Cation field-strength effects on ion irradiation-induced mechanical property changes of borosilicate glass structures

We examine the impact of the glass network-modifier cation field strength (CFS) on ion irradiation-induced mechanical property changes in borosilicate (BS) glasses for the ternary M₂O–B₂O₃–SiO₂ systems with M = {Na, K, Rb} and the quaternary 0.5M₍₂₎O–0.5Na₂O]–B₂O₃–SiO₂ systems with M = {Li, Na, K, Rb Mg, Ca, Sr, Ba}. ¹¹B nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments on the as-prepared BS glasses yielded the fractional population of four-coordinated B species (B^4]) out of all {B^3], B^4]} groups in the glass network, along with the fraction of B^4]–O–Si linkages out of all B^4]–O–Si/B bonds. Both parameters correlated linearly with the (average) CFS of the M⁺ and/or {M⁽²⁾⁺, Na⁺} cations. Both the nanoindentation-derived hardness and Young's modulus values of the glasses reduced upon their irradiation by Si²⁺ ions, with the property deterioration decreasing linearly with increasing M^z+ CFS, that is, for higher M^z+⋅⋅⋅O interaction strength. The irradiation damage of the glass network also increased linearly with the fraction of B^4]–O–Si linkages, which are the second weakest in the structure after the M^z+⋅⋅⋅O bonds. Our results underscore the advantages of employing BS glasses with high-CFS cations for enhancing the radiation resistance for nuclear waste storage.