法律论证中的融贯论——转型时期和谐理念的司法体现

在市场经济和全球化背景下,转型时期凸显利益多元化特征,而和谐社会的司法建构,应当在保证争讼主体机会平等的基础上,以整体性观念衡量利益纷争.对话的法律论证模式从程序上保证了多元主体参与法律决定、表达自身利益诉求的权利.但是,只有平等的对话与协商难以有效解决纠纷,法律决定是在对话式法律论证的基础上,依据融贯的司法信念进行整体衡量的结果.

Coherence Theory in Legal Argumentation——Harmonious Theory's Judicial Realization in Transformation

In the background of market economy and globalization,multi-interests is the character of transformation society.Harmonious society should be practiced in the course of judgment.Judge should weigh interests by integrate idea on the basis of ensuring formal equality of litigants.Legal argumentation model ensure formally litigants' rights.Litigants can participate in legal decision and express their interest requirement.But,it is impossible to solve availably dispute by dialoguing and debating equally alone.In the base of legal argumentation of dialogue,legal decision is the result of integrate weighing by coherent judicial faith system.