Microsecond hydrophobic collapse in the folding of Escherichia coli dihydrofolate reductase, an alpha/beta-type protein

Using small-angle X-ray scattering combined with a continuous-flow mixing device, we monitored the microsecond compaction dynamics in the folding of Escherichia coli dihydrofolate reductase, an alpha/beta-type protein. A significant collapse of the radius of gyration from 30 A to 23.2 A occurs within 300 micros after the initiation of refolding by a urea dilution jump. The subsequent folding after the major chain collapse occurs on a considerably longer time-scale. The protein folding trajectories constructed by comparing the development of the compactness and the secondary structure suggest that the specific hydrophobic collapse model rather than the framework model better explains the experimental observations. The folding trajectory of this alpha/beta-type protein is located between those of alpha-helical and beta-sheet proteins, suggesting that native structure determines the folding landscape.     

Kinetic studies of the refolding of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase: comparison with the isolated engineered domains.

Unfolding and refolding kinetics of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase were studied by following the time-dependent changes of two signals: the ellipticity at 218 nm and 222 nm, and the fluorescence emission at 330 nm (following excitation at 295 nm). The protein is composed of two similar-sized structural domains. Each domain has been produced by recombinant DNA techniques. It has been previously demonstrated that the engineered isolated domains are able to fold into a quasinative structure (Minard, P., et al., 1989b, Protein Eng. 3, 55-60; Missiakas, D., Betton, J.M., Minard, P., & Yon, J.M., 1990, Biochemistry 29, 8683-8689). The behavior of the isolated domains was studied using the same two conformational probes as for the whole enzyme. We found that the refolding kinetics of each domain are multiphasic. In the whole protein, domain folding and pairing appeared to be simultaneous events. However, it was found that some refolding steps occurring during the refolding of the isolated C-domain are masked during the refolding of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase. The N-domain was also found to refold faster when it was isolated than when integrated.     

Compactness of the kinetic molten globule of bovine alpha-lactalbumin: a dynamic light scattering study.

During folding of globular proteins, the molten globule state was observed as an equilibrium intermediate under mildly denaturing conditions as well as a transient intermediate in kinetic refolding experiments. While the high compactness of the equilibrium intermediate of alpha-lactalbumin has been verified, direct measurements of the compactness of the kinetic intermediate have not been reported until now. Our dynamic light scattering measurements provide a complete set of the hydrodynamic dimensions of bovine alpha-lactalbumin in different conformational states, particularly in the kinetic molten globule state. The Stokes radii for the native, kinetic molten globule, equilibrium molten globule, and unfolded states are 1.91, 1.99, 2.08, and 2.46 nm, respectively. Therefore, the kinetic intermediate appears to be even more compact than its equilibrium counterpart. Remarkable differences in the concentration dependence of the Stokes radius exist revealing strong attractive but repulsive intermolecular interactions in the kinetic and equilibrium molten globule states, respectively. This underlines the importance of extrapolation to zero protein concentration in measurements of the molecular compactness.     

Fast compaction of alpha-lactalbumin during folding studied by stopped-flow X-ray scattering

To monitor the fast compaction process during protein folding, we have used a stopped-flow small-angle X-ray scattering technique combined with a two-dimensional charge-coupled device-based X-ray detector that makes it possible to improve the signal-to-noise ratio of data dramatically, and measured the kinetic refolding reaction of alpha-lactalbumin. The results clearly show that the radius of gyration and the overall shape of the kinetic folding intermediate of alpha-lactalbumin are the same as those of the molten globule state observed at equilibrium. Thus, the identity between the kinetic folding intermediate and the equilibrium molten globule state is firmly established. The present results also suggest that the folding intermediate is more hydrated than the native state and that the hydrated water molecules are dehydrated when specific side-chain packing is formed during the change from the molten globule to the native state.     

Hierarchic finite level energy landscape model: to describe the refolding kinetics of phosphoglycerate kinase

One of the most intriguing predictions of energy landscape models is the existence of non-exponential protein folding kinetics caused by hierarchical structures in the landscapes. Here we provide the strongest evidence so far of such hierarchy and determine the time constants and weights of the kinetic components of the suggested hierarchic energy landscape. To our knowledge, the idea of hierarchical folding energy barriers has never been tested over such a broad timescale. Refolding of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase was initiated from the guanidine-unfolded state by stopped-flow or manual mixing and monitored by tryptophan fluorescence from 1 ms to 15 min. The strategy to build a model that describes folding of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase was to start from the simplest paradigm and modify it stepwise to the necessary minimal extent after repeated comparisons with the experiments. We made no a priori assumptions about the folding landscape. The result was a hierarchic finite level landscape model that quantitatively describes the refolding of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase from 1 ms to 15 min. The early steps of the folding process happen in the upper region of the landscape, where the surface has a hierarchic structure. This leads to stretched kinetics in the early phase of the folding. The lower region of the energy landscape is dominated by a trap that reflects the accumulation of molten globule intermediate state. From this intermediate, the protein can reach the global energy minimum corresponding to the native state through a cross-barrier folding step.     

Asymmetric effect of domain interactions on the kinetics of folding in yeast phosphoglycerate kinase

The aim of this work is to shed more light on the effect of domain-domain interactions on the kinetics and the pathway of protein folding. A model protein system consisting of several single-tryptophan variants of the two-domain yeast phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) and its individual domains was studied. Refolding was initiated from the guanidine-unfolded state by stopped-flow or manual mixing and monitored by tryptophan fluorescence from 1 msec to 1000 sec. Denaturant titrations of both individual domains showed apparent two-state unfolding transitions. Refolding kinetics of the individual domains from different denaturant concentrations, however, revealed the presence of intermediate structures during titration for both domains. Refolding of the same domains within the complete protein showed that domain-domain interactions direct the folding of both domains, but in an asymmetric way. Folding of the N domain was already altered within 1 msec, while detectable changes in the folding of the C domain occurred only 60-100 msec after initiating refolding. All mutants showed a hyperfluorescent kinetic intermediate. Both the disappearance of this intermediate and the completion of the folding were significantly faster in the individual N domain than in the complete protein. On the contrary, folding of the individual C domain was slower than in the complete protein. The presence of the C domain directs the refolding of the N domain along a completely different pathway than that of the individual N domain, while folding of the individual C domain follows the same path as within the complete protein.     

Relationship between kinetic and equilibrium folding intermediates of creatine kinase

Creatine kinase (CK) is a dimeric enzyme important in ATP regeneration in cells where energy demands are high. The folding of CK under equilibrium and transient conditions has been studied in detail and is found to be complex. At equilibrium in 0.8 M GuHCl, 90% of CK molecules are in the form of a partially structured, monomeric intermediate. We exploit this property to measure kinetics of refolding and unfolding to and from this equilibrium intermediate (EI), using far-UV circular dichroism and intrinsic fluorescence as structural probes. We are thus able to compare the properties of EI and the kinetic intermediate formed during the burst phase in refolding. Native CK and EI unfold with rate constants in seconds and milliseconds, respectively. As is observed for refolding of fully-denatured CK, refolding from EI to the native state shows a burst phase followed by two exponential phases. The burst phase refolding intermediate is inferred to have more structure and greater stability than the equilibrium intermediate. When refolding from the fully-denatured state in 0.8 M GuHCl, the equilibrium intermediate is formed within the dead-time of mixing in the stopped-flow apparatus. The equilibrium intermediate may thus represent a kinetic intermediate formed early during folding.     

Conversion of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase into amyloid-like structure

Yeast phosphoglycerate kinase is a structurally well-characterized enzyme consisting of 415 amino acids without disulfide bonds. Anion-induced refolding from its acid-unfolded state gives rise to the formation of worm-like amyloid fibrils with a persistence length of 73 nm. Electron microscopy and small-angle X-ray scattering data indicate that the fibrils have an elliptical cross-section with dimensions of 10.2 nm x 5.1 nm. About half of all amino acids are organized in form of cross-beta structure which gives rise to typical infrared spectra, X-ray diffraction and yellow-green birefringence after Congo red staining. The kinetics of amyloid formation, monitored by infrared spectroscopy, dynamic light scattering and X-ray scattering, was found to be strongly dependent on protein concentration. The infrared data indicate that the formation of cross-beta structure practically comes to an end already after some hours, whereas the length-growth of the amyloid fibrils, monitored by small-angle X-ray scattering, was not yet completed after 1,300 hours.     

Kinetic studies of the unfolding-refolding of horse muscle phosphoglycerate kinase induced by guanidine hydrochloride

The kinetics of the unfolding and refolding of horse muscle phosphoglycerate kinase were studied with three different signals: fluorescence emission intensity at 336 nm (excitation at 292 nm), ellipticity at 220 nm, and enzyme activity. The results corroborate the conclusion on the existence of intermediates in the folding pathway obtained from equilibrium studies. Kinetic studies showed at least two phases of refolding, as revealed by fluorescence as well as by circular dichroism measurements. During the fast phase, an intermediate was formed with a fluorescence intensity higher than that of the native protein, but devoid of enzyme activity. The fluorescence emission spectrum of this intermediate was determined. Only the slow phase was detected for the unfolding process; it was not attributable to proline isomerization. Several models were assumed, and simulated kinetics derived from these models were compared with the experimental results. A plausible one accounting for most of the data is proposed.     

Proline can have opposite effects on fast and slow protein folding phases

Proline isomerization is well known to cause additional slow phases during protein refolding. We address a new question: does the presence of prolines significantly affect the very fast kinetics that lead to the formation of folding intermediates? We examined both the very slow (10-100 min) and very fast (4 micro s-2.5 ms) folding kinetics of the two-domain enzyme yeast phosphoglycerate kinase by temperature-jump relaxation. Phosphoglycerate kinase contains a conserved cis-proline in position 204, in addition to several trans-prolines. Native cis-prolines have the largest effect on folding kinetics because the unfolded state favors trans isomerization, so we compared the kinetics of a P204H mutant with the wild-type as a proof of principle. The presence of Pro-204 causes an additional slow phase upon refolding from the cold denatured state, as reported in the literature. Contrary to this, the fast folding events are sped up in the presence of the cis-proline, probably by restriction of the conformational space accessible to the molecule. The wild-type and Pro204His mutant would be excellent models for off-lattice simulations probing the effects of conformational restriction on short timescales.     

Folding of ribonuclease T1. 2. Kinetic models for the folding and unfolding reactions

The slow refolding of ribonuclease T1 was investigated by different probes. Structural intermediates with secondary structure are formed early during refolding, as indicated by the rapid regain of a native-like circular dichroism spectrum in the amide region. This extensive structure formation is much faster than the slow steps of refolding, which are limited in rate by the reisomerization of incorrect proline isomers. The transient folding intermediates were also detected by unfolding assays, which make use of the reduced stability of folding intermediates relative to that of the native protein. The results of this and the preceding paper [Kiefhaber et al. (1990) Biochemistry (preceding paper in this issue)] were used to propose kinetic models for the unfolding and refolding of ribonuclease T1. The unfolding mechanism is based on the assumption that, after the structural unfolding step, the slow isomerizations of two X-Pro peptide bonds occur independently of each other in the denatured protein. At equilibrium a small amount of fast-folding species coexists with three slow-folding species: two with one incorrect proline isomer each and another, dominant species with both these prolines in the incorrect isomeric state. In the mechanism for refolding we assume that all slow-folding molecules can rapidly regain most of the secondary and part of the tertiary structure early in folding. Reisomerizations of incorrect proline peptide bonds constitute the slow, rate-limiting steps of refolding. A peculiar feature of the kinetic model for refolding is that the major unfolded species with two incorrect proline isomers can enter two alternative folding pathways, depending on which of the two reisomerizes first. The relative rates of reisomerization of the respective proline peptide bonds at the stage of the rapidly formed intermediate determine the choice of pathway. It is changed in the presence of prolyl isomerase, because this enzyme catalyzes these two isomerizations with different efficiency and consequently leads to a shift from the very slow to the intermediate refolding pathway.     

The interaction of the GroEL chaperone with early kinetic intermediates of renaturing proteins inhibits the formation of their native structure

The main function of the chaperone GroEL is to prevent nonspecific association of nonnative protein chains and provide their correct folding. In the present work, the renaturation kinetics of three globular proteins (human alpha-lactalbumin, bovine carbonic anhydrase, and yeast phosphoglycerate kinase) in the presence of different molar excess of GroEL (up to 10-fold) was studied. It was shown that the formation of the native structure during the refolding of these proteins is retarded with an increase in GroEL molar excess due to the interaction of kinetic protein intermediates with the chaperone. Mg(2+)-ATP and Mg(2+)-ADP weaken this interaction and decrease the retarding effect of GroEL on the protein refolding kinetics. The theoretical modeling of protein folding in the presence of GroEL showed that the experimentally observed linear increase in the protein refolding half-time with increasing molar excess of GroEL must occur only when the protein adopts its native structure outside of GroEL (i.e. in the free state), while the refolding of the protein in the complex with GroEL is inhibited. The dissociation constants of GroEL complexed with the kinetic intermediates of the proteins studied were evaluated, and a simple mechanism of the functioning of GroEL as a molecular chaperone was proposed.     

Cooperativity of a protein folding reaction probed at multiple chain positions by real-time 2D NMR spectroscopy

The refolding reaction of S54G/P55N ribonuclease T1 is a two-step process, where fast formation of a partly folded intermediate is followed by the slow reaction to the native state, limited by a trans --> cis isomerization of Pro39. The hydrodynamic radius of this kinetic folding intermediate was determined by real-time diffusion NMR spectroscopy. Its folding to the native state was monitored by a series of 128 very fast 2D (15)N-HMQC spectra, to observe the kinetics of 66 individual backbone amide probes. We find that the intermediate is as compact as the native protein with many native chemical shifts. All 66 analyzed amide probes follow the rate-limiting prolyl isomerization, which indicates that this cooperative refolding reaction is fully synchronized. The stability of the folding intermediate was determined from the protection factors of 45 amide protons derived from a competition between refolding and H/D exchange. The intermediate has already gained 40% of the Gibbs free energy of refolding with many protected amides in not-yet-native regions.     

Monitoring of unfolding and refolding in fungal phytase (phyA) by dynamic light scattering

Role of disulfide bridges in phytase's unfolding-refolding was probed using dynamic light scattering. Phytase was unfolded by guanidinium chloride and then refolded by removing the denaturant by dialysis. Thiol reagents prevented refolding; thus, disulfide bridge formation is an integral step in phytase folding. Catalytic demise of phytase after unfolding and refolding in presence of Tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine (TCEP) indicates that disulfide bridges are necessary for refolding. The hydrodynamic radius (rh) of active and unfolded phytase is 4 and 14 nm, respectively. Removal of denaturant through dialysis refolds phytase; its rh shifts back to 4 nm. When TCEP remains in the refolding media, the rh remains high. The unfolded phytase when diluted in assay medium refolds as a function of time at 25 and 37 degrees C, but not at higher temperature. Monitoring rh under denaturing and renaturing condition gives an accurate measure of the folding status of phytase.     

Structure of a rapidly formed intermediate in ribonuclease T1 folding.

Kinetic intermediates in protein folding are short-lived and therefore difficult to detect and to characterize. In the folding of polypeptide chains with incorrect isomers of Xaa-Pro peptide bonds the final rate-limiting transition to the native state is slow, since it is coupled to prolyl isomerization. Incorrect prolyl isomers thus act as effective traps for folding intermediates and allow their properties to be studied more easily. We employed this strategy to investigate the mechanism of slow folding of ribonuclease T1. In our experiments we use a mutant form of this protein with a single cis peptide bond at proline 39. During refolding, protein chains with an incorrect trans proline 39 can rapidly form extensive secondary structure. The CD signal in the amide region is regained within the dead-time of stopped-flow mixing (15 ms), indicating a fast formation of the single alpha-helix of ribonuclease T1. This step is correlated with partial formation of a hydrophobic core, because the fluorescence emission maximum of tryptophan 59 is shifted from 349 nm to 325 nm within less than a second. After about 20 s of refolding an intermediate is present that shows about 40% enzymatic activity compared to the completely refolded protein. In addition, the solvent accessibility of tryptophan 59 is drastically reduced in this intermediate and comparable to that of the native state as determined by acrylamide quenching of the tryptophan fluorescence. Activity and quenching measurements have long dead-times and therefore we do not know whether enzymatic activity and solvent accessibility also change in the time range of milliseconds. At this stage of folding at least part of the beta-sheet structure is already present, since it hosts the active site of the enzyme. The trans to cis isomerization of the tyrosine 38-proline 39 peptide bond in the intermediate and consequently the formation of native protein is very slow (tau = 6,500 s at pH 5.0 and 10 degrees C). It is accompanied by an additional increase in tryptophan fluorescence, by the development of the fine structure of the tryptophan emission spectrum, and by the regain of the full enzymatic activity. This indicates that the packing of the hydrophobic core, which involves both tryptophan 59 and proline 39, is optimized in this step. Apparently, refolding polypeptide chains with an incorrect prolyl isomer can very rapidly form partially folded intermediates with native-like properties.     

GroE facilitates refolding of citrate synthase by suppressing aggregation.

The molecular chaperone GroE facilitates correct protein folding in vivo and in vitro. The mode of action of GroE was investigated by using refolding of citrate synthase as a model system. In vitro denaturation of this dimeric protein is almost irreversible, since the refolding polypeptide chains aggregate rapidly, as shown directly by a strong, concentration-dependent increase in light scattering. The yields of reactivated citrate synthase were strongly increased upon addition of GroE and MgATP. GroE inhibits aggregation reactions that compete with correct protein folding, as indicated by specific suppression of light scattering. GroEL rapidly forms a complex with unfolded or partially folded citrate synthase molecules. In this complex the refolding protein is protected from aggregation. Addition of GroES and ATP hydrolysis is required to release the polypeptide chain bound to GroEL and to allow further folding to its final, active state.     

Folding of ribonuclease T1. 1. Existence of multiple unfolded states created by proline isomerization

It is our aim to elucidate molecular aspects of the mechanism of protein folding. We use ribonuclease T1 as a model protein, because it is a small single-domain protein with a well-defined secondary and tertiary structure, which is stable in the presence and absence of disulfide bonds. Also, an efficient mutagenesis system is available to produce protein molecules with defined sequence variations. Here we present a preliminary characterization of the folding kinetics of ribonuclease T1. Its unfolding and refolding reactions are reversible, which is shown by the quantitative recovery of the catalytic activity after an unfolding/refolding cycle. Refolding is a complex process, where native protein is formed on three distinguishable pathways. There are 3.5% fast-folding molecules, which refold within the millisecond time range, and 96.5% slow-folding species, which regain the native state in the time range of minutes to hours. These slow-folding molecules give rise to two major, parallel refolding reactions. The mixture of fast- and slow-folding molecules is produced slowly after unfolding by chain equilibration reactions that show properties of proline isomerization. We conclude that part of the kinetic complexity of RNase T1 folding can be explained on the basis of the proline model for protein folding. This is supported by the finding that the slow refolding reactions of this protein are accelerated in the presence of the enzyme prolyl isomerase. However, several properties of ribonuclease T1 refolding, such as the dependence of the relative amplitudes on the probes, used to follow folding, are not readily explained by a simple proline model.     

Chain collapse can occur concomitantly with the rate-limiting step in protein folding.

We have directly characterized the extent of chain collapse early in the folding of protein L using time-resolved small angle X-ray scattering. We find that, immediately after the initiation of refolding, the protein exhibits dimensions indistinguishable from those observed under highly denaturing, equilibrium conditions and that this expanded initial state collapses with the same rate as that of the overall folding reaction. The observation that chain compaction need not significantly precede the rate-limiting step of folding demonstrates that rapid chain collapse is not an obligatory feature of protein folding reactions.     

Evidence of an associative intermediate on the myoglobin refolding pathway.

Time-resolved small-angle x-ray scattering using the stopped-flow method has been applied successfully to investigate the refolding of myoglobin. This is the only method to date that yields direct information on protein physical dimensions during the folding process. It has the potential to detect and probe important processes, such as protein compaction and association, on a millisecond time scale. Initial experiments were performed with horse myoglobin denatured in high concentrations of urea. The denatured protein was diluted rapidly into a buffer containing no urea or low concentrations of urea. The time-course of the forward-scattered intensity shows a decrease in amplitude which is clearly not engendered by the compaction of the protein, but does correspond well to a dimer dissociation process. Initial and final radii of gyration correspond well to a dimer and a monomer, respectively. Kratky plots of the initial and final states also support the transient dimerization model. The apparent dissociation rate constant was obtainable directly from the data. An association rate constant and an equilibrium constant could be estimated. The dimerizing intermediate is speculated to be a globular non-native state with an exposed hydrophobic surface.