The Impact of Biased Sampling on the Estimation of the Semivariogram Within Fractured Media Containing Multiple Fracture Sets

Monte Carlo simulation was used to examine the error (statistical bias) introduced in estimating a sample semivariogram through application of oriented sampling patterns to variables which are correlated with fracture orientation. Sample semivariograms of the directional components of the water velocity were used to illustrate that oriented sampling schemes can provide biased data sets which result in error in the estimation of the semivariogram, particularly in the estimation of the sill (or variance). Three sampling patterns were used to analyze directional semivariograms of the components of the fluid velocity: sampling along lines parallel to the mean regional hydraulic gradient, sampling among lines perpendicular to the mean regional hydraulic gradient, and sampling along fracture segments. The first two sampling patterns were shown to introduce substantial error in the sills of the velocity variograms. It is argued that this error is due to the combination of unequal sampling of fractures with different orientations (i.e., sampling bias) and the systematic variation in the magnitude of the velocity components with orientation of the fracture. As a consequence, it is suggested that correction factors developed to correct fracture frequency statistics need to be extended to improve estimation of spatial moments of variables which are correlated with fracture orientation.