Investigation on solid particle erosion behaviour of polyetherimide and its composites

The present investigation reports about, the solid particle erosion behaviour of randomly oriented short E-glass, carbon fibre and solid lubricants (PTFE, graphite, MoS₂) filled polyetherimide (PEI) composites. The erosion rates (ERs) of these composites have been evaluated at different impingement angles (15–90°) and impact velocities (30–88 m/s). Mechanical properties such as tensile strength (S), ultimate elongation to fracture (e), hardness (H_V), Izod impact strength (I) and shear strength (S_s) seems to be controlling the erosion rate of PEI and its composites. Polyetherimide and its glass, carbon fibre reinforced composites showed semi-ductile erosion behaviour with peak erosion rate at 60° impingement angle. However, glass fibre reinforced PEI composite filled with solid lubricants showed peak erosion rate at 60° impingement angle for impact velocities of 30 and 88 m/s, whereas for intermediate velocities (52 and 60 m/s) peak erosion rate observed at 30° impingement angle. It is observed that 20% (w/w) glass fibre reinforcement helps in improving erosive wear resistance of neat PEI matrix. Erosion efficiency (η) values (0.23–8.2%) indicate micro-ploughing and micro-cutting dominant wear mechanisms. The morphology of eroded surfaces was examined by using scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Possible erosion mechanisms are discussed.     

Solid particle erosion of unidirectional fibre reinforced thermoplastic composites

In the present study, the solid particle erosion behaviour of neat PEEK matrix and unidirectional glass fibre (GF) and carbon fibre (CF) reinforced polyetheretherketone (PEEK) and polyetherketoneketone (PEKK) composites has been studied. The erosion experiments have been carried out by using silica sand particles (200 ± 50 μm) as an erodent. Steady state erosion rates of these composites have been evaluated at different impact angles and impact velocities. The neat PEEK exhibited peak erosion rate at 30° impingement angle whereas the composites exhibited a semi-ductile behaviour with peak erosion rate at 60° impact angle. The erosion rate of the glass fibre reinforced composites was higher than that of the carbon fibre reinforced composites. The results show that the fibre orientation has a significant influence on erosion rate only at lower impact angles. The erosion rate of the composites was higher when the particles impact perpendicular to the fibre direction than parallel to the fibres. The morphology of eroded surfaces was observed under scanning electron microscope and damage mechanisms were discussed.     

Solid particle erosion behaviour of glass fibre reinforced boric acid filled epoxy resin composites

The tests which involved angular aluminium (Al₂O₃) particles with two different sizes of approximately 200 and 400 μm were conducted at the operating conditions namely different impact velocities of approximately 23, 34 and 53 m/s, two different fibre directions [0° (0/90) and 45° (45/−45)] and three different impingement angles of 30°, 60° and 90°. New composites with addition of Boric Acid filler material at 15% of resin exhibited upper wear than the neat materials without filler material. This means the filler material has decreased the erosion wear resistance. SEM views showing worn out surfaces of the test specimens were scrutinised.     

Solid particle erosion studies on polyphenylene sulfide composites and prediction on erosion data using artificial neural networks

Solid particle erosion behavior of polyphenylene sulfide, reinforced by short glass fibers with varying fiber content (0–40 wt%) has been studied. Steady-state erosion rates have been evaluated at different impact angles (15–90°) and impact velocities (25–66 m/s) using silica sand particles (200 ± 50 μm) as an erodent. PPS and its composites exhibited maximum erosion rate at 30° impact angle indicating ductile erosion behavior. Though PPS is a brittle thermoplastic, incubation period was found for neat resin and its composites at normal impact (α = 90°). The erosion rates of PPS composites increased with increasing amount of glass fiber. Morphology of eroded surfaces was examined using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and possible wear mechanisms were discussed. Also, artificial neural networks (ANNs) technique has been used to predict the erosion rate based on the experimentally measured database of PPS composites. The results show that the predicted data are well acceptable when comparing them to measured values. A well-trained ANN is expected to be very helpful for prediction of wear data for systematic parameter studies.     

Effect of carbide volume fraction on erosive wear behaviour of hardfacing cast irons

The present work reports the effect of carbide volume fraction on erosive wear behaviour of hardfacing cast irons. Five different grades of weld hardfacing cast irons were selected for the present investigation. The solid particle erosion experiments were carried out with blast furnace sinter, silica sand and alumina particles under mild (53–75 μm, 25 m s⁻¹), moderately severe (125–150 μm/100–150 μm, 50 m s⁻¹) and under severe erosion conditions (300–425 μm, 90 m s⁻¹) at impingement angles of 30 and 90°. The variation in erosion rate with carbide volume fraction was observed to be strong function of the erodent particle hardness, impingement angle and the impact velocity. Under mild erosion conditions, erosion rate decreased with increasing carbide volume fraction (CVF), whereas erosion rate increased with CVF under moderately severe erosion condition with alumina particles. With silica sand particles under moderately severe erosion conditions the beneficial effect of large volume fraction of carbides could only be observed at 30°, whereas at normal impact erosion rate increased with increasing CVF. The erosion rate showed power law relationship with ratio of hardness of erodent particle to that of the target material (H_e/H_t) and expressed as E=c(H_e/H_t)^p.With increasing severity of erosion conditions erosion rate showed stronger dependence on H_e/H_t as compared to those under mild and moderately severe erosion conditions. The mechanism of materials removal from the carbides involved Hertzian fracture with softer sinter particles, whereas harder alumina particles could plastically indent and cause gross fracture of the carbides.     

Impact of stacking sequence on tribological wear performance of woven jute-glass hybrid epoxy composites

Natural fibre-reinforced plastic (FRP) composites have gained much interest because of their environment friendliness and cost-effectiveness compared to synthetic fibre-reinforced composites. The availability of natural fibre and ease of manufacturing have tempted researchers worldwide to develop a locally available low-cost fibre and study their feasibility for reinforcement purposes and to what extent they can satisfy the required specifications of well-reinforced polymer composite for tribological application. FRP composites have various applications in the automobile, aerospace and marine fields. They are applied to inlet cone, fan exit guide vanes and other parts of structures in a turbofan engine for lightening an engine. The erosion characteristics of the FRP composites are of vital importance due to the operational requirements in dusty environments. In this present work, the impact of stacking sequence on erosion wear behaviour of untreated woven jute and glass fabric-reinforced epoxy hybrid composites has been investigated experimentally. The orientation of glass and jute fabric was kept at (0°–90°) and (45°–45°) for all stacking sequences. All the laminates were prepared using four plies, and, the number and position of glass layers were varied so as to obtain four different stacking sequences. The erosion rate of these composites were evaluated at different impingement angles (30°–90°) at three different impact velocities (V = 48, 70, 82 m/s). Silica sand was used as the erodent. Our results showed that the impingement angle had a significant influence on the erosion rate. The composite materials showed semi-ductile behaviour with the maximum erosion at an impingement angle of 60°. The morphologies of the eroded surface were observed by a scanning electron microscope, and the possible erosion mechanisms were discussed.     

Solid particle erosion of CFRP composite with different laminate orientations

The solid particle erosion behavior of epoxy base unidirectional and multidirectional carbon fiber reinforced plastic composites was investigated. The erosion rates of these composites were evaluated at various impingement angles (15–90°) with a particle velocity of 70 m/s. Irregular SiC particles with an average diameter of 80 μm was used. The dependence of impingement angle on the erosive wear resembled the conventional ductile behavior with maximum erosion rate at 15–30° impingement angle. The erosion rate of unidirectional composites at acute impingement angle was higher for [90] than for [45] and [0] while the difference disappeared at normal impingement angle (90°). On the other hand, the erosion rates of multidirectional laminated composites ([0/90], [45/−45], [90/30/−30] and [0/60/−60]) were not much influenced by the fiber orientation except for 15° impingement angle.     

Influence of fiber orientation on abrasive wear of unidirectionally reinforced carbon fiber–polyetherimide composites

A composite with continuous carbon fibers (CF) (80% by vol.) and high performance thermoplastic polyetherimide (PEI) matrix was developed and evaluated for various mechanical properties as a function of fiber orientation angle (0°, 30°, 45°, 60° and 90°). It was observed that Young's modulus, Poisson's ratio, toughness and % strain decreased with the increase of fiber orientation angle with respect to loading direction. In-plane shear modulus was highest for fibers with 45°. Overall, unidirectional (UD) CF reinforcement enhanced all strength properties of PEI significantly. Composites with fibers in 0° (parallel to loading direction) proved best in almost all the properties. Tribological evaluation in abrasive wear mode under different loads and fiber orientations indicated that coefficient of friction (μ) and specific wear rate (K₀) decreased with load, in general. Comparatively low specific wear rate (K₀), (in the order of 0.7 1×10^?9 m³/Nm) was observed for 0° fiber orientation, while fibers in 90° showed almost three times higher wear rate. Overall fiber reinforcement in 0° orientations proved beneficial from both strength and tribological performance point of view. SEM proved useful to correlate wear rate with surface topography.     

Effects of fibre content and relative fibre-orientation on the solid particle erosion of GF/PP composites

The erosive wear behaviour of glass fibre (GF) reinforced thermoplastic polypropylene (PP) composites was studied in a modified sandblasting apparatus as a function of the impact angle (30, 60 and 90°), relative fibre-orientation (parallel Pa and perpendicular Pe), fibre length (discontinuous, continuous) and fibre content (40–60 wt.%).The results showed a strong dependence of the erosive wear on the relative fibre-orientation at low impact angles (30°), but hardly any difference for 60 and 90° impact angles. In contrast, the fibre length did not affect the erosive wear behaviour especially at high impact angles.The inclusion of brittle GF led to higher erosive wear rates (ER) of the GF/PP composites; the higher the fibre content, the higher was the ER. Nevertheless, the composites still failed in a ductile manner. Different approaches proposed to describe the relationship between ER and fibre content were applied. Best results were generally delivered with the inverse rule of mixture. The modified rule of mixtures proposed for abrasive wear do not seem to apply for erosive wear.     

Tribological behaviors of hierarchical porous PEEK composites with mesoporous titanium oxide whisker

Hierarchical porous PEEK self-lubricating composites were prepared by mold-leaching and vacuum melting process under high temperature. The tribological behaviors were investigated for the porous PEEK composite and the porous composite after incorporating micro-porogen (NaCl) and mesoporous titanium oxide whiskers. If only micro-porogen was incorporated, the lowest steady state specific wear rate was observed for PEEK composites filled with 30% NaCl. Based on this porous PEEK composite, the effects of mesoporous titanium oxide whiskers and non-perforated titanium oxide whiskers on the friction and wear properties of PEEK composites were studied. Results showed that nano-micro porous PEEK composites with 30 wt% micro-porogen and 5 wt% mesoporous titanium oxide whiskers reached the lowest friction coefficient and specific wear rate, which were recorded as 0.0194 and 2.135×10^–16 m³/Nm under the load of 200 N. Compared with 15 wt% carbon fiber-reinforced PEEK composite which is widely used in industry, the wear resistance of the designed hierarchical porous PEEK composite increased by 41 times, showing outstanding wear resistance.     

Determination of particle impacts and impact energy in the erosion of X65 carbon steel using acoustic emission technique

An in-situ acoustic emission (AE) monitoring technique has been implemented in a submerged jet impingement (SIJ) system in an effort to investigate the effect of sand particle impact on the degradation mechanism of X65 carbon steel pipeline material in erosion conditions.A detailed analysis of the acoustic events' count rate enabled the number of impacts per second to be quantified for a range of flow velocities (7, 10, 15 m/s) and solid loadings (0, 50, 200, 500 mg/L) in a nitrogen-saturated solution at 50 °C. The number of impacts obtained from acoustic signals showed a strong agreement with theoretical prediction for flow velocities 7 and 10 m/s. A deviation between practical readings and theory is observed for flow velocity of 15 m/s which may be due to error from detected emissions of multiple rebounded particles.Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) was used in conjunction with particle tracking to model the impingement system and predict the velocity and impact angle distribution on the surface of the sample. Data was used to predict the kinetic energy of the impacts and was correlated with the measured AE energy and material loss from gravimetric analysis. The results demonstrate that AE is a useful technique for quantifying and predicting the erosion damage of X65 pipeline material in an erosion–corrosion environment.     

Microstructure and erosion resistance enhancement of nodular cast iron by laser melting

The surface of nodular graphite cast iron samples was melted by 50% overlapping passes from a 3 kW CW CO₂ laser. The objective was to modify the microstructure and improve the hardness and erosion resistance of the surface. The results showed that laser melting led to complete dissolution of the graphite nodules which on solidifying created an inter-dendritic network of ledeburite eutectic with a very fine structure, good homogeneity, and high hardness. Sand particle erosion experiments were carried out at impingement angles of 30°, 60°, and 90° using angular particles of size between 300 and 600 μm. The velocity of the sand particles was 50 m/s, which was controlled by the gas pressure and measured by the double-disc method. The erosion resistance of the laser treated nodular cast iron was 110 times greater than the untreated material. The erosion mechanism of the untreated nodular cast iron under normal and oblique angles was by severe plastic deformation and ploughing; whilst the mechanism for the treated specimens was by fatigue cracking. The improvements of erosion resistance after laser treatment were considered due to the very fine structure, high micro hardness (650 Hv0.1) with the resistance to plastic flow and to the dissolution of the graphite nodules.     

Erosive wear properties of unidirectional carbon fiber reinforced PEEK composites

The erosive wear properties of unidirectional carbon fiber (CF) reinforced polyetheretherketone (PEEK) composites were studied. A semi-ductile erosive wear manner was found regardless of the CF orientation. Wear mechanism analysis revealed that both cutting and deformation mechanisms existed in the erosion of the composites, although different damaging forms were involved depending on the impingement angles and CF orientation. To give further support on the erosion mechanisms, a special procedure was designed to observe the cross-sectional surface of the eroded composites, and the surface temperature variation was registered. It increased with increasing impingement angle, indicating higher energy dissipation by deformation, which is consistent with the revealed shift of the main erosive wear mechanism from cutting to deformation and “wholesale” fiber fracture.     

A study on erosion of upper bainitic ADI and PDI

Ductile iron containing ∼3.5 wt.% C and 2.1–4.2 wt.% Si (2.1, 2.8 and 4.2 wt.%) was studied. Three sets of specimens with differing Si contents were made into austempered ductile iron (ADI) and pearlite ductile iron (PDI) through heat treatment. These specimens were then eroded with Al₂O₃ particles and SiO₂ particles of 275–295 μm grit size to understand the relationship between erosion rate and microstructure. The ADI specimens were upper bainitic matrices that were austempered for different periods of time at 420 °C. The heat treatment of PDI was conducted at 870 or 930 °C for 1 h then forced air cooled or oil quenched to room temperature.Two types of wear curves, single peak curves and double peak curves, were found when plotting the erosion rate figures derived from the experimental results. 2.1 wt.% Si and 2.8 wt.% Si ADI tempered for a long period of time, due to their decreased retained austenite content and increased carbide content, had a single peak erosion rate curve. This embrittlement effect caused the impact angle of maximum erosion rate to increase from ∼30 to ∼45°. Decreasing the interspacing of the lamellae cementite promoted the hardness and improved the low-angle erosion wear resistance of PDI. The high hardness and brittleness of the matrix reduces the high-angle erosion resistance and the peak erosion rate occurs at a higher angle.For 2.1Si-ADI and 2.8Si-ADI tempered for a short duration, increasing the volume fraction of martensite in the matrix increases the erosion rate at an impact angle of 30°, but the maximum erosion rate is found at 75°. This results in a curve with a double peak. The double peak curve was also observed for high silicon ADI tempered for a long duration. The high solid solution hardness of 4.2Si-ADI, due to low retained austenite content and the presence of carbide in the matrix, results in poor erosion resistance. When this material is austempered for a long period, the erosion rate curve shifts from a single peak curve (30°) to a double peak curve (30°; 60°).     

Erosion behavior of thermal sprayed,recycled polymer and ethylene–methacrylic acid composite coatings

Polymer consumption is increasing and the recycling rate is 30–40 wt.%. Thus any process or application that uses recycled plastic residue will be looked upon with favor. It has been demonstrated that post-consumer commingled polymer, or PCCP, coatings can be produced by thermal spraying. Furthermore, polymeric coatings are widely used as protective coatings against solid particle erosion. Therefore, in this paper the erosion behavior of thermal spray coatings that have some PCCP material is investigated. The coatings were produced using a low velocity combustion thermal spray process and a PCCP mixed with different levels of virgin ethylene–methacrylic acid co-polymer (EMAA). The erosion rates using 50 μm alumina were determined at impact angles of 30° and 90°. The wear features were analyzed by scanning electron microscopy and profilometry. The results exhibited brittle wear features, consistent with the relationship between erosion rates and mechanical properties of the polymers. However, a decrease in erosion rate with an increase in impact angle, from 30° to 90°, indicates ductile behavior during erosion.     

Erosion-oxidation of uncoated,aluminized and chromized-aluminized 9Cr–1Mo steels under fluidized-bed conditions at 550–700 °C

Protective coatings, deposited mainly by thermal spraying and diffusion techniques, are considered a solution to extend the lifetime of many components in the energy production sector, such as heat exchangers. In this paper, some results are presented for uncoated, aluminized and chromized-aluminized 9Cr–1Mo steel, subjected to air and to impacts by 200 μm silica particles at angles of 30° and 90° and speeds of 7.0–9.2 m s^?1 at 550 –700 °C, in a laboratory fluidized-bed rig, to determine whether or not aluminized and chromized-aluminized diffusion coatings could protect the steel under such conditions. Erosion-oxidation damage was characterized by measurement of the mean thickness changes using a micrometer and examination of worn surfaces by scanning electron microscopy.Under most conditions, the coatings provided some protection to the substrate: under 30° impacts, up to 650 °C, and under 90° impacts, at 700 °C, both coatings were effective, whereas under 90° impacts, up to 650 °C, only the chromized-aluminized coating gave significant protection. However, for 30° at 700 °C, the oxide scale on the substrate was protective and the coatings were not needed. Explanations for these observations are presented in this paper, in terms of interactions between the erosion and oxidation processes for the materials.     

The lubrication of poly(etheretherketone) by an aqueous solution of nattokinase

Poly(etheretherketone) (PEEK) is a high strength and high temperature engineering polymer. However, its tribological performance is not very good in its pure form unless fillers or fibers are added to form composites. As polymers are often used for applications where traditional oil based lubrication may become an issue, water-based lubrication is desirable. This paper explores the lubrication performance of a natural fibrinolytic enzyme, nattokinase, found in fermented soybean (natto) in the aqueous solution. Pins of PEEK were slid against a steel disk in a pin-on-disk tester with the aqueous lubrication. The counterface disk material was a tool steel (R_a=0.37 μm). Tests were conducted at a rotational speed of 100 rpm and a normal load of 80 N. For comparison, tests were also conducted in NaCl solution. Nattokinase aqueous solution provides a coefficient of friction of 0.2 between PEEK and steel as compared to 0.3–0.35 for dry condition. The specific wear rates of PEEK for dry, deionized water, NaCl solution and aqueous nattokinase solution conditions were 10.5×10^?6, 51.6×10^?6, 228×10^?6 and 8.8×10^?6 mm³/N m, respectively. The fibrinolytic nattokinase enzyme provides lubricity with alkalinity reducing corrosion and eventually reducing wear.     

Solid particle erosion studies on biomorphic Si/SiC ceramic composites

Solid particle erosion tests were conducted on four different types of silicon carbide ceramic composites. The composites are cotton fabric based Si/SiC with and without chemical vapour infiltration, fine teak wood powder based Si/SiC and coarse teak wood powder based Si/SiC. The erodents used are angular SiC particles of average size 80, 250 and 450 μm. The velocities with which particles impacted on the target materials were varied from 20 to 50 m/s. Similarly the angle of impact was varied from 20° to 90°. Scanning electron microscopic observations on the eroded surface show brittle and cleavage like fracture. Fine teak wood powder based Si/SiC ceramic shows better erosion resistance than the other ceramics. Homogenous distribution of SiC grains with the presence of very fine grains of silicon and carbon is responsible for the improved erosion resistance. The higher erosion rate in cotton fabric based SiC arises from its microstructure. Here, the free carbon and free silicon grains are large in size and the SiC phase has very low hardness as compared to the erodent.     

Influence of orientation and volume fraction of Aramid fabric on abrasive wear performance of polyethersulfone composites

In case of fabric reinforced composites of specialty polymers influence of orientation of fabric and its volume fraction on tribo-behaviour is sparingly studied. In our earlier work, we have reported on the influence of amount of Aramid fabric (AF) in polyethersulfone (PES) on abrasive wear performance. However, orientation effect of fabric with respect to abrading plane was not investigated. In this work three orientations of composites of PES containing Aramid (Kevlar 29) fabric with three concentrations 64, 72 and 83 wt.% were selected to study the influence on abrasive wear performance. Composites developed by compression molding technique were characterized for their mechanical and physical properties. The abrasive wear performance of the composites was evaluated by abrading 10 mm × 10 mm × 10 mm sample against silicon carbide (SiC) paper under various loads and two grades of abrasive papers. The fabric reinforcement enhanced the abrasive wear resistance of PES significantly (approximately 1.35–9.46 times depending on the operating conditions). It was observed that 83% fabric composite showed the highest resistance to abrasive wear and impact along with the best tensile strength and elongation properties. Its flexural strength and ILSS values, however, were the lowest. Sixty-four percent fabric composite, on the other hand, showed an exactly reverse trend among the three composites. Among the three orientations, fibres in normal and parallel (N–P) and normal and anti-parallel (N–AP) direction with respect to sliding plane proved to impart maximum wear resistance. N–P was best for light loads while N–AP was best for high loading conditions. Orientation parallel and anti-parallel (P–AP) was least beneficial in this respect. Moreover, the extent of improvement very much depended on the operating parameters such as grit size and load. Benefits endowed due to reinforcement were higher at less coarse grade paper. With increase in load, however, wear rate of composites with N–P orientation increased and for other two orientations it decreased. Thus, for severe operating conditions, N–AP orientation proved to be most beneficial. SEM studies proved supporting for understanding the influence of orientation on wear performance.     

Studies on wear behavior of nano-intermetallic reinforced Al-base amorphous/nanocrystalline matrix in situ composite

Resistance to wear is an important factor in design and selection of structural components in relative motion against a mating surface. The present work deals with studies on fretting wear behavior of in situ nano-Al₃Ti reinforced Al–Ti–Si amorphous/nanocrystalline matrix composite, processed by high pressure (8 GPa) sintering at room temperature, 350, 400 or 450 °C. The wear experiments were carried out in gross slip fretting regime to investigate the performance of this composite against Al₂O₃ at ambient temperature (22–25 °C) and humidity (50–55%). The highest resistance to fretting wear has been observed in the composites sintered at 400 °C. The fretting wear involves oxidation of Al₃Ti particles in the composite. A continuous, smooth and protective tribolayer is formed on the worn surface of the composite sintered at 400 °C, while fragmentation and spallation leads to a rougher surface and greater wear in the composite sintered at 450 °C.