Changes in lipid fractions and sensory properties of Idiazabal cheese induced by lipase addition

This work studied the addition of an adequate lipase to enhance lipolysis reactions and the development of piquant flavour and sharp odour in Idiazabal cheese, as an alternative to the use of lamb rennet paste. Cheeses were manufactured from bulk raw ewes' milk in 50 l vats with commercial bovine rennet and 80 lipase units of pregastric or 180 lipase units of fungal lipase and ripened for 180 days. A higher lipolytic activity was induced by lipase addition promoting strong changes in odour and flavour attributes. Both fungal and pregastric lipases increased the content of total free fatty acids (FFA), but the fungal lipase released mainly medium- and long-chain FFA. In contrast, the pregastric lipase preferably released short-chain FFA. Diglyceride (DG) content was considerably higher in cheeses made with added pregastric lipase compared with those made with fungal lipase or with no lipase. Monoglycerides (MG) were detected only in cheeses made with either lipase added, reaching comparable concentrations after ripening for 180 days. The cheeses made with pregastric lipase had the highest scores for odour and flavour intensity, and sharp and rennet odours, desirable attributes for the Idiazabal cheese made with lamb rennet paste. None of the texture attributes were significantly influenced by the concentrations of MG and DG in the cheeses made with either lipase. Thus, the pregastric lipase was more appropriate than the fungal lipase to develop a more traditionally-flavoured Idiazabal cheese.     

Free fatty acid composition of regionally-produced Spanish goat cheese and relationship with sensory characteristics

A study was made of free fatty acid composition and sensory characteristics (odour and taste) in regionally-produced Spanish goat cheeses. The most abundant FFAs were oleic, palmitic, stearic, capric and myristic acid which together accounted for roughly 85% of total FFAs. These cheeses generally underwent a lower degree of lipolysis than did other goat cheeses. Panellists judged the cheeses as having considerable odour and flavour intensity. However, both total FFA content and sensory attributes varied considerably among cheeses due, in all likelihood, to differences in ripening time and to production by different manufacturers. Principal component analysis generated three principal components (PC) that accounted for 70% of total variance; the variables that best correlated with them were long-chain and medium-chain free fatty acids (PC1), brine odour, bitterness and goat milk odour (PC2) and short-chain free fatty acids (PC3).     

Comparison of the volatile composition and sensory characteristics of Spanish PDO cheeses manufactured from ewes’ raw milk and animal rennet

Idiazabal, Manchego, Roncal and Zamorano varieties are the Spanish cheeses manufactured under Protected Denomination of Origin (PDO) from ewes’ raw milk and coagulated with animal rennet. Two batches of each cheese variety were ripened for six months and the cheeses were compared for sensory characteristics and composition of volatile compounds. Seventy-six volatile compounds were identified by GC-MS analysis of headspaces of the cheeses. The volatile profile of the four PDO cheeses differed significantly. Acids were the most abundant volatile compounds in Idiazabal, Roncal, and Zamorano cheeses, whereas alcohols were the main volatile compounds in Manchego cheese due to the large percentage of 2-butanol. Aldehydes, ketones and esters were minor compounds in all the cheese varieties, whereas terpenes and unsaturated hydrocarbons were only found in Manchego cheese. The sensory profiles, of the four PDO cheeses also differed significantly. The highest scores for sharp, brine and rennet odours, and rancid and rennet flavours were assessed in Idiazabal and Zamorano cheeses, whereas milky and buttery odour scores were higher in Manchego, Roncal and Zamorano cheeses than in Idiazabal cheese. Principal component analysis was applied to sensory attributes and volatile composition of the cheeses. Differences in flavour and odour attributes were correlated with differences in the volatile compounds. Two principal components correlating sensory attributes and volatile compounds were defined as “strength factor” and “sweetness factor”. The “strength factor” distinguished among the four cheese varieties, except between Roncal and Manchego cheeses, and the “sweetness factor” distinguished the Zamorano cheese from the Idiazabal, Manchego and Roncal cheeses.     

Relationships between the gross,non-volatile and volatile compositions and the sensory attributes of eight hard-type cheeses

Relationships between individual flavour attributes of eight hard-type cheeses and their volatile compounds, free amino acids (FAA), free fatty acids (FFA) and gross compositional constituents were determined. Relationships were also determined between individual texture attributes and gross compositional constituents. A trained panel of 15 assessors described the sensory characteristics of the cheeses using eight odour, twenty flavour, four appearance and nine texture attributes. Volatile compounds were isolated using a model-mouth device. FAA, FFA and gross compositional constituents were determined using standard methods. Relationships were determined by using partial least squares regression coupled with a new jack-knife method for identification and elimination of non-contributing variables. Eight flavour attributes were found to be correlated with subsets of volatile compounds, FAA, FFA and gross compositional constituents. For instance, the “nutty” flavour of Emmental was found to be positively correlated with the concentrations of propionic acid, ethyl acetate and 2-pentanone. “Nutty” flavour was negatively correlated with the concentrations of salt in moisture and pH 4.6-soluble nitrogen (pH 4.6-SN). Four texture attributes were correlated with subsets of gross compositional constituents. For example, “firmness” was positively correlated with concentrations of protein, calcium and phosphorous and negatively correlated with pH value and level of pH 4.6-SN.     

Variations in volatile compounds and flavour in Idiazabal cheese manufactured from ewe's milk in farmhouse and factory

Stage of lactation, use of bulk milk or milk from individual flocks, and cheese‐making in farmhouse or industrial factory are important factors affecting the production and quality of Idiazabal cheese. The volatile composition of cheese samples made from raw ewe's milk in farmhouses or industrial plants at two different times of the year and aged for 90 and 180 days was analysed by dynamic headspace coupled to GC‐MS. Short‐chain fatty acids, primary and secondary alcohols, methyl ketones and ethyl esters were the most abundant compounds in the aroma of Idiazabal cheese samples. Differences in the volatile composition were found between farmhouse and industrial cheeses made at different times of the year and ripened for 90 or 180 days. Likewise, the sensory profiles of the farmhouse and industrial cheeses were significantly different, regardless of the time of the year and ripening time. The results for the principal component analysis (PCA) performed on the sensory attributes of the cheese samples showed two PCs defined as ‘farmhouse flavour factor’ and ‘industrial flavour factor’. Farmhouse cheeses showed high scores for buttery, milky and toasty odours, and buttery and nutty flavours, whereas industrial cheeses showed high scores for sharp, rennet and brine odours, and rennet and rancid flavours. The percentages of methyl ketones such as 3‐hydroxy‐2‐butanone, 2‐butanone, 2‐pentanone and 2‐heptanone, and acids such as n‐propanoic, 2‐methylpropanoic and 3‐methylbutanoic acids were higher in farmhouse cheeses than in industrial cheeses. On the other hand, the percentages of esters such as ethyl butanoate and ethyl hexanoate, and alcohols such as 3‐methyl‐1‐butanol, and acids like n‐hexanoic acid were higher in industrial cheeses than in farmhouse cheeses. Relationships between sensory attributes and volatile compounds were studied on the basis of the differences found in sensory profile and volatile composition between farmhouse and industrial cheeses. Copyright © 2005 Society of Chemical Industry     

Volatile composition and sensory properties of industrially produced Idiazabal cheese

The volatile composition and sensory properties of industrially produced Idiazabal cheeses made from ewes’ raw milk (RM) or pasteurised milk (PM) and with addition of different starter cultures were compared. Cheeses were analysed at 90 and 180 d of ripening. Acids were the major volatile compounds in RM cheeses. Methyl ketones were the major volatile compounds in PM cheeses at 90 ripening days. However, the content of acids strongly increased with ripening whereas the content of ketones decreased in PM cheeses. The concentration of esters was higher in RM cheeses than in PM cheeses. No differences were found in the content of alcohols. Most aldehydes, hydrocarbons, terpenes and furans identified were minor volatile compounds in both RM and PM cheeses. In RM cheeses, characteristic sensory attributes for the aroma of Idiazabal cheese were present at 3 months, whereas in PM cheeses those desirable sensory attributes did not appear until 6 months of ripening.     

Relationships between sensory attributes and the volatile compounds,non-volatile and gross compositional constituents of six blue-type cheeses

Relationships between odour and flavour attributes of six blue-type cheeses and their volatile compounds, free amino acids (FAA), free fatty acids (FFA) and gross compositional constituents were determined. Relationships were also determined between texture attributes and gross compositional constituents. Fifteen assessors described the odour, flavour, appearance and texture profile of cheeses. Volatile compounds were isolated using a model-mouth apparatus. FAA, FFA and gross compositional constituents were determined using standard methods. Using Partial Least Squares Regression two odour and five flavour attributes were found to correlate with subsets of volatile compounds, FAA, FFA and gross compositional constituents. For example, “mouldy” flavour was positively correlated with the concentrations of pH 4.6-soluble nitrogen and 2-pentanone, 2-heptanone, 2-octanone and 2-nonanone. Three texture attributes were found to correlate with subsets of gross compositional constituents. For example, “crumbly” texture was positively correlated with concentration of fat and protein and negatively correlated with levels of moisture in the non-fat substance and moisture.     

Swiss-type and Swiss–Cheddar hybrid-type cheeses: effects of manufacture on sensory character and relationships between the sensory attributes and volatile compounds and gross compositional constituents

The effects of manufacturing steps, including rate of acidification in the vat, hot room step, curd wash and ripening temperature, on the sensory character of Swiss-type and Swiss–Cheddar hybrid-type cheeses were determined. In addition, relationships were determined between sensory attributes of cheeses and their gross compositional constituents and volatile compounds. Ten assessors described the sensory characteristics using 12 odour, 19 flavour, four appearance and nine texture attributes. Gross compositional constituents were determined using standard methods. Volatile compounds were isolated using a model mouth apparatus that included a mastication device. Statistical methods were used to reduce the original sensory vocabulary to four odour, eight flavour, three appearance and five texture attributes. Results of a principal component analysis on the sensory data showed clear differences in sensory character between cheese types. For example, the Swiss-type with a low rate of acid production in the vat and a hot room step had a more 'nutty' and 'sweet' flavour than the modified Swiss-type with higher acid production and no hot room step. However, the modified Swiss–Cheddar hybrid with a curd wash step, a higher acid production and no hot room step also had a 'nutty' and 'sweet' flavour. Ripening temperature also has an effect on sensory character. Relationships between sensory character and volatile compounds and/or gross compositional constituents were determined by using partial least squares regression. One odour and one flavour attribute were shown to be correlated with subsets of volatile compounds and gross compositional constituents. Four texture attributes were correlated with subsets of gross compositional constituents. The availability of information on the manufacturing process increased the interpretability of the models.     

Effect of a food-grade enzyme preparation fromAspergillus oryzae on free fatty acid release in Manchego-type cheese from ovine and bovine milk

The addition of 50 mg Flavor Age (blend of lipase, proteinases and peptidases fromAspergillus oryzae) per kilogram of mixed ovine plus bovine milk for the manufacture of Manchego-type cheese caused the release of abundant free fatty acids (FFA), especially the short-chain fatty acids (C₄ to C₁₀). The effect accentuated with ripening time, the cheeses reaching a level of FFA around 2% at 120 days. The high concentration of FFA could have partially inhibited the growth of starter culture, as can be deduced from the higher residual lactose content of enzyme-treated cheeses. The results are compared and related to those obtained in a previous study on proteolysis and flavour development by the same enzyme preparation. They suggest that in the case of Man-chego-type cheese the liberation of FFA, although necessary, could be less important for flavour enhancement than the production of free amino acids.     

Effect of freeze–dried kefir culture on proteolysis in feta-type and whey-cheeses

The effect of freeze–dried kefir culture on the proteolysis of feta-type and whey-cheese was investigated. All nitrogen fractions increased during ripening. Although no significant differences were observed in total nitrogen (TN), the levels of water-soluble nitrogen (WSN), pH 4.4-soluble nitrogen (SN), 12% trichloroacetic acid-soluble nitrogen (TCA-SN) and phosphotungstic acid-soluble nitrogen (PTA-SN) were significantly higher in cheeses produced by freeze–dried kefir culture during the later stages of ripening. Content of total free amino acids (FAA) was significantly affected by freeze–dried kefir starter culture and it was continuously increased in kefir-cheese while, in rennet-cheese it was increased up to 30 days of ripening and then slightly decreased. On the other hand, FAA content continuously decreased in kefir-whey-cheese whereas it increased in whey-cheese. The cheese samples produced by freeze–dried kefir as starter culture were characterised as high-quality products during the preliminary sensory evaluation and they were accepted by the panel. Overall, the use of freeze–dried kefir suggested acceleration of cheese ripening and resulted in improved sensory characteristics.     

Influence of the season on proteolysis and sensory characteristics of Idiazabal cheese

The present study examined the influence of the manufacturing time on proteolysis and sensory characteristics of Idiazabal cheese. Samples of Idiazabal cheeses made using traditional manufacturing methods at two different times of year were collected at a plant operating under the auspices of the Idiazabal Cheese Appellation of Origin. The cheeses were made in February and June, roughly the beginning and the end of the manufacturing season. Chemical analyses were performed on d 1, 90, and 180 of ripening and sensory analyses on d 90, 120, and 180 of ripening. Higher nitrogen fraction (soluble and nonprotein nitrogen) levels and free amino acid contents were observed in the cheeses manufactured during the month of June. Degradation of the alphas- and beta-caseins was also greater in the cheeses made at that time of year. The cheeses manufactured in February earned higher sensory analysis scores for characteristic odor and taste and higher total sensory scores. The cheeses manufactured in June earned higher scores for the sensory attributes sweet flavor and bitter taste.     

Hygienic quality of ewes' milk cheeses manufactured with artisan-produced lamb rennet pastes

The use of artisan-produced lamb rennet pastes, but not any of the other commercial animal rennets, imparts a characteristic flavour to the cheese, so most Mediterranean ewes' milk cheeses are coagulated with this kind of rennet paste. In contrast to the advantages of using lamb or kid rennet pastes from the sensory point of view, questions are still raised as to their hygienic quality. The goal was to examine the microbiological and enzymic quality of lamb rennet pastes prepared by cheese manufacturers for their own use, and evaluate the hygienic quality of raw sheeps' milk cheeses made with them, using Idiazabal cheese as a model. Lamb rennet pastes prepared by artisan cheese makers from the Basque region of Spain (27), and Italy (8) were evaluated. For cheese making experiments 5 different lamb rennet pastes were selected among the 27 samples from the Basque Country region of Spain. Microbiological analyses were carried out on samples from rennet pastes, rennet extracts, milks and cheeses during ripening. Enzymic activities studied in rennet paste were: total coagulating strength and lipase. Analysis of variance and Student's t-tests was performed. The results show that the artisan-produced rennet pastes contain high levels of a variety of microorganisms. After 60 ripening days, which is the minimum ripening period required for Idiazabal cheese prior to its commercialization, no Eschericia coli, Clostridium, Salmonella spp. or Listeria monocytogenes were detected, and levels for the rest of the microorganisms were below the limits of the European legislative standards for cheese manufactured with raw milk. We can conclude that the use of artisan-produced lamb rennet pastes of questionable hygienic quality for the manufacture of raw milk hard cheeses yields products of good hygienic quality.     

Influence of ripening temperature on the volatiles profile and flavour of Cheddar cheese made from raw or pasteurised milk

Cheddar cheeses were made from raw (R1, R8) or pasteurised (P1, P8) milk and ripened at 1°C (P1, R1) or 8°C (P8, R8). Volatile compounds were extracted from 6 month-old cheeses and analysed, identified and quantified by gas chromatography-mass-spectrometry. A detailed sensory analysis of the cheeses was performed after 4 and 6 months of ripening. The R8 cheeses had the highest and P1 the lowest concentrations of most of the volatile compounds quantified (fatty acids, ketones, aldehydes, esters, alcohols, lactones and methional). The R8 and P8 cheeses contained higher levels of most of the volatiles than R1 and P1 cheeses. Ripening temperature and type of milk influenced most of the flavour and aroma attributes. Principal component analysis (PCA) of aroma and flavour attributes showed that P1 and R1 had similar aroma and flavour profiles, while R8 had the highest aroma and flavour intensities, highest acid aroma and sour flavour. The age of cheeses influenced the perception of creamy/milky and pungent aromas. PCA of the texture attributes separated cheeses on the basis of ripening temperature. The R8 and P8 cheeses received significantly higher scores for perceived maturity than P1 and R1 cheeses. The P1 and R1 cheeses had similar values for perceived maturity. In a related study, it was found that concentrations of amino acids and fatty acids were similar in R1 and P1 during most of the ripening period, and R1 and P1 cheeses had low numbers of non-starter lactic acid bacteria (NSLAB). The panel found that ripening temperature, type of milk and age of cheeses did not influence the acceptability of cheese. It is concluded that NSLAB contribute to the formation of volatile compounds and affect the aroma and flavour profiles and the perceived maturity of Cheddar cheese.     

Flavour precursor development in Cheddar cheese due to lactococcal starters and the presence and lysis of Lactobacillus helveticus.

The rapid release of intracellular enzymes due to autolysis of lactic acid bacteria in the cheese matrix has been shown to accelerate cheese ripening. The objective of this work was to investigate the evolution of the flavour precursors, individual free amino acids (FAAs), free fatty acids (FFAs) and volatile compounds that contribute to the sensory profiles of cheeses at 2, 6 and 8 months of ripening in Cheddar cheese manufactured using starter systems which varied with respect to their autolytic properties. Starter system A contained a blend of two commercial Lactococcus lactis strains (223 and 227) which had a low level of autolysis. System B was identical to A but also included a highly autolytic strain of Lactobacillus helveticus (DPC4571). System C contained only strain DPC4571. Levels of all individual FAAs were elevated in cheeses B and C relative to A after 2 months of ripening. By 8 months of ripening the main FAA were glutamate, leucine, lysine, serine, proline and valine. Levels of C_6:0, C_8:0, C_12:0 and C_18:0 fatty acids did not vary greatly over ripening, while levels of C_4:0, C_10:0, C_14:0, C_16:0 and C_18:1 were elevated in cheeses B and C. Principal component analysis of the headspace volatiles separated cheese A from cheeses B and C. Cheeses B and C had highest levels of dimethyl disulphide, carbon sulphide, heptanal, dimethyl sulphide, ethyl butanoate, 2-butanone, and 2-methyl butanal and were described as having a ‘caramel’ odour and ‘sweet’, ‘acidic’ and ‘musty’ flavour. Cheese A had highest levels of 2-butanol, 2-pentanone, 2-heptanone, 1-hexanol and heptanal and was described as having a ‘sweaty/ sour’ odour and ‘soapy’, ‘bitter’ and ‘mouldy’ flavour. The results highlight the impact of starter lactococci on flavour precursor development and the positive effect of Lb. helveticus and the lysis of this strain on enhancing levels of substrate and flavour precursors early during ripening resulting in early flavour development.     

Influence of fat replacers on chemical composition, proteolysis, texture profiles, meltability and sensory properties of low-fat Kashar cheese

Changes in chemical composition, proteolysis, lipolysis, texture, melting and sensory properties of low-fat Kashar cheese made with three different fat replacers (Simplesse D-100, Avicel Plus CM 2159 or beta-glucan) were investigated throughout ripening. The low-fat cheeses made with fat replacers were compared with full- and low-fat counterparts as controls. Reduction of fat caused increases in moisture and protein contents and decreases in moisture-in-non fat substance and yield values in low-fat cheeses. The use of fat replacers in the manufacture of low-fat Kashar cheese increased water binding capacity and improved overall quality of the cheeses. Use of fat replacer in low-fat cheese making has enhanced cheese proteolysis. All samples underwent lipolysis during ripening and low-fat cheeses with fat replacers had higher level of total free fatty acid than full- or low-fat control cheeses. Texture attributes and meltability significantly increased with addition of fat replacers. Sensory scores showed that the full-fat cheese was awarded best in all stages of ripening and low-fat variant of Kashar cheeses have inferior quality. However, fat replacers except beta-glucan improved the appearance, texture and flavour attributes of low-fat cheeses. When the fat replacers are compared, the low-fat cheese with Avicel Plus CM 2159 was highly acceptable and had sensory attributes closest to full-fat Kashar cheese.     

Evolution of free amino acid content during ripening of Mahon cheese

Evolution of free amino acids (FAA) during ripening (10–300 days) of five batches of Mahon cheese was studied; three batches were made from raw milk and two from pasteurized milk. Major FAA were GLU, VAL, LEU, LYS and PHE (43–67% of total FAA). Relative THR, SER, GLU and GLY contents significantly increased during ripening whereas LEU, PHE and ORN decreased. GLU, ILE, SER, THR, GLY and PHE varied during ripening according to a zero order reaction (r² > 0.99). Principal component analysis showed that the first principal component could be considered representative of the ripening time. The most ripened cheeses showed high GLU, GLY, SER and THR contents and the less ripened cheeses presented high ORN, LEU, PHE and ALA contents. The second component distinguished between cheeses made with pasteurized milk (with high ASN and GLN contents) and raw milk. Indigenous microflora of raw milk showed a strong influence on the proteolytic activity in Mahon cheese.     

Influence of starter culture ratios and warm room treatment on free fatty acid and amino acid in Swiss cheese

Quantification of water-soluble volatile free fatty acids (FFA) and free amino acids (FAA) was performed as a ripening index and an indirect measure of flavor development in Swiss-type cheeses. The objective of this research was to assess the effect of warm room treatment (WRT) and usage ratio of starter cultures, Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus helveticus vs. propionibacteria, on the concentration of FFA and FAA in pilot plant-scale Swiss cheese. A capillary gas chromatograph equipped with a flame ionization detector was used for the analysis of FFA in Swiss cheese. Free amino acids were analyzed by the Cd-ninhydrin method. Starter culture ratios did not affect development of FAA during the cheese ripening. However, duration of WRT had an effect on the concentration of FAA in the Swiss cheese. Free amino acids increased considerably during WRT. A continuous increase in FAA was shown during 70-d ripening time after WRT. The concentrations of C2:0 and C3:0 fatty acids were affected by starter culture ratios after 2-wk WRT, but these differences had mostly disappeared after 3-wk WRT. Similar concentrations of FFA and FAA reported in previous studies were developed in Swiss cheese with a 3-wk WRT and a 0.33:1 ratio of Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus helveticus to propionibacteria.     

Characterization and Comparison of Free Fatty Acid Profiles of Eleven Varieties of Turkish Cheeses

Free fatty acids profiles of 11 different cheese varieties sold in Turkey were determined to assess the development of lipolysis. Results obtained showed that the concentrations of short chain fatty acids (C₄ and C₆ free fatty acids) were close in all cheeses (P > 0.05), except for Canak cheese. However, significant differences were noted among the samples for other free fatty acids including C₈ to C_18:2 (P < 0.05). Palmitic (C₁₆) and oleic (C_18:1) acids were the most abundant free fatty acids in all cheese samples. Principal component analysis was applied to simplify interpretation of the data and distinguish the variety of the cheeses on the plot. Canak cheese gave a dramatically different free fatty acid profile from the other cheeses, probably because of the fact that ripening of this variety is achieved in the earthenware pots for about 1 year. Van Otlu (ripened with special herbs) and Civil (ripened by spontaneously molding on its surface) cheeses differed from the others by ANOVA and principal component analysis techniques. In conclusion, the degree of lipolysis in the cheeses could be classified into extreme (Canak), high (Civil, Divle Tulum, Mihalic, and Van Otlu), mild (Ezine, Orgu, and Urfa), and low (Dil, Hellim, and Malatya) based on their FFA profiles.