论多维视角下中文科技图书学术影响力评价体系的构建

目的/意义]在分析当前图书评价研究现状的基础上,结合现实的数据应用特征,从多维角度建立中文科技图书学术影响力评价体系,进行图书学术影响力评价的有益探索.方法/过程]采用书评分析、引文分析、专家调查法、层次分析法、加权综合评价法等多种方法进行研究,在评价的基本框架内选取27个研究指标并将其归纳为4个维度,在确定权重的基础上选取医学领域3个学科进行实证分析.结果/结论]实证分析结果给出了3个学科不同类型最有影响力的图书目录;发现科技图书呈现长尾分布、外文图书翻译版影响力高等特点.最后利用CALIS馆藏图书馆数量对实证分析评价结果进行验证,证明评价体系的有效性.

The Construction of Academic Impact Evaluation System of Sci-Tech Books in China Under Multiple Dimensions

Purpose/significance] Based on the present development of the book evaluation research, the article combines with the feature of real data and constructs the academic impact evaluation system of Sci-Tech Books in China from multiple dimensions. It is a beneficial exploration evaluation of academic influence of books. Method/process] Based on review analysis, citation analysis, expert survey, AHP and so on, 27 indexes are selected from evaluation framework and summarized from different levels of academic influence. Result/conclusion] After determining the weight coefficients of indicators, the article carries out empirical analysis in the medical field. Eventually we obtain the most influential academic books in those subject and type. The results show some features, such as long-tailed distributions, highly influential of foreign language books translated version and so on. CALIS holdings data evaluates the effectiveness of the result.