A systematic review of the methodological quality of economic evaluations in genetic screening and testing for monogenic disorders

PurposeUnderstanding the value of genetic screening and testing for monogenic disorders requires high-quality, methodologically robust economic evaluations. This systematic review sought to assess the methodological quality among such studies and examined opportunities for improvement.MethodsWe searched PubMed, Cochrane, Embase, and Web of Science for economic evaluations of genetic screening/testing (2013-2019). Methodological rigor and adherence to best practices were systematically assessed using the British Medical Journal checklist.ResultsAcross the 47 identified studies, there were substantial variations in modeling approaches, reporting detail, and sophistication. Models ranged from simple decision trees to individual-level microsimulations that compared between 2 and >20 alternative interventions. Many studies failed to report sufficient detail to enable replication or did not justify modeling assumptions, especially for costing methods and utility values. Meta-analyses, systematic reviews, or calibration were rarely used to derive parameter estimates. Nearly all studies conducted some sensitivity analysis, and more sophisticated studies implemented probabilistic sensitivity/uncertainty analysis, threshold analysis, and value of information analysis.ConclusionWe describe a heterogeneous body of work and present recommendations and exemplar studies across the methodological domains of (1) perspective, scope, and parameter selection; (2) use of uncertainty/sensitivity analyses; and (3) reporting transparency for improvement in the economic evaluation of genetic screening/testing.     

Right aortic arch detected in fetal life.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the prenatal distribution, associated conditions and outcome of the different types of right aortic arch (RAA) detected in fetal life. METHODS: This was a retrospective review of all cases of RAA detected prenatally between 1998 and 2005 in two tertiary referral centers. RESULTS: In the study period 71 cases of RAA were detected; 26 (37%) had RAA with aberrant left subclavian artery, 23 (32%) had RAA with mirror-image branching, 20 (28%) had RAA of unknown type and two (3%) had double aortic arch. While 20/26 cases with RAA and aberrant left subclavian artery were isolated findings, all 23 cases with RAA and mirror-image branching were associated with cardiac defects, namely tetralogy of Fallot (43%) or pulmonary atresia with ventricular septal defect (22%). Of the 20 cases with RAA, 19 of unknown type were associated with heterotaxy syndromes and had additional cardiac malformations and ambiguities of the situs. The two cases with DAA were isolated findings. Seven cases in our series (10%) had a microdeletion 22q11 and these were significantly associated with extracardiac malformations. The outcome in our series depended solely on the associated cardiac and extracardiac malformations, with the exception of one infant with isolated DAA, in whom a surgical correction was warranted. CONCLUSIONS: RAA detected in fetal life is associated frequently with other cardiac/non-cardiac malformations, heterotaxy syndromes and microdeletions 22q11. The associated conditions vary depending on the branching type of the brachiocephalic vessels and the presence of extracardiac malformations.     

Poor results after surgery for bronchioloalveolar carcinoma.

BACKGROUND: Bronchioloalveolar carcinoma (BAC) is suggested to be less aggressive than other types of lung cancer. To assess the option of treatment modification, actual outcome data were studied and compared with results for other types of lung cancer. METHOD: Retrospective analysis of all consecutive patients who underwent resection for stage I lung cancer in our hospital. For 18 BAC cases, histological specimens were re-evaluated and in three cases diagnosis was revised. RESULTS: In the period 1989 through 2000, 15 patients with BAC and 260 patients with other tumour types underwent surgery in our hospital. Five-year survival rates were 24 and 53%, respectively, (p = 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Given the poor results after standard surgery, parenchyma-sparing operations do not seem justified in patients with invasive BAC.     

Nutritional status in anorexia nervosa: clinical chemistry, vitamins, iron and zinc

Routine clinical chemical variables and parameters of the vitamin, iron and zinc status were measured in 20 female patients with anorexia nervosa (AN) and in 10 lean and 10 normal weight, healthy, female control subjects. Patients with AN had higher activities of L-gamma-glutamyl transferase (gamma-GT) and glutamate pyruvate transaminase (SGPT) and a higher concentration of prealbumin in serum and lower leucocyte and lymphocyte counts in blood. For the other routine clinical chemical parameters no significant differences between the groups were observed. AN patients had higher serum vitamin B12 and retinol levels. No significant differences were found for the status parameters of thiamin, vitamin B6, vitamin C, folate, vitamin E and vitamin D. Contradictory results were obtained for the riboflavin status: AN patients had a lower level of flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) in blood and a lower stimulation ratio of the glutathione reductase activity in erythrocytes (alpha-EGR). Patients with AN had higher serum ferritin concentration and lower total iron binding capacity (TIBC). However, haemoglobin (Hb), haematocrit (Ht) and iron saturation were not significantly different. No significant difference was found in the concentration of zinc in plasma. In spite of the poor intake of nutrients and energy, the results obtained did not indicate an inadequate status of vitamins, iron and zinc in patients with AN.     

Activation of glucocorticoid receptors and the effect of naloxone during hemorrhagic hypotension.

Evidence indicates that endogenous opioid peptides and glucocorticoids participate in the control of cardiovascular regulation during hemorrhagic shock. In the present study, we investigated a possible interaction between brain opioid peptides and adrenal corticosteroids regarding the control of arterial pressure during hemorrhage. The bleeding volumes required to lower arterial pressure to 80, 60 and 40 mmHg were studied in anesthetized sham-operated (SHAM) and adrenalectomized (ADX) rats. I.c.v. administration of 10 micrograms of naloxone resulted in a significant increase in the bleeding volume required to lower arterial pressure from 60 to 40 mmHg in SHAM animals, whereas no effect of naloxone was observed in ADX animals. Replacement therapy with a 100% corticosterone pellet (100 mg, s.c.), but not with a 12.5% corticosterone pellet (12.5 mg corticosterone and 87.5 mg cholesterol, s.c.), resulted in an effect of naloxone on the bleeding volume in ADX animals. The effect of replacement therapy could be inhibited by i.c.v. pretreatment with the synthetic glucocorticoid receptor antagonist, RU38486 (100 ng). These data suggest that (1) opioid mechanisms are involved in the regulation of blood pressure during hemorrhage, and (2) occupancy of glucocorticoid receptors is required for naloxone to exert its hemodynamic effect during hemorrhagic hypotension in ADX rats.     

On verification of hyperthermia treatment planning for cervical carcinoma patients.

PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to verify hyperthermia treatment planning calculations by means of measurements performed during hyperthermia treatments. The calculated specific absorption rate (SAR(calc)) was compared with clinically measured SAR values, during 11 treatments in seven cervical carcinoma patients. METHODS: Hyperthermia treatments were performed using the 70 MHz AMC-4 waveguide system. Temperatures were measured using multisensor thermocouple probes. One invasive thermometry catheter in the cervical tumour and two non-invasive catheters in the vagina were used. For optimal tissue contact and fixation of the catheters, a gynaecological tampon was inserted, moisturized with distilled water (4 treatments), or saline (6 treatments) for better thermal contact. During one treatment no tampon was used. At the start of treatment the temperature rise (DeltaT(meas)) after a short power pulse was measured, which is proportional to SAR(meas). The SAR(calc) along the catheter tracks was extracted from the calculated SAR distribution and compared with the DeltaT(meas)-profiles. RESULTS: The correlation between DeltaT(meas) and SAR(calc) was on average R = 0.56 +/- 0.28, but appeared highly dependent on the wetness of the tampon (preferably with saline) and the tissue contact of the catheters. Correlations were strong (R approximately 0.85-0.93) when thermal contact was good, but much weaker (R approximately 0.14-0.48) for cases with poor thermal contact. CONCLUSION: Good correlations between measurements and calculations were found when tissue contact of the catheters was good. The main difficulties for accurate verification were of clinical nature, arising from improper use of the gynaecological tampon. Poor thermal contact between thermocouples and tissue caused measurement artefacts that were difficult to correlate with calculations.     

Lack of effect of the calcium antagonist isradipine on cyclosporine pharmacokinetics in renal transplant patients.

Hypertension has emerged as a frequent side effect in transplant recipients on effective doses of cyclosporine (CsA). To control hypertension in renal transplant patients, calcium channel blockers have been used; some of these, however, have been shown to cause significant increases in CsA levels. These findings point out that possible interactions of each calcium antagonist with CsA deserve investigation. We performed an open, placebo-controlled study in 12 stable renal transplant recipients to determine whether short-term isradipine influences CsA pharmacokinetics. All patients had mild to moderate hypertension and received triple immunosuppressive therapy with CsA, azathioprine, and prednisolone. Throughout a 4-week period of isradipine treatment, blood CsA levels (specific and nonspecific monoclonal antibodies) remained stable. The mean trough specific level was 121 +/- 14 micrograms/L following placebo, compared to 120 +/- 14 micrograms/L during isradipine. Corresponding non-specific values were 465 +/- 68 and 474 +/- 63 micrograms/L. Also, values for Cmax, AUC, and t1/2 were not significantly changed following 4 weeks of isradipine. Mean arterial pressure was significantly reduced at the end of the study. This study implies that isradipine does not influence CsA metabolism. Further studies should be carried out to determine its long-term effects on CsA pharmacokinetics and renal function in transplanted patients.