Investigation of the intracellular stability and formation of a triple helix formed with a short purine oligonucleotide targeted to the murine c-pim-1 proto-oncogene promotor.

In our previous work we have shown that the oligonucleotide 5'-GGGGAGGGGGAGG-3' gives a very stable and specific triplex with the promoter of the murine c-pim-1 proto-oncogene in vitro[Svinarchuk, F., Bertrand, J.-R. and Malvy, C.(1994)Nucleic Acids Res., 22, 3742-3747]. In the present work, we have tested triplex formation with some derivatives of this oligonucleotide which are designed to be degradation-resistant inside the cells, and we show that phosphorothioate and the oligonucleotide with a 3' terminal amino group are still able to form triplexes. Moreover these oligonucleotides, like the 13mer oligonucleotide of similar composition [Svinarchuk, F., Paoletti, J., and Malvy, C. (1995) J. Biol. Chem., 270, 14068-14071], are able to stabilize the targeted duplex. In vivo DMS footprint analysis after electroporation of the pre-formed triplex into the cell have shown the presence of the triple helix inside the cells. This triplex structure partially blocks c-pim-1 promotor activity as shown by transient assay with a c-pim-1 promoter-luciferase gene construct. To our knowledge these data are the first direct evidence that conditions inside cells are favorable for triplex stability with non-modified oligonucleotides. However we were unable to show triplex formation inside living cells using various methods of oligonucleotide delivery. We suppose that this may be due to the oligonucleotide being sequestered by cellular processes or proteins. Further work is needed to find oligonucleotide derivatives and ways of their delivery to overcome the problem of triplex formation inside the cells.     

The stability of DNA triplexes inside cells as studied by iodine-125 radioprinting.

We studied the stability of a DNA triplex resulting from the binding of a 38 nt long purine motif triplex-forming oligonucleotide (TFO) to a covalently closed plasmid containing a target sequence from the human HPRT gene. Our in vitro experiments showed that the triplex formed at plasmid and TFO concentrations as low as 10(-9)M. Once formed, the triplex was remarkably stable and could withstand 10 min incubation at 65 degrees C. We next delivered these TFO-plasmid complexes into cultured human cells. To monitor the TFO-plasmid complexes inside cells we applied a new technique that we call 'radioprinting'. Because the TFO was(125)I labeled, we could quantitatively monitor the triplexes by measuring(125)I-induced DNA strand breaks in the target plasmid sequence. We found that the triplexes remain stable inside the cells for at least 48 h. Based on these findings we propose using TFO for indirect labeling of intact plasmid DNA. As a demonstration, we show that the intracellular distribution of a fluorescein-labeled TFO was different when it was liposome-delivered into cultured human cells alone or in a complex with the plasmid. In the latter case, the fluorescence was detected in nearly all the cells while detection of the plasmid by use of a marker gene (beta-galactosidase) revealed expression of the gene in only half of the cells.     

Exclusion of RNA strands from a purine motif triple helix.

Research concerning oligonucleotide-directed triple helix formation has mainly focused on the binding of DNA oligonucleotides to duplex DNA. The participation of RNA strands in triple helices is also of interest. For the pyrimidine motif (pyrimidine.purine.pyrimidine triplets), systematic substitution of RNA for DNA in one, two, or all three triplex strands has previously been reported. For the purine motif (purine.purine.pyrimidine triplets), studies have shown only that RNA cannot bind to duplex DNA. To extend this result, we created a DNA triple helix in the purine motif and systematically replaced one, two, or all three strands with RNA. In dramatic contrast to the general accommodation of RNA strands in the pyrimidine triple helix motif, a stable triplex forms in the purine motif only when all three of the substituent strands are DNA. The lack of triplex formation among any of the other seven possible strand combinations involving RNA suggests that: (i) duplex structures containing RNA cannot be targeted by DNA oligonucleotides in the purine motif; (ii) RNA strands cannot be employed to recognize duplex DNA in the purine motif; and (iii) RNA tertiary structures are likely to contain only isolated base triplets in the purine motif.     

Stability of DNA triplexes on shuttle vector plasmids in the replication pool in mammalian cells

Triple helix-forming oligonucleotides may be useful as gene-targeting reagents in vivo, for applications such as gene knockout. One important property of these complexes is their often remarkable stability, as demonstrated in solution and in cells following transfection. Although encouraging, these measurements do not necessarily report triplex stability in cellular compartments that support DNA functions such as replication and mutagenesis. We have devised a shuttle vector plasmid assay that reports the stability of triplexes on DNA that undergoes replication and mutagenesis. The assay is based on plasmids with novel variant supF tRNA genes containing embedded sequences for triplex formation and psoralen cross-linking. Triple helix-forming oligonucleotides were linked to psoralen and used to form triplexes on the plasmids. At various times after introduction into cells, the psoralen was activated by exposure to long wave ultraviolet light (UVA). After time for replication and mutagenesis, progeny plasmids were recovered and the frequency of plasmids with mutations in the supF gene determined. Site-specific mutagenesis by psoralen cross-links was dependent on precise placement of the psoralen by the triple helix-forming oligonucleotide at the time of UVA treatment. The results indicated that both pyrimidine and purine motif triplexes were much less stable on replicated DNA than on DNA in vitro or in total transfected DNA. Incubation of cells with amidoanthraquinone-based triplex stabilizing compounds enhanced the stability of the pyrimidine triplex.     

A new approach to overcome potassium-mediated inhibition of triplex formation.

G,A-containing purine oligonucleotides of various lengths form extremely stable and specific triplexes with the purine-pyrimidine stretch of the vpx gene [Svinarchuk,F., Monnot,M., Merle,A., Malvy,C. and Fermandjian,S. (1995) Nucleic Acids Res., 22, 3742--3747]. The potential application of triple-helix-forming oligonucleotides (TFO) in gene-targeted therapy has prompted us to study triplex formation mimicking potassium concentrations and temperatures in cells. Triplex formation was tested by dimethyl sulphate (DMS) footprinting, gel-retardation, UV melting studies and electron microscopy. In the presence of 10 mM MgCl2, KCl concentrations up to 150 mM significantly lowered both efficiency (triplex : initial duplex) and rate constants of triplex formation. The KCl effect was more pronounced for 11mer and 20mer TFOs than for 14mer TFO. Since the dissociation half-life for the 11mer TFO decreases from 420 min in the absence of monovalent cations to 40 min in the presence of 150 mM KCI, we suggest that the negative effect could be explained by a decrease in triplex stability. In contrast, for the 20mer TFO no dissociation of the triplex was observed during 24 h of incubation either in the absence of monovalent cations or in the presence of 150 mM KCl. We suppose that in the case of the 20mer TFO the negative effect of KCI on triplex formation is probably due to the self-association of the oligonucleotide in competitive structures such as parallel duplexes and/or tetraplexes. This negative effect may be overcome by the prior formation of a short duplex either on the 3'- or 5'-end of the 20mer TFO. We refer to these partial duplexes as 'zipper' TFOs. It was demonstrated that a 'zipper' TFO can form a triplex over the full length of the target, thus unzipping the short complementary strand. The minimal single-stranded part of the 'zipper' oligonucleotide which is sufficient to initiate triplex formation can be as short as three nucleotides at the 3'-end and six nucleotides at the 5'-end. We suggest that this type of structure may prove useful for in vivo applications.     

Pyrimidine morpholino oligonucleotides form a stable triple helix in the absence of magnesium ions

Oligonucleotides can be used as sequence-specific DNA ligands by forming a local triple helix. In order to form more stable triple-helical structures or prevent their degradation in cells, oligonucleotide analogues that are modified at either the backbone or base level are routinely used. Morpholino oligonucleotides appeared recently as a promising modification for antisense applications. We report here a study that indicates the possibility of a triple helix formation with a morpholino pyrimidine TFO and its comparison with a phosphodiester and a phosphoramidate oligonucleotide. At a neutral pH and in the presence of a high magnesium ion concentration (10 mM), the phosphoramidate oligomer forms the most stable triple helix, whereas in the absence of magnesium ion but at a physiological monovalent cation concentration (0.14 M) only morpholino oligonucleotides form a stable triplex. To our knowledge, this is the first report of a stable triple helix in the pyrimidine motif formed by a noncharged oligonucleotide third strand (the morpholino oligonucleotide) and a DNA duplex. We show here that the structure formed with the morpholino oligomer is a bona fide triple helix and it is destabilized by high concentrations of potassium ions or divalent cations (Mg(2+)).     

Presence of divalent cation is not mandatory for the formation of intramolecular purine-motif triplex containing human c-jun protooncogene target

Modulation of endogenous gene function, through sequence-specific recognition of double helical DNA via oligonucleotide-directed triplex formation, is a promising approach. Compared to the formation of pyrimidine motif triplexes, which require relatively low pH, purine motif appears to be the most gifted for their stability under physiological conditions. Our previous work has demonstrated formation of magnesium-ion dependent highly stable intermolecular triplexes using a purine third strand of varied lengths, at the purine?pyrimidine (Pu?Py) targets of SIV/HIV-2 (vpx) genes (Svinarchuk, F., Monnot, M., Merle, A., Malvy, C., and Fermandjian, S. (1995) Nucleic Acids Res. 23, 3831-3836). Herein, we show that a designed intramolecular version of the 11-bp core sequence of the said targets, which also constitutes an integral, short, and symmetrical segment (G(2)AG(5)AG(2))?(C(2)TC(5)TC(2)) of human c-jun protooncogene forms a stable triplex, even in the absence of magnesium. The sequence d-C(2)TC(5)TC(2)T(5)G(2)AG(5)AG(2)T(5)G(2)AG(5)AG(2) (I-Pu) folds back twice onto itself to form an intramolecular triple helix via a double hairpin formation. The design ensures that the orientation of the intact third strand is antiparallel with respect to the oligopurine strand of the duplex. The triple helix formation has been revealed by non-denaturating gel assays, UV-thermal denaturation, and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. The monophasic melting curve, recorded in the presence of sodium, represented the dissociation of intramolecular triplex to single strand in one step; however, the addition of magnesium bestowed thermal stability to the triplex. Formation of intramolecular triple helix at neutral pH in sodium, with or without magnesium cations, was also confirmed by gel electrophoresis. The triplex, mediated by sodium alone, destabilizes in the presence of 5'-C(2)TC(5)TC(2)-3', an oligonucleotide complementary to the 3'-oligopurine segments of I-Pu, whereas in the presence of magnesium the triplex remained impervious. CD spectra showed the signatures of triplex structure with A-like DNA conformation. We suggest that the possible formation of pH and magnesium-independent purine-motif triplexes at genomic Pu?Py sequences may be pertinent to gene regulation.     

Pyrimidine oligodeoxyxylonucleotides form triplexes with purine DNA in neutral media

Interactions of oligonucleotides comprising (1-beta-D-2'-deoxy-threo-pentafuranosyl)thymine and (1-beta-D-2'-deoxy-threo-pentafuranosyl)cytosine residues (oligodeoxyxylonucleotides or OXNs) with complementary single-stranded DNA fragments were investigated. Using nondenaturing gel electrophoresis, footprinting, and melting assays, pyrimidine OXNs were shown to form triplexes with the purine DNA template, which are stable at neutral pH and comparable in heat stability with the corresponding natural polypurine-polypyrimidine DNA duplexes. In such triplexes, the N3 of cytosines in one of the OXNs are protonated. As revealed by CD spectroscopy in the 210-340 nm range, the form of the triple helix depends on the nucleotide composition and sequence of the DNA template, and is intermediate between A and B.     

Energetics of strand-displacement reactions in triple helices: a spectroscopic study.

DNA triple helices offer exciting new perspectives toward oligonucleotide-directed inhibition of gene expression. Purine and GT triplexes appear to be the most promising motifs for stable binding under physiological conditions compared to the pyrimidine motif, which forms at relatively low pH. There are, however, very little data available for comparison of the relative stabilities of the different classes of triplexes under identical conditions. We, therefore, designed a model system which allowed us to set up a competition between the oligonucleotides of the purine and pyrimidine motifs targeting the same Watson-Crick duplex. Several conclusions may be drawn: (i) a weak hypochromism at 260 nm is associated with purine triplex formation; (ii) delta H degree of GA, GT and TC triplex formation (at pH 7.0) was calculated as -0.1, -2.5 and -6.1 kcal/mol per base triplet, respectively. This unexpectedly low delta H degree for the purine triple helix formation implies that its delta G degree is nearly temperature-independent and it explains why these triplexes may still be observed at high temperatures. In contrast, the pyrimidine triplex is strongly favoured at lower temperatures; (iii) as a consequence, in a system where two third-strands compete for triplex formation, displacement of the GA or GT strand by a pyrimidine strand may be observed at neutral pH upon lowering the temperature. This original purine-to-pyrimidine triplex conversion shows a significant hypochromism at 260 nm and a hyperchromism at 295 nm which is similar to the duplex-to-triplex conversion in the pyrimidine motif. Further evidence for this triplex-to-triplex conversion is provided by mung bean-nuclease foot-printing assay.     

Extension of the range of DNA sequences available for triple helix formation: stabilization of mismatched triplexes by acridine-containing oligonucleotides.

Triple helix formation usually requires an oligopyrimidine*oligopurine sequence in the target DNA. A triple helix is destabilized when the oligopyrimidine*oligopurine target contains one (or two) purine*pyrimidine base pair inversion(s). Such an imperfect target sequence can be recognized by a third strand oligonucleotide containing an internally incorporated acridine intercalator facing the inverted purine*pyrimidine base pair(s). The loss of triplex stability due to the mismatch is partially overcome. The stability of triplexes formed at perfect and imperfect target sequences was investigated by UV thermal denaturation experiments. The stabilization provided by an internally incorporated acridine third strand oligonucleotide depends on the sequences flanking the inverted base pair. For triplexes containing a single mismatch the highest stabilization is observed for an acridine or a propanediol tethered to an acridine on its 3'-side facing an inverted A*T base pair and for a cytosine with an acridine incorporated to its 3'-side or a guanine with an acridine at its 5'-side facing an inverted G*C base pair. Fluorescence studies provided evidence that the acridine was intercalated into the triplex. The target sequences containing a double base pair inversion which form very unstable triplexes can still be recognized by oligonucleotides provided they contain an appropriately incorporated acridine facing the double mismatch sites. Selectivity for an A*T base pair inversion was observed with an oligonucleotide containing an acridine incorporated at the mismatched site when this site is flanked by two T*A*T base triplets. These results show that the range of DNA base sequences available for triplex formation can be extended by using oligonucleotide intercalator conjugates.     

Chemical modification of the third strand: differential effects on purine and pyrimidine triple helix formation.

DNA triple helices offer exciting perspectives toward oligonucleotide-directed control of gene expression. Oligonucleotide analogues are routinely used with modifications in either the backbone or the bases to form more stable triple-helical structures or to prevent their degradation in cells. In this article, different chemical modifications are tested in a model system, which sets up a competition between the purine and pyrimidine motifs. For most modifications, the DeltaH degrees of purine triplex formation is close to zero, implying a nearly temperature-independent affinity constant. In contrast, the pyrimidine triplex is strongly favored at lower temperatures. The stabilization induced by modifications previously known to be favorable to the pyrimidine motif was quantified. Interestingly, modifications favorable to the GT motif (propynyl-U and dU replacing T) were also discovered. In a system where two third strands compete for triplex formation, replacement of the GA or GT strand by a pyrimidine strand may be observed at neutral pH upon lowering the temperature. This purine-to-pyrimidine triplex conversion depends on the chemical nature of the triplex-forming strands and the stability of the corresponding triplexes.     

Promotion of triplex formation by a fixed N-form sugar puckering: thermodynamic and kinetic studies.

We analyzed the effect of a fixed N-form sugar puckering of TFO (triplex-forming oligonucleotide) on the pyrimidine motif triplex formation at neutral pH, a condition where pyrimidine motif triplexes are unstable. Both thermodynamic and kinetic analyses revealed that the binding constant of the pyrimidine motif triplex formation at pH 6.8 with modified TFO containing the fixed N-form sugar puckering was about 20-times larger than that observed with unmodified TFO. Kinetic data also demonstrated that the observed increase in the binding constant at neutral pH by the fixed N-form sugar puckering resulted from the considerable decrease in the dissociation rate constant. Our results certainly support the idea that the fixed N-form sugar puckering of TFO could be a key modification and may eventually lead to progress in therapeutic applications of the antigene strategy in vivo.     

Effect of third strand composition on the triple helix formation: purine versus pyrimidine oligodeoxynucleotides.

Exon 5 of the human aprt gene contains an oligo-purine-oligopyrimidine stretch of 17 bp (5'-CCCTCTTCTCTCTCCT-3') within the coding region. (T,C)-, (G,T)- and (G,A)-containing oligonucleotides were compared for their ability to form stable triple helices with their DNA target. (G,T) oligodeoxynucleotides, whether parallel or antiparallel, were unable to bind to this sequence. This is in contrast to (G,A) (purine) and (T,C) (pyrimidine) oligonucleotides, which bind to the duplex at near neutral pH. Binding was highly sequence specific, as unrelated competitors were unable to interfere with target recognition. A major difference between the purine and pyrimidine oligodeoxynucleotides was observed in the kinetics of binding: the (G,A) oligonucleotide binds to its target much faster than the (T,C) oligomer. With the purine oligonucleotide, complete binding was achieved in a matter of minutes at micromolar concentrations, whereas several hours were required with the pyrimidine oligomer. Thus, the general observation that triplex formation is slow with pyrimidine oligodeoxynucleotides does not hold for (G,A) oligodeoxynucleotides. Purine and pyrimidine oligodeoxynucleotides covalently linked to a psoralen group were able to induce crosslinks on the double-stranded DNA target upon UV irradiation. This study provides a detailed comparison of the different types of DNA triplexes under the same experimental conditions.     

Promotion of triplex formation by 2'-O,4'-C-methylene bridged nucleic acid (2',4'-BNA) modification: thermodynamic and kinetic studies

We analyzed the effect of 2'-O,4'-C-methylene bridged nucleic acid (2',4'-BNA) modification of triplex-forming oligonucleotide (TFO) on pyrimidine motif triplex formation at neutral pH, a condition where pyrimidine motif triplexes are unstable. The binding constant of the pyrimidine motif triplex formation at pH 6.8 with 2',4'-BNA modified TFO was about 20 times larger than that observed with unmodified TFO. The observed increase in the binding constant at neutral pH by the 2',4'-BNA modification resulted from the considerable decrease in the dissociation rate constant.     

Mechanism of intermolecular purine-purine-pyrimidine triple helix stabilization by comb-type polylysine graft copolymer at physiologic potassium concentration

We previously reported a novel strategy to stabilize purine motif triplex DNA within a mammalian gene promoter at physiologically relevant pH, temperature, and potassium (K(+)) concentrations by a comb-type poly(L-lysine)-graft-dextran copolymer [Ferdous et al., (1998) Nucleic Acids Res. 26, 3949-3954]. Here we describe the major contribution(s) of the copolymer to stabilize the purine motif triplex DNA at physiological K(+) concentrations. Self-aggregation through guanine-quartet formation of guanine-rich (G-rich) triplex-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) has long been proposed for K(+)-mediated inhibition of the purine motif triplex formation. However, this was not the case for the severe inhibitory effect of K(+) observed under our reaction conditions. Rather significant decrease in rate of triplex formation involving a G-rich TFO was a major factor to confer K(+) inhibition. Interestingly, in the presence of the copolymer the rate of triplex formation was tremendously increased and K(+)-induced dissociation of preformed triplexes was not observed. Moreover, the triplex-promoting/stabilizing efficiency of the copolymer was amazingly higher than that of physiological concentrations of spermine. An absolute increase in binding constant of the TFO to the target duplex could therefore be the predominant mechanistic source for the copolymer-mediated triplex stabilization under physiological conditions in vitro.     

Nucleosides and nucleotides. 218. Alternate-strand triple-helix formation by the 3'-3'-linked oligodeoxynucleotides using a purine motif

In this paper, we describe the synthesis of the 3'-3'-linked TFOs that can form the antiparallel triplexes with the duplex DNA target by reverse Hoogsteen hydrogen bonds. Stability of the alternate-strand triplexes between these TFOs and the target DNAs was investigated using the electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA). It was found that the alternate-strand triplexes were significantly stabilized by linking the TFO fragments with the pentaerythritol linker. And, unlike the alternate-strand triplexes composed of the pyrimidine motif, the terminal ammonium ion of the aminobutyl-linker and the intercalator of the TFOs did not contribute to the stability of the alternate-strand triplex comprised of the purine motif. We also tested the ability of the 3'-3'-linked TFOs to inhibit cleavage of the duplex DNA target 17 by the restriction enzyme EcoT14I and found that the 3'-3'-linked TFOs 12 and 13 inhibited the cleavage by the enzyme more effectively than the unlinked decamer 8. Thus, the TFOs linked with pentaerythritol may be useful as the antigene oligonucleotide to the DNA targets, which have alternating oligopyrimidine-oligopurine sequences.     

Nuclear magnetic resonance structural studies of intramolecular purine.purine.pyrimidine DNA triplexes in solution. Base triple pairing alignments and strand direction

Recently, P.A. Beal and P.B. Dervan, expanding on earlier observations by others, have established the formation of purine.purine.pyrimidine triple helices stabilized by G.GC, A.AT and T.AT base triples where the purine-rich third strand was positioned in the major groove of the Watson-Crick duplex and anti-parallel to its purine strand. The present nuclear magnetic resonance (n.m.r.) study characterizes the base triple pairing alignments and strand direction in a 31-mer deoxyoligonucleotide that intramolecularly folds to generate a 7-mer (R/Y-)n.(R+)n(Y-)n triplex with the strands linked by two T5 loops and stabilized by potential T.AT and G.GC base triples. (R and Y stand for purine and pyrimidine, respectively, while the signs establish the strand direction.) This intramolecular triplex gives well-resolved exchangeable and non-exchangeable proton spectra with Li+ as counterion in aqueous solution. These studies establish that the T1 to C7 pyrimidine and the G8 to A14 purine strands are anti-parallel to each other and align through Watson-Crick A.T and G.C pair formation. The T15 to G21 purine-rich third strand is positioned in the major groove of this duplex and pairs through Hoogsteen alignment with the purine strand to generate T.AT and G.GC triples. Several lines of evidence establish that the thymidine and guanosine bases in the T15 to G21 purine-rich third strand adopt anti glycosidic torsion angles under conditions where this strand is aligned anti-parallel to the G8 to A14 purine strand. We have also recorded imino proton n.m.r. spectra for an (R-)n.(R+)n(Y-)n triplex stabilized by G.GC and A.AT triples through intramolecular folding of a related 31-mer deoxyoligonucleotide with Li+ as counterion. The intramolecular purine.purine.pyrimidine triplexes containing unprotonated G.GC, A.AT and T.AT triples are stable at basic pH in contrast to pyrimidine.purine.pyrimidine triplexes containing protonated C+.GC and T.AT triples, which are only stable at acidic pH.     

Recognition of CG interrupting site by W-shaped nucleoside analogs (WNA) having the pyrazole ring in an anti-parallel triplex DNA

We have previously developed W-shaped nucleoside analogs (WNA) for recognition of TA and CG interrupting sites, which are the intrinsic limitation for the formation of a stable triplex DNA by the natural triplex-forming oligonucleotide (TFO). However, the stabilization effect of WNA is dependent on the neighboring nucleobases at both sides of the WNA analogs within the TFO. Considering that the base is located at the hindered site constructed of three bases of the target duplex and the TFO, it was expected that replacement of the pyrimidine base of the WNA analog with a smaller pyrazole ring might avoid steric repulsion to produce a greater stability for the triplex. In this study, the new WNA analogs bearing the pyrazole ring, 3-aminopyrazole (AP), and 4-methyl-3-pyrazole-5-on (MP) were synthesized, incorporated into the TFOs, then their stabilizing effects on the triplexes were evaluated. A remarkable success was illustrated by the fact that the TFO containing WNA-βAP in the 3′G-WNA-G-5′ sequence formed a stable triplex with selectivity to the CG interrupting site where the previous WNA-βC did not induce the triplex formation.