Efficient Packet Scheduling Using Channel Adaptive Fair Queueing in Distributed Mobile Computing Systems

In a distributed mobile computing system, an efficient packet scheduling policy is a crucial component to achieve a high utilization of the precious bandwidth resources while satisfying users' QoS (quality of service) demands. An important class of scheduling techniques, namely, the wireless fair queueing algorithms, have been extensively studied recently. However, a major drawback in existing approaches is that the channel model is overly simplified – a two-state channel (good or bad) is assumed. While it is relatively easy to analyze the system using such a simple model, the algorithms so designed are of a limited applicability in a practical environment, in which the level of burst errors is time-varying and can be exploited by using channel adaptive coding and modulation techniques. In this paper, we first argue that the existing algorithms cannot cater for a more realistic channel model and the traditional notion of fairness is not suitable. We then propose a new notion of fairness, which bounds the actual throughput normalized by channel capacity of any two data connections. Using the new fairness definition, we propose a new fair queueing algorithm called CAFQ (Channel Adaptive Fair Queueing), which, as indicated in our numerical studies, outperforms other algorithms in terms of overall system throughput and fairness among error prone connections.     

An Improved Round Robin Packet Scheduler for Wireless Networks

Scheduling algorithms are important components for providing quality-of-service (QoS) guarantees in wireless networks. The design of such algorithms need to take into account bursty errors and location-dependent channel capacity that are characteristics of wireless networks. In this paper, a new scheduling algorithm for packet cellular networks, wireless deficit round robin (WDRR), is proposed. WDRR is a round robin scheduler that has low implementation complexity and offers a low delay bound, tight fairness index, and good isolation property. In error-prone channels, the algorithm provides short-term fairness among sessions that perceive a clean channel, long-term fairness among all sessions, ability to meet specified throughput objectives for all sessions, and graceful service degradation among sessions that received excess service. Both analysis and simulation are used to verify the WDRR properties.     

Self-coordinating localized fair queueing in wireless ad hoc networks

Distributed fair queueing in a multihop, wireless ad hoc network is challenging for several reasons. First, the wireless channel is shared among multiple contending nodes in a spatial locality. Location-dependent channel contention complicates the fairness notion. Second, the sender of a flow does not have explicit information regarding the contending flows originated from other nodes. Fair queueing over ad hoc networks is a distributed scheduling problem by nature. Finally, the wireless channel capacity is a scarce resource. Spatial channel reuse, i.e., simultaneous transmissions of flows that do not interfere with each other, should be encouraged whenever possible. In this paper, we reexamine the fairness notion in an ad hoc network using a graph-theoretic formulation and extract the fairness requirements that an ad hoc fair queueing algorithm should possess. To meet these requirements, we propose maximize-local-minimum fair queueing (MLM-FQ), a novel distributed packet scheduling algorithm where local schedulers self-coordinate their scheduling decisions and collectively achieve fair bandwidth sharing. We then propose enhanced MLM-FQ (EMLM-FQ) to further improve the spatial channel reuse and limit the impact of inaccurate scheduling information resulted from collisions. EMLM-FQ achieves statistical short-term throughput and delay bounds over the shared wireless channel. Analysis and extensive simulations confirm the effectiveness and efficiency of our self-coordinating localized design in providing global fair channel access in wireless ad hoc networks.     

A Packet Scheduling Approach to QoS Support in Multihop Wireless Networks

Providing packet-level quality of service (QoS) is critical to support both rate-sensitive and delay-sensitive applications in bandwidth-constrained, shared-channel, multihop wireless networks. Packet scheduling has been a very popular paradigm to ensure minimum throughput and bounded delay access for packet flows. This work describes a packet scheduling approach to QoS provisioning in multihop wireless networks. Besides minimum throughput and delay bounds for each flow, our scheduling disciplines seek to achieve fair and maximum allocation of the shared wireless channel bandwidth. However, these two criteria can potentially be in conflict in a generic-topology multihop wireless network where a single logical channel is shared among multiple contending flows and spatial reuse of the channel bandwidth is possible. In this paper, we propose a new scheduling model that addresses this conflict. The main results of this paper are the following: (a) a two-tier service model that provides a minimum fair allocation of the channel bandwidth for each packet flow and additionally maximizes spatial reuse of bandwidth, (b) an ideal centralized packet scheduling algorithm that realizes the above service model, and (c) a practical distributed backoff-based channel contention mechanism that approximates the ideal service within the framework of the CSMA/CA protocol.     

无线网络中的分组调度算法

探讨了将有线网络的分组调度算法引入无线网络需要改进的事项,分析了公平排队算法,建立了一个基本的无线分组调度模型,并综述了一些目前存在的无线分组调度算法。     

一种支持服务类别的无线公平调度算法

本文提出了一种支持服务类别的无线公平调度算法:CoSB－WFS(基于服务类别的无线公平调度).算法区分不同的服务类别并可根据其业务需要进行不同的调度.考虑到无线信道的特殊性,算法引入了补偿和再分配模式.在仿真工具OPNET上模拟了算法并得到了性能改良的结果.     

Fair scheduling in wireless packet networks

Fair scheduling of delay and rate-sensitive packet flows over a wireless channel is not addressed effectively by most contemporary wireline fair-scheduling algorithms because of two unique characteristics of wireless media: (1) bursty channel errors and (2) location-dependent channel capacity and errors. Besides, in packet cellular networks, the base station typically performs the task of packet scheduling for both downlink and uplink flows in a cell; however, a base station has only a limited knowledge of the arrival processes of uplink flows. We propose a new model for wireless fair-scheduling based on an adaptation of fluid fair queueing (FFQ) to handle location-dependent error bursts. We describe an ideal wireless fair-scheduling algorithm which provides a packetized implementation of the fluid mode, while assuming full knowledge of the current channel conditions. For this algorithm, we derive the worst-case throughput and delay bounds. Finally, we describe a practical wireless scheduling algorithm which approximates the ideal algorithm. Through simulations, we show that the algorithm achieves the desirable properties identified in the wireless FFQ model     

QoS maintenance for fair queueing algorithms in wireless mobile networks

In order to extend fair queueing algorithms to wireless networks, we propose a channel error and handoff compensation scheme. A compensation is performed by a compensation server and a priority swapping mechanism. The proposed compensation scheme provides a short‐term fairness guarantee for an error‐free session, long‐term fairness guarantee for an erroneous session, fast handoff and traffic‐specific quality of service control. Copyright 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

A topology-independent wireless fair queueing model in ad hoc networks

Fair queueing of rate and delay-sensitive packet flows in a shared-medium, multihop wireless network is challenging due to the unique design issues. These issues include: 1) spatial contention among transmitting flows in a spatial locality, as well as spatial reuse of bandwidth through concurrent flow transmissions in different network locations; 2) conflicts between ensuring fairness and maximizing spatial channel reuse; and 3) the distributed nature of ad hoc fair queueing. In this paper, we propose a new topology-independent fair queueing model for a shared-medium ad hoc network. Our fairness model ensures coordinated fair channel access among spatially contending flows, while seeking to maximize spatial reuse of bandwidth. We describe packetized algorithms that realize the fluid fairness model with analytical performance bounds. We further design a distributed implementation which approximates the ideal centralized algorithm. We present simulations and analysis on the performance of our proposed algorithms.     

一种提高802.11无线Ad Hoc网络公平性的新机制-FFMA

实现多个数据流对无线信道的公平共享是802.11无线Ad Hoc网络中的一个重要议题,但802.11DCF机制在无线Ad Hoc网络中存在严重的公平性问题,甚至有可能出现单个节点或数据流独占信道而其他节点和数据流处于"饥饿"状态的情况.论文提出了一种新颖的保证数据流间公平性的MAC层接入机制FFMA(Flow rate-based Fair Medium Access),通过公平调度和公平竞争的方式,FFMA能够在数据流间公平地分配信道带宽资源.仿真结果表明,在无线Ad Hoc网络中,FFMA可以在保证信道吞吐量的前提下取得远优于802.11 DCF的数据流间的公平性.     

Efficient fair queueing algorithms for packet-switched networks

Although weighted fair queueing (WFQ) has been regarded as an ideal scheduling algorithm in terms of its combined delay bound and proportional fairness properties, its asymptotic time complexity increases linearly with the number of sessions serviced by the scheduler, thus limiting its use in high-speed networks. An algorithm that combines the delay and fairness bounds of WFQ with O(1) timestamp computations had remained elusive so far. In this paper we present two novel scheduling algorithms that have O(1) complexity for timestamp computations and provide the same bounds on end-to-end delay and buffer requirements as those of WFQ. The first algorithm, frame-based fair queueing (FFQ), uses a framing mechanism to periodically recalibrate a global variable tracking the progress of work in the system, limiting any short-term unfairness to within a frame period. The second algorithm, starting potential based fair queueing (SPFQ), performs the recalibration at packet boundaries, resulting in improved fairness while still maintaining the O(1) timestamp computations. Both algorithms are based on the general framework of rate-proportional servers (RPSs) introduced by Stiliadis and Varma (see ibid., vol.6, no.2, p.164-74, 1998). The algorithms may be used in both general packet networks with variable packet sizes and in asynchronous transfer mode (ATM) networks     

Rate-proportional servers: a design methodology for fair queueingalgorithms

Generalized processor sharing (GPS) has been considered as an ideal scheduling discipline based on its end-to-end delay bounds and fairness properties. Until recently, emulation of GPS in a packet server has been regarded as the ideal means of designing a packet-level scheduling algorithm to obtain low delay bounds and bounded unfairness. Strict emulation of GPS, as required in the weighted fair queueing (WFQ) scheduler, however, incurs a time-complexity of O(N) where N is the number of sessions sharing the link. Efforts in the past to simplify the implementation of WFQ, such as self-clocked fair queueing (SCFQ), have resulted in degrading its isolation properties, thus affecting the delay bound. We present a methodology for the design of scheduling algorithms that provide the same end-to-end delay bound as that of WFQ and bounded unfairness without the complexity of GPS emulation. The resulting class of algorithms, called rate-proportional servers (RPSs), are based on isolating scheduler properties that give rise to ideal delay and fairness behavior. Network designers can use this methodology to construct efficient fair-queueing algorithms, balancing their fairness with implementation complexity     

一种具有小尺度公平的无线分组调度算法

本文在调度判决时考虑到用户的访问时延限制,比例公平调度算法基础上提出了M-PF算法。本文建立了无线分组调度系统模型,通过仿真对新算法在小尺度服务时间保证、大尺度服务时间公平和系统吞吐量等方面的性能进行分析,研究了系统参数对算法性能的影响。结果证明,新算法在保证系统吞吐量和大尺度公平性的同时可以提供更好的小尺度服务时间保证。     

Analysis of minimum transmit sum power and scheduling power gain for multi‐user MIMO‐OFDM networks with rate constraints

Minimum transmit sum power (MTSP) is of high theoretical and practical value in multi‐user rate‐constrained systems; it is, however, quite difficult to be numerically characterized in complex channels for the prohibitively high computational power required. In this paper, we present a computationally efficient method to approximate the MTSP in multi‐user multiple‐input multiple‐output orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (MU‐MIMO‐OFDM) wireless networks. Specifically, we propose both lower and upper bounds of the MTSP, which are asymptotically accurate in the limit of large K, the number of users. Then, we develop two iterative water‐filling algorithms to numerically solve the proposed bounds. These algorithms are with low complexity, that is, linear in K, and therefore enable the analysis of MTSP in complex channels even if K is large. Numerical results demonstrate the effectiveness of the bounds in approximating the MTSP and the high computational efficiency of the proposed iterative water‐filling algorithms. With the proposed bounds, we further numerically study scheduling power gain (SPG), which is defined as MTSP reduction achieved by scheduling resources over multiple channel blocks in time domain. We simulate the SPG in different wireless environments defined in Third Generation Partnership Project spatial channel extended model and find insignificant SPG in some cases, indicating that the benefit from scheduling over multiple channel blocks is limited and simply allocating resources within the present channel is sufficient. Our analysis on the MTSP and SPG provides guidelines on the design of resource schedulers in MU‐MIMO‐OFDM networks. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Design and analysis of an algorithm for fair service in error‐prone wireless channels

In order to support diverse communication‐intensive real‐time and non‐real‐time data flows over a scarce, varying and shared wireless channel with location‐dependent and bursty errors, we define a service model that has the following characteristics: short‐term fairness among flows which perceive a clean channel, long‐term fairness for flows with bounded channel error, worst‐case delay bounds for packets, short‐term throughput bounds for flows with clean channels and long‐term throughput bounds for all flows with bounded channel error, expanded schedulable region, and support for both delay sensitive and error sensitive data flows. We present the wireless fair service algorithm, and show through both analysis and simulation that it achieves the requirements of the service model in typical wireless network environments. The key aspects of the algorithm are the following: (a) an enhanced fair queueing based service scheme that supports decoupling of delay and bandwidth, (b) graceful service compensation for lagging flows and graceful service degradation for leading flows, (c) support for real‐time delay sensitive flows as well as non‐real‐time error sensitive flows, and (d) an implementation within the framework of the simple and robust CSMA/CA wireless medium access protocol. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Analysis of performance trade-offs for an adaptive channel-aware wireless scheduler

In this paper, we consider the scheduling problem where data packets from K input-flows need to be delivered to K corresponding wireless receivers over a heterogeneous wireless channel. Our objective is to design a wireless scheduler that achieves good throughput and fairness performance while minimizing the buffer requirement at each wireless receiver. This is a challenging problem due to the unique characteristics of the wireless channel. We propose a novel idea of exploiting both the long-term and short-term error behavior of the wireless channel in the scheduler design. In addition to typical first-order Quality of Service (QoS) metrics such as throughput and average delay, our performance analysis of the scheduler permits the evaluation of higher-order metrics, which are needed to evaluate the buffer requirement. We show that variants of the proposed scheduler can achieve high overall throughput or fairness as well as low buffer requirement when compared to other wireless schedulers that either make use only of the instantaneous channel state or are channel-state independent in a heterogenous channel.     

Solving the trade-off between fairness and throughput: Token bucket and leaky bucket-based weighted fair queueing schedulers

In this article, we present two efficient weighted fair queueing (WFQ) scheduling algorithms leaned on the well-known token bucket and leaky bucket shaping/policing algorithms. The performance of the presented algorithms is compared to those of the state-of-the-art WFQ approximations such as weighted round robin (WRR) and the recently proposed bin sort fair queueing (BSFQ). Our simulation results show that the proposed algorithms provide a better fairness at a lower implementation complexity while simultaneously achieving a comparable network utilization.     

Latency-rate servers: a general model for analysis of trafficscheduling algorithms

We develop a general model, called latency-rate servers (ℒℛ servers), for the analysis of traffic scheduling algorithms in broadband packet networks. The behavior of an ℒℛ server is determined by two parameters-the latency and the allocated rate. Several well-known scheduling algorithms, such as weighted fair queueing, virtualclock, self-clocked fair queueing, weighted round robin, and deficit round robin, belong to the class of ℒℛ servers. We derive tight upper bounds on the end-to-end delay, internal burstiness, and buffer requirements of individual sessions in an arbitrary network of ℒℛ servers in terms of the latencies of the individual schedulers in the network, when the session traffic is shaped by a token bucket. The theory of ℒℛ servers enables computation of tight upper bounds on end-to-end delay and buffer requirements in a heterogeneous network, where individual servers may support different scheduling architectures and under different traffic models     

Soft QoS provisioning using the token bank fair queuing scheduling algorithm

Future-generation wireless packet networks will support multimedia applications with diverse QoS requirements. Much of the research on scheduling algorithms has been focused on hard QoS provisioning of integrated services. Although these algorithms give hard delay bounds, their stringent requirements sacrifice the potential statistical multiplexing performance and flexibility of the packet-switched network. Furthermore, the complexities of the algorithms often make them impractical for wireless networks. There is a need to develop a packet scheduling scheme for wireless packet-switched networks that provides soft QoS guarantees for heterogeneous traffic, and is also simple to implement and manage. This article proposes token bank fair queuing (TBFQ), a soft scheduling algorithm that possesses these qualities. This algorithm is work-conserving and has a complexity of O(1). We focus on packet scheduling on a reservation-based TDMA/TDD wireless channel to service integrated real-time traffic. The TBFQ scheduling mechanism integrates the policing and servicing functions, and keeps track of the usage of each connection. We address the impact of TBFQ on mean packet delay, violation probability, and bandwidth utilization. We also demonstrate that due to its soft provisioning capabilities, the TBFQ performs rather well even when traffic conditions deviate from the established contracts.     

Efficient algorithms for scheduling data broadcast

With the increasing acceptance of wireless technology, mechanisms to efficiently transmit information to wireless clients are of interest. The environment under consideration is asymmetric in that the information server has much more bandwidth available, as compared to the clients. It has been proposed that in such systems the server should broadcast the information periodically. A broadcast schedule determines what is broadcast by the server and when. This paper makes the simple, yet useful, observation that the problem of broadcast scheduling is related to the problem of fair queueing. Based on this observation, we present a log‐time algorithm for scheduling broadcast, derived from an existing fair queueing algorithm. This algorithm significantly improves the time‐complexity over previously proposed broadcast scheduling algorithms. Modification of this algorithm for transmissions that are subject to errors is considered. Also, for environments where different users may be listening to different number of broadcast channels, we present an algorithm to coordinate broadcasts over different channels. Simulation results are presented for proposed algorithms.