Lithium dilution cardiac output measurement: a comparison with thermodilution

OBJECTIVE: To compare the results of cardiac output measurements obtained by lithium dilution and thermodilution. DESIGN: Case series, observational study. SETTING: High-dependency postoperative unit and intensive care unit of a teaching hospital. PATIENTS: Forty patients were studied. Thirty-four patients had undergoing heart surgery requiring cardiopulmonary bypass within the previous 2 days; the diagnoses in the other patients were myocardial infarct (n = 2), septicemia (n = 2), adult respiratory distress syndrome, and pericardectomy. INTERVENTIONS: Cardiac output was measured five times in each patient, using lithium dilution (single measurement) and bolus thermodilution (series of three to six measurements according to standard clinical practice, taking the average of the closest three). In a subgroup of 14 patients, cardiac output was also measured using "continuous thermodilution." MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Comparing lithium dilution with bolus thermodilution, the mean of the differences (lithium dilution-thermodilution) was -0.25 +/- 0.46 [SD] L/min. Linear regression analysis gave y = 0.31 + 0.89x (r2 = .94) for lithium dilution vs. thermodilution. CONCLUSIONS: The overall agreement between the two methods was good. The variability of the thermodilution measurements was greater than that of the lithium dilution measurements. The lithium dilution method is at least as accurate as bolus thermodilution and, since pulmonary artery catheterization is not needed, it has the advantages of being safe and quick to perform.     

Errors in the measurement of cardiac output by thermodilution

Cardiac output (CO) determination by thermodilution, which was introduced by Fegler in 1954, has gained wide acceptance in clinical medicine and animal experiments because it has several advantages over other methods with respect to simplicity, accuracy, reproducibility, repeated measurements at short intervals, and because there is no need for blood withdrawal. However, errors in determination of CO by thermodilution may be introduced by technical factors and the patients' pathological conditions. The current review summarizes these issues and provides our recommendations, based on the medical literature published between 1954-1992. To obtain more reproducible and accurate CO values by thermodilution, one should make several determinations (1) by using 10 ml injectate at room temperature for adults and 0.15 ml.kg-1 injectate for infants and children; (2) at evenly spaced intervals of the ventilation cycle; (3) when rapid intravenous fluid administration is discontinued; (4) by observing thermodilution curves so that baseline pulmonary artery temperature drift or the existence of intra- and extracardiac shunts are noticed. Finally, CO determination by thermodilution may be unreliable or impossible in patients with low CO states and tricuspid or pulmonary regurgitation. Since non-invasive CO monitoring has not replaced CO determination by thermodilution, intimate knowledge of this method is crucial for anaesthetists to prevent errors in the management of patients.     

Validity of cardiac output measurement by the thermodilution method in the presence of acute tricuspid regurgitation

Evaluation of patients with acute tricuspid insufficiency may include assessment of cardiac output by the thermodilution method. The accuracy of estimates of thermodilution-derived cardiac output in the presence of tricuspid insufficiency has been questioned. This study was designed to determine the validity of the thermodilution technique in a canine model of acute reversible tricuspid insufficiency. Cardiac output as measured by thermodilution and electromagnetic flowmeter was compared at two grades of regurgitation. The relationship between these two methods (thermodilution/electromagnetic) changed significantly from a regression slope of 1.01 +/- 0.18 (mean +/- standard deviation) during control conditions to a slope of 0.86 +/- 0.23 (p < 0.02) during severe regurgitation. No significant change was observed between control and mild regurgitation or between the initial control value and a control measurement repeated after tricuspid insufficiency was reversed at the termination of the study. This study shows that in a canine model of severe acute tricuspid regurgitation the thermodilution method underestimates cardiac output by an amount that is proportional to the level of cardiac output and to the grade of regurgitation.     

Measurement of cardiac output by pulse dye densitometry using indocyanine green: a comparison with the thermodilution method

BACKGROUND: A new method for determining cardiac output (CO, l/min) using dye dilution combined with pulse dye densitometry (PDD), based on the principle of pulse oximetry, has been developed. The aim of the study was to determine the accuracy and precision of PDD by comparing it with the thermodilution method. METHODS: A prospective study was performed in 22 patients having surgery who were monitored using a pulmonary arterial catheter. In addition to the catheter, a specially designed photodetector was placed on the nasal wing. Ten milliliters of ice-cold indocyanine green dissolved in a 5% glucose solution (0.5 mg/ml) was injected. The dye and thermal dilution curves were simultaneously measured to calculate CO. Three to six injections were performed before and after surgery. Paired data were assessed in absolute terms, and the percentage errors were calculated by the degree of agreement and compared at three levels of CO (low < or = 3.5 < medium < or = 6 < high) by analysis of variance. RESULTS: The mean and SDs of the differences between dye and thermodilution CO were 0.16 +/- 0.80 l/min or 4.5 +/- 19.6% for 191 paired data. Measurement after surgery failed in one patient. The percentage error with low CO (9.3 +/- 19.3%) was greater (P < 0.05) than those obtained with other CO. CONCLUSIONS: Pulse dye densitometry could measure CO repeatedly in patients having major surgery with the same degree of accuracy as the thermodilution method; however, a considerable degree of error was observed in some patients.     

Comparison of pulse dye densitometry and thermodilution method in cardiac output measurement]

We measured cardiac outputs at forty points from five patients by pulse dye densitometry and compared these with those measured by thermodilution method. We obtained a good correlation (y = 1.090 x = . 0.030, n = 40, 5 cases) and small mean bias (0.348 +/- 0.830 l.min-1, n = 40, 5 cases) between the two methods. We suggest that this method of cardiac output measurement by pulse dye densitometry is not invasive and may be more effective than that by thermodilution method.     

Evaluation of continuous measurement of cardiac output with thermodilution in critical patients

Pregnant women with inflammatory bowel disease and their physicians should be aware of factors that may affect the outcome of the pregnancy. Proper patient education, along with a physician team approach, usually ensure completion of an uneventful pregnancy.     

Comparison of impedance cardiography with indirect Fick (CO2) method of measuring cardiac output in healthy children during exercise

Shortened hospital stays have decreased women's access to postpartum nursing care. Providers and payers together must address clinical and cost issues to develop a model of maternity care that covers the postpartum period. A short-stay maternity program was developed in 1989 by Professional Nurse Associates, Inc., in conjunction with Kaiser Permanente. The program includes prenatal preparation of families, a brief hospital stay, postpartum home visits, and postvisit case management. Readmission rates or mothers and newborns in the program have been less than 1%. The program has saved about $1 million a year since 1991, and consumer satisfaction has been measured at 99%.     

Comparison of the accuracy of the lithium dilution technique with the thermodilution technique for measurement of cardiac output

A new indicator dilution technique for measurement of cardiac output is described. Lithium chloride is injected via a central venous catheter and its dilution curve measured in arterial blood using a lithium-selective electrode. We assessed the lithium dilution cardiac output measurement (LiDCO) and a conventional thermodilution cardiac output measurement (ThDCO) by comparing the results of both with cardiac output determined by electromagnetic flowmetry (EMCO) under controlled laboratory conditions in 10 swine. They were monitored with a pulmonary artery catheter, femoral artery catheter and electromagnetic flowmeter placed around the ascending aorta. LiDCO, ThDCO and EMCO measurements were determined at baseline, in a hyperdynamic state produced by administration of dobutamine, at a second baseline and finally in a hypodynamic state induced by propranolol during deep anaesthesia. Data were analysed by linear regression analysis and the comparison method described by Bland and Altman; bias and precision of both LiDCO and ThDCO compared with EMCO were calculated by the method of Sheiner and Beal. The correlation coefficient between LiDCO and EMCO (0.95) was higher than that between ThDCO and EMCO (0.87). The precision value of LiDCO (0.04) was significantly less (i.e. better) than that of ThDCO (0.09). The results of this study indicated that LiDCO was more reliable compared with conventional ThDCO.     

Comparison between intraarterial pulsegraphy and thermodilution method for determination of cardiac output during anesthesia and operation in patients undergoing cardiac valve replacement

BACKGROUND: During the past 15 years, three models of the Rotorod Sampler have been manufactured for aeroallergen sampling. Although several studies have considered pollen recovery by specific Rotorod models, none explored inter-model sampling differences. OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this present investigation was to compare pollen recovery by three Rotorod models that are widely used by allergists. METHODS: Two Model 85s, two Model 95s, and two Model 40s were installed 1.5 m above the flat rooftop of a surburban 3-story office building. Fifty atmospheric samples collected between June and August 1996 were analyzed according to the standard conventions suggested by the manufacturer. Differences in pollen recovery were evaluated using an analysis of variance followed by Duncan's multiple range test. RESULTS: Pollen counts ranged from 7.4 to 406.8 pollen grains per cubic meter of air. Differences in pollen recovery by the six devices were not statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: Pollen counts obtained with three models of the Rotorod Sampler were generally similar and could be compared directly. This study demonstrated continuity in the performance of the Rotorod Sampler over successive generations of the device.     

Measurement of cardiac output with continuous thermodilution. b1 Clinical experience with the Intellicath-Vigilans system

BACKGROUND: Thermodilution cardiac output measurements are commonly obtained by a manual bolus technique with a pulmonary artery catheter. METHODS: A new thermodilution catheter has been developed which utilizes an integral thermal filament and provides semicontinuous online cardiac output. The response of this new device in 25 patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting was examined. A total of 250 data pairs was obtained; the cardiac outputs ranged from 2.2 to 11.9 lts.min. RESULTS: The linear regression is represented by the following equation: continuous thermodilution = 0.7196 bolus thermodilution +1.038. The correlation coefficient was 0.75; the mean bias was 0.493 +/- 1.034. CONCLUSIONS: The new technique provides acceptable accuracy in many clinical situations except when sudden haemodynamic changes occur.     

Continuous monitoring of cardiac output by analysis of the pulse contour

One method of continuous cardiac output monitoring by analysis of the radial pulse contour (Qcp) relates left ventricular stroke volume and systolic blood pressure by calculating the impedence characteristic of the aorta (Zao). It was assessed during haemodynamic monitoring by comparing it with the thermodilation method in the pulmonary artery (Qtd) in 20 patients with cardiac failure due to dilated cardiomyopathy (6 cases) and ischaemic cardiomyopathy (14 cases) treated by inotropic agents or vasodilators. Over an average monitoring period of 35 hours 159 measurements of cardiac output were performed by the two methods. There was an excellent correlation between the two methods (r = 0.90; p < 0.001; Qcp = 0.97 Qtd). The systematic error (bias) between the two methods was about 2.5%. The accuracy of Qcp compared with Qtd was 12.5%. During infusion with a vasoactive agent (Piroximone), the method based on pulse contour analysis did not reflect sudden variations in cardiac output. The systematic error between the two methods rose to 19% of the value measured, reflecting the lack of adaptation of parameters of correction in this situation and which necessitated recalibration of Zao at least once after injection of the drug.     

Estimation of cardiac output by an N2O rebreathing method in adults and children

Double-stranded ribonucleic acid present in virus-infected mushrooms of Agaricus bisporus has been resolved through polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis into six molecular-weight forms. Identification of these six double-stranded ribonucleic acids in mushrooms by this procedure has proven to be a useful and diagnostic method for viral infection in the cultivated mushroom.     

Continuous measurements of cardiac output in the perioperative period

Management of critically ill patients is based on knowledge of fundamental physiological variables. Automatized and continuous measurement of these variables is preferable. A new system based upon the thermodilution method has been developed to measure cardiac output automatically and continuously. We evaluated the system in the potentially unstable perioperative period with possible great and rapid changes in cardiac output. Twenty patients, scheduled for open heart or abdominal aortic aneurysm surgery, were included into the study, which was approved by the local ethical committee. The patients were monitored for up to 30 hours. At random intervals five iced bolus thermodilution cardiac output (BCO) determinations were made and compared to the continuous measurements (CCO). Two hundred and thirty-one pairs of data were obtained. The cardiac outputs ranged from 2.5-14.9 l/min. The absolute bias was 0.31 l/min (95% limits of agreement -1.4 l/min to 2.0 l/min). The mean relative error was 4.7% with a standard deviation of the relative error of 15.4%. The linear regression was represented by: CCO = 11.352 x BCO - 0.36. The correlation coefficient R was 0.90 (p < 0.001). In conclusion, the CCO measurement technique is a promising clinical method. The method is straightforward, requires no calibration, is independent of vascular geometry and measures with its limitations volumetric flow. Finally automatic and continuous patient monitoring provides more information and has potential to reveal previously undetected haemodynamic events.     

Quantification of mitral regurgitation by automated cardiac output measurement: experimental and clinical validation

OBJECTIVES: To develop and validate an automated noninvasive method to quantify mitral regurgitation. BACKGROUND: Automated cardiac output measurement (ACM), which integrates digital color Doppler velocities in space and in time, has been validated for the left ventricular (LV) outflow tract but has not been tested for the LV inflow tract or to assess mitral regurgitation (MR). METHODS: First, to validate ACM against a gold standard (ultrasonic flow meter), 8 dogs were studied at 40 different stages of cardiac output (CO). Second, to compare ACM to the LV outflow (ACMa) and inflow (ACMm) tracts, 50 normal volunteers without MR or aortic regurgitation (44+/-5 years, 31 male) were studied. Third, to compare ACM with the standard pulsed Doppler-two-dimensional echocardiographic (PD-2D) method for quantification of MR, 51 patients (61+/-14 years, 30 male) with MR were studied. RESULTS: In the canine studies, CO by ACM (1.32+/-0.3 liter/min, y) and flow meter (1.35+/-0.3 liter/min, x) showed good correlation (r=0.95, y=0.89x+0.11) and agreement (deltaCO(y-x)=0.03+/-0.08 [mean+/-SD] liter/min). In the normal subjects, CO measured by ACMm agreed with CO by ACMa (r=0.90, p < 0.0001, deltaCO=-0.09+/-0.42 liter/min), PD (r=0.87, p < 0.0001, deltaCO=0.12+/-0.49 liter/min) and 2D (r=0.84, p < 0.0001, deltaCO=-0.16+/-0.48 liter/min). In the patients, mitral regurgitant volume (MRV) by ACMm-ACMa agreed with PD-2D (r= 0.88, y=0.88x+6.6, p < 0.0001, deltaMRV=2.68+/-9.7 ml). CONCLUSIONS: We determined that ACM is a feasible new method for quantifying LV outflow and inflow volume to measure MRV and that ACM automatically performs calculations that are equivalent to more time-consuming Doppler and 2D measurements. Additionally, ACM should improve MR quantification in routine clinical practice.     

A comparison between the Fick method and indirect calorimetry for determining oxygen consumption in patients with fulminant hepatic failure

OBJECTIVE: To compare the Fick method of determining oxygen consumption (VO2) with a gas exchange method in a group of patients in whom the cardiac output and mixed venous oxygen saturation values were consistently high. DESIGN: A prospective, observational study. SETTING: A ten-bed intensive therapy unit at a university teaching hospital. PATIENTS: Seventeen patients suffering from fulminant hepatic failure who required ventilatory support and invasive hemodynamic monitoring. All patients were sedated and paralyzed throughout the study period. INTERVENTIONS: None. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: VO2 was determined simultaneously by indirect calorimetry and by the Fick method five or six times in each patient over a 5-hr period after resuscitation with fluids and, if clinically indicated, norepinephrine infusion. The agreement between the methods was poor (limits of agreement +19 to -101 mL/min/m2) and the Fick method consistently underestimated gas exchange measurements (mean bias 41 mL/min/m2). The bias varied widely, both between and within individual patients. The reproducibility of the Fick-derived VO2 was worse than the indirect calorimetry measurements, indicating that the dispersion of data attributable to measurement error was greater with the Fick method. CONCLUSIONS: Under clinical conditions, the agreement between Fick calculations and indirect calorimetry measurements of VO2 in hyperdynamic patients with fulminant hepatic failure was extremely poor. The reproducibility of Fick calculations was less than the reproducibility derived by gas exchange measurements because of the large measurement errors that may occur with the Fick method when the cardiac output is large and the arterial-venous oxygen content difference is small. Fick calculations systematically underestimate gas exchange measurements. The Fick method is inaccurate and unreliable when an estimation of VO2 is required in patients with this hemodynamic pattern.