Reflection and time-dependent computing: Experiences with the R2 architecture

In this paper we present an application of computational reflection in the programming oftime-dependent systems. A time-dependent system performs its tasks according to timing specifications specified within the system or imposed from outside the system. Reflective techniques can be applied to programming time-dependent systems because (1) some application programs require the introduction of a new language construct for specifying timing requirements and (2) different applications may require domain-specific scheduling algorithms. To allow a programmer to add or modify language constructs or scheduling algorithms, however, a clear reflective architecture and program interfaces must be provided. This paper proposes a concurrent object-based reflective architecture (R ² architecture) for time-dependent computing. This architecture is based on anindividual reflection scheme and introduces new meta-level objects (real-time meta objects) that are responsible for time-dependent capabilities. An alarm-clock object and a scheduler object are introduced, and message protocols between them and real-time meta objects are defined. We implemented this architecture on ABCL/R2 and created the Sampled Sound Player program as an application. With this application we provided three different scheduler objects and measured the impact of different scheduling algorithms on sound playback. The measured results show that a scheduler with more complex computations at the meta level exhibited less scheduling overhead, thus was capable of better sound playback. The other example, Time-dependent Graceful Degradation Scheme, demonstrates the programming of functionality degradation triggered by failure to satisfy timing specifications.     

Real-time refinement in Manna and Pnueli's temporal logic

A refinement calculus for the development of real-time systems is presented. The calculus is based upon a wide-spectrum language called TAM (the Temporal Agent Model), within which both functional and timing properties can be expressed in either abstract or concrete terms. A specification oriented semantics is given for the language. Program development is considered as a refinement process i.e. thecalculation of a structured program from an unstructured specification. An example program is developed.     

Online Scheduling of Parallel Programs on Heterogeneous Systems with Applications to Cilk

We study the problem of executing parallel programs, in particular Cilk programs, on a collection of processors of different speeds. We consider a model in which each processor maintains an estimate of its own speed, where communication between processors has a cost, and where all scheduling must be online. This problem has been considered previously in the fields of asynchronous parallel computing and scheduling theory. Our model is a bridge between the assumptions in these fields. We provide a new more accurate analysis of an old scheduling algorithm called the maximum utilization scheduler . Based on this analysis, we generalize this scheduling policy and define the high utilization scheduler . We next focus on the Cilk platform and introduce a new algorithm for scheduling Cilk multithreaded parallel programs on heterogeneous processors. This scheduler is inspired by the high utilization scheduler and is modified to fit in a Cilk context. A crucial aspect of our algorithm is that it keeps the original spirit of the Cilk scheduler. In fact, when our new algorithm runs on homogeneous processors, it exactly mimics the dynamics of the original Cilk scheduler.     

Chronological scheduling of transactions with temporal dependencies

Database applications often impose temporal dependencies between transactions that must be satisfied to preserve data consistency. The extant correctness criteria used to schedule the execution of concurrent transactions are either time independent or use strict, difficult to satisfy real-time constraints. On one end of the spectrum, serializability completely ignores time. On the other end, deadline scheduling approaches consider the outcome of each transaction execution correct only if the transaction meets its real-time deadline. In this article, we explore new correctness criteria and scheduling methods that capture temporal transaction dependencies and belong to, the broad area between these two extreme approaches. We introduce the concepts ofsuccession dependency andchronological dependency and define correctness criteria under which temporal dependencies between transactions are preserved even if the dependent transactions execute concurrently. We also propose achronological scheduler that can guarantee that transaction executions satisfy their chronological constraints. The advantages of chronological scheduling over traditional scheduling methods, as well as the main issues in the implementation and performance of the proposed scheduler, are discussed.     

Dynamic Scheduling and Fault-Tolerance: Specification and Verification

Considera distributed real-time program which is executed on a systemwith a limited set of hardware resources. Assume the programis required to satisfy some timing constraints, despite the occurrenceof anticipated hardware failures. For efficient use of resources,scheduling decisions must be taken at run-time, considering deadlines,the load and hardware failures. The paper demonstrates how toreason about such dynamically scheduled programs in the frameworkof a timed process algebra and modal logic. The algebra providesa uniform process encoding of programs, hardware and schedulers,with an operational semantics of a process depending on the assumptionsabout faults. The logic specifies the timing properties of aprocess and verifies them via this fault-affected semantics,establishing fault-tolerance. The approach lends itself to applicationof existing tools and results supporting reasoning in processalgebras and modal logics.     

Real-time task scheduling by multiobjective genetic algorithm

Real-time tasks are characterized by computational activities with timing constraints and classified into two categories: a hard real-time task and a soft real-time task. In hard real-time tasks, tardiness can be catastrophic. The goal of hard real-time tasks scheduling algorithms is to meet all tasks’ deadlines, in other words, to keep the feasibility of scheduling through admission control. However, in the case of soft real-time tasks, slight violation of deadlines is not so critical.In this paper, we propose a new scheduling algorithm for soft real-time tasks using multiobjective genetic algorithm (moGA) on multiprocessors system. It is assumed that tasks have precedence relations among them and are executed on homogeneous multiprocessor environment.The objective of the proposed scheduling algorithm is to minimize the total tardiness and total number of processors used. For these objectives, this paper combines adaptive weight approach (AWA) that utilizes some useful information from the current population to readjust weights for obtaining a search pressure toward a positive ideal point. The effectiveness of the proposed algorithm is shown through simulation studies.     

Real-time preemptive scheduling of sporadic tasks based on supervisory control of discrete event systems

This paper presents a preemptive scheduling scheme for real-time systems with sporadic tasks based on the supervisory control theory of discrete event systems. In particular, we present a systematic method of computing a schedulable language that includes all achievable sequences that meet the given deadlines of accepted sporadic tasks. A supervisor that achieves the schedulable language corresponds to a scheduler that can secure the deadlines of all accepted tasks. We further show that the schedulable language includes the decisions on whether a scheduler accepts or rejects a newly arrived sporadic task.     

基于Petri网的分布式实时调度模型研究

Petri网作为一种可视化的规格语言,越来越多地用于实时系统的评估和分析。该文提出了一种基于Petri网的分布式实时系统模型,并对该模型中的局部调度器和消息调度器进行了描述。根据该模型可以开发相应的分布式实时调度模拟器,这样就可以在系统的开发初期,利用模拟器来验证在给定的局部调度策略和消息调度策略下,系统任务的时间约束是否能够得到有效的保障。同时该模型还可以很容易地转化为系统的快速原型。     

Application‐specific thread schedulers for distributed applications

This paper describes our work to improve the performance of distributed applications. We aim at certain application characteristics such as balancing load, allowing separately written applications to work better together, allowing a distributed application to adapt its behavior in more flexible ways, and so on. Our approach is to write application‐specific schedulers, which can access the global state of the application in making scheduling decisions. To achieve this goal, we extended our earlier work on CATAPULTS ( C reating A nd T esting AP plication‐specific U ser L evel T hread S chedulers), a domain‐specific language for creating and testing application‐specific user‐level thread schedulers, to distributed applications by adding ‘master schedulers’ for dealing with the distributed parts of applications. This paper presents our design of, experimentation with, and implementation of distributed CATAPULTS. This paper presents several realistic examples to measure the feasibility of this approach, specifically: a website application, an embedded application, and load balancing. Each example has a scheduling goal for which we developed a customized scheduler. We measured the performance with and without the customized scheduler. The customized scheduler for each example was fairly straightforward to develop and each achieved its scheduling goal. Copyright © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

An optimal boundary fair scheduling algorithm for multiprocessor real-time systems

With the emergence of multicore processors, the research on multiprocessor real-time scheduling has caught more researchers’ attention recently. Although the topic has been studied for decades, it is still an evolving research field with many open problems. In this work, focusing on periodic real-time tasks with quantum-based computation requirements and implicit deadlines, we propose a novel optimal scheduling algorithm, namely boundary fair (Bfair), which can achieve full system utilization as the well-known Pfair scheduling algorithms. However, different from Pfair algorithms that make scheduling decisions and enforce proportional progress (i.e., fairness) for all tasks at each and every time unit, Bfair makes scheduling decisions and enforces fairness to tasks only at tasks’ period boundaries (i.e., deadlines of periodic tasks). The correctness of the Bfair algorithm to meet the deadlines of all tasks’ instances is formally proved and its performance is evaluated through extensive simulations. The results show that, compared to that of Pfair algorithms, Bfair can significantly reduce the number of scheduling points (by up to 94%) and the overhead of Bfair at each scheduling point is comparable to that of the most efficient Pfair algorithm (i.e., PD²). Moreover, by aggregating the time allocation of tasks for the time interval between consecutive period boundaries, the resulting Bfair schedule can dramatically reduce the number of required context switches and task migrations (as much as 82% and 85%, respectively) when compared to those of Pfair schedules, which in turn reduces the run-time overhead of the system.     

Nonpreemptive scheduling of periodic tasks in uni- and multiprocessor systems

In this paper we study the problem of scheduling a set of periodic tasks nonpreemptively in hard-real-time systems, where it is critical for all requests of the tasks to be processed in time. A taskT is characterized by itsarrival time A, itsperiod P, and itsexecution time C. Starting fromA, a new request ofT arrives in everyP units of time, requestingC units of processing time, and itsdeadline coincides with the arrival of the next request ofT. All requests must be processed nonpreemptively to meet their corresponding deadlines. We show that the problem of testing the feasibility of a given task set {T ¹,T ²,,T ⁿ} satisfyingP ₁₊₁=k_i p_i, wherek _i; is an integer 1 for 1i n–1, on a single processor is NP-hard in the strong sense, even if all tasks have the same arrival time. For task sets satisfyingP ⁱ⁺¹=K Pⁱ, whereK is an integer 2 for 1 i n–1 and all tasks have the same arrival time, we present linear-time (in the number of requests) optimal scheduling algorithms as well as linear-time (in the number of tasks, i.e.,n) algorithms for testing feasibility in both uniprocessor and multiprocessor systems. We also extend our results to more general task sets.     

Event-Triggered Real-Time Scheduling of Stabilizing Control Tasks

In this note, we revisit the problem of scheduling stabilizing control tasks on embedded processors. We start from the paradigm that a real-time scheduler could be regarded as a feedback controller that decides which task is executed at any given instant. This controller has for objective guaranteeing that (control unrelated) software tasks meet their deadlines and that stabilizing control tasks asymptotically stabilize the plant. We investigate a simple event-triggered scheduler based on this feedback paradigm and show how it leads to guaranteed performance thus relaxing the more traditional periodic execution requirements.     

Scheduling Threads for Low Space Requirement and Good Locality

The running time and memory requirement of a parallel program with dynamic, lightweight threads depends heavily on the underlying thread scheduler. In this paper we present a new asynchronous, space-efficient scheduling algorithm for shared memory machines that combines the low scheduling overheads and good locality of work stealing with the low space requirements of depth-first schedulers. For a nested-parallel program with depth D and serial space requirement S ₁ , we show that the expected space requirement is S ₁ + O(K⋅ p⋅ D) on p processors. Here, K is a user-adjustable runtime parameter, which provides a tradeoff between running time and space requirement. Our algorithm achieves good locality and low scheduling overheads by automatically increasing the granularity of the work scheduled on each processor. We have implemented the new scheduling algorithm in the context of a native, user-level implementation of Posix standard threads or Pthreads, and evaluated its performance using a set of C-based benchmarks that have dynamic or irregular parallelism. We compare the performance of our scheduler with that of two previous schedulers: the thread library's original scheduler (which uses a FIFO queue), and a provably space-efficient depth-first scheduler. At a fine thread granularity, our scheduler outperforms both these previous schedulers, but requires marginally more memory than the depth-first scheduler. We also present simulation results on synthetic benchmarks to compare our scheduler with space-efficient versions of both a work-stealing scheduler and a depth-first scheduler. The results indicate that unlike these previous approaches, the new algorithm covers a range of scheduling granularities and space requirements, and allows the user to trade the space requirement of a program with the scheduling granularity. Received June 11, 2000, and in revised form March 19, 2001, and in final form August 7, 2001. Online publication April 5, 2002.     

Processing real-time transactions in a replicated database system

A database system supporting a real-time application has to provide real-time information to the executing transactions. Each real-time transaction is associated with a timing constraint, typically in the form of a deadline. It is difficult to satisfy all timing constraints due to the consistency requirements of the underlying database. In scheduling the transactions it is aimed to process as many transactions as possible within their deadlines. Replicated database systems possess desirable features for real-time applications, such as a high level of data availability, and potentially improved response time for queries. On the other hand, multiple copy updates lead to a considerable overhead due to the communication required among the data sites holding the copies. In this paper, we investigate the impact of storing multiple copies of data on satisfying the timing constraints of real-time transactions. A detailed performance model of a distributed database system is employed in evaluating the effects of various workload parameters and design alternatives on the system performance. The performance is expressed in terms of the fraction of satisfied transaction deadlines. A comparison of several real-time concurrency control protocols, which are based on different approaches in involving timing constraints of transactions in scheduling, is also provided in performance experiments. Recommended by: A. ElmagarmidThis work was initiated while the author was at the Computer Science Department, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.     

On earliest deadline first scheduling for temporal consistency maintenance

A real-time object is one whose state may become invalid with the passage of time. A temporal validity interval is associated with the object state, and the real-time object is temporally consistent if its temporal validity interval has not expired. Clearly, the problem of maintaining temporal consistency of data is motivated by the need for a real-time system to track its environment correctly. Hence, sensor transactions must be able to execute periodically and also each instance of a transaction should perform the relevant data update before its deadline. Unfortunately, the period and deadline assignment problem for periodic sensor transactions has not received the attention that it deserves. An exception is the More-Less scheme, which uses the Deadline Monotonic (DM) algorithm for scheduling periodic sensor transactions. However, there is no work addressing this problem from the perspective of dynamic priority scheduling. In this paper, we examine the problem of temporal consistency maintenance using the Earliest Deadline First (EDF) algorithm in three steps: First, the problem is transformed to another problem with a sufficient (but not necessary) condition for feasibly assigning periods and deadlines. An optimal solution for the problem can be found in linear time, and the resulting processor utilization is characterized and compared to a traditional approach. Second, an algorithm to search for the optimal periods and deadlines is proposed. The problem can be solved for sensor transactions that require any arbitrary deadlines. However, the optimal algorithm does not scale well when the problem size increases. Hence, thirdly, we propose a heuristic search-based algorithm that is more efficient than the optimal algorithm and is capable of finding a solution if one exists.

On-line scheduling of scalable real-time tasks on multiprocessor systems

The computation time of scalable tasks depends on the number of processors allocated to them in multiprocessor systems. As more processors are allocated to a scalable task, the overall computation time of the task decreases but the total amount of processors’ time devoted to the execution of the task, called workload, increases due to parallel execution overhead. In this paper, we propose a task scheduling algorithm that utilizes the property of scalable tasks for on-line and real-time scheduling. In the proposed algorithm, the total workload of all scheduled tasks is reduced by managing processors allocated to the tasks as few as possible without missing their deadlines. As a result, the processors in the system have less load to execute the scheduled tasks and can execute more newly arriving tasks before their deadlines. Simulation results show that the proposed algorithm performs significantly better than the conventional algorithm based on a fixed number of processors to execute each task.     

RealNet: a neural network architecture for real-time systems scheduling

Real-time embedded systems are spreading to more and more new fields and their scope and complexity have grown dramatically in the last few years. Nowadays, real-time embedded computers or controllers can be found everywhere, both in very simple devices used in everyday life and in professional environments. Real-time embedded systems have to take into account robustness, safety and timeliness. The most-used schedulability analysis is the worst-case response time proposed by Joseph and Pandya (Comput J 29:390–395,1986). This test provides a bivaluated response (yes/no) indicating whether the processes will meet their corresponding deadlines or not. Nevertheless, sometimes the real-time designer might want to know, more exactly, the probability of the processes meeting their deadlines, in order to assess the risk of a failed scheduling depending on critical requirements of the processes. This paper presents RealNet, a neural network architecture that will generate schedules from timing requirements of a real-time system. The RealNet simulator will provide the designer, after iterating and averaging over some trials, an estimation of the probability that the system will not meet the deadlines. Moreover, the knowledge of the critical processes in these schedules will allow the designer to decide whether changes in the implementation are required.This revised version was published online in November 2004 with a correction to the accepted date.     

Preference-oriented real-time scheduling and its application in fault-tolerant systems

In this paper, we consider a set of real-time periodic tasks where some tasks are preferably executed as soon as possible (ASAP) and others as late as possible (ALAP) while still meeting their deadlines. After introducing the idea of preference-oriented (PO) execution, we formally define the concept of PO-optimality. For fully-loaded systems (with 100% utilization), we first propose a PO-optimal scheduler, namely ASAP-Ensured Earliest Deadline (SEED), by focusing on ASAP tasks where the optimality of ALAP tasks’ preference is achieved implicitly due to the harmonicity of the PO-optimal schedules for such systems. Then, for under-utilized systems (with less than 100% utilization), we show the discrepancies between different PO-optimal schedules. By extending SEED, we propose a generalized Preference-Oriented Earliest Deadline (POED) scheduler that can obtain a PO-optimal schedule for any schedulable task set. The application of the POED scheduler in a dual-processor fault-tolerant system is further illustrated. We evaluate the proposed PO-optimal schedulers through extensive simulations. The results show that, comparing to that of the well-known EDF scheduler, the scheduling overheads of SEED and POED are higher (but still manageable) due to the additional consideration of tasks’ preferences. However, SEED and POED can achieve the preference-oriented execution objectives in a more successful way than EDF.     

General purpose schedulers for database systems

Summary A family of simple models for database systems is defined, where a system is composed of a scheduler, a data manager and several user transactions. The basic correctness criterion for such systems is taken to be consistency preservation. The central notion of the paper is that of a general purpose scheduler, a database system scheduler that is blind to the semantics of transactions and integrity assertions. Consistency preservation of a database system is shown to be precisely equivalent to a restriction on the output of a general purpose scheduler GPS, called weak serializability. That is, any database system using GPS will preserve consistency iff the output of GPS is always weakly serializable. This establishes a tight connection between database system correctness and scheduler behavior. Also, aspects of restart facilities and predeclared data accesses are discussed. Finally, several examples of schedulers correct with respect to weak serializability are presented.