XPS, TOF-SIMS, NEXAFS, and SPR characterization of nitrilotriacetic acid-terminated self-assembled monolayers for controllable immobilization of proteins

For immobilization of proteins onto surfaces in a specific and controlled manner, it is important to start with a well-defined surface that contains specific binding sites surrounded by a nonfouling background. For immobilizing histidine-tagged (his-tagged) proteins, surfaces containing nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA) headgroups and oligo(ethylene glycol) (OEG) moieties are a widely used model system. The surface composition, structure, and reactivity of mixed NTA/OEG self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) on Au substrates were characterized in detail using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), near-edge X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy (NEXAFS), time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS), and surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensoring. XPS results for sequential adsorption of NTA thiols followed by OEG thiols showed that OEG molecules were incorporated into an incompletely formed NTA monolayer until a complete mixed SAM was formed. The surface concentration of NTA headgroups was estimated to be 0.9-1.3 molecule/nm2 in the mixed NTA/OEG monolayers, compared to 1.9 molecule/nm2 in pure NTA monolayers. Angle-dependent XPS indicated NTA headgroups were slightly reoriented toward an upright position after OEG incorporation, and polarization-dependent NEXAFS results indicated increased ordering of the alkane chains of the molecules. Nitrogen-containing and OEG-related secondary ion fragments from the TOF-SIMS experiments confirmed the presence of NTA headgroups and OEG moieties in the monolayers. A multivariate peak intensity ratio was developed for estimating the relative NTA concentration in the outermost (10 A) of the monolayers. SPR measurements of a his-tagged, humanized anti-lysozyme variable fragment (HuLys Fv) immobilized onto Ni(II)-treated mixed NTA/OEG and pure NTA monolayers demonstrated the reversible, site-specific immobilization of his-tagged HuLys Fv (108-205 ng/cm2) with dissociation rates (koff) between 1.0 x 10-4 and 2.1 x 10-5 s-1, both depending on the NTA surface concentration and orientation. The monolayers without Ni(II) treatment exhibited low nonspecific adsorption of his-tagged HuLys Fv (<2 ng/cm2).     

Direct immobilization of protein g variants with various numbers of cysteine residues on a gold surface

Protein G is an antibody binding protein, which specifically targets the Fc region of an antibody. It therefore has been widely used to immobilize different types of antibodies in numerous immunoassays. Here, we have engineered Streptococcus protein G to contain various numbers of cysteine residues at the N-terminus and therefore to form well-oriented protein G films on bare gold. SPR and SPR imaging analyses indicated that a gold surface treated with cysteine-tagged protein G possesses a superior antibody binding ability compared to one treated with tag-free protein G. AFM images indicated a higher surface coverage by antibody binding on the cysteine-tagged protein G surface than the intact protein G surface. The proper orientation of cysteine-tagged protein G on a gold surface also afforded better orientation of immobilized antibodies, resulting in enhanced antigen detection. Moreover, the protein G surfaces maintained their high antibody binding ability during multiple rounds of antibody interaction tests. The cysteine-tagged protein G constructed in this study can be a valuable link for oriented antibody immobilization in a variety of immunosensors.     

TOF-SIMS and principal component analysis characterization of the multilayer surface grafting of small molecules: antibacterial furanones

Furanone compounds (fimbrolides) have attracted interest as antibacterial compounds for use in human health care, for instance, as an antibacterial coating for medical devices to combat device-centered infections. To ensure effectiveness for extended periods of time, they must be immobilized covalently onto a device surface; in this study, this was done via azide/nitrene chemistry and photochemical coupling. However, the detection and quantification of surface-immobilized small molecules such as furanones presents a considerable analytical challenge, yet is necessary for optimization of coatings and reliable interpretation of biological responses. We have utilized the surface sensitivity and chemical specificity of time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) to characterize each step of the grafting sequence. On account of the complexity of the data, principal component analysis (PCA) was used to interpret and compare spectra. The results demonstrate the utility of TOF-SIMS with PCA for the detection of the surface-grafted small molecules azidoaniline and a brominated furanone; imaging of the bromine ion peaks also enabled assessment of grafting uniformity. Thus, successful multilayer coating and furanone grafting was observed, and substantial and uniform coverage of furanone molecules on the surface. Even multiple grafting steps involving, in the present case, two low molecular weight compounds can readily be disentangled by PCA. The utility of TOF-SIMS analysis with PCA is particularly well illustrated in the present case by the grafting of the furanone molecules, which did not yield a singular unique peak in the positive ion mass spectra, whereas the collective spectral changes elucidated by PCA provided unambiguous verification of successful grafting of this low molecular weight compound.     

Surface-immobilized peptide aptamers as probe molecules for protein detection

We demonstrate the use of surface-immobilized, oriented peptide aptamers for the detection of specific target proteins from complex biological solutions. These peptide aptamers are target-specific peptides expressed within a protein scaffold engineered from the human protease inhibitor stefin A. The scaffold provides stability to the inserted peptides and increases their binding affinity owing to the resulting three-dimensional constraints. A unique cysteine residue was introduced into the protein scaffold to allow orientation-specific surface immobilization of the peptide aptamer and to ensure exposure of the binding site to the target solution. Using dual-polarization interferometry, we demonstrate a strong relationship between binding affinity and aptamer orientation and determine the affinity constant KD for the interaction between an oriented peptide aptamer ST(cys+)_(pep9) and the target protein CDK2. Further, we demonstrate the high selectivity of the peptide aptamer STM_(pep9) by exposing surface-immobilized ST(cys+)_(pep9) to a complex biological solution containing small concentrations of the target protein CDK2.     

Enhanced TOF-SIMS imaging of a micropatterned protein by stable isotope protein labeling

Patterning of biomolecules on surfaces is an increasingly important technological goal. Because the fabrication of biomolecule arrays often involves stepwise, spatially resolved derivatization of surfaces, spectroscopic imaging of these arrays is important in their fabrication and optimization. Although imaging time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) is a powerful method for spatially resolved surface analysis, TOF-SIMS images of micropatterned proteins on organic substrates can be difficult to acquire, because of the lack of high intensity, protein-specific molecular ions that are essential for imaging under static conditions. In contrast, low-mass ions are of suitable intensity for imaging, but can originate from different chemical species on the surface. A potential solution to this problem is to utilize stable isotope labeled proteins, an approach that has heretofore not been explored in TOF-SIMS imaging of micropatterned proteins and peptides. To investigate the feasibility of stable isotope enhanced TOF-SIMS imaging of proteins, we synthesized 15N-labeled streptavidin by labeling of the protein during expression from a recombinant gene. The spatial distribution of streptavidin bound to biotin micropatterns, fabricated on a polymer and on a self-assembled monolayer on gold, was imaged by TOF-SIMS. Imaging of high-intensity, low-m/z secondary ions (e.g., C15N-) unique to streptavidin enabled unambiguous spatial mapping of the micropatterned protein with a lateral resolution of a few micrometers. TOF-SIMS imaging of micropatterned 15N-labeled streptavidin also illustrated the exquisite sensitivity of TOF-SIMS to low fractional coverage of protein (5 A effective thickness) in the background regions of the protein micropattern.     

Structure and DNA hybridization properties of mixed nucleic acid/maleimide-ethylene glycol monolayers

The surface structure and DNA hybridization performance of thiolated single-strand DNA (HS-ssDNA) covalently attached to a maleimide-ethylene glycol disulfide (MEG) monolayer on gold have been investigated. Monolayer immobilization chemistry and surface coverage of reactive ssDNA probes were studied by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry. Orientation of the ssDNA probes was determined by near-edge X-ray absorption fine structure (NEXAFS). Target DNA hybridization on the DNA-MEG probe surfaces was measured by surface plasmon resonance (SPR) to demonstrate the utility of these probe surfaces for detection of DNA targets from both purified target DNA samples and complex biological mixtures such as blood serum. Data from complementary techniques showed that immobilized ssDNA density is strongly dependent on the spotted bulk DNA concentration and buffer ionic strength. Variation of the immobilized ssDNA density had a profound influence on the DNA probe orientation at the surface and subsequent target hybridization efficiency. With increasing surface probe density, NEXAFS polarization dependence results (followed by monitoring the N 1s --> pi* transition) indicate that the immobilized ssDNA molecules reorient toward a more upright position on the MEG monolayer. SPR assays of DNA targets from buffer and serum showed that DNA hybridization efficiency increased with decreasing surface probe density. However, target detection in serum was better on the "high-density" probe surface than on the "high-efficiency" probe surface. The amounts of target detected for both ssDNA surfaces were several orders of magnitude poorer in serum than in purified DNA samples due to nonspecific serum protein adsorption onto the sensing surface.     

Self-directed and self-oriented immobilization of antibody by protein G-DNA conjugate

A versatile biolinker for efficient antibody immobilization was prepared by site-specific coupling of protein G to DNA oligonucleotide. This protein G-DNA conjugate ensures the controlled immobilization of an antibody to the intended area on the surface of bioassay chips or particles, while maintaining the activity and orientation of the bound antibody. Streptococcus protein G tagged with a cysteine residue at the N-terminus was chemically linked to amine-modified, single-stranded DNA. SPR analysis indicated that the protein G-DNA conjugates sequence-specifically bind to complementary surface-bound DNA probes. More importantly, the resulting protein G, which is hybridized onto the DNA surface, possesses a greater antibody/antigen binding ability than even properly oriented protein G linked on the chip surface by chemical bonding. Antibody targeting on glass slides could also be achieved by using this linker system without modifying or spotting antibodies. Moreover, the protein G-DNA conjugate provided a simple but effective method to label DNA-functionalized gold nanoparticles with target antibodies. The DNA-linked protein G construct introduced in this study offers a useful strategy to manage antibody immobilization in many immunoassay systems.     

Ellipsometry analysis of conformational change of immobilized protein monolayer on plasma polymer surfaces

The conformational stability of surface immobilized protein monolayers is a key issue in applications requiring preservation of the protein bioactivity such as in biosensors and in vivo implants. Ellipsometry was used to detect conformational changes in a single monolayer of immobilized proteins on plasma polymer surfaces. The areal mass density of immobilized proteins was used to validate the data analysis in the protein denaturation analysis. We observed that the rate of conformation change was strongly dependent on the properties of the immobilized protein. Immobilized catalase showed a significantly slower denaturation rate than the immobilized horseradish peroxidase, indicating that the tetramer catalase is more stable than the immobilized monomer horseradish peroxidase at the surface/air interfaces. The ellipsometry results were in a good agreement with the enzyme activity analysis.     

Fabrication of a reversible protein array directly from cell lysate using a stimuli-responsive polypeptide

We report a new method to reversibly bind proteins to a surface in a functionally active orientation directly from cell lysate by exploiting a thermodynamically reversible hydrophilic-hydrophobic lower critical solution temperature (LCST) transition exhibited by a recombinant, stimuli-responsive elastin-like polypeptide (ELP). An ELP is covalently micropatterned on a glass surface against an inert BSA background. The ELP-patterned surface is incubated with the soluble fraction of E. coli lysate containing an expressed ELP fusion protein, which is appended with the same ELP as on the surface. The LCST transition of the grafted ELP and the ELP fusion protein is simultaneously triggered by an external stimulus. The LCST transition results in capture of the ELP fusion protein from solution onto the immobilized ELP by hydrophobic interactions between the grafted ELP and the ELP fusion protein. The captured ELP fusion protein is oriented such that the fusion partner is accessible to binding of its target from solution. We also demonstrate that TRAP is reversible; the bound protein-ligand complex is released from the surface by reversing the LCST transition. The triggered control of interfacial properties provided by an immobilized stimuli-responsive polypeptide at the solid-water interface is an enabling technology that allows reversible and functional presentation of ELP fusion proteins on a surface directly from cell lysate without the necessity of intermediate purification steps and subsequent recovery of the protein-ligand complex for downstream analysis by other analytical techniques. TRAP has application in lab-on-a-chip bioanalytical devices as well as in the fabrication of peptide and protein arrays.     

Significance of antibody orientation unraveled: well-oriented antibodies recorded high binding affinity

To investigate the effect of antibody orientation on its immunological activities, we developed a novel and versatile platform consisting of a well-defined phospholipid polymer surface on which staphylococcal protein A (SpA) was site-selectively immobilized. The application of a biocompatible phospholipid-based platform ensured minimal denaturation of immobilized antibodies, and the site-selective immobilization of SpA clarified the effect of antibody orientation on immunological activities. The phospholipid polymer platform was prepared on silicon substrates using the surface-initiated atom transfer radical polymerization (SI-ATRP) technique. An enzymatic reaction was performed for orientation-selective coupling of SpA molecules to the polymer brush surface. Orientation-controlled antibodies were achieved using enzymatic reactions, and these antibodies captured 1.8 ± 0.1 antigens on average, implying that at least 80% of immobilized antibodies reacted with two antigens. Theoretical multivalent binding analysis further revealed that orientation-controlled antibodies had antigen-antibody reaction equilibrium dissociation constants (K(d)) as low as 8.6 × 10(-10) mol/L, whereas randomly oriented and partially oriented antibodies showed K(d) values of 2.0 × 10(-7) and 1.2 × 10(-7) mol/L, respectively. Strict control of antibody orientation not only formed an approximately 100-fold stronger antigen-antibody complex than the controls but also sustained the native antibody K(d) (10(-10)-10(-9) mol/L). These findings support the significance of antibody orientation because controlling the orientation resulted in high reactivity and theoretical binding capacity.     

Interpretation of static time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectra of adsorbed protein films by multivariate pattern recognition

Multivariate analysis has become increasingly common in the analysis of multidimensional spectral data. We previously showed that the multivariate analysis technique principal component analysis (PCA) is an excellent method for interpreting the static time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) spectra of adsorbed protein films. PCA is an unsupervised pattern recognition technique that loses resolution between spectra of different proteins as more proteins are added to the data set due to large within-group variation. The supervised pattern recognition techniques discriminant principal component analysis (DPCA) and linear discriminant analysis (LDA), which aim to control within-group variation while maximizing between-group separation to enhance discrimination between groups, were compared with PCA using data sets of TOF-SIMS spectra of proteins adsorbed onto mica and PTFE substrates. DPCA and LDA quantitatively improved discrimination between groups and provided different information about the data than PCA. LDA was able to classify unknown samples with a misclassification rate lower than PCA or DPCA. Both unsupervised and supervised pattern recognition techniques are useful for the interpretation and classification of static TOF-SIMS spectra of adsorbed protein films.     

Controlled and oriented immobilization of protein by site-specific incorporation of unnatural amino acid

Immobilization of proteins in a functionally active form and proper orientation is crucial for effective surface-based analysis of proteins. Here we present a general method for controlled and oriented immobilization of protein by site-specific incorporation of unnatural amino acid and click chemistry. The utility and potential of this method was demonstrated by applying it to the analysis of interaction between a pathogenic protein DrrA of Legionella pneumophila and its binding partner Rab1 of human. Kinetic analysis of Rab1 binding onto the DrrA-immobilized surfaces using surface plasmon resonance revealed that immobilization of site-specifically biotinylated DrrA results in about 10-fold higher sensitivity in binding assay than the conventional immobilization of DrrA with random orientation. The present method is expected to find wide applications in the fields of the surface-based studies of protein-protein (or ligand) interactions, drug screening, biochip, and single molecule analysis.     

A model study of artificial linker system using self-assembled calix[4]arene derivative monolayers for protein immobilization

The attachment of biomolecules, in particular proteins, onto solid supports is fundamental in the development of advanced biosensors, biochips, bioreactors, and many diagnostic techniques. In addition, the effective investigation of biomolecular structure and function with chip-based modern instruments often requires effective attachment of the biomolecule to a substrate. For this reason, it is very important to construct well-characterized linker system that can immobilize protein efficiently. Here, we investigate the formation of self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) with calix[4]arene ethylester and carboxylic acid derivatives that can serve as a model system for protein immobilization at solid surfaces. The calix[4]arene derivative monolayers were formed on Au surface and carefully characterized by atomic force microscopy (AFM), Fourier transform infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy (FTIR-RAS) and surface plasmon resonance (SPR). Immobilization process of protein using bovine serum albumin (BSA) on the artificial linker layer was measured by SPR. The surface concentration of BSA was calculated by simulation of experimental SPR data. The surface concentration of BSA on the carboxylic acid form was higher than that of the ethylester. These results can help in modeling and understanding of protein immobilization on the linker layer.     

Systematic investigation of optimal aptamer immobilization for protein-microarray applications

Aptamers are short single-stranded DNA or RNA oligonucleotides that can bind to a wide range of target molecules with high affinity and specificity. As nucleic acids, aptamers can undergo denaturation, but the process is reversible. As a result of this stability and the possibility of automated selection of aptamers, these oligonucleotides are highly promising capture molecules in microarray formats. In this study, his-tagged proteins and an aptamer directed against the his-tag were chosen as a model system. Different factors affect the activity of aptamers immobilized on a solid support like a microarray surface. The orientation of the immobilized aptamer plays an important role in correct aptamer folding and, thus, in effective binding of the corresponding target. Other important parameters identified in this work are the microarrays' surface charge as well as the length of the spacer between aptamer and solid support. These parameters were investigated systematically, resulting in the development of an aptamer-based microarray for detection of his-tagged proteins. The general applicability of the developed immobilization strategy was demonstrated by utilization of three different aptamers.     

Fabrication of histidine-tagged fusion protein arrays for surface plasmon resonance imaging studies of protein-protein and protein-DNA interactions

The creation and characterization of histidine-tagged fusion protein arrays using nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA) capture probes on gold thin films for the study of protein-protein and protein-DNA interactions is described. Self-assembled monolayers of 11-mercaptoundecylamine were reacted with the heterobifunctional linker N-succinimidyl S-acetylthiopropionate (SATP) to create reactive sulfhydryl-terminated surfaces. NTA capture agents were immobilized by reacting maleimide-NTA molecules with the sulfhydryl surface. The SATP and NTA attachment chemistry was confirmed with Fourier transform infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy. Oriented protein arrays were fabricated using a two-step process: (i) patterned NTA monolayers were first formed through a single serpentine poly(dimethylsiloxane) microchannel; (ii) a second set of parallel microchannels was then used to immobilize multiple His-tagged proteins onto this pattern at discrete locations. SPR imaging measurements were employed to characterize the immobilization and specificity of His-tagged fusion proteins to the NTA surface. SPR imaging measurements were also used with the His-tagged fusion protein arrays to study multiple antibody-antigen binding interactions and to monitor the sequence-specific interaction of double-stranded DNA with TATA box-binding protein. In addition, His-tagged fusion protein arrays created on gold surfaces were also used to monitor antibody binding with fluorescence microscopy in a sandwich assay format.     

Exploring the surface sensitivity of TOF-secondary ion mass spectrometry by measuring the implantation and sampling depths of Bi(n) and C60 ions in organic films

The surface sensitivity of Bi(n)(q+) (n = 1, 3, 5, q = 1, 2) and C(60)(q+) (q = 1, 2) primary ions in static time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) experiments were investigated for molecular trehalose and polymeric tetraglyme organic films. Parameters related to surface sensitivity (impact crater depth, implantation depth, and molecular escape depths) were measured. Under static TOF-SIMS conditions (primary ion doses of 1 × 10(12) ions/cm(2)), the 25 keV Bi(1)(+) primary ions were the most surface sensitive with a molecular escape depth of 1.8 nm for protein films with tetraglyme overlayers, but they had the deepest implantation depth (~18 and 26 nm in trehalose and tetraglyme films, respectively). The 20 keV C(60)(+2) primary ions were the second most surface sensitive with a slightly larger molecular escape depth of 2.3 nm. The most important factor that determined the surface sensitivity of the primary ion was its impact crater depth or the amount of surface erosion. The most surface sensitive primary ions, Bi(1)(+) and C(60)(+2), created impact craters with depths of 0.3 and 1.0 nm, respectively, in tetraglyme films. In contrast, Bi(5)(+2) primary ions created impact craters with a depth of 1.8 nm in tetraglyme films and were the least surface sensitive with a molecular escape depth of 4.7 nm.     

Residue-specific immobilization of protein molecules by size-selected clusters

The atomic force microscope (AFM), operating in contact mode, has been employed in buffer solution to study two proteins; (i) green fluorescent protein (GFP), from the hydromedusan jellyfish Aequorea victoria; and (ii) human oncostatin M (OSM), in the presence of size-selected gold nanoclusters pinned on to a highly oriented pyrolytic graphite substrate. The AFM images have revealed immobilization of single molecules of OSM, which are strongly bound to the gold nanoclusters. Conversely, no strong immobilization has been observed for the GFP, as these molecules were easily displaced by the scanning tip. The contrasting behaviour of the two proteins can be explained by the exposed molecular surface area of their cysteine residues as modelled on the basis of their respective X-ray crystallographic data structures. GFP contains two cysteine residues, but neither is readily available to chemisorb on the gold clusters, because the cysteines are largely inaccessible from the surface of the protein. In contrast, OSM has a total of five cysteine residues, with different degrees of accessibility, which make the protein amenable to anchoring on the nanoclusters. Statistical analysis of the height of the OSM molecules bound to the nanoclusters is in accordance with crystallographic data, and suggests various configurations of the proteins on the clusters, associated with the presence of different cysteine anchoring sites. These results suggest that the three-dimensional conformation of protein molecules is preserved when they are chemisorbed to size-selected gold clusters, thus opening a new route towards oriented immobilization of individual protein molecules.     

Nanoscale fabrication of myoglobin monolayer on self-assembled DTSSP for bioelectronic device

The fabrication method of nanoscale myoglobin monolayer using chemical linker is introduced in this study because control of amount and orientation of protein immobilized on electronic device is one of main issues to be solved for the realization of biomolecular electronic device. Myoglobin, metalloprotein, is selected as active material due to its electrochemical property. To immobilize myoglobin on Au surface, 3,3-dithiobis (sulphosuccinimidyl propionate) (DTSSP) is utilized as a chemical linker. The optimum amount of protein is investigated by surface plasmon resonance (SPR). SPR and scanning tunneling microscope (STM) results confirm the nano scale protein layer formed on DTSSP self assembled monolayer (SAM) on Au surface. Protein layer on Au surface using DTSSP as chemical linker was more stable than random adsorption without linker as aspect of redox character due to the fact that myoglobin immobilized with chemical linker did not lose its redox property after long usages.     

Enhanced affinity capture MALDI-TOF MS: orientation of an immunoglobulin G using recombinant protein G

Although immobilization of antigen-specific immunoglobulins onto matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) targets allows the specific detection and enrichment of an antigen from complex biological fluids, the process of antibody immobilization is not optimal. The principal reason is that the antibody can bind to the template in various orientations, many of which block antigen recognition. An affinity capture MALDI mass spectrometry methodology was developed by covalently immobilizing an Fc receptor (recombinant protein G) onto MALDI gold targets for the purpose of orientating an immunoglobulin G, with the Fab domains pointing away from the target surface. The pregnancy and cancer marker, human chorionic gonadotropin beta core fragment (hCGbetacf), was our chosen test substance. To optimize the methodology, different surface densities of protein G and immunoglobulin were achieved by employing varying concentrations for immobilization. Captured amounts of hCGbetacf were compared using an external standard (cytochrome c). Orientation of immunoglobulin resulted in an approximately 3-fold increase in MALDI signal compared to using randomly immobilized antibody. Higher antibody concentrations resulted in diminished MALDI signals, which were explained by steric hindrance. Purification and enrichment of hCGbetacf was achieved from a test solution containing contaminant peptides and proteins using oriented immunoglobulins on-target.     

Characterization by potentiometric procedures of the Acid-base and metal binding properties of two new classes of immobilized metal ion affinity adsorbents developed for protein purification

The acid-base protonation constants of two recently introduced chelating ligands for protein purification, O-phosphoserine and 8-hydroxyquinoline immobilized onto Sepharose CL-4B, and the stability constants of their derived immobilized metal ion chelate complexes have been determined by potentiometric methods. The data confirm that immobilization thermodynamically constrains the ligands, with the electron-withdrawing characteristics of the group linking the ligand to the support material affecting the magnitude of the stability constant of the immobilized metal ion complex vis-à-vis the free ligand-metal ion complex in solution. The influence of buffer composition, ionic strength, and pH on the stability constant of the immobilized hard metal ion chelate complexes has also been examined. Collectively, the results have confirmed that coordination complexes with stoichiometries other than the simply 1:1 ML-type exist with these systems, with hard metal ions exhibiting a preference for hydrolytic M(OH)(m)L(n) complexes where m or n > 1. These findings on the participation of coordination complexes of different stoichiometry depending on the characteristics of the chelating ligand and metal ion have fundamental implications for the interpretation of immobilized metal ion affinity chromatographic separation of proteins.