Optimization of interval type-2 fuzzy logic controllers using evolutionary algorithms

A method for designing optimal interval type-2 fuzzy logic controllers using evolutionary algorithms is presented in this paper. Interval type-2 fuzzy controllers can outperform conventional type-1 fuzzy controllers when the problem has a high degree of uncertainty. However, designing interval type-2 fuzzy controllers is more difficult because there are more parameters involved. In this paper, interval type-2 fuzzy systems are approximated with the average of two type-1 fuzzy systems, which has been shown to give good results in control if the type-1 fuzzy systems can be obtained appropriately. An evolutionary algorithm is applied to find the optimal interval type-2 fuzzy system as mentioned above. The human evolutionary model is applied for optimizing the interval type-2 fuzzy controller for a particular non-linear plant and results are compared against an optimal type-1 fuzzy controller. A comparative study of simulation results of the type-2 and type-1 fuzzy controllers, under different noise levels, is also presented. Simulation results show that interval type-2 fuzzy controllers obtained with the evolutionary algorithm outperform type-1 fuzzy controllers.     

Hybrid learning for interval type-2 fuzzy logic systems based on orthogonal least-squares and back-propagation methods

This paper presents a novel learning methodology based on a hybrid algorithm for interval type-2 fuzzy logic systems. Since only the back-propagation method has been proposed in the literature for the tuning of both the antecedent and the consequent parameters of type-2 fuzzy logic systems, a hybrid learning algorithm has been developed. The hybrid method uses a recursive orthogonal least-squares method for tuning the consequent parameters and the back-propagation method for tuning the antecedent parameters. Systems were tested for three types of inputs: (a) interval singleton, (b) interval type-1 non-singleton, and (c) interval type-2 non-singleton. Experiments were carried out on the application of hybrid interval type-2 fuzzy logic systems for prediction of the scale breaker entry temperature in a real hot strip mill for three different types of coil. The results proved the feasibility of the systems developed here for scale breaker entry temperature prediction. Comparison with type-1 fuzzy logic systems shows that hybrid learning interval type-2 fuzzy logic systems provide improved performance under the conditions tested.     

Interval type-2 fuzzy inverse controller design in nonlinear IMC structure

In the recent years it has been demonstrated that type-2 fuzzy logic systems are more effective in modeling and control of complex nonlinear systems compared to type-1 fuzzy logic systems. An inverse controller based on type-2 fuzzy model can be proposed since inverse model controllers provide an efficient way to control nonlinear processes. Even though various fuzzy inversion methods have been devised for type-1 fuzzy logic systems up to now, there does not exist any method for type-2 fuzzy logic systems. In this study, a systematic method has been proposed to form the inverse of the interval type-2 Takagi-Sugeno fuzzy model based on a pure analytical method. The calculation of inverse model is done based on simple manipulations of the antecedent and consequence parts of the fuzzy model. Moreover, the type-2 fuzzy model and its inverse as the primary controller are embedded into a nonlinear internal model control structure to provide an effective and robust control performance. Finally, the proposed control scheme has been implemented on an experimental pH neutralization process where the beneficial sides are shown clearly.     

Type-1 and type-2 fuzzy inference systems as integration methods in modular neural networks for multimodal biometry and its optimization with genetic algorithms

We describe in this paper a comparative study between fuzzy inference systems as methods of integration in modular neural networks for multimodal biometry. These methods of integration are based on techniques of type-1 fuzzy logic and type-2 fuzzy logic. Also, the fuzzy systems are optimized with simple genetic algorithms with the goal of having optimized versions of both types of fuzzy systems. First, we considered the use of type-1 fuzzy logic and later the approach with type-2 fuzzy logic. The fuzzy systems were developed using genetic algorithms to handle fuzzy inference systems with different membership functions, like the triangular, trapezoidal and Gaussian; since these algorithms can generate fuzzy systems automatically. Then the response integration of the modular neural network was tested with the optimized fuzzy systems of integration. The comparative study of the type-1 and type-2 fuzzy inference systems was made to observe the behavior of the two different integration methods for modular neural networks for multimodal biometry.     

Computing derivatives in interval type-2 fuzzy logic systems

This paper makes type-2 fuzzy logic systems much more accessible to fuzzy logic system designers, because it provides mathematical formulas and computational flowcharts for computing the derivatives that are needed to implement steepest-descent parameter tuning algorithms for such systems. It explains why computing such derivatives is much more challenging than it is for a type-1 fuzzy logic system. It provides derivative calculations that are applicable to any kind of type-2 membership functions, since the calculations are performed without prespecifying the nature of those membership functions. Some calculations are then illustrated for specific type-2 membership functions.     

A simple design method for interval type-2 fuzzy pid controllers

In this study, a design method for single Input interval type-2 fuzzy PID controller has been developed. The most important feature of the proposed type-2 fuzzy controller is its simple structure consisting of a single input variable. The presented simple structure gives an opportunity to the designer to form the type-2 fuzzy controller output in closed form formulation for the first time in literature. This formulation cannot be achieved with present type-2 fuzzy PID controller structures which have employed the Karnik-Mendel type reduction. The closed form solution is derived in terms of the tuning parameters which are chosen as the heights of lower membership functions of the antecedent interval type-2 fuzzy sets. Elaborations are done on the derived closed form output and a simple strategy is presented for a single input type-2 fuzzy PID controller design. The presented interval type-2 fuzzy controller structure still keeps the most preferred features of the PID controller such as simplicity and easy design. We will illustrate how the extra degrees of freedom provided by the antecedent interval type-2 fuzzy sets can be used to enhance the control performance on linear and nonlinear benchmark systems by simulations. Moreover, the type-2 fuzzy controller structure has been implemented on experimental pH neutralization. The simulation and experimental results will illustrate that the proposed type-2 fuzzy controller produces superior control performance and can handle nonlinear dynamics, parameter uncertainties, noise and disturbances better in comparison with the standard PID controllers. Hence, the results and analyses of this study will give the control engineers an opportunity to draw a bridge and connect the type-2 fuzzy logic and control theory.     

A review on the design and optimization of interval type-2 fuzzy controllers

A review of the methods used in the design of interval type-2 fuzzy controllers has been considered in this work. The fundamental focus of the work is based on the basic reasons for optimizing type-2 fuzzy controllers for different areas of application. Recently, bio-inspired methods have emerged as powerful optimization algorithms for solving complex problems. In the case of designing type-2 fuzzy controllers for particular applications, the use of bio-inspired optimization methods have helped in the complex task of finding the appropriate parameter values and structure of the fuzzy systems. In this review, we consider the application of genetic algorithms, particle swarm optimization and ant colony optimization as three different paradigms that help in the design of optimal type-2 fuzzy controllers. We also mention alternative approaches to designing type-2 fuzzy controllers without optimization techniques. We also provide a comparison of the different optimization methods for the case of designing type-2 fuzzy controllers.     

广义二型模糊逻辑系统降型及其采样离散Nie-Tan算法

广义二型模糊逻辑系统在近年来成为学术研究的热点问题,而降型是该系统中的核心模块。最近的研究证明了连续Nie-Tan(CNT)算法是计算区间二型模糊集质心的准确方法。发现了离散Nie-Tan(NT)算法中的求和运算和CNT算法中的求积分运算的内在联系,用2类算法完成基于广义二型模糊集α-平面表达理论的广义二型模糊逻辑系统质心降型。3个计算机仿真实验表明,当适当增加主变量采样点个数时,所提出的基于主变量采样的离散NT算法计算出的广义二型模糊逻辑系统质心降型集和解模糊化值结果可以精确地逼近基准的CNT算法,且采样离散NT算法的计算效率远远高于CNT算法的效率。     

Control of a distillation column by type-2 and type-1 fuzzy logic PID controllers

The aim of this paper is to develop a type-1 and a type-2 fuzzy logic PID controller (type-1 FLC and type-2 FLC, respectively) for the control of a binary distillation column, the mathematical model of which is characterized by both high nonlinearities and parameter uncertainties. Attention was focused on the tuning procedure proposed by the authors and representing a development of the original Jantzen [1] method for type-1 and type-2 fuzzy controllers, in particular including input type-2 Gaussian membership functions. A theoretical explanation of the differences in fuzzy controller performance was in fact provided in the light of simulation results. The performance of a type-1 FLC was then compared in simulation with the one of type-2 FLC. All the simulation results confirmed the robustness and the effective control action of each fuzzy controller, with evident advantages for the type-2 FLC.     

Genetic algorithm design of neural network and fuzzy logic controllers

This paper discusses the design of neural network and fuzzy logic controllers using genetic algorithms, for real-time control of flows in sewerage networks. The soft controllers operate in a critical control range, with a simple set-point strategy governing “easy” cases. The genetic algorithm designs controllers and set-points by repeated application of a simulator. A comparison between neural network, fuzzy logic and benchmark controller performance is presented. Global and local control strategies are compared. Methods to reduce execution time of the genetic algorithm, including the use of a Tabu algorithm for training data selection, are also discussed. The results indicate that local control is superior to global control, and that the genetic algorithm design of soft controllers is feasible even for complex flow systems of a realistic scale. Neural network and fuzzy logic controllers have comparable performance, although neural networks can be successfully optimised more consistently.     

Experimental study of intelligent controllers under uncertainty using type-1 and type-2 fuzzy logic

Uncertainty is an inherent part in control systems used in real world applications. The use of new methods for handling incomplete information is of fundamental importance. Type-1 fuzzy sets used in conventional fuzzy systems cannot fully handle the uncertainties present in control systems. Type-2 fuzzy sets that are used in type-2 fuzzy systems can handle such uncertainties in a better way because they provide us with more parameters and more design degrees of freedom. This paper deals with the design of control systems using type-2 fuzzy logic for minimizing the effects of uncertainty produced by the instrumentation elements, environmental noise, etc. The experimental results are divided in two classes, in the first class, simulations of a feedback control system for a non-linear plant using type-1 and type-2 fuzzy logic controllers are presented; a comparative analysis of the systems’ response in both cases was performed, with and without the presence of uncertainty. For the second class, a non-linear identification problem for time-series prediction is presented. Based on the experimental results the conclusion is that the best results are obtained using type-2 fuzzy systems.     

离散型和连续型改进Karnik-Mendel算法在高阶模糊系统降型中的关系研究

降型是广义二型模糊逻辑系统的核心模块。比较和分析了离散改进Karnik-Mendel（EKM）算法中求和运算和连续EKM(CEKM)算法中求积分运算,基于广义二型模糊集的α-平面表达理论,扩展EKM算法计算完成广义二型模糊逻辑系统质心降型。当计算广义二型模糊逻辑系统的质心降型集和质心解模糊化值时,用2个仿真实验说明了当适当增加广义二型模糊集主变量采样个数时,离散EKM算法的计算结果可以准确地逼近CEKM算法。     

Ⅱ型模糊控制综述

Ⅱ型模糊集合是传统Ⅰ型模糊集合的扩展,其特征是隶属度值本身为模糊集合.基于Ⅱ型模糊集合的Ⅱ型模糊控制器可以同时有效地处理语言和数据不确定性,在高小确定场合具有明显超过相应Ⅰ型控制器的性能表现.本文首先对Ⅱ型模糊集合及系统理论进行了概述,然后对Ⅱ型非自适应模糊控制器Ⅱ型自适应模糊控制器和Ⅱ型自组织模糊控制器的研究进展分别...     

Interval type-2 fuzzy expert system for prediction of carbon monoxide concentration in mega-cities

This paper presents an indirect approach to interval type-2 fuzzy logic system modeling to forecaste the level of air pollutants. The type-2 fuzzy logic system permits us to model the uncertainties among rules and the parameters related to data analysis. In this paper, we propose an indirect method to create an interval type-2 fuzzy logic system from a historical data, where Footprint of Uncertainties of fuzzy sets are extracted by implementation of an interval type-2 FCM algorithm and based on an upper and lower value for the level of fuzziness m in FCM. Finally, the proposed model is applied for prediction of carbon monoxide concentration in Tehran air pollution. It is shown that the proposed type-2 fuzzy logic system is superior in comparison to type-1 fuzzy logic systems in terms of two performance indices.     

Intuit before tuning: Type-1 and type-2 fuzzy logic controllers

Although a considerable amount of effort has been put in to show that fuzzy logic controllers have exceptional capabilities of dealing with uncertainty, there are still noteworthy concerns, e.g., the design of fuzzy logic controllers is an arduous task due to the lack of closed-form input–output relationships which is a limitation to interpretability of these controllers. The role of design parameters in fuzzy logic controllers, such as position, shape, and height of membership functions, is not straightforward. Motivated by the fact that the availability of an interpretable relationship from input to output will simplify the design procedure of fuzzy logic controllers, the main aims in this work are derive fuzzy mappings for both type-1 and interval type-2 fuzzy logic controllers, analyse them, and eventually benefit from such a nonlinear mapping to design fuzzy logic controllers. Thereafter, simulation and real-time experimental results support the presented theoretical findings.     

Evolving an interval type-2 fuzzy PID controller for the redundant robotic manipulator

Robotic manipulators are a multi-input multi-output, dynamically coupled, highly time-varying, complex and highly nonlinear systems wherein the external disturbances, parameter variations, and random noise adversely affects the performance of the robotic system. Therefore, in order to deal with such complexities, however, an intriguing task for control researchers, these systems require an efficient and robust controller. In this paper, a novel application of genetic algorithms (GA) optimization approach to optimize the scaling factors of interval type-2 fuzzy proportional derivative plus integral (IT2FPD+I) controllers is proposed for 5-DOF redundant robot manipulator for trajectory tracking task. All five controllers' parameters are optimized simultaneously. Further, a procedure for selecting appropriate initial search space is also demonstrated. In order to make a fair comparison between different controllers, the tuning of each of the controllers' parameters is done with GA. This optimization technique uses the time domain optimal tuning while minimizing the fitness function as the sum of integral of multiplication of time with square error (ITSE) for each joint. To ascertain the effectiveness of IT2FPID controller, it is compared against type-1 fuzzy PID (T1FPID) and conventional PID controllers. Furthermore, robustness testing of developed IT2FPID controller for external disturbances, parameter variations, and random noise rejection is also investigated. Finally, the experimental study leads us to claim that our proposed controller can not only assure best trajectory tracking in joint and Cartesian space, but also improves the robustness of the systems for external disturbances, parameter variations, and random noise.     

Genetic learning and performance evaluation of interval type-2 fuzzy logic controllers

Type-2 fuzzy sets, which are characterized by membership functions (MFs) that are themselves fuzzy, have been attracting interest. This paper focuses on advancing the understanding of interval type-2 fuzzy logic controllers (FLCs). First, a type-2 FLC is evolved using Genetic Algorithms (GAs). The type-2 FLC is then compared with another three GA evolved type-1 FLCs that have different design parameters. The objective is to examine the amount by which the extra degrees of freedom provided by antecedent type-2 fuzzy sets is able to improve the control performance. Experimental results show that better control can be achieved using a type-2 FLC with fewer fuzzy sets/rules so one benefit of type-2 FLC is a lower trade-off between modeling accuracy and interpretability.     

Automatic Tuning of a Fuzzy Visual System Using Evolutionary Algorithms: Single-Objective Versus Multiobjective Approaches

One of the main advantages of fuzzy systems is their ability to design comprehensible models of real-world systems, thanks to the use of a fuzzy rule structure easily interpretable by human beings. This is especially useful for the design of fuzzy logic controllers, where the knowledge base can be extracted from expert knowledge. Even more, the availability of a readable structure allows the human expert to customize the fuzzy controller to different environments by manually tuning its components. Nevertheless, this tuning task is usually a time-consuming procedure when done manually, especially when several measures are considered to evaluate the controller performance, and thus the interest in the design of automatic tuning procedures for fuzzy systems has increased along the last few years. In this paper, we tackle the tuning of the fuzzy membership functions of a fuzzy visual system for autonomous robots. This fuzzy visual system is based on a hierarchical structure of three different fuzzy classifiers, whose combined action allows the robot to detect the presence of doors in the images captured by its camera. Although the global knowledge represented in the fuzzy system knowledge base makes it perform properly in the door detection task, its adaptation to the specific conditions of the environment where the robot is operating can significantly improve the classification accuracy. However, the tuning procedure is complex as two different performance indexes are involved in the optimization process (true positive and false positive detections), thus becoming a multiobjective problem. Hence, in order to automatically put the fuzzy system tuning into effect, different single and multiobjective evolutionary algorithms are considered to optimize the two criteria, and their behavior in problem solving is compared.     

A type-2 fuzzy logic controller design for buck and boost DC–DC converters

Conventional (type-1) fuzzy logic controllers have been commonly used in various power converter applications. Generally, in these controllers, the experience and knowledge of human experts are needed to decide parameters associated with the rule base and membership functions. The rule base and the membership function parameters may often mean different things to different experts. This may cause rule uncertainty problems. Consequently, the performance of the controlled system, which is controlled with type-1 fuzzy logic controller, is undesirably affected. In this study, a type-2 fuzzy logic controller is proposed for the control of buck and boost DC–DC converters. To examine and analysis the effects of the proposed controller on the system performance, both converters are also controlled using the PI controller and conventional fuzzy logic controller. The settling time, the overshoot, the steady state error and the transient response of the converters under the load and input voltage changes are used as the performance criteria for the evaluation of the controller performance. Simulation results show that buck and boost converters controlled by type-2 fuzzy logic controller have better performance than the buck and boost converters controlled by type-1 fuzzy logic controller and PI controller.     

一类区间二型模糊PI控制器设计算法

区间二型模糊控制器在处理不确定性方面优于传统的模糊控制器,但带来的一个问题就是区间二型模糊控制器需要降阶过程。常用的KM等迭代式降阶算法效率低下,难以用于实时性较高的场合。本文利用直接降阶算法和动态解模糊化算法,提出了一类区间二型模糊PI控制器设计算法。该算法在降阶过程中考虑偏差和偏差变化量对控制器输出的影响,避免了KM等迭代式降阶过程。通过二阶迟延对象以及一个非线性对象的仿真实验表明,本文算法能够有效降低系统超调,降低系统的稳态时间,控制器在设定值附近的输出更为平滑。