Relationships between muscle characteristics and meat quality traits of young Charolais bulls

Charolais bull calves (106) were used to study the variability in meat quality attributes in relation to the variability in muscle characteristics in the Longissimus thoracis (LT) muscle. The variability in traits was adjusted either to constant age or constant weight at slaughter and thus originated only from differences between animals born, reared and fattened in the same location. The following meat quality attributes were measured: the strength of the myofibrillar resistance to a 20% compression strain measured on the raw meat 2, 7 and 21 days post mortem; and taste panel scores of tenderness (initial and overall), flavour and juiciness of steaks grilled to a 55°C core temperature 6 or 15 days post-mortem. The following muscle characteristics were measured 24 h after slaughter: pH, dry matter, protein, lipid, heme iron and collagen contents, collagen solubility, LDH and ICDH activity, the proportion of slow twitch myosin heavy chain, the mean muscle fibre area and the mean sarcomere length. One fourth to one third of the variability of 2 day mechanical strength and 15 day tenderness or flavour scores were related to the variability in muscle characteristics. Tenderness and strength measurements were predominantly related to the muscle fibre area, collagen characteristics and energetic metabolic activity. Dry matter content was the principal muscle characteristic related to flavour.     

Effects of pre-slaughter administration of antifreeze proteins on frozen meat quality

The effects of pre-slaughter administration of antifreeze glycoproteins to lambs were assessed on lamb meat quality after thawing. Various concentrations of antifreeze glycoproteins (AFGP) from Antarctic Cod were injected intravenously into lambs (35 ± 5 kg liveweight) at various times prior to slaughter. The lambs were electrically stunned, slaughtered, then subjected to high voltage electrical stimulation. The rate of glycolysis was assessed by monitoring the rate of pH fall and the ultimate pH. Longissimus dorsi muscles were removed from the carcasses 24 h post-slaughter. Samples were vacuum packed and stored frozen at -20 °C for 2-16 weeks. Upon thawing, samples were assessed for drip loss and sensory properties (foreign flavour, storage flavour, texture, tenderness, juiciness and overall acceptability). At certain times, frozen samples were examined by scanning electron microscopy after ice sublimation. Injection of AFGP had no effect on the rate of pH decline, and for all treatments the pH of samples was not significantly different. Injection of AFGP 10 min before slaughter had no effect at any of the concentrations of AFGP for any of the factors assessed, suggesting that 10 min was insufficient time for the AFGP to become associated with the muscle tissue. Injection of AFGP at either 1 or 24 h before slaughter reduced drip loss and ice crystal size. Crystals were smallest in the lambs injected to a final concentration of 0.01 μg/kg AFGP, particularly when injected 24 h before slaughter. These results suggest that the addition of AFGP could reduce damage due to frozen storage of meat, if a cost-effective and consumer-acceptable method could be developed to incorporate these proteins into meat prior to freezing.     

Consumer and sensory investigations in relation to physical/chemical aspects of cooked pork in Scandinavia

The present study addresses sensory quality and liking for pork (eight samples) varying in quality due to adrenaline injection resulting in elevated ultimate pH post-slaughter (24h), meat ageing, cooking temperature and warmed-over flavour (WOF) among consumers (n=288) in Scandinavia. The consumers preferred meat with higher pH (pH(24h)=6.0), cooked to the lowest temperature (65?°C versus 80?°C). Consumers least preferred samples with WOF described as metallic, acidic and off-flavour by a trained panel. "Elevated pH(24h) meat" cooked to 65?°C resulted in a more sweet and tender meat. Juiciness, tenderness and the absence of off-flavour were the most important characteristics for consumers' liking of pork. Consumption frequency and liking of pork were positively related. The consumers that were most satisfied with pork quality reported highest consumption frequency. Elderly people and males expressed the highest liking score and consumption frequency, respectively.     

Muscularity and eating quality of lambs: Effects of breed, sex and selection of sires using muscularity measurements by computed tomography

Differences in muscularity of the hind leg (HL) and lumbar region (LR) were investigated between sexes (ram vs ewe lambs), breeds (Scottish Blackface, SBF vs Texel, TEX) and progeny of high- and low-muscularity sires (HM, LM) (n=471). The influence of these factors on meat eating quality (MEQ) was also examined (n=229). TEX lambs had 16% greater muscularity than SBF in both regions, whilst differences between sire groups were 4%. Ewe lambs had slightly higher values of muscularity for the HL than rams, but values were similar for the LR. Meat from SBF lambs had higher tenderness, stronger lamb flavour and higher overall liking than TEX meat. Sex had a weak influence with ram lambs having a stronger abnormal flavour and lower overall liking in the LR only. No significant differences in MEQ were found between HM- and LM-sired lambs, suggesting that improvements in muscularity would not have unfavourable effects on MEQ.     

The effect of growth rate and ultimate pH on meat quality of lambs

Entire male Romney lambs (n = 60) were grown slowly (67 g/day) and slaughtered at 14 months of age at an anticipated carcass weight of 18 kg. Another group of ram lambs (n = 15) from the same genetic background (born 7 months later) were grown rapidly (162 g/day) for 7 months and slaughtered at the same time and at a similar carcass weight. Preslaughter shearing (20 days prior to slaughter) and swim washing (3 times) were variously imposed upon the 14-month old lambs to give them a graded preslaughter stress. The lambs were head-only electrically stunned and slaughtered. Dressed carcasses were electrically stimulated at 20 min post mortem for 90 s at 14·3 pulses/s, 1·8-2 A and 1130 V peak, then held at 12°C for 2 h and frozen so that the deep leg reached -4°C in 12 h. The ultimate pH was measured for the longissimus dorsi, and loin samples were assessed by tenderometer and a sensory panel. The groups with the greatest stresses imposed had the highest ultimate pH. The most tender meat came either from carcasses with an ultimate high pH greater than 6·3 or from young lambs with an ultimate pH from 5·5-5·7. While 7-month old lambs were slightly more tender than the 14-month old lambs of iso pH, the 14-month old lambs of high pH were the most tender. This suggests that age-related connective tissue effects were minimal for the loin. The shear force values and taste panel tenderness scores were linearly related. When the shear force and panellists' tenderness scores were expressed in relation to ultimate pH, there was a decreased acceptance of meat with a moderate ultimate pH between 5·8 and 6·0. Panel texture assessments showed a less clearly defined, but statistically significant decrease in acceptance at pH 5·8-6·0. Other sensory attributes of flavour, juiciness and aroma were uniform across the whole ultimate pH spectrum.     

Effect of concentrate feeding on instrumental meat quality and sensory characteristics of fallow deer venison

Venison from twenty four hybrid fallow deer does, 36 months old with an initial body condition score (BCS) of 2, was tested to determine the influence of feed type on meat quality. Feeding with concentrates increased BCS (P < 0.01) but did not affect ultimate pH (P > 0.05). BCS 4 animals had higher intra muscular fat (IMF) (P < 0.01), and more tender meat (P < 0.05). Venison from does fed over 24 weeks exhibited less redness (P < 0.01) than those fed for 19 weeks regardless of feed type.Panellists evaluated samples for colour, flavour, tenderness, juiciness and overall liking. They detected significantly (P < 0.05) stronger flavour in meat from animals fed concentrates. Male panellists detected flavour differences within meat from animals fed concentrates (P < 0.05), with longer feeding periods resulting in stronger flavour. There was no difference in overall liking, therefore finishing fallow deer on grain-based concentrate feeds prior to slaughter provided little commercial advantage.     

Associations of sire estimated breeding values and objective meat quality measurements with sensory scores in Australian lamb

The impact of selecting for lean meat yield using breeding values for increased eye muscle depth (PEMD) and decreased fat depth (PFAT) on the consumer acceptance of lamb meat was evaluated. Consumer sensory scores (tenderness, juiciness, flavour, odour, overall liking) were obtained for the longissimus lumborum (loin) and semimembranosus (topside) muscles of 1471 lambs. On average loin samples were more acceptable for consumers. Sensory scores increased with higher IMF levels, with lower shear force levels, and when animals were younger and less muscular. Increasing PEMD decreased tenderness, overall liking and flavour scores in both muscles, and decreasing PFAT reduced tenderness within the loin samples only. This negative impact of PEMD and PFAT is not solely driven through the phenotypic impact of IMF and shear force on sensory scores. Our results confirm the growing concerns that selecting for lean meat yield would reduce consumer eating quality, and highlight that careful monitoring of selection programmes is needed to maintain lamb eating quality.     

Effects of breed, feed level and conditioning time on the tenderness of pork

This study of 80 pigs compared the effects of breed (Duroc vs Large White), feed level (High vs 0.8 High, termed Low) and conditioning time (1 vs 10 days at 1 °C) on the tenderness and other aspects of the eating quality of pork. Conditioning time had the biggest effect (increase of 1.0 units on 1-8 taste panel scale between 1 and 10 days) and this was associated with an increase in the myofibrillar fragmentation index (MFI) from 19 to 24 units. Tenderness was not different between the two breeds although pork flavour intensity and overall liking scores were higher in Durocs. Durocs had higher concentrations of total lipid (marbling fat) in muscle (13.7 and 5.4 mg/g) and most polyunsaturated fatty acids except α-linolenic (C18:3 n-3) were at lower concentrations in Durocs, reflecting dilution of phospholipid fatty acids within a larger total lipid pool. Pigs fed at the high level were fatter than those fed restrictedly in terms both of P2 fat thickness and marbling fat. There was also a tendency, although not significant, for the meat to be more tender. When the data from all pigs were pooled, MFI was shown to correlate well with tenderness (r = 0.45) and marbling fat with juiciness (r = 0.36).     

Effects of breed, diet and muscle on fat deposition and eating quality in pigs

A study in 192 entire male pigs examined the effects of breed, diet and muscle on growth, fatness, sensory traits and fatty acid composition. There were four breeds: two modern breeds, Duroc and Large White and two traditional breeds, Berkshire and Tamworth. The diets differed in energy:protein ratio, being conventional (C) and low protein (LP) diets, respectively. Muscles investigated were the ‘white' longissimus dorsi (LD) and the ‘red' psoas major (PS). Breed influenced growth rate and fatness, the modern breeds being faster-growing with leaner carcasses. However, the concentrations of neutral lipid fatty acids and marbling fat (neutral lipid + phosopholipid fatty acids) were higher in Berkshire and Duroc, in both LD and PS. Relationships between marbling fat and P2 fat thickness showed clear breed effects, with Duroc having high marbling fat at low P2 and Tamworth low marbling fat at high P2. Breed effects on sensory scores given by the trained taste panel to griddled LD and PS steaks were relatively small. Breed affected the fatty acid composition of intramuscular neutral lipid, with high % values for the saturated fatty acids, 14:0 and 16:0 in Berkshire and Tamworth (fat carcasses) and high values for polyunsaturated fatty acids in Duroc and Large White (lean carcasses). Duroc had particularly high concentrations of the long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids, 20:5n−3 and 22:6n−3 in phospholipid of both muscles. Diet influenced growth rate and fatness, the LP diet slowing growth and producing fatter meat, more so in the two modern breeds, and particularly in intramuscular rather than subcutaneous fat. This diet produced more tender and juicy meat, although pork flavour and flavour liking were reduced. The PS muscle had higher tenderness, juiciness, pork flavour, flavour liking and overall liking scores than LD. The concentration of phospholipid fatty acids was higher in PS than LD but neutral lipid fatty acid content and marbling fat were higher in LD.     

Diverse lamb genotypes. 3. Eating quality and the relationship between its objective measurement and sensory assessment

The effect of genotype on eating quality was evaluated on m. Longissimus thoracis et lumborum (LTL) muscle of 60 lambs. The lambs were sired by a selection of Texel (T), Poll Dorset (PD), Border Leicester (BL) and Merino (M) rams, crossed with Border Leicester x Merino (BLM) and Merino (M) ewes giving six genotypes (TxBLM, PDxBLM, TxM, PDxM, BLxM and MxM). The relationships between sensory panel assessment of eating quality attributes and pH, cooking loss and shear force were also investigated. No significant differences were observed between genotypes for panel assessment of tenderness, juiciness, aroma liking, aroma strength, flavour liking, overall acceptability and rating. MxM lambs had a significantly (P<0.05) higher flavour strength than BLxM lambs. pH was a poor indicator of any eating quality attributes, except aroma strength (r=0.3, P<0.05). Warner Bratzler shear force value (WB) and tenderness showed a significant (P<0.001) negative correlation (-0.7). Tenderness, flavour and juiciness were the most important sensory attributes, explaining 86.5% of the total variation in overall acceptability.     

Eating quality of commercially processed hot boned sheep meat

The aim of this work was to establish consumer perceptions of the eating quality of commercially processed hot boned sheep meat. The eating quality scores for tenderness, flavour, juiciness, and overall liking of grilled m. longissimus thoracis et lumborum (LL) were derived from untrained consumers. The animals used in this experiment were sourced from three different properties and were of various ages, breed, and sex, and had been on various quality pastures. All carcases were subjected to immobilisation, spinal discharge and high voltage electrical stimulation and boned within 2 h of slaughter. All LL samples were frozen after boning according to the system applied at the abattoir and samples kept for consumer assessment and measurement of meat quality. The results showed, on average carcases entered rigor at high temperatures with a pH of 5.95 at 29.3 °C. With an average sarcomere length of 1.68 μm, some shortening was evident and there was a significant difference between lots in sarcomere length (P < 0.05). A large percentage (82%) of samples had a pH greater than 5.8 at the time of freezing. All samples taken for shear force analysis exceeded a recommended threshold for acceptable table meat of 49 N and there was no significant difference between lots (P > 0.05). Only 13.5% of the samples met the ‘good everyday’ requirement following sensory assessment and there were significant differences between lots for eating quality traits (P < 0.05). This work clearly shows that the application of effective electrical stimulation is not sufficient to ensure that hot boned sheep meat will be suitable as a table meat. These findings highlight the need for the inclusion of other intervention techniques.     

Meat quality, fatty acid composition and flavour analysis in Belgian retail beef

The objective of this study was to evaluate the differences in biochemical, sensorial and quality characteristics of retail beef in Belgium. Four types of beef (Belgian Blue double-muscled, Limousin, Irish and Argentine) and two different muscles (longissimus lumborum and semimembranosus) were bought at the retail level and compared with regard to colour, shear force, collagen content, fatty acid analysis, taste panel evaluation as well as flavour analysis. Belgian Blue and Limousin beef had a paler colour, lower collagen and intramuscular fat contents. Fatty acid profiles were significantly different between the four types, with significantly higher PUFA/SFA and n-6/n-3 ratios for Belgiam Blue and Limousin beef compared to Argentine and Irish beef. There were significant differences between the meat types for taste panel tenderness and shear force, however both measurements did not fully correspond. Flavour analysis by gas chromatography–mass spectrometry as well as sensory analysis demonstrated that Irish and Argentine beef had a higher flavour intensity related to higher contents of volatile compounds. Differences in tenderness and flavour between the meat types were probably affected by differences in ageing time, related to import vs local production of meat.     

Effect of Duroc content, sex and ageing period on meat and eating quality attributes of pork loin

This study was conducted to determine the effect of percentage Duroc content of entire male and female pigs and ageing period on meat and eating quality attributes of pork loin (M. longissimus thoracis et lumborum). A total of 84 pigs [entire males (n=42) and female (n=42)] of 0% Duroc (100% Large White), 50% Duroc (Duroc×Large White) or 100% Duroc (n=14 pigs per sex×genotype combination) were slaughtered at a liveweight of 100 kg. Steaks from the M. longissimus lumborum of female pigs were aged for either 2 or 7 days post-slaughter and evaluated using a consumer taste panel. Eating quality attributes of tenderness, flavour and overall liking of pork loin steaks from female pigs were not (P>0.05) influenced by Duroc content. Pork from 100% Duroc pigs was juicier (P=0.05) and had a higher (1.84%, P=0.05) intramuscular fat content than pork from 0 and 50% Duroc pigs (1.40 and 1.25%, respectively). Pork from entire male pigs had a lower (P<0.001) intramuscular fat content, was darker (P<0.01) in colour and recorded higher (P<0.01) Warner Bratzler shear force values compared with pork from female carcasses. Ageing pork loin steaks in vacuum bags for 7 days improved tenderness (P<0.01), flavour (P<0.05) and overall liking (P<0.05) compared with steaks aged for 2 days post-slaughter. Ageing of pork steaks for 7 days post-slaughter improved eating quality attributes far more effectively than increasing percentage Duroc content of pigs, which only influenced consumer scores for juiciness.     

Dietary manipulation of muscle long-chain omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids and sensory properties of lamb meat

The effects of dietary manipulation of muscle long-chain omega-3 fatty acids (FA) on sensory properties of cooked meat in second cross ([Merino×Border Leicester]×Poll Dorset) wether lambs were evaluated. Lambs fed dietary supplements of fish meal (FM, Exp. 1) and fish oil (FO, Exp. 2) showed moderately (P<0.01) and markedly (P<0.001) increased muscle long-chain omega-3 FA content compared with those fed the basal diet of lucerne chaff and oat chaff. Protected canola seed (PCS, Exp. 1) significantly (P<0.001) increased omega-6 FA content of the longissimus muscle. In each of the 2 experiments (1 and 2), after being fed experimental diets for 6 weeks lambs were slaughtered at a commercial abattoir. At 24 h post-mortem (PM) the semitendinosus and biceps femoris muscles were removed from animals and stored at -20°C until evaluation of sensory properties using experienced panel members. The muscle samples were stored for 3 (Exp. 1) and 12 (Exp. 2) months then removed, thawed and cooked for sensory evaluation. The meat samples were cooked under standardized conditions in a convection microwave at 180°C (20-25 min) to an internal temperature of 75°C. Cooked samples were tested for flavour, aroma, juiciness and overall palatability. The significant increase in muscle long-chain omega-3 with FM (Exp. 1 and 2) and FO (Exp. 2) or omega-6 FA with PCS (Exp. 1) were not detrimental to sensory panel evaluations of flavour or aroma of cooked meat when compared with the basal diet. However, meat from FM (Exp. 1) had lower juiciness and FO (Exp. 2) had lower overall palatability. Protected sunflower meal protein with FO (Exp. 2) significantly lowered ratings for flavour, juiciness and overall palatability. Lamb meat with increased levels of long-chain omega-3 FA can be produced without altering the sensory quality (flavour or aroma) of the cooked meat.     

Post-mortem processing of export beef in Costa Rica

Eighteen intact male beef animals of 2 1 2 to 3 years of age, weighing 400-425 kg and fed entirely on rangelands grass, were slaughtered in a Costa Rican export plant. Six animals each were assigned to: low-voltage stimulation (75V), high-voltage stimulation (350V) and control. Hot-boning coupled with various chilling rates was also investigated. Mean muscle pH values for all treatment groups were above 6·4 at 1 1 2 h after slaughter, which may be related to the fact the animals were intact males which had been exposed to stressful conditions prior to slaughter. Palatability traits measured were tenderness, juiciness, flavor and overall desirability. With the exception of tenderness, there were no significant differences among electrical stimulation or chill treatments, and there were no interactions. The low-voltage electrical-stimulation treatment produced less tender meat (P<0·05) than the high-voltage treatment, but there was no significant difference compared to the control. In an attempt to explain the finding that electrical stimulation had little or no effect on tenderness, the data were inspected in regard to ultimate pH. The panel score for samples with an ultimate pH less than 6 was 3·27, and for samples with a pH higher than 6 it was 5·70. A possible explanation is to suggest that the high-pH group underwent appreciable neutral proteolytic enzyme activity compared to the low-pH group.     

Breed, slaughter weight and ageing time effects on consumer appraisal of three muscles of lamb

Consumers (n = 265) tasted semitendinosus (ST), semimembranosus (SM) and gluteo biceps (GB) (right and left) from 180 entire male lambs. Muscles were from three Spanish breeds: Rasa Aragonesa (local meat breed), Churra (local dairy breed) and Spanish Merino. Within breed, three slaughter live weights were considered (10–12, 20–22 or 30–32 kg). Isolated muscles were aged under vacuum package for 1, 2, 4, 8 or 16 days. Consumers evaluated tenderness, flavour quality and overall acceptability. Globally, the three attributes were significantly influenced by breed, slaughter live weight and ageing. Considering breed effect, Churra had the lowest scores for tenderness in the heaviest lambs while Spanish Merino was the most tender at 20–22 kg but there were no differences between either for 10–12 kg lambs. Muscles from the heaviest lambs were considered the toughest and those from the 10–12 kg lambs the most tender. Tenderness improved with ageing, but more for SM and GB. Flavour was better in the lightest lambs and, in general, it was not affected negatively by ageing. Consumers preferred meat from the 10–12 kg lambs in all breeds (the most tender and with the best flavour) and aged for intermediate to long periods (4–16 days). For the three attributes, the ST muscle had the best ratings at short ageing times and GB at long ageing times.     

Influence of CaCl2 and NaCl injections on the texture and flavour of beef

The present study compares the effects of pre− and post-rigor injections of 0.1 m CaCl₂ or 0.15 m NaCl on sensory characteristics (appearance, texture and flavour) and on physical measurements (sarcomere length, drip loss and mechanical resistance of raw myofibres) of beef meat at 2, 6 and 14 days of ageing. An injection of CaCl₂ 1 h post-mortem (pH ≈6.8) greatly decreased sarcomere length and myofibrillar resistance, increased drip loss, contracted appearance and brightness, and induced abnormal flavour, mainly bitterness, whatever the ageing time. CaCl₂-treatment 1 h post-mortem produced little effect on tenderness during ageing; it was slightly higher at day 2 and lower at day 14 than controls. CaCl₂-injection at 24 h post-mortem did not change the sarcomere length but produced a smaller increase in drip loss and a decrease in the resistance of raw myofibres. Improved meat tenderness compared to controls occurred mainly at days 2 and 6 but, during ageing, abnormal flavour appeared by day 6. NaCl-injection had no effect on either sarcomere length or resistance of raw myofibres, but produced higher drip loss and saltier taste at day 14 only. Thus pre-rigor injection of CaCl₂ is not recommended because of adverse effects on flavour and appearance of meat. Post-rigor injection of CaCl₂ has a beneficial effect on tenderness in the first part of the ageing period, but after complete ageing, the only overall benefit is a decrease in the variability between animals.     

Effects of breed and marination on the sensory attributes of pork from Large White and Hampshire-sired pigs

The effects of breed and marination were tested for their effects on meat pH, water holding (marinade uptake and losses) and eating quality (tenderness, juiciness and flavour).

Loins were removed from one side of 20 Large White-sired and 20 Hampshire-sired pigs after slaughter, cut into four pieces and injected to 112% of their initial weight with water, a polyphosphate-containing marinade (pH 7.7) or a high pH marinade (pH 10.3). An uninjected piece of loin served as control. Samples were left overnight and then frozen before being thawed, cooked and assessed by a trained ten member sensory panel using 1–8 category scales.

Hampshires had higher intramuscular fat (0.95%) than Large Whites (0.62%) but otherwise the effects of breed were small compared with marination. Both marinades significantly increased meat pH from 5.5 (control) by 0.2 U, significantly reduced the cooking loss and increased the meat yield from about 80% to 90%. Water-injected samples lost large amounts of added water as drip after thawing and had a yield (76%) similar to the control. Marinaded samples retained more water post-cooking. Both marinades significantly increased tenderness (p < 0.001) and juiciness (p < 0.001) by about 1.0 U compared with the control (4.4 for tenderness and 4.2 for juiciness). Pork flavour, however, was significantly reduced (p < 0.001) and abnormal flavour was significantly increased (p < 0.001) by marination. Tenderness was positively correlated with pH after injection (0.83) and yield (0.75); juiciness was also positively correlated with pH after injection (0.78) and yield (0.87).

The absence of any significant difference in eating quality between control and water-injected samples, and the relatively large effects of marination, suggest that retained water (after cooking) is crucial in determining perceived tenderness and juiciness in pork.