Applying the case method for teaching within the health professions--teaching the teachers

The case method provides training in problem solving and is useful in clinical education within health professions. The method consumes less teaching resources and might be useful in a situation with increasing numbers of students and staff cuts. As it is a relatively new method within the Faculty of Medicine, University of Lund, a training program for teachers has been established with a short, practical, course. This paper describes the application and introduction of the case method and evaluation of the introductory course by 106 teachers. In this course the case method is introduced and demonstrated. The participants construct cases and take an active part as both students and teachers. Almost everyone was planning to incorporate the case method in their teaching practice, at both undergraduate and graduate levels. To have constructed and led cases themselves was considered a great strength. More time was requested as well as a follow-up session after practically using the case method.     

Testing the embryo, testing the fetus

This paper stems from an ethnographic, multidisciplinary study that explored the views and experiences of practitioners and scientists on social, ethical and clinical dilemmas encountered when working in the area of PGD for serious genetic disorders. We focus here on staff perceptions and experiences of working with embryos and helping women/couples to make choices that will result in selecting embryos for transfer and disposal of 'affected' embryos, compared to the termination of affected pregnancies following PND. Analysis and discussion of our data led us to consider the possible advantages of PGD and whether a gradualist account of the embryo's and fetus's moral status can account for all of these, particularly since a gradualist account concentrates on the significance of time (developmental stage) and makes no comment as to the significance of place (in-vitro, in-utero).     

Beyond the Moral Status of the Fetus

Book reviewed in this article: Abortion and Woman's Choice: The State, Sexuality, and Reproductive Freedom . By Rosalind P. Petchesky. Abortion and the Politics of Motherhood . By Kristin Luker.     

Bioethics in the Language of the Law

Law provides a rich language for thinking about bioethical issues and is a tool for action as well as talk. But the language of the law, often inapt, regularly fails to achieve its desired effect.     

From the local to the global: bioethics and the concept of culture

Cultural models of health, illness, and moral reasoning are receiving increasing attention in bioethics scholarship. Drawing upon research tools from medical and cultural anthropology, numerous researchers explore cultural variations in attitudes toward truth telling, informed consent, pain relief, and planning for end-of-life care. However, culture should not simply be equated with ethnicity. Rather, the concept of culture can serve as an heuristic device at various levels of analysis. In addition to considering how participation in particular ethnic groups and religious traditions can shape moral reasoning, bioethicists need to consider processes of socialization into professional cultures, organizational cultures, national civic culture, and transnational culture. From the local world of the community clinic or oncology unit to the transnational workings of human rights agencies, attentiveness to the concept of culture can illuminate how patients, family members, and health care providers interpret illness, healing, and moral obligations.     

Medicine and the public: the 1962 report of the Royal College of Physicians and the new public health

The 1962 report of the Royal College of Physicians on smoking was a significant event in the history of smoking. Its significance was, however, more than smoking-specific: the RCP committee's appointment, its membership, its work, and the manner of its publication signified the changes within social medicine, and within the medical profession more generally, in postwar Britain. Doctors assumed the right to speak to the public and to government on matters of individual health, and a new risk-based public health was in the process of formation. A public health "policy community" formed, and governments began to assume responsibility for advising the public on health matters. The use of research in the report, and of social research in response to it, was important in the emergence of evidence-based medicine within public health. The paper argues for greater attention to the change in public health epitomized by the report in current debates on the concept of the 1960s "permissive society." It was the harbinger of a new style of "coercive permissiveness" in health.     

The ends of medical intervention and the demarcation of the normal from the pathological

This study examines the ends of medical intervention and argues that mainstream contemporary medicine assumes that appropriate ends may be discovered (i.e., naturalism), rather than created or decided upon (i.e., conventionalism). The essay then applies these considerations to the problem of the demarcation of the normal from the pathological. I argue that the common formulations of this dispute commit a fallacy, as they characterize the "normal" as a state of the organism and not as an ongoing process within it. Such a process may be characterized as self-creation and self-repair. Such considerations support the conclusion that normality may be regarded as a regulative idea, rather than as an end-state, and as part of the ends of medical intervention, depending upon choice and context.