality were evaluated for susceptible, insecticide‐resistant, and Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) Cry 3A‐selected Colorado potato beetle (Leptinotarsa decemlineata Say) (Coleoptera, Chrysomelidae) larvae fed on: cultivated potato, a Solanum chacoense line expressing leptine glycoalkaloids, a transformed line expressing Bt toxin, or the leptine line transformed to express Bt toxin. Larvae selected for resistance to Bt‐Cry3A performed better on Bt foliage, but not as well on the leptine foliage, compared to susceptible or insecticide‐resistant larvae. Neither leptine nor Bt toxin completely inhibited the feeding and growth of 3rd and 4th instars of all three strains of Colorado potato beetle. However, for all three strains of Colorado potato beetle on leptine + Bt foliage, feeding was almost zero, growth was zero or negative, and mortality was near 100%.     

Constitutive Activation of the Midgut Response to Bacillus thuringiensis in Bt-Resistant Spodoptera exigua

Bacillus thuringiensis is the most effective microbial control agent for controlling numerous species from different insect orders. The main threat for the long term use of B. thuringiensis in pest control is the ability of insects to develop resistance. Thus, the identification of insect genes involved in conferring resistance is of paramount importance. A colony of Spodoptera exigua (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) was selected for 15 years in the laboratory for resistance to Xentari™, a B. thuringiensis-based insecticide, reaching a final resistance level of greater than 1,000-fold. Around 600 midgut ESTs were analyzed by DNA-macroarray in order to find differences in midgut gene expression between susceptible and resistant insects. Among the differentially expressed genes, repat and arylphorin were identified and their increased expression was correlated with B. thuringiensis resistance. We also found overlap among genes that were constitutively over-expressed in resistant insects with genes that were up-regulated in susceptible insects after exposure to Xentari™, suggesting a permanent activation of the response to Xentari™ in resistant insects. Increased aminopeptidase activity in the lumen of resistant insects in the absence of exposure to Xentari™ corroborated the hypothesis of permanent activation of response genes. Increase in midgut proliferation has been proposed as a mechanism of response to pathogens in the adult from several insect species. Analysis of S. exigua larvae revealed that midgut proliferation was neither increased in resistant insects nor induced by exposure of susceptible larvae to Xentari™, suggesting that mechanisms other than midgut proliferation are involved in the response to B. thuringiensis by S. exigua larvae.     

Incorporation of Novel <Emphasis Type="Italic">Ceutorhynchus obstrictus</Emphasis>-resistant Canola Genotypes Into Mixed Cropping Strategies: Evidence for Associational Resistance

Canola genotypes resistant to the cabbage seedpod weevil, Ceutorhynchus obstrictus (Marsham) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae), have recently been developed through introgression of Sinapis alba L. to Brassica napus L. Several lines express antixenosis and antibiosis resistance and have been shown to be less attractive to weevils in visual and olfactory behavioral bioassays. This paper details a small-plot study that assessed the effects on distribution dynamics of weevil adults and larvae of interspersing susceptible among resistant genotypes relative to monocultures over two growing seasons. Results indicate that mixes reduced weevil numbers and oviposition in pods of susceptible genotypes. These results are consistent with associational resistance.     

Survival and behavior of Plutella xylostella larvae on cabbages with leaf waxes altered by treatment with S-ethyl dipropylthiocarbamate

Cabbages (Brassica oleracea L.) treated with S-ethyl dipropylthiocarbamate (EPTC) herbicide had reduced amounts of leaf surface waxes (40.6% of controls) and reduced densities of leaf surface wax crystallites (20.8% of controls). Leaf waxes of EPTC-treated plants chemically and morphologically resembled leaf waxes of genetically glossy cabbages resistant to the diamondback moth Plutella xylostella (L.) (Lepidoptera: Plutellidae). Survival of larvae was significantly reduced on EPTC-treated cabbage plants in three out of four experiments (62.0–15.3% of survival on controls). P. xylostella neonates also moved more rapidly on EPTC-treated plants than on untreated controls (1.84±0.16 cm/min on controls vs. 3.94±0.24 cm/min on treated plants; P=0.0001). These results support the hypotheses that reduction in leaf waxes is the basis of resistance to P. xylostella in genetically glossy plants and that reduced acceptance by larvae is associated with this resistance. Modification of leaf surface waxes with EPTC or similar compounds may have potential as an economic control for P. xylostella in Brassica crops.     

Reduction of resistance of Culex pipiens larvae to the binary toxin from Bacillus sphaericus by coexpression of cry4Ba from Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis with the binary toxin gene

The cry4Ba gene from Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis and the binary toxin gene from B. sphaericus C3-41 were cloned together into a shuttle vector and expressed in an acrystalliferous strain of B. thuringiensis subsp. israelensis 4Q7. Transformed strain Bt-BW611, expressing both Cry4Ba protein and binary toxin protein, was more than 40-fold more toxic to Culex pipiens larvae resistant to B. sphaericus than the transformed strains expressing Cry4Ba protein or binary toxin protein independently. This result showed that the coexpression of cry4Ba of B. thuringiensis subsp. israelensis with B. sphaericus binary toxin gene partly suppressed more than 10,000-fold resistance of C. pipiens larvae to the binary toxin. It was suggested that production of Cry4Ba protein and binary toxin protein interacted synergistically, thereby increasing their mosquito-larvicidal toxicity.