Justification logics, logics of knowledge, and conservativity

Several justification logics have been created, starting with the logic LP, (Artemov, Bull Symbolic Logic 7(1):1–36, 2001). These can be thought of as explicit versions of modal logics, or of logics of knowledge or belief, in which the unanalyzed necessity (knowledge, belief) operator has been replaced with a family of explicit justification terms. We begin by sketching the basics of justification logics and their relations with modal logics. Then we move to new material. Modal logics come in various strengths. For their corresponding justification logics, differing strength is reflected in different vocabularies. What we show here is that for justification logics corresponding to modal logics extending T, various familiar extensions are actually conservative with respect to each other. Our method of proof is very simple, and general enough to handle several justification logics not directly corresponding to distinct modal logics. Our methods do not, however, allow us to prove comparable results for justification logics corresponding to modal logics that do not extend T. That is, we are able to handle explicit logics of knowledge, but not explicit logics of belief. This remains open.     

Two-Way Automata Versus Logarithmic Space

We strengthen a previously known connection between the size complexity of two-way finite automata ( ) and the space complexity of Turing machines (tms). Specifically, we prove that

every s-state has a poly(s)-state that agrees with it on all inputs of length ≤s if and only if NL?L/poly, and

every s-state has a poly(s)-state that agrees with it on all inputs of length ≤2 ^s if and only if NLL?LL/polylog.

Here, and are the deterministic and nondeterministic , NL and L/poly are the standard classes of languages recognizable in logarithmic space by nondeterministic tms and by deterministic tms with access to polynomially long advice, and NLL and LL/polylog are the corresponding complexity classes for space O(loglogn) and advice length poly(logn). Our arguments strengthen and extend an old theorem by Berman and Lingas and can be used to obtain variants of the above statements for other modes of computation or other combinations of bounds for the input length, the space usage, and the length of advice.     

On the power of unambiguity in log-space

We report progress on the NL versus UL problem.

We show that counting the number of s-t paths in graphs where the number of s-v paths for any v is bounded by a polynomial can be done in FUL: the unambiguous log-space function class. Several new upper bounds follow from this including ${{{ReachFewL} \subseteq {UL}}}$ and ${{{LFew} \subseteq {UL}^{FewL}}}$

We investigate the complexity of min-uniqueness—a central notion in studying the NL versus UL problem. In this regard we revisit the class OptL[log n] and introduce UOptL[log n], an unambiguous version of OptL[log n]. We investigate the relation between UOptL[log n] and other existing complexity classes.

We consider the unambiguous hierarchies over UL and UOptL[log n]. We show that the hierarchy over UOptL[log n] collapses. This implies that ${{{ULH} \subseteq {L}^{{promiseUL}}}}$ thus collapsing the UL hierarchy.

We show that the reachability problem over graphs embedded on 3 pages is complete for NL. This contrasts with the reachability problem over graphs embedded on 2 pages, which is log-space equivalent to the reachability problem in planar graphs and hence is in UL.

     

An AC 1-complete model checking problem for intuitionistic logic

We show that the model checking problem for intuitionistic propositional logic with one variable is complete for logspace-uniform AC ¹. For superintuitionistic logics with one variable, we obtain NC ¹-completeness for the model checking problem.     

Self-Referential Justifications in Epistemic Logic

This paper is devoted to the study of self-referential proofs and/or justifications, i.e., valid proofs that prove statements about these same proofs. The goal is to investigate whether such self-referential justifications are present in the reasoning described by standard modal epistemic logics such as  $\mathsf{S4}$ . We argue that the modal language by itself is too coarse to capture this concept of self-referentiality and that the language of justification logic can serve as an adequate refinement. We consider well-known modal logics of knowledge/belief and show, using explicit justifications, that $\mathsf{S4}$ , $\mathsf{D4}$ , $\mathsf{K4}$ , and  $\mathsf{T}$ with their respective justification counterparts  $\mathsf{LP}$ , $\mathsf{JD4}$ , $\mathsf{J4}$ , and  $\mathsf{JT}$ describe knowledge that is self-referential in some strong sense. We also demonstrate that self-referentiality can be avoided for  $\mathsf{K}$ and  $\mathsf{D}$ . In order to prove the former result, we develop a machinery of minimal evidence functions used to effectively build models for justification logics. We observe that the calculus used to construct the minimal functions axiomatizes the reflected fragments of justification logics. We also discuss difficulties that result from an introduction of negative introspection.     

Computing Sparse Multiples of Polynomials

We consider the problem of finding a sparse multiple of a polynomial. Given f??F[x] of degree d over a field F, and a desired sparsity t, our goal is to determine if there exists a multiple h??F[x] of f such that h has at most t non-zero terms, and if so, to find such an h. When F=? and t is constant, we give an algorithm which requires polynomial-time in d and the size of coefficients in h. When F is a finite field, we show that the problem is at least as hard as determining the multiplicative order of elements in an extension field of F (a problem thought to have complexity similar to that of factoring integers), and this lower bound is tight when t=2.     

Approximation Algorithms for the Directed k-Tour and k-Stroll Problems

We consider two natural generalizations of the Asymmetric Traveling Salesman problem: the k-Stroll and the k-Tour problems. The input to the k-Stroll problem is a directed n-vertex graph with nonnegative edge lengths, an integer k, as well as two special vertices s and t. The goal is to find a minimum-length s-t walk, containing at least k distinct vertices (including the endpoints s,t). The k-Tour problem can be viewed as a special case of k-Stroll, where s=t. That is, the walk is required to be a tour, containing some pre-specified vertex s. When k=n, the k-Stroll problem becomes equivalent to Asymmetric Traveling Salesman Path, and k-Tour to Asymmetric Traveling Salesman. Our main result is a polylogarithmic approximation algorithm for the k-Stroll problem. Prior to our work, only bicriteria (O(log² k),3)-approximation algorithms have been known, producing walks whose length is bounded by 3OPT, while the number of vertices visited is Ω(k/log² k). We also show a simple O(log² n/loglogn)-approximation algorithm for the k-Tour problem. The best previously known approximation algorithms achieved min(O(log³ k),O(log² n?logk/loglogn)) approximation in polynomial time, and O(log² k) approximation in quasipolynomial time.     

Visibly rational expressions

Regular expressions (RE) are an algebraic formalism for expressing regular languages, widely used in string search and as a specification language in verification. In this paper, we introduce and investigate visibly rational expressions (VRE), an extension of RE for the class of visibly pushdown languages (VPL). We show that VRE capture precisely the class of VPL. Moreover, we identify an equally expressive fragment of VRE which admits a quadratic time compositional translation into the automata acceptors of VPL. We also prove that, for this fragment, universality, inclusion and language equivalence are EXPTIME-complete. Finally, we provide an extension of VRE for VPL over infinite words.     

Shorthand Universal Cycles for Permutations

The set of permutations of ??n??={1,??,n} in one-line notation is ??(n). The shorthand encoding of a ₁?a _n ????(n) is a ₁?a _n?1. A shorthand universal cycle for permutations (SP-cycle) is a circular string of length n! whose substrings of length n?1 are the shorthand encodings of ??(n). When an SP-cycle is decoded, the order of ??(n) is a Gray code in which successive permutations differ by the prefix-rotation ?? _i =(1 2 ? i) for i??{n?1,n}. Thus, SP-cycles can be represented by n! bits. We investigate SP-cycles with maximum and minimum ??weight?? (number of ?? _n?1s in the Gray code). An SP-cycle n a n b?n z is ??periodic?? if its ??sub-permutations?? a,b,??,z equal ??(n?1). We prove that periodic min-weight SP-cycles correspond to spanning trees of the (n?1)-permutohedron. We provide two constructions: B(n) and C(n). In B(n) the spanning trees use ??half-hunts?? from bell-ringing, and in C(n) the sub-permutations use cool-lex order by Williams (SODA, 987?C996, 2009). Algorithmic results are: (1)?memoryless decoding of B(n) and C(n), (2)?O((n?1)!)-time generation of B(n) and C(n) using sub-permutations, (3)?loopless generation of B(n)??s binary representation n bits at a time, and (4)?O(n+??(n))-time ranking of B(n)??s permutations where ??(n) is the cost of computing a permutation??s inversion vector. Results (1)?C(4) improve on those for the previous SP-cycle construction D(n) by Ruskey and Williams (ACM Trans. Algorithms 6(3):Art.?45, 2010), which we characterize here using ??recycling??.     

AutoRELAX: automatically RELAXing a goal model to address uncertainty

Dynamically adaptive systems (DAS) must cope with system and environmental conditions that may not have been fully understood or anticipated during development. RELAX is a fuzzy logic-based specification language for identifying and assessing sources of environmental uncertainty, thereby making DAS requirements more tolerant of unanticipated conditions. This paper presents AutoRELAX, an approach that automatically generates RELAXed goal models to address environmental uncertainty. Specifically, AutoRELAX identifies goals to RELAX, which RELAX operators to apply, and the shape of the fuzzy logic function that establishes the goal satisfaction criteria. AutoRELAX generates different solutions by making tradeoffs between minimizing the number of RELAXed goals and maximizing delivered functionality by reducing the number of adaptations triggered by minor and adverse environmental conditions. In a recent extension, AutoRELAX uses a stepwise adaptation of weights to balance these two competing concerns and thereby further improve the utility of AutoRELAX. We apply it to two industry-based applications involving network management and a robotic controller, respectively.     

Small Space Analogues of Valiant’s Classes and the Limitations of Skew Formulas

In the uniform circuit model of computation, the width of a boolean circuit exactly characterizes the “space” complexity of the computed function. Looking for a similar relationship in Valiant’s algebraic model of computation, we propose width of an arithmetic circuit as a possible measure of space. In the uniform setting, we show that our definition coincides with that of VPSPACE at polynomial width. We introduce the class VL as an algebraic variant of deterministic log-space L; VL is a subclass of VP. Further, to define algebraic variants of non-deterministic space-bounded classes, we introduce the notion of “read-once” certificates for arithmetic circuits. We show that polynomial-size algebraic branching programs (an algebraic analog of NL) can be expressed as read-once exponential sums over polynomials in ${{\sf VL}, {\it i.e.}\quad{\sf VBP} \in \Sigma^R \cdot {\sf VL}}$ . Thus, read-once exponential sums can be viewed as a reasonable way of capturing space-bounded non-determinism. We also show that Σ ^R ·VBP = VBP, i.e. VBPs are stable under read-once exponential sums. Though the best upper bound we have for Σ ^R ·VL itself is VNP, we can obtain better upper bounds for width-bounded multiplicatively disjoint (md-) circuits. Without the width restriction, md- arithmetic circuits are known to capture all of VP. We show that read-once exponential sums over md- constant-width arithmetic circuits are within VP and that read-once exponential sums over md- polylog-width arithmetic circuits are within VQP. We also show that exponential sums of a skew formula cannot represent the determinant polynomial.     

Complexity of Rational and Irrational Nash Equilibria

We introduce two new natural decision problems, denoted as ? RATIONAL NASH and ? IRRATIONAL NASH, pertinent to the rationality and irrationality, respectively, of Nash equilibria for (finite) strategic games. These problems ask, given a strategic game, whether or not it admits (i) a rational Nash equilibrium where all probabilities are rational numbers, and (ii) an irrational Nash equilibrium where at least one probability is irrational, respectively. We are interested here in the complexities of ? RATIONAL NASH and ? IRRATIONAL NASH. Towards this end, we study two other decision problems, denoted as NASH-EQUIVALENCE and NASH-REDUCTION, pertinent to some mutual properties of the sets of Nash equilibria of two given strategic games with the same number of players. The problem NASH-EQUIVALENCE asks whether or not the two sets of Nash equilibria coincide; we identify a restriction of its complementary problem that witnesses ? RATIONAL NASH. The problem NASH-REDUCTION asks whether or not there is a so called Nash reduction: a suitable map between corresponding strategy sets of players that yields a Nash equilibrium of the former game from a Nash equilibrium of the latter game; we identify a restriction of NASH-REDUCTION that witnesses ? IRRATIONAL NASH. As our main result, we provide two distinct reductions to simultaneously show that (i) NASH-EQUIVALENCE is co- $\mathcal{NP}$ -hard and ? RATIONAL NASH is $\mathcal{NP}$ -hard, and (ii) NASH-REDUCTION and ? IRRATIONAL NASH are both $\mathcal{NP}$ -hard, respectively. The reductions significantly extend techniques previously employed by Conitzer and Sandholm (Proceedings of the 18th Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence, pp. 765–771, 2003; Games Econ. Behav. 63(2), 621–641, 2008).     

Highly-Efficient Wait-Free Synchronization

We study a simple technique, originally presented by Herlihy (ACM Trans. Program. Lang. Syst. 15(5):745–770, 1993), for executing concurrently, in a wait-free manner, blocks of code that have been programmed for sequential execution and require significant synchronization in order to be performed in parallel. We first present an implementation of this technique, called Sim, which employs a collect object. We describe a simple implementation of a collect object from a single shared object that supports atomic Add (or XOR) in addition to read; this implementation has step complexity O(1). By plugging in to Sim this implementation, Sim exhibits constant step complexity as well. This allows us to derive lower bounds on the step complexity of implementations of several shared objects, like Add, XOR, collect, and snapshot objects, from LL/SC objects. We then present a practical version of Sim, called PSim, which is implemented in a real shared-memory machine. From a theoretical perspective, PSim has worse step complexity than Sim, its theoretical analog; in practice though, we experimentally show that PSim is highly-efficient: it outperforms several state-of-the-art lock-based and lock-free synchronization techniques, and this given that it is wait-free, i.e. that it satisfies a stronger progress condition than all the algorithms that it outperforms. We have used PSim to get highly-efficient wait-free implementations of stacks and queues.     

Approximating Node-Connectivity Augmentation Problems

We consider the (undirected) Node Connectivity Augmentation (NCA) problem: given a graph J=(V,E _J ) and connectivity requirements $\{r(u,v): u,v \in V\}$ , find a minimum size set I of new edges (any edge is allowed) such that the graph J∪I contains r(u,v) internally-disjoint uv-paths, for all u,v∈V. In Rooted NCA there is s∈V such that r(u,v)>0 implies u=s or v=s. For large values of k=max? _u,v∈V r(u,v), NCA is at least as hard to approximate as Label-Cover and thus it is unlikely to admit an approximation ratio polylogarithmic in k. Rooted NCA is at least as hard to approximate as Hitting-Set. The previously best approximation ratios for the problem were O(kln?n) for NCA and O(ln?n) for Rooted NCA. In this paper we give an approximation algorithm with ratios O(kln?² k) for NCA and O(ln?² k) for Rooted NCA. This is the first approximation algorithm with ratio independent of?n, and thus is a constant for any fixed k. Our algorithm is based on the following new structural result which is of independent interest. If $\mathcal{D}$ is a set of node pairs in a graph?J, then the maximum degree in the hypergraph formed by the inclusion minimal tight sets separating at least one pair in $\mathcal{D}$ is O(? ²), where ? is the maximum connectivity in J of a pair in $\mathcal{D}$ .     

Exploiting structure in LTL synthesis

In this paper, we show how to exploit the structure of some automata-based construction to efficiently solve the LTL synthesis problem. We focus on a construction proposed in Schewe and Finkbeiner that reduces the synthesis problem to a safety game, which can then be solved by computing the solution of the classical fixpoint equation νX.Safe ∩ CPre(X), where CPre(X) are the controllable predecessors of X. We have shown in previous works that the sets computed during the fixpoint algorithm can be equipped with a partial order that allows one to represent them very compactly, by the antichain of their maximal elements. However the computation of CPre(X) cannot be done in polynomial time when X is represented by an antichain (unless P = NP). This motivates the use of SAT solvers to compute CPre(X). Also, we show that the CPre operator can be replaced by a weaker operator CPre _crit where the adversary is restricted to play a subset of critical signals. We show that the fixpoints of the two operators coincide, and so, instead of applying iteratively CPre, we can apply iteratively CPre _crit. In practice, this leads to important improvements on previous LTL synthesis methods. The reduction to SAT problems and the weakening of the CPre operator into CPre _crit and their performance evaluations are new.     

On Uniformity and Circuit Lower Bounds

We explore relationships between circuit complexity, the complexity of generating circuits, and algorithms for analyzing circuits. Our results can be divided into two parts:

1. Lower bounds against medium-uniform circuits. Informally, a circuit class is “medium uniform” if it can be generated by an algorithmic process that is somewhat complex (stronger than LOGTIME) but not infeasible. Using a new kind of indirect diagonalization argument, we prove several new unconditional lower bounds against medium-uniform circuit classes, including: ? For all k, P is not contained in P-uniform SIZE(n ^k ). That is, for all k, there is a language \({L_k \in {\textsf P}}\) that does not have O(n ^k )-size circuits constructible in polynomial time. This improves Kannan’s lower bound from 1982 that NP is not in P-uniform SIZE(n ^k ) for any fixed k. ? For all k, NP is not in \({{\textsf P}^{\textsf NP}_{||}-{\textsf {uniform SIZE}}(n^k)}\) .This also improves Kannan’s theorem, but in a different way: the uniformity condition on the circuits is stronger than that on the language itself. ? For all k, LOGSPACE does not have LOGSPACE-uniform branching programs of size n ^k .
2. Eliminating non-uniformity and (non-uniform) circuit lower bounds. We complement these results by showing how to convert any potential simulation of LOGTIME-uniform NC ¹ in ACC ⁰/poly or TC ⁰/poly into a medium-uniform simulation using small advice. This lemma can be used to simplify the proof that faster SAT algorithms imply NEXP circuit lower bounds and leads to the following new connection: ? Consider the following task: given a TC ⁰ circuit C of n ^O(1) size, output yes when C is unsatisfiable, and output no when C has at least 2 ^n-2 satisfying assignments. (Behavior on other inputs can be arbitrary.) Clearly, this problem can be solved efficiently using randomness. If this problem can be solved deterministically in 2 ^n-ω(log n) time, then \({{\textsf{NEXP}} \not \subset {\textsf{TC}}^0/{\rm poly}}\) .

Another application is to derandomize randomized TC ⁰ simulations of NC ¹ on almost all inputs: ?Suppose \({{\textsf{NC}}^1 \subseteq {\textsf{BPTC}}^0}\) . Then, for every ε > 0 and every language L in NC ¹, there is a LOGTIME?uniform TC ⁰ circuit family of polynomial size recognizing a language L′ such that L and L′ differ on at most \({2^{n^{\epsilon}}}\) inputs of length n, for all n.     

A UTP semantics for Circus

Circus specifications define both data and behavioural aspects of systems using a combination of Z and CSP constructs. Previously, a denotational semantics has been given to Circus; however, a shallow embedding of Circus in Z, in which the mapping from Circus constructs to their semantic representation as a Z specification, with yet another language being used as a meta-language, was not useful for proving properties like the refinement laws that justify the distinguishing development technique associated with Circus. This work presents a final reference for the Circus denotational semantics based on Hoare and He’s Unifying Theories of Programming (UTP); as such, it allows the proof of meta-theorems about Circus including the refinement laws in which we are interested. Its correspondence with the CSP semantics is illustrated with some examples. We also discuss the library of lemmas and theorems used in the proofs of the refinement laws. Finally, we give an account of the mechanisation of the Circus semantics and of the mechanical proofs of the refinement laws.     

ATP and Presentation Service for Mizar Formalizations

This paper describes the Automated Reasoning for Mizar ( $\textsf{Miz}\mathbb{AR}$ ) service, which integrates several automated reasoning, artificial intelligence, and presentation tools with Mizar and its authoring environment. The service provides ATP assistance to Mizar authors in finding and explaining proofs, and offers generation of Mizar problems as challenges to ATP systems. The service is based on a sound translation from the Mizar language to that of first-order ATP systems, and relies on the recent progress in application of ATP systems in large theories containing tens of thousands of available facts. We present the main features of $\textsf{Miz}\mathbb{AR}$ services, followed by an account of initial experiments in finding proofs with the ATP assistance. Our initial experience indicates that the tool offers substantial help in exploring the Mizar library and in preparing new Mizar articles.     

ReachFewL = ReachUL

We show that two complexity classes introduced about two decades ago are unconditionally equal. ReachUL is the class of problems decided by nondeterministic log-space machines which on every input have at most one computation path from the start configuration to any other configuration. ReachFewL, a natural generalization of ReachUL, is the class of problems decided by nondeterministic log-space machines which on every input have at most polynomially many computation paths from the start configuration to any other configuration. We show that ReachFewL = ReachUL.     

Encoding Cryptographic Primitives in a Calculus with Polyadic Synchronisation

We thoroughly study the behavioural theory of epi, a ??-calculus extended with polyadic synchronisation. We show that the natural contextual equivalence, barbed congruence, coincides with early bisimilarity, which is thus its co-inductive characterisation. Moreover, we relate early bisimilarity with the other usual notions, ground, late and open, obtaining a lattice of equivalence relations that clarifies the relationship among the ??standard?? bisimilarities. Furthermore, we apply the theory developed to obtain an expressiveness result: epi extended with key encryption primitives may be fully abstractly encoded in the original epi calculus. The proposed encoding is sound and complete with respect to barbed congruence; hence, cryptographic epi (crypto-epi) gets behavioural theory for free, which contrasts with other process languages with cryptographic constructs that usually require a big effort to develop such theory. Therefore, it is possible to use crypto-epi to analyse and to verify properties of security protocols using equational reasoning. To illustrate this claim, we prove compliance with symmetric and asymmetric cryptographic system laws, and the correctness of a protocol of secure message exchange.