Sliding-pin shapes and lubricant thickness change on a thin-film magnetic disk

In developing hard disk drives, it is necessary to keep lubricant as thick as possible during operations. For this purpose, we studied lubricant loss under different-shape contact-sliders on thin-film magnetic disks by using transparent-pin sliding tests with a built-in ellipsometer. We compared sliding pins with spherical, flat circle, flat square, and double-flat-rail surfaces.We found that lubricant loss was smaller under flat pins than under the spherical pin, and the smallest under the double-flat-rail pin among flat sliders. The results show that the horizontal and vertical shapes of sliders must carefully be selected for contact recording systems.     

Functional Collapse of Designed Surface Texture for Stiction Prevention in Storage Disk Drives

Laser texture is widely used to prevent stiction in the head disk interface. The stiction protection depends on the effective height of the laser texture. The balance between the meniscus and mechanical deformation forces is described when lubricant migrates into the head disk interface. When the elastic deformation forces cannot balance the meniscus force, the laser texture bumps collapse and the protection against stiction is lost. A critical bump height is defined. Bump collapse is experimentally demonstrated by monitoring the capacitance between head and disk when lubricant migrates from the trailing edge of a slider into the head disk interface. An interface with high bumps shows a small capacitance increase since the mechanical deformation forces can balance the meniscus forces with only small bump compression. Consistent with a calculated capacitance increase under bump collapse, an interface with low bumps shows a large capacitance increase.     

Autophobic Dewetting of Perfluoropolyether Films on Amorphous-Nitrogenated Carbon Surfaces

The dewetting of perfluoropolyether (PFPE) films on amorphous nitrogenated carbon, CNx, is investigated. An optical surface analyzer is used to image perfluoropolyether films on CNx-overcoated magnetic recording disks. An autophobic dewetting transition is observed to result when the PFPE film thickness applied to the disk surface exceeds a critical value. This critical dewetting thickness is linearly dependent on the PFPE molecular weight. Addition of the phosphazine, X-1P, to the PFPE film reduces the critical dewetting thickness compared to that of the neat lubricant. Dewetting in these molecularly-thin PFPE lubricant films is shown to occur at thicknesses where the total disjoining pressure is negative. The impact of this autophobic dewetting on the performance of a head--disk interface is inferred from take-off height measurements conducted as a function of PFPE film thickness. A steep reduction in the slider--disk clearance is observed when the PFPE film is present at thicknesses in excess of the critical dewetting thickness.     

Additive Mechanism Investigation of Perfluoropolyether Lubricants with a Phosphazene Additive

The tribological characteristics of magnetic thin film media coated with perfluoropolyether (PFPE) lubricants (ZDOL and AM300J) and a phosphazene additive (X-IP) were investigated in this study. The drag test results show that under ambient and hot/wet conditions the media coated with AM300J lubricant have higher retention on the test track than those coated with ZDOL 2000 PFPE lubricant. The phosphazene additive X-IP was observed to strongly anchored to the surface and was not as easily removed as PFPE lubricants alone. The retention characteristics of X-IP are independent of either AM or ZDOL. Secondary Ion Mass Spectroscopy (SIMS) depth profile data and Angle-Resolved X-Ray Photo-electron Spectroscopy (XPS) reveal that X-IP molecules were distributed near the disk surface in the X-IP and PFPE lubricants mixed layer, indicating a strong bonding/adhesion of X-IP to the disk surface. Together with the drag testing data, the authors conclude that the preferential distribution of X-IP close to the disk surface in the mixed layer helps to improve lubricant retention performance at the head-disk interface.     

Direct observation of PFPE lubricant molecules by cryogenic AFM under ultra-high vacuum

Surface lubrication is one of the essential technologies in modern magnetic disk systems and improvement of the surface lubrication is very important in the development of next generation systems. In this study, we used AFM for the direct observation of perfluoropolyether (PFPE) lubricant molecules on atomically flat surfaces. We used a cryogenic non-contact AFM to observe the molecules in a frozen state of micro-Brownian motion of PFPE segments, because the glass transition temperature of PFPE is very low. To avoid freezing a trace amount of water vapor on the sample surface at liquid nitrogen temperatures, the AFM observation was performed under ultra-high vacuum. We observed that on a gold surface the size of the molecules increases with repeated AFM scans. This is because the mechanical stimulus causes the fusion of PFPE lubricant molecules to form reversed micelles at the non-polar surface. At a hydrophilic silicon wafer surface, however, we succeeded in observing single lubricant molecules. This is because almost all PFPE lubricant molecules are fixed to the hydrophilic solid surface by polar–polar bond formation and they cannot move around on the surface and thus they cannot fuse to each other. As formation of the reversed micelle structure is a rather general phenomenon in the PFPE lubricant thin layer at non-polar surfaces, we also will discuss briefly the expected molecular structures of PFPE lubricants at the surface of the carbon overcoat of magnetic disks.     

Wear durability studies of ultra-thin perfluoropolyether lubricant on magnetic hard disks

This paper presents wear and friction studies on ultra-thin (~2 nm) film of perfluoropolyether (PFPE) coated on glass substrate magnetic hard disks. The lubricant was coated on the disk by the dip-coating method and the tribological tests were carried out by sliding a 3 mm diameter glass ball slider (normal load=20 mN) on the rotating disk surface. Lube thickness and lube wear profile were measured using an ellipsometer whereas the worn disk surface was studied using a surface reflectivity analyzer. The sliding speed and the lube bonding conditions were varied during the test. From the results, it is concluded that about 80% bonding of the lube to the disk surface leads to an increase in the wear durability of the lubricant by a factor of 2 when compared to the as-lubed condition. Lube bonding has an effect on increasing the coefficient of friction. Initially, increasing sliding speed increases both friction and wear but for very high sliding speed these values tend to decrease. The glass ball surface showed wear due to asperity interactions as well as lube transfer from the disk to the glass surface.     

Study on the cyclotriphosphazene film on magnetic head surface

Stable lubrication is very important to the slider/disk interface with the increasing demand on the life of computer hard disk drive (HDD). The inert lubricant perfluoropolyether (PFPE) on the surface of magnetic hard disk is still prone to be catalyzed to decomposition by the slider material Al₂O₃. The properties of a partial fluorinated hexaphenoxy cyclotriphosphazene, X-1P, are investigated and its function to reduce the catalytic decomposition of PFPE is discussed. The results of contact start–stop (CSS) tester indicate that the thermal stability of the lubricant was greatly improved in the presence of X-1P, and its film thickness has a great influence on the lubrication properties of the HDD.     

Experimental and analytical studies of dynamic friction at the head/disk interface

Friction is an important parameter that critically impacts the tribological performance of a head/disk interface. The head/disk interface with laser zone texture affords a model system for the study of dynamic friction by virtue of its precisely-controlled contact geometry. By using two types of head sliders, i.e. the conventional slider and the padded slider, and a matrix of hard disks with a wide range of laser zone texture parameters, head/disk contacts involving a small number as well as a large number of bumps are realized. A rich variety of dynamic friction behaviors are observed with respect to bump height and bump density variations. To shed new light on the nature of HDI dynamic friction, an analytical model that treats both the deformational and the adhesive friction components on equal footings is formulated. It is shown that, based on the model analysis, the friction is deformation-dominated for HDIs involving a small number of contacting bumps and adhesion-dominated for HDIs involving a large number of contacting bumps. In the former case the friction decreases with bump density, whereas in the latter the friction increases with bump density.     

Tribological evaluation and analysis of the head/disk interface with perfluoropolyether and X1-P phosphazene mixed lubricants

The retention characteristics of magnetic thin film media coated with perfluoropolyether (PFPE) lubricants and a phosphazene additive, X-1P, were investigated in this study. The retention performance was evaluated by a drag test with a waffle head sliding against the disk that was designed to mechanically wear out the lubricant layer. An IR beam was aligned on the test track to directly measure the amount of PFPE lubricants and X-1P left on the media surfaces for determining the retention characteristics of the lubricants. The drag test results show that under ambient and hot/wet conditions the media coated with AM3001 PFPE lubricant have higher retention ratio on the test track than those coated with ZDOL 2000 PFPE lubricant. The phosphazene additive X-1P was observed to strongly anchor on the surface and not easily removed as PFPE lubricants (ZDOL and AM3001). The retention characteristics of X-1P are independent of lube combination, either AM or ZDOL lubricants. It is demonstrated that X1-P exhibits a good antiwear property and excellent retention performance. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Velocity-Dependent Adhesion with Lubricants on Thin-Film Disks

The well-known problem of stiction in a magnetic disk drive largely depends on the forces induced by the presence of a thin liquid film. It is commonly recognized that both adhesive and viscous effects contribute to the magnitude of the stiction force, but is is not known what relative roles the two effects have in a lubricated contact. In the present work, the nature of adhesive and viscous effects is investigated for the slider/disk interface under conditions of constant-speed sliding.

Friction measurements are conducted over a range of sliding speeds, 0.25-250 mm/s, with eight perfluoropolyether (PFPE) lubricants applied in various thicknesses, 0-6.6 nm, to carbon-coated magnetic thin-film disks. The lubricants were selected to cover a broad range of viscosities. For several sliding speeds and lubricant film thicknesses, the friction force is found to decrease significantly with increasing sliding speed for all lubricants. In several instances, large friction forces are observed at the lowest sliding speeds, indicating stiction-like behavior, whereas, at higher speeds, the friction is reduced to even below unlubricated friction levels. At the highest film thickness and sliding speed, the friction was found to increase with speed for some lubricants. The implications of these results on current models of lubricant-mediated adhesion are discussed.     

Contributions of Mobile and Bonded Molecules to Dynamic Friction of Nanometer-Thick Perfluoropolyether Films Coated on Magnetic Disk Surfaces

To protect the interface against intermittent head–disk contact in hard disk drives, nanometer-thick perfluoropolyether (PFPE) films consisting of both “bonded” and “mobile” molecules are applied on the disk surfaces. Because of their different adsorption states and mobility, the bonded and mobile molecules are supposed to contribute differently to friction properties, which directly impact the stability of ultra-low flying head–disk interfaces. By measuring the friction force at light loads and low to high speeds as a function of bonded and mobile film thicknesses, we studied the contributions of bonded and mobile molecules to the dynamic friction of nanometer-thick PFPE films. We found that the friction coefficient of lubricant films without or with less bonded molecules increased as a power function of sliding speed, whereas that of lubricant films with more bonded molecules increased logarithmically with sliding speed. We suggest that these results can be explained by the following mechanisms: the dynamic friction of lubricant films without and with less bonded molecules is dominated by shear thinning behavior of mobile molecules, while that of lubricant films with more bonded molecules is governed by bonded molecules which lead to boundary lubrication.     

The Effect of Phosphazene additives to passivate and stabilize lubricants at the head/disk interface

There have been a number of applications for lubricant additives in the disk drive media area, the first of which was for pseudo-contact recording with inductive heads (tri-pad sliders) in an effort to stabilize the head/disk interface and minimize lube decomposition under hot/wet conditions. A number of additives have been tried which include antioxidants as well as Lewis bases, the latter in an effort to passivate the catalytic activity of the Lewis Acid sites on the slider which results in the decomposition of the perfluoropolyether (PFPE) lubricants such as Z-Dol, AM and Z-Tetraol. In addition to this passivation action of the phosphazene toward catalytic decomposition of the lubricant, it has recently been reported that the use of X-1P (a cyclic phosphazene) also enhances reflow of the lube, increasing the durability of the head disk interface. In this regard there are still a number of unanswered questions that pertain to the mechanism of the interaction of the X-1P with the lubricant and/or carbon to cause this increase in mobility of the lubricant resulting in the enhanced durability.There are numerous technical issues associated with the use of the various additives with the main one being compatibility between the additive and the PFPEs as well as the carbon surfaces on which they are coated. These issues include bonding, phase separation of the components, and the transfer mechanism for the additive to the slider where the passivation is required.In this paper, we will look at the interaction of the X-1P with the carbon overcoat on the media in an effort to try to better understand the mechanism of such an interaction and its effect on the mobility of the lubricant as well as the amount of bonded lube on the disks.     

Behavior of ultrathin liquid lubricant films for contact sliders in hard disk drives

In this paper, we describe the behavior of ultrathin liquid lubricant films for contact sliders in hard disk drives. In the experiments, the ultrathin liquid lubricant film behavior is investigated using Zdol and cyclotriphosphazene-terminated PFPE lubricant which have different end groups as a function of lubricant film thickness. The disks are examined with a scanning microellipsometer before and after contact slider experiments. It is found that the lubricant film thickness profiles almost do not change, when the lubricant film thickness is less than one monolayer. It can also be observed that lubricant film thickness instability due to dewetting occurs as a result of slider-disk contacts for the tested lubricants and the films undergo spontaneous redistributions, resulting in significantly nonuniform film thickness profiles, when the lubricant film thickness is thicker than one monolayer. In addition, it is found that the observed behavior of ultrathin liquid lubricant films for cyclotriphosphazine-terminated PFPE lubricant contrasts markedly with that for Zdol. The difference between cyclotriphosphazene-terminated PFPE lubricant and Zdol is only the functional end group. Therefore, it may be concluded that their unstable lubricant behavior depends on the chemical structure of functional end groups.     

Effects of diffusion on lubricant distribution under flying headon thin-film disks

Lubricants on thin-film disks have large effects on head–disk interface characteristics. They reduce head and disk wear while thick lubricant film increases friction force between them and lubricant transfer onto head surfaces. Therefore, we have to know the lubricant behavior in many cases. Lubricant depletion due to disk rotation has been studied very well. However, the effects of flying heads have not been understood systematically until now. We developed a simulation program to numerically calculate the change in lubricant thickness under a flying head on a thin-film magnetic disk. The program included the effects of centrifugal force, shear stress from the air due to disk rotation with a flying head, and the effect of lubricant diffusion. We first calculated a change in lubricant thickness under a flying head using previously published data without the effect of diffusion. Calculated results showed fairly good agreement with the published experimental data with very high peaks on both sides of the flying head rails. With the introduction of diffusion effects, these peaks became moderate and the calculated result agreed very well with the experimental data. The coefficient of diffusion obtained to best fit to the experimental data was close to that reported in a literature. We analyzed the effects of air shear stress patterns under flying head on the change in lubricant distribution. We found that the side shapes had large effect on the distribution. We also confirmed that our program could calculate lubricant depletion on rotating disks without a flying head.     

Reversed Micelle Structures in PFPE Lubricant Thin Films on Magnetic Disk Surface Observed by Non-Contact AFM

PFPE lubricants (Fomblin Z-dol) for hard disk surface lubrication have two hydroxyl groups, one at each end of the molecules, and form stable insoluble monolayers at the water surface. In this study, molecular weight-fractionated PFPE lubricant monolayers were transferred from the water surface to solid substrates such as a hydrophilized silicon wafer, gold-sputtered mica, and a hard disk after adjusting the two-dimensional density of the lubricant molecules. The molecular structures of the PFPE lubricant molecules at the solid surfaces were observed by the cryogenic non-contact AFM under ultra-high vacuum. At the hydrophilic silicon wafer surface we could observe a single lubricant molecule in a random coil sphere shape. However, at the non-polar gold surface we confirmed the formation of reversed micelle structures. At the hard disk surface we detected various sizes of reversed micelles of PFPE lubricant in a flat oval shape.     

The effects of texture height and thickness of amorphous carbon nitride coating of a hard disk slider on the friction and wear of the slider against a disk

In order to minimize the stiction force caused by contact of the extremely smooth surfaces of head sliders and disks in hard disk drives, texture is usually applied on the disk surface. For future contact/near-contact recording, the stiction-induced high friction between slider and disk will become a problem. Texture on the slider/disk interface will still be an expected method to reduce friction. Recently, it was suggested to texture the slider surface. A protective coating is usually required on the textured slider surface to reduce wear of the texture. The results showed that texture on the slider surface was effective in reducing the friction between head sliders and disks. On the other hand, the texture and coating on the slider surface increase the spacing between the read/write element and the magnetic layer of the disk. The necessary and effective texture height and coating thickness are still not clear. In the present research, island-type textures with different heights (3–18 mn) were formed on slider surfaces by ion-beam etching. Amorphous carbon nitride (a-CN_x) coatings of different thicknesses (0–50 nm) were coated on the textured slider surfaces as a protective overcoat. The friction and wear properties of these sliders were evaluated by constant-speed drag tests against hard disks coated with diamond-like carbon (DLC). The results show that 2 nm texture on a slider surface is sufficient for low (0.3–0.5) and stable friction of the slider against the disk in a drag test, and coatings thicker than 5 nm show similar wear resistances of the texture on slider surfaces.     

Formation of Lubricant “Sierra” at Boundary Between Perfluoropolyether Solution Dipped and Undipped Zones over Diamond Like Carbon Coated Magnetic Disks

An unstable phenomenon arising at the boundary between perfluoropolyether (PFPE) solution dipped and undipped zones over diamond like carbon (DLC) coated magnetic disks was studied. The formation conditions of a ridge of lubricant, or “sierra,” at this boundary and the structure of the “sierra” were clarified. It was found that the “sierra” structure of the lubricant suddenly formed when withdrawing the disk from the lubricant solution was decreased to less than a specified value of around 1 mm/s. The “sierra” was less likely to form for a lower lubricant concentration and a longer elapsed time after making the lubricant solution. It was also revealed that, along the ridgeline of the “sierra,” peaks formed periodically and the peak feet propagated in the direction perpendicular to the boundary, forming convex fronts and leaving multiplex bead chains of lubricant accumulations inside the convex.     

Self-assembled monolayer on diamond-like carbon surface: formation and friction measurements

We have investigated self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of heptadecafluoro-1,1,2,2-tetradecyltrietoxysilane (FTE) on diamond-like carbon (DLC) surfaces formed by a simple immersing process. SAM formation on DLC surfaces was verified by contact angle measurements, ellipsometry and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). Water and hexadecane contact angles increased gradually with immersing time and saturated at about 110 and 70 degrees, respectively. Ellipsometric measurements showed that the film thickness was 1.4 to 1.6 nm, which corresponded reasonably to the thickness of FTE monolayer. XPS data showed the presence of FTE molecules on the DLC surface. These results ensured the SAM formation of FTE molecules on the DLC surface.We further measured and compared the friction of unlubricated, SAM coated and 2 nm thick perfluoropolyether (PFPE) coated DLC surfaces using lateral force microscopy (LFM) as functions of the applied load and the sliding velocity. The SAM coated DLC surfaces showed lower friction than the unlubricated DLC surfaces and the friction coefficient decreased by about 15% compared to the unlubricated DLC surfaces. Scratch tests revealed that the critical load of the DLC film increased due to the SAM deposition. These results are attributed to the hydrophobic nature of the SAM coated surface. On the other hand, even though the water contact angle of the SAM coated surface was larger than the 2 nm thick PFPE coated surface, the friction of the SAM coated surface was larger than that of the PFPE coated surface. Also, the critical load of the SAM coated DLC surface in scratch test was lower than the PFPE coated surface. These results indicate that the hydrophobic nature of the surface is not the only factor which determines the friction characteristics in the nano-lubricating system, and it is attributed to the mobile characteristic of PFPE lubricant.     

Grafting Lubricant Molecular Chains to the Carbon Overcoat

It was conceived and demonstrated that irradiation of magnetic disks coated with PFPE (perfluoropolyether) lubricants terminated with a carboxylic group at one terminus with long-UV (254 nm) would lead to grafting, via a bona fide C–C chemical bond, of genuine PFPE molecular chains to the carbon overcoat all at one terminus with all the remaining chain segments being free to sway. The water contact angle of disks coated with PFPE lubricants terminated with end-groups having hydroxyl unit(s) (e.g., Z-dol and Z-tetraol) decreases gradually, after the initial contact of the droplet, reaching an asymptote in 20–30 s. The gradual temporal change is accounted for by shifting of the equilibrium disposition of hydroxyl units of the lubricant molecules from that determined by the interaction with the surface of the carbon overcoat to that determined by the interaction with surfaces of both the carbon overcoat and the liquid droplet. The water contact angle of disks prepared by the presently conceived photo-grafting method is high (>110 degrees) and shows no temporal change. In a preliminary spin-stand drag test, disks with PFPE chains photo-grafted by this method and also the heads (for the read/write process) with similar photo-grafted PFPE chains exhibited extraordinary durability.     

Thickness Change in Molecularly Thin Lubricant Under Flying Head in Hard Disk Drives

In hard disk drives (HDDs), lubricants on disks are very important material to reduce head and disk wear. Thus, it is necessary to know changes in lubricant thickness to keep lubricant thickness constant on rotating disks. For this purpose, we have to know changes in lubricant thickness during HDD operations. We developed a simulation program to simulate changes in lubricant thickness during HDD operations numerically. First, we had simulated the changes in lubricant thickness of 10-nm-thick non-polar lubricant film under a flying head. The result corresponded to a reported experimental result. In recent HDDs, a lubricant thickness has become molecularly thin and lubricants with polar end groups have been used. In molecularly thin polar lubricants, diffusion depends on their thickness and their viscosity becomes very high. Next, we simulated the change in the lubricant thickness of 2-nm-thick polar lubricant film considering the effects of lubricant initial thickness. The simulated results showed that the changes were very small in 2-nm-thick lubricant film, but they were not confirmed with the experiment. In this paper, experimental results of the change in the thickness of molecularly thin non-polar and polar lubricants under a flying head were first measured. The simulations that took account of thickness-dependent diffusion and thin-film viscosity were then performed with the simulation parameters based on the experiments. The simulated results of lubricant distribution were in good agreement with the experimental results.