Using Meta-Modelling and Graph Grammars to Create Modelling Environments

This paper presents the combined use of meta-modelling and graph grammars for the generation of visual modelling tools for simulation formalisms. In meta-modelling, formalisms are described at a meta-level. This information is used by a meta-model processor to generate modelling tools for the described formalisms. We combine meta-modelling with graph grammars to extend the model manipulation capabilities of the generated modelling tools, as we store (meta-)models as graphs, and thus, express model manipulations as graph grammars.We show the design and implementation of these concepts in AToM³ (A Tool for Multi-formalism, Meta-Modelling). As an example we will present a meta-model for Causal Block Diagrams and a graph grammar to generate OOCSMP code, a continuous simulation language which has a compiler able to generate Java applets from the simulations models.     

Distributed Event Graphs: Formalizing Component-based Modelling and Simulation

In this work an extension to the classical Event Graphs formalism for discrete-event simulation is presented. The extensions are oriented towards the specification of component-based models. The abstract syntax has been defined through meta-modelling. Several methodological issues are discussed, concerning the use of two different meta-modelling levels or collapsing the language into a single one, where “instance-of” relationships are used between processes and their classes. The operational semantics have been defined through graph transformation. This formal definition enables analysis before code is generated from the model. The syntax and semantics of the visual language have been implemented in the multi-paradigm tool AToM³, together with a code generator that produces stand-alone applications able to run the analysed models in real-time.     

Combining unit and specification-based testing for meta-model validation and verification

Meta-models play a cornerstone role in Model-Driven Engineering as they are used to define the abstract syntax of modelling languages, and so models and all sorts of model transformations depend on them. However, there are scarce tools and methods supporting their Validation and Verification (V&V), which are essential activities for the proper engineering of meta-models.In order to fill this gap, we propose two complementary meta-model V&V languages. The first one has similar philosophy to the xUnit framework, as it enables the definition of meta-model unit test suites comprising model fragments and assertions on their (in-)correctness. The second one is directed to express and verify expected properties of a meta-model, including domain and design properties, quality criteria and platform-specific requirements.As a proof of concept, we have developed tooling for both languages in the Eclipse platform, and illustrate its use within an example-driven approach for meta-model construction. The expressiveness of our languages is demonstrated by their application to build a library of meta-model quality issues, which has been evaluated over the ATL zoo of meta-models and some OMG specifications. The results show that integrated support for meta-model V&V (as the one we propose here) is urgently needed in meta-modelling environments.     

Event-driven grammars: relating abstract and concrete levels of visual languages

In this work we introduce event-driven grammars, a kind of graph grammars that are especially suited for visual modelling environments generated by meta-modelling. Rules in these grammars may be triggered by user actions (such as creating, editing or connecting elements) and in their turn may trigger other user-interface events. Their combination with triple graph transformation systems allows constructing and checking the consistency of the abstract syntax graph while the user is building the concrete syntax model, as well as managing the layout of the concrete syntax representation. As an example of these concepts, we show the definition of a modelling environment for UML sequence diagrams. A discussion is also presented of methodological aspects for the generation of environments for visual languages with multiple views, its connection with triple graph grammars, the formalization of the latter in the double pushout approach and its extension with an inheritance concept. This is a revised and extended version of a paper presented at the ICGT’04 conference, see [21].     

上下文相关图文法的表达能力分析

上下文相关图文法是描述可视化语言的形式化工具.为了直观地刻画并高效地分析可视化语言,已有图文法形式框架均着重于文法形式和分析算法的研究,而忽略了对它们之间表达能力的分析.在对已有上下文相关图文法形式框架的关键特征进行分析和归纳的基础上,通过构造不同形式框架之间的转换算法,揭示并形式化证明了它们表达能力之间的关系.而且,转换算法在不同形式框架之间建立了关联,使图文法的应用不必再局限于一个框架,而是可以选择不同框架分别进行图的描述和分析,从而提高了上下文相关图文法的易用性.     

Visual specification of measurements and redesigns for domain specific visual languages

Ensuring model quality is a key success factor in many computer science areas, and becomes crucial in recent software engineering paradigms like the one proposed by model-driven software development. Tool support for measurements and redesigns becomes essential to help developers improve the quality of their models. However, developing such helper tools for the wide variety of (frequently domain specific) visual notations used by software engineers is a hard and repetitive task that does not take advantage from previous developments, thus being frequently forgotten.In this paper we present our approach for the visual specification of measurements and redesigns for Domain Specific Visual Languages (DSVLs). With this purpose, we introduce a novel DSVL called SLAMMER that contains generalisations of some of the more used types of internal product measurements and redesigns. The goal is to facilitate the task of defining measurements and redesigns for any DSVL, as well as the generation of tools from such specification reducing or eliminating the necessity of coding. We rely on the use of visual patterns for the specification of the relevant elements for each measurement and redesign type. In addition, SLAMMER allows the specification of redesigns either procedurally or by means of graph transformation rules. These redesigns can be triggered when the measurements reach a certain threshold.These concepts have been implemented in the meta-modelling tool AToM³. In this way, when a DSVL is designed, it is possible to specify measurements and redesigns that will become available in the final modelling environment generated for the language. As an example, we show a case study in the web modelling domain.     

vCGG:一种基于虚结点的空间图文法形式框架

作为一种二维的形式化方法,图文法为可视化语言提供了直观而规范的描述手段.然而,大多数图文法形式框架在空间语义处理能力方面有所不足,影响了图文法的表达能力及其实际应用范围.针对现存的问题,构建了一种新型空间图文法形式框架vCGG （virtual-node based coordinate graph grammar）.区别于其他空间图文法,vCGG在产生式中通过定义虚结点的概念描述产生式与主图之间的语法结构与空间语义关系,在保留抽象能力的同时,提高了其空间语义配置性能.通过与几种典型空间图文法框架比较,vCGG形式框架在直观性、规范性、表达能力以及分析效率方面均有着较好的表现.     

A grammatical approach to self-organizing robotic systems

In this paper, we define a class of graph grammars that can be used to model and direct concurrent robotic self-assembly and similar self-organizing processes. We give several detailed examples of the formalism and then focus on the problem of synthesizing a grammar so that it generates a given, prespecified assembly. In particular, to generate an acyclic graph we synthesize a binary grammar (rules involve at most two parts), and for a general graph we synthesize a ternary grammar (rules involve at most three parts). In both cases, we characterize the number of concurrent steps required to achieve the assembly. We also show a general result that implies that no binary grammar can generate a unique stable assembly. We conclude the paper with a discussion of how graph grammars can be used to direct the self-assembly of robotic parts.     

Parsing nonlinear languages

The diagrammatic approach to user interfaces for computer-aided software development toolkits, visual query systems, and visual programming environments, is based on the use of diagrams and charts traditionally drawn on paper. In particular, the VLG system (Visual Language Generator) has been proposed to generate icon-oriented visual languages customized for given applications. The syntactical model underlying the interpretation of a visual language in VLG has been designed to describe icon-oriented visual languages. In order to enable the VLG system to apply to any kind of graphical languages, like diagrammatic ones, it is necessary to find a more general syntactical model able to support both their generation and interpretation. This paper addresses the comprehension of the features that a grammatical formalism for nonlinear languages must have to match any requirement for an efficient parsing. To this aim, relation grammars support an easy implementation of a general parsing algorithm for multidimensional languages, parametric with respect to the rewriting rules of the grammar. We compare the expressive power of relation grammars to grammatical formalisms for graph grammars     

The equivalence of four extensions of context-free grammars

There is currently considerable interest among computational linguists in grammatical formalisms with highly restricted generative power. This paper concerns the relationship between the class of string languages generated by several such formalisms, namely, combinatory categorial grammars, head grammars, linear indexed grammars, and tree adjoining grammars. Each of these formalisms is known to generate a larger class of languages than context-free grammars. The four formalisms under consideration were developed independently and appear superficially to be quite different from one another. The result presented in this paper is that all four of the formalisms under consideration generate exactly the same class of string languages.This work has been supported by NSF Grants MCS-82-19116-CER, MCS-82-07294, DCR-84-10413, IRI-8909810, ARO Grant DAA29-84-9-0027, and DARPA Grant N0014-85-K0018.     

UML vs. classical vs. rhapsody statecharts: not all models are created equal

State machines, represented by statecharts or state machine diagrams, are an important formalism for behavioural modelling. According to the research literature, the most popular statechart formalisms appear to be Classical, UML, and that implemented by Rhapsody. These three formalisms seem to be very similar; however, there are several key syntactic and semantic differences. These differences are enough that a model written in one formalism could be ill-formed in another formalism. Worse, a model from one formalism might actually be well-formed in another, but be interpreted differently due to the semantic differences. This paper summarizes the results of an informal comparative study of these three formalisms with the help of several illustrative examples. We present a classification of the differences according to the nature of potential problems caused by each difference. In addition, for each difference we discuss how translation between formalisms can be achieved, if at all.     

Syntax and semantics of the compositional interchange format for hybrid systems

Different modeling formalisms for timed and hybrid systems exist, each of which addresses a specific set of problems, and has its own set of features. These formalisms and tools can be used in each stage of the embedded systems development, to verify and validate various requirements.The Compositional Interchange Format (CIF), is a formalism based on hybrid automata, which are composed using process algebraic operators. CIF aims to establish interoperability among a wide range of formalisms and tools by means of model transformations and co-simulation, which avoids the need for implementing many bilateral translators.This work presents the syntax and formal semantics of CIF. The semantics is shown to be compositional, and proven to preserve certain algebraic properties, which express our intuition about the behavior of the language operators. In addition we show how CIF operators can be combined to implement widely used constructs present in other timed and hybrid formalisms, and we illustrate the applicability of the formalism by developing several examples.Based on the formal specification of CIF, an Eclipse based simulation environment has been developed. We expect this work to serve as the basis for the formal definition of semantic preserving transformations between various languages for the specification of timed and hybrid systems.     

Actor grammars

Actor systems are a model of massively parallel systems based on asynchronous message passing. This paper presents a formalism for a restricted version of actor systems in the framework of graph grammars. To this aim actor grammars are introduced, motivated, and illustrated by examples. Some of the basic properties pertinent to graph transformations in actor grammars are discussed.     

Expression of syntactic and semantic features in logic-based grammars

In this paper, we introduce and initiate a formalism to represent syntactic and semantic features in logic-based grammars. We also introduce technical devices to express feature-checking and feature-inheritance mechanisms. This leads us to propose some extensions to the basic unification mechanism of PROLOG. Finally, we consider the problem of long-distance dependency relations between constituents in gapping grammars rules from the point of view of morphosyntactic features that may change depending on the position occupied by the moved constituents. What we propose is not a new linguistic theory about features, but rather a formalism and a set of tools that we think will be useful to grammar writers to describe features and their relations in grammar rules.     

UML元模型图实例自动生成算法

UML元模型建模与实例生成是软件自动生成技术的重要环节之一,相关理论和技术在领域建模语言DSL中得到广泛应用。元模型自动生成实例技术不仅可以降低软件开发难度和成本,还可以提高软件开发效率。在已有元模型实例生成图语法理论的基础上,提出相应的元模型图实例自动生成算法,证明了该算法与图语法的等价性。并且在可视化UML建模平台中实现了这一算法,得到了从UML元模型自动生成大量实例的预期结果。     

一种基于边的上下文相关图文法形式化框架

围绕解决图文法中的主要问题——嵌入问题,提出了一种基于边的上下文相关图文法形式化框架,并对由此定义的文法的一些性质及相应的归约算法进行了讨论.对所提出的图文法与已有的文法进行了比较.同时,展望了今后值得进一步研究的一些问题和方向.     

Highly Constrained Unification Grammars

Unification grammars are widely accepted as an expressive means for describing the structure of natural languages. In general, the recognition problem is undecidable for unification grammars. Even with restricted variants of the formalism, off-line parsable grammars, the problem is computationally hard. We present two natural constraints on unification grammars which limit their expressivity and allow for efficient processing. We first show that non-reentrant unification grammars generate exactly the class of context-free languages. We then relax the constraint and show that one-reentrant unification grammars generate exactly the class of mildly context-sensitive languages. We thus relate the commonly used and linguistically motivated formalism of unification grammars to more restricted, computationally tractable classes of languages.     

图文法综述

形式语言理论对计算机科学的发展起了重大的作用,作为对传统字符文法扩展的图文法的形式化研究,其重要意义是不言而喻的.本文在概述图文法的产生、发展和现状的基础上,着重介绍了从一维字符文法扩展到二维图文法所出现的新问题,以及在形式化处理上引出的新方法,其中最主要的是嵌入问题的解决、文法类型的划分和成员问题的判定.文中以目前较为流行的图文法为例,特别是一些典型的上下文无关和上下文相关的图文法,对上述的问题进行了深入的讨论,指出了现有方法中的一些不足之处,并展望了图文法今后值得研究的问题和方向.