Perception of Beer Flavour Associates with Thermal Taster Status

Beer flavour, and thus much of the consumer experience of beer, is determined by the sensations elicited when it is taken into the mouth. Thus, individual differences in the perception of these oral sensations may contribute to the variation in consumer behaviour. A new taste phenotype shown to associate with the intensity of oral sensations elicited by simple solutions is thermal taster status (TTS). Thermal tasters (TTs) perceive ‘phantom’ tastes with thermal stimulation of the tongue, while thermal non‐tasters (TnTs) do not. Here, we investigate the effect of TTS on the perceived intensity of bitterness, sourness, sweetness, fullness, carbonation and overall flavour intensity elicited by seven beers representing classic styles — wheat beer, brown ale, pale ale, low‐alcohol lager, standard lager, high‐alcohol lager and stout. A strong trend was observed for TTs (n = 20) to rate attributes higher than TnTs (n = 20) for all beers except the stout, with these differences significant in many instances (ANOVA or binomial analysis). It is concluded that TTS may be an important determinant of individual differences in the perception of beer flavour, but beer liking and preference are more complex phenomena than can be accounted for by this phenotype alone.     

Gender differences in the influence of personality traits on spicy food liking and intake

It has been proposed, and only minimally explored, that personality factors may play a role in determining an individual’s sensitivity to and preference for capsaicin containing foods. We explored these relationships further here. Participants rated a number of foods and sensations on a generalized liking scale in a laboratory setting; after leaving the laboratory, they filled out an online personality survey, which included Arnett’s Inventory of Sensation Seeking (AISS) and the Sensitivity to Punishment and Sensitivity to Reward Questionnaire (SPSRQ). Recently, we reported strong and moderate correlations between the liking of a spicy meal and the personality constructs of Sensation Seeking (AISS) and Sensitivity to Reward (SPSRQ), respectively. Here, we use moderation models to explore the relationships between personality traits, perceived intensity of the burn of capsaicin, and the liking and consumption of spicy foods. Limited evidence of moderation was observed; however differential effects of the personality traits were seen in men versus women. In men, Sensitivity to Reward associated more strongly with liking and consumption of spicy foods, while in women, Sensation Seeking associated more strongly with liking and intake of spicy foods. These differences suggest that in men and women, there may be divergent mechanisms leading to the intake of spicy foods; specifically, men may respond more to extrinsic factors, while women may respond more to intrinsic factors.     

Analysis of total polyphenols,bitterness and haze in pale and dark lager beers produced under different mashing and boiling conditions

Malting and brewing processes should be performed under process conditions in a way that minimizes beer bitterness, maximizes polyphenol content and reduces the amount of raw materials ending up in solution in the form of hazes, particles and precipitates. This work examined the influence of different mashing temperature conditions and boiling procedures on the total polyphenol content, bitterness and haze of pale and dark lager beers produced on an industrial scale. Two hop types (hop pellets and/or hop extract) and different hop varieties (Hallertau Magnum, Styrian Goldings, Saaz, Aurora and Sladek) were utilized with varying times of hop addition into the wort. Measurements of total polyphenols, colour, bitterness, alcohol content, CO₂ and pH were carried out on the beer samples. Results showed that pale lager beers had a lower total polyphenol concentration (110–179 mg/L) than dark beers (230–260 mg/L). Using hop extracts instead of hop pellets led to a lower total polyphenol concentration and to less beer foam creation. The change in the proteolytic temperature during mashing only had an influence on the total polyphenol content in the pale lager beer hopped with the pellets. Conducting proteolysis over a 20 min period led to a haze increase in all of the beers produced. In the dark beer, the haze was substantial after just 10 min at 52°C. Copyright © 2015 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling     

Aging characteristics of different beer types

Eight commercial beers (3 lager beers, 2 dark ales and 3 high-alcoholic ales) were aged for one year under normal storage conditions, and the changes with time of flavour profile and the concentration of 15 volatile compounds were monitored. The compounds were chosen as markers to evaluate the importance of different reactions in the aging process of each beer type. The development of typical aging flavours during beer storage could be linked to the Maillard reaction, the formation of linear aldehydes, ester formation, ester degradation, acetal formation, etherification and the degradation of hop bitter compounds. A difference in the nature of aging flavours between lager and specialty beers was found and seemed to be mainly the result of an increased Maillard reaction in specialty beers. Based on the results, some practical strategies are proposed to improve the flavour stability, depending on the beer type.     

Relationships of Sensory Bitterness in Lager Beers to Iso‐α‐Acid Contents

Iso‐α‐acids and their chemically modified variants play a large role in evoking the bitter sensory attributes of lager character, but individual consumers may vary in their perception of bitterness. Sixteen lagers were scored in rank‐rating for bitterness by 14 trained assessors and the concentrations of the six bitter components in these beers were determined by high performance liquid chromatography. Relationships between bitterness intensity and the bitter components were modelled well using partial least square regression with a correlation value of 0.92. When 8 assessors carried out time‐intensity scoring of bitterness, profiles for single products were very different. However, single assessor profiles for multiple products showed qualitative similarities but quantitative differences. That individual assessors perceived bitter characters differently in relation to time has implications for new product development.     

Females' attitude and preference for beer: a conjoint analysis study

In order to sustain the fast‐expanding beer industry, companies need to attract new female consumers. The main objective of this study was to identify the extrinsic and intrinsic attributes that drive female consumers' purchase of beer. A literature review and focus group (n = 6) were conducted, and six attributes were identified as purchase drivers of beer. These attributes included flavour, appearance (colour), packaging, brand, production methods and beer style. These attributes were used to design a choice‐based conjoint analysis survey. The survey was administered to 277 females (aged 35.09 ± 15.2) residing in Nova Scotia (Canada). The results indicated that sweetness has a positive effect on liking. Bitterness has a strong negative effect on liking of beer. Black colour, stouts and macro‐brewed beers also had negative effects on liking of beer products. The consumer clusters showed that generally all of the consumer groups liked sweet beers with low bitterness.     

Draught beer hygiene: a survey of on‐trade quality

The quality of draught beer in 57 on‐trade licensed premises in 10 locations in the UK Midlands was assessed using a forcing test. Of 149 samples of standard lager (‘SL’, abv ≤ 4.2%), 44% were in the ‘excellent’ quality band compared with 16% of 88 samples of keg ale (‘KA’, abv ≤ 4.2%). Of the total of 237 samples, >90% were represented by two lager and two ale national brands. There were differences in the quality index (QI) between the brands, with lager SL3 having a QI of 84% compared with 72% for lager SL6, 71% for ale KA5 and 68% for ale KA1. The susceptibility of the four brands to spoilage was assessed using a challenge test with microorganisms taken from forced draught beer samples of the brands. Ale KA5 (challenge test QI = 87.5%) was the most resistant to spoilage followed by lager SL3 (81.3%), lager SL6 (75%) and ale KA1 (62.5%). Keg beers in accounts with a national cask beer quality accreditation had the same QI as those without accreditation. Analysis of price vs quality showed that the most expensive price band had the lowest quality. Draught beer quality declined as the number of dispense taps increased across the bar. It was also noted that dispense into branded half‐pint glasses had variable take‐up, with lager SL3 served in the correct branded glassware on 71% of occasions but only on 5% of occasions for lager SL6. None of the keg ales were served in correctly branded glassware. © 2018 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling     

Modification of perceived beer bitterness intensity,character and temporal profile by hop aroma extract

The effect of hop aroma on perceived bitterness intensity, character and temporal profile of beer was investigated. A hop aroma extract was added at 3 levels (0, 245, 490 mg/L) to beers at low, medium and high bitterness. Beers were evaluated for perceived bitterness intensity, harshness, roundedness and linger by a trained panel using a rank-rating technique at each bitterness level, with and without nose clips. The use of nose clips enabled the olfactory aspect to be decoupled from taste and mouthfeel aspects of bitterness perception. Results showed significant modification of perceived bitterness in beer by hop aroma depending on the inherent level of bitterness. These modifications were mainly driven by olfaction – in an example of taste-aroma interactions, as well as certain tactile sensations elicited by the hop aroma extract in the oral cavity. At low bitterness, beers with hop aroma added were perceived as more bitter, and of ‘rounded’ bitterness character relative to those without hop aroma. When judges used nose clips, this effect was completely eliminated but the sample was perceived to have a ‘harsh’ bitterness character. Conversely, at high bitterness, even when nose clips were used, judges still perceived beers containing hop aroma to be more bitter. These increases in bitterness perception with nose clips indicates the stimulating of other receptors, e.g. trigeminal receptors by hop aroma extract, which in tandem with the high bitterness, cause perceptual interactions enhancing bitterness intensity and also affecting bitterness character. Bitterness character attributes such as ‘round’ and ‘harsh’ were found to significantly depend on bitterness and aroma levels, with the second level of aroma addition (245 mg/L) giving a ‘rounded’ bitterness in low bitterness beers but ‘harsh’ bitterness in high bitterness beers. The impact of aroma on temporal bitterness was also confirmed with time-intensity measurements, and found to be mostly significant at the highest level of hop aroma addition (490 mg/L) in low bitterness beers. These findings represent a significant step forward in terms of understanding bitterness flavour perception and the wider impact of hop compounds on sensory perception.     

Flavour Instability of Pale Lager Beers: Determination of Analytical Markers in Relation to Sensory Ageing

Flavour changes of six Belgian pale lager beers were studied in order to estimate the importance of different parameters and reactions in relation to the ageing process. An attempt was made to link analytical data with sensory evaluation using multivariate statistical analysis. Partial least squares regression techniques (PLSR) were employed on the analytical and sensory data. As apparent from the PLSR model, significant indicators of lager beer ageing are aldehyde markers (especially total aldehydes, furfural, hexanal, 2‐methylpropanal, 2‐methylbutanal, and 3‐methylbutanal), cold and permanent haze, and beer colour. Conversely, compounds or parameters that load negatively in the PLSR model for beer ageing are trans‐isohumulones, cis‐isohumulones, total bitterness, the T/C‐ratio, polyphenolic markers (especially proanthocyanidins), the flavanoid content, and, to a lesser extent, the TB‐index and reducing power (TRAP). The integrated analytical‐sensorial methodology is proposed as a useful tool for evaluation of the flavour instability of pale lager beers.     

The role of sour and bitter perception in liking,familiarity and choice for phenol-rich plant-based foods

Among factors influencing food preferences and choices, individual differences in taste perception play a key role in defining eating behaviour. In particular, sour and bitter responsiveness could be associated with the acceptance and the consumption of phenol-rich plant-based foods recommended for a healthy diet. The aim of this study was to investigate, in a large population sample, the associations among sour and bitter responsiveness and liking, familiarity and choice for plant-based foods characterized by these target tastes. Adults aged 18 to 60 years (n = 1198; 58% women) were tested for their sour and bitter responsiveness both in water solutions and in food models (pear juice-based beverages modified in citric acid content to induce different levels of sourness: 0.5, 2.0, 4.0 and 8.0 g/kg; chocolate pudding samples modified in sucrose content to induce different levels of bitterness: 38, 83, 119, 233 g/kg). Familiarity, stated liking and choice for fruit juices and vegetables varying for sour/bitter taste (high in bitter/sour taste: e.g. grapefruit juice and cauliflower; low in bitter/sour taste: e.g. zucchini and pineapple juice) were measured. Results showed a significant positive correlation between bitter and sour taste perception in water solutions and model foods, as well as a positive correlation between the perceived intensity of the two taste stimuli. Subjects characterized by high responsiveness to the two target stimuli were found to give lower liking scores to foods characterized by sour/bitter tastes and tended to choose less sour/bitter foods compared to less responsive subjects.Thus, food choice for phenol rich plant-based products could be associated with a reduced responsiveness to bitter and sour tastes and a consequent higher acceptance of food products characterized by these taste qualities.     

CAPRYLIC FLAVOUR AS A FEATURE OF BEER FLAVOUR

Caprylic flavour is part of the distinctive overall flavour of a large proportion of beers in trade. The flavour occurs in the majority of lager beers and in about 20% of ales. It is correlated with the levels of octanoic acid and decanoic acid present in beer. Lager yeasts (S. uvarum) tend to liberate larger amounts of these two fatty acids during fermentation than do ale yeasts (S. cerevisiae). The flavour significance of these acids has been determined by correlating the results of sensory and instrumental analyses and also by adding the purified acids to beer. Implications of these two methods for assessing the flavour significance of chemical constituents of a complex product are discussed.     

USE OF EXTRACTS PREPARED WITH LIQUID CARBON DIOXIDE AS A SUBSTITUTE FOR DRY HOPS

Liquid carbon dioxide hop extracts were prepared for use as a substitute for dry hops. Many of these extracts were oil rich fractions containing up to 14% (w/w) hop oil. Extracts of Styrian Golding, Wye Target and Wye Northdown hops were used to treat ales prior to completion of beer processing and subsequent packaging. Emulsion/suspension systems were developed as carriers to facilitate addition of these extracts to beers before the chilling process. A loss of hop character from beer was found to occur during fining and filtration. Beers, treated with the extracts, exhibited natural though varietally distinct dry hop character. Production scale trials using these extracts have been successfully carried out to dry hop a brewery conditioned draught bitter and to match a traditionally dry hopped premium pale ale. The quantities of extract used indicated that economies in hop usage can be achieved when substituting liquid carbon dioxide hop extracts for dry hops.     

Supplementing hedonic and sensory consumer research on beer with cognitive and emotional measures,and additional insights via consumer segmentation

A consumer-based multivariate approach to the study of eight commercial beers (mass-produced, speciality and craft) was undertaken in New Zealand with ∼200 people. The beers spanned a wide range of sensory characteristics, from traditional lager and ale styles to high flavour impact beers with novel flavours (e.g. liquorice and rosemary) and less common styles (weisse and gose). These flavour differences were a larger driver of consumers’ hedonic/emotional/cognitive responses than alcohol content, which ranged from 0.5 to 7.2% alcohol by volume (ABV). The supplementation of hedonic and perceptual measures with emotional and cognitive variables resulted in a more detailed differentiation of products, which was further enhanced by consumer segmentation. In the rapidly evolving beer market, there is significant value in product-focused consumer research that delivers insights “beyond liking” and provide a deeper level of understanding about consumers’ product experiences. The research also contributed methodologically to the multivariate approach by considering pros and cons of study implementation aspects such as free-listing and ballot length. This will benefit future researchers in study planning and execution.     

Alterations of the Profiles of Iso‐α‐Acids During Beer Ageing,Marked Instability of Trans‐Iso‐α‐Acids and Implications for Beer Bitterness Consistency in Relation to Tetrahydroiso‐α‐Acids

Age‐induced decomposition of iso‐α‐acids, the main bittering principles of beer, determines the consistency of the beer bitter taste. In this study, the profiles of iso‐α‐acids in selected high‐quality top‐fermented and lager beers were monitored by quantitative high‐performance liquid chromatography at various time intervals during ageing. The degradation of the iso‐α‐acids as a function of time is represented by the ratio, in percentage, of the sum of the concentrations of trans‐isocohumulone and trans‐isohumulone to the sum of the concentrations of cis‐isocohumulone and cis‐isohumulone. This parameter is relevant with respect to the evaluation of bitterness deterioration in aged beers. Trans‐iso‐α‐acids having a shelf half‐life of less than one year proved to be significantly less stable than cis‐iso‐α‐acids, but it appears feasible to counteract degradation if a suitable beer matrix is available. The fate of the trans‐iso‐α‐acids in particular adversely affects beer bitterness consistency. In addition to using hop products containing low amounts of trans‐iso‐α‐acids, brewers may profit of the remarkable stability of tetrahydroiso‐α‐acids, even on prolonged storage, for the production of consistently bitter beers.     

A study of beer bitterness loss during the various stages of the Romanian beer production process

Beer is one of the oldest known alcoholic beverages produced by a yeast fermentation of a cereal extract that was germinated in water beforehand. The bitter taste of beer comes from the group of substances introduced during wort boiling, which are the extracted components of hops. The aim of this study was to determine some characteristics of beer (original extract, alcohol content, colour, pH, total acidity, carbon dioxide and bitterness values) during the three stages of the beer production process in a typical Romanian brewery. Measurements were carried out on 60 samples of beers, 10 measurements for each step of the process examining wort, unfiltered fermented beer and bottled beer (final product) from two different types of beer (light and dark). Statistical process control of the beer was performed. Losses in the bitterness units during the production process were between 24.7 and 41.54%, reported in terms of final product. Copyright © 2013 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling     

NITROSAMINES IN ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES

A limited survey was carried out to determine the nitrosamine content of several varieties of alcoholic beverages (beer and ale, whiskey, wine, cider, etc.) sold in Canada. Of 22 samples of different beers and ales analyzed all but one contained traces of dimethylnitrosamine; the overall mean level found was 1.5 ppb. Only one Canadian rye and one Scotch whiskey out of a total of 13 samples contained traces of either dimethylnitrosamine or diethylnitrosamine. All the 8 wines and 7 cider samples were negative.     

COMPARISON OF TIME-INTENSITY WITH CATEGORY SCALING OF BITTERNESS OF ISO-α-ACIDS IN MODEL SYSTEMS AND IN BEER*

A 17-point non-numerical category scale indicated a direct, linear relationship between average perceived bitterness and concentration of iso-α-acids in water and in a commercial lager. Time-intensity (T-I) tracings yielded additional information: the rate of increase in bitterness after taking the sample into the mouth; the rate of decrease after reaching maximum intensity; the events associated with swallowing; and total duration, which ranged from 13 to 42 s across judges. The T-I curves revealed a burst of bitterness intensity immediately after swallowing, which was proportional to the concentration of iso-α-acids for water solutions, but not for beer. Addition of 2.6% ethyl alcohol to the lager enhanced bitterness, particularly at low levels of added iso-α-acids, whereas addition of 2.0% glucose reduced bitterness in the control as well as in beer with added iso-α-acids. In water, 20 and 30 ppm of iso-α-acids were more bitter and had a longer duration than in beer. Among judges there were marked differences in the patterns of the T-I tracings, but there was excellent reproducibility within judges across replications.