Techno-economic analysis of processes with integration of fluidized bed heat exchangers for H2 production – Part 2: Chemical-looping combustion

This work covers a techno-economic assessment for processes with inherent CO₂ separation, where a fluidized bed heat exchanger (FBHE) is used as heat source for steam reforming in a hydrogen production plant. This article builds upon the work presented in Part 1 of this study by Stenberg et al. [1], where a process excluding CO₂ capture was examined. Part 2 suggests two process configurations integrating steam reforming with a chemical-looping combustion (CLC) system, thus providing inherent CO₂ capture. The first system (case CM) uses natural gas as supplementary fuel whereas the second system (case CB) uses solid biomass, which enables net negative CO₂ emissions. In both systems, the reformer tubes are immersed in a bubbling fluidized bed where heat for steam reforming is efficiently transferred to the tubes. The processes include CO₂ compression for pipeline transportation, but excludes transport and storage. The CLC system is designed based on key parameters, such as the oxygen carrier circulation rate and oxygen transport capacity. The first system displays a process with net zero emissions and a hydrogen production efficiency which is estimated to 76.2%, which is almost 8% higher than the conventional process. The levelized production cost is 1.6% lower at below 2.6 €/kg H₂. The second system shows the possibility to reduce the emissions to ?34.1 g CO₂/MJ_H2 compared to the conventional plant which emits 80.7 g CO₂/MJ_H2. The hydrogen production efficiency is above 72% and around 2% higher than the conventional process. The capital investments are higher in this plant and the levelized hydrogen production cost is estimated to around 2.67 €/kg. The cost of CO₂ avoidance, based on a reference SMR plant with CO₂ capture, is low for both cases (?4.3 €/ton_CO2 for case CM and 2.7 €/ton_CO2 for case CB).     

Economic assessment of membrane-assisted autothermal reforming for cost effective hydrogen production with CO2 capture

A recent techno-economic study (Spallina et al., Energy Conversion and Management 120: p. 257–273) showed that the membrane assisted chemical looping reforming (MA-CLR) technology can produce H₂ with integrated CO₂ capture at costs below that of conventional steam methane reforming. A key technical challenge related to MA-CLR is the achievement of reliable solids circulation between the air and fuel reactors at large scale under the high (>50 bar) operating pressures required for optimal performance. This work therefore presents process modelling and economic assessments of a simplified alternative; membrane assisted autothermal reforming (MA-ATR), that inherently avoids this technical challenge. The novelty of MA-ATR lies in replacing the MA-CLR air reactor with an air separation unit (ASU), thus avoiding the need for oxygen carrier circulation. The economic assessment found that H₂ production from MA-ATR is only 1.5% more expensive than MA-CLR in the base case. The calculated cost of hydrogen (compressed to 150 bar) in the base case was 1.55 €/kg with a natural gas price of €6/GJ and an electricity price of €60/MWh. Both concepts show continued performance improvements with an increase in reactor pressure and temperature, while an optimum cost is achieved at about 2 bar H₂ permeate pressure. Sensitivities to other variables such as financing costs, membrane costs, fuel and electricity prices are similar between MA-ATR and MA-CLR. Natural gas prices represent the most important sensitivity, while the sensitivity to membrane costs is relatively small at high reactor pressures. MA-ATR therefore appears to be a promising alternative to achieve competitive H₂ production with CO₂ capture if technical challenges significantly delay scale-up and deployment of MA-CLR technology. The key technical demonstration required before further MA-ATR scale-up is membrane longevity under the high reactor pressures and temperatures required to minimize the cost of hydrogen.     

Optimization of hydrogen production from three reforming approaches of glycerol via using supercritical water with in situ CO2 separation

A pathway for hydrogen production from supercritical water reforming of glycerol integrated with in situ CO₂ removal was proposed and analyzed. The thermodynamic analysis carried out by the minimizing Gibbs free energy method of three glycerol reforming processes for hydrogen production was investigated in terms of equilibrium compositions and energy consumption using AspenPlus™ simulator. The effect of operating condition, i.e., temperature, pressure, steam to glycerol (S/G) ratio, calcium oxide to glycerol (CaO/G) ratio, air to glycerol (A/G) ratio, and nickel oxide to glycerol (NiO/G) ratio on the hydrogen production was investigated. The optimum operating conditions under maximum H₂ production were predicted at 450 °C (only steam reforming), 400 °C (for autothermal reforming and chemical looping reforming), 240 atm, S/G ratio of 40, CaO/G ratio of 2.5, A/G ratio of 1 (for autothermal reforming), and NiO/G ratio of 1 (for chemical looping reforming). Compared to three reforming processes, the steam reforming obtained the highest hydrogen purity and yield. Moreover, it was found that only autothermal reforming and chemical looping reforming were possible to operate under the thermal self-sufficient condition, which the hydrogen purity of chemical looping reforming (92.14%) was higher than that of autothermal reforming (52.98%). Under both the maximum H₂ production and thermal self-sufficient conditions, the amount of CO was found below 50 ppm for all reforming processes.     

Performance comparison among different multifunctional reactors operated under energy self-sufficiency for sustainable hydrogen production from ethanol

Four ethanol-derived hydrogen production processes including conventional ethanol steam reforming (ESR), sorption enhanced steam reforming (SESR), chemical looping reforming (CLR) and sorption enhanced chemical looping reforming (SECLR) were simulated on the basis of energy self-sufficiency, i.e. process energy requirement supplied by burning some of the produced hydrogen. The process performances in terms of hydrogen productivity, hydrogen purity, ethanol conversion, CO₂ capture ability and thermal efficiency were compared at their maximized net hydrogen. The simulation results showed that the sorption enhanced processes yield better performances than the conventional ESR and CLR because their in situ CO₂ sorption increases hydrogen production and provides heat from the sorption reaction. SECLR is the most promising process as it offers the highest net hydrogen with high-purity hydrogen at low energy requirement. Only 12.5% of the produced hydrogen was diverted into combustion to fulfill the process's energy requirement. The thermal efficiency of SECLR was evaluated at 86% at its optimal condition.     

Thermodynamic evaluation of hydrogen production from methane

Exergetic and energetic analysis has been utilized to estimate the effect of process design and conditions on the hydrogen purity and yield, exergetic efficiencies and CO₂ avoided. Methane was chosen as a model compound for evaluating single stage separation. Simple steam reforming was considered as the base – case system. The other chemical processes that were considered were steam reforming with CO₂ capture with and without chemical looping of a reactive carbon dioxide removal agent, and steam gasification with both the Boudouard reaction catalyst and the reactive carbon dioxide removal agent with and without the solids regeneration. The information presented clearly demonstrates the differences in efficiencies between the various chemical looping processes for hydrogen generation. The incremental changes in efficiencies as a function of process parameters such as temperature, steam amount, chemical type and amount were estimated. Energy and exergy losses associated with generation of syngas, separation of hydrogen from CO_x as well as exergetic loss associated with emissions are presented. The optimal conditions for each process by minimizing these losses are presented. The majority of the exergy destruction occurs due to the high irreversibility of chemical reactions. The results of this investigation demonstrate the utility of exergy analysis. The paper provides a procedure for the comparison of various technologies for the production of hydrogen from carbon based materials based on First and Second Law Analysis. In addition, two figures of merit, namely the comparative advantage factor and the sustainable advantage factor have been proposed to compare the various hydrogen production methods using carbonaceous fuels.     

An overview of solar decarbonization processes,reacting oxide materials,and thermochemical reactors for hydrogen and syngas production

Solar decarbonization processes are related to the different thermochemical conversion pathways of hydrocarbon feedstocks for solar fuels production using concentrated solar energy as the external source of high-temperature process heat. The main investigated routes aim to convert gaseous and solid feedstocks (methane, coal, biomass …) into hydrogen and syngas via solar cracking/pyrolysis, reforming/gasification, and two-step chemical looping processes using metal oxides as oxygen carriers, further associated with thermochemical H₂O/CO₂ splitting cycles. They can also be combined with metallurgical processes for production of energy-intensive metals via solar carbothermal reduction of metal oxides. Syngas can be further converted to liquid fuels while the produced metals can be used as energy storage media or commodities. Overall, such solar-driven processes allow for improvements of conversion yields, elimination of fossil fuel or partial feedstock combustion as heat source and associated CO₂ emissions, and storage of intermittent solar energy in storable and dispatchable chemical fuels, thereby outperforming the conventional processes. The different solar thermochemical pathways for hydrogen and syngas production from gaseous and solid carbonaceous feedstocks are presented, along with their possible combination with chemical looping or metallurgical processes. The considered routes encompass the cracking/pyrolysis (producing solid carbon and hydrogen) and the reforming/gasification (producing syngas). They are further extended to chemical looping processes involving redox materials as well as metallurgical processes when metal production is targeted. This review provides a broad overview of the solar decarbonization pathways based on solid or gaseous hydrocarbons for their conversion into clean hydrogen, syngas or metals. The involved metal oxides and oxygen carrier materials as well as the solar reactors developed to operate each decarbonization route are further described.     

Techno – Economic assessment of flexible decarbonized hydrogen and power co-production based on natural gas dry reforming

The need for flexible power plants could increase in the future as variable renewable energy (VRE) share will increase in the power grid. These power plants could balance the increasing strain on electricity grids by renewables. The proposed plant in this paper can adapt to these ramps in electricity demand of the power grid by maintaining a constant feed and producing also high purity hydrogen. Dry methane reforming (DMR) is incorporated into a flexible power plant model and the key performance indicators are calculated from a techno-economic perspective. The net output of the plant is 450 MW with the possibility to lower power production and produce hydrogen, maintaining a high CO₂ capture rate (72%). Two cases are compared to the base case to quantify: (i) energy and cost penalties for CO₂ capture and (ii) advantages of flexible power plant operation. The levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) for the base case is 67 Euro/MWh, the addition of a carbon capture unit increases it to 82 Euro/MWh. In the case of flexible operation, both the LCOE and levelized cost of hydrogen (LCOH) are calculated and the two depend on the cost allocation factor. The LCOE ranges from 65 to 85 Euro/MWh while the LCOH from 0.15 to 0.073 Euro/Nm³. The DMR power plant presented in Cases 1 and 2 present little advantages in today's market conditions however, the flexible plant (Case 3) can be viable option in balancing VRE.     

Hydrogen-rich syngas production and carbon dioxide formation using aqueous urea solution in biogas steam reforming by thermodynamic analysis

Biogas is a renewable biofuel that contains a lot of CH₄ and CO₂. Biogas can be used to produce heat and electric power while reducing CH₄, one of greenhouse gas emissions. As a result, it has been getting increasing academic attention. There are some application ways of biogas; biogas can produce hydrogen to feed a fuel cell by reforming process. Urea is also a hydrogen carrier and could produce hydrogen by steam reforming. This study then employes steam reforming of biogas and compares hydrogen-rich syngas production and carbon dioxide with various methane concentrations using steam and aqueous urea solution (AUS) by Thermodynamic analysis. The results show that the utilization of AUS as a replacement for steam enriches the production of H₂ and CO and has a slight CO₂ rise compared with pure biogas steam reforming at a temperature higher than 800 °C. However, CO₂ formation is less than the initial CO₂ in biogas. At the reaction temperature of 700 °C, carbon formation does not occur in the reforming process for steam/biogas ratios higher than 2. These conditions led to the highest H₂, CO production, and reforming efficiency (about 125%). The results can be used as operation data for systems that combine biogas reforming and applied to solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC), which usually operates between 700 °C to 900 °C to generate electric power in the future.     

Pure hydrogen co-production by membrane technology in an IGCC power plant with carbon capture

The CO₂ capture in Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC) plants causes a significant increase of the cost of electricity (COE) and thus determines high CO₂ mitigation cost (cost per ton of avoided CO₂ emissions). In this work the economic sustainability of the co-production of pure hydrogen in addition to the electricity production was assessed by detailed process simulations and a techno-economic analysis. To produce pure hydrogen a Water Gas Shift reactor and a Selexol^® process was combined with H₂ selective palladium membranes. This innovative process section was compared with the more conventional Pressure Swing Adsorption in order to produce amount of pure hydrogen up to 20% of the total hydrogen available in the syngas.Assuming for a base case a hydrogen selling price of 3 €/kg and a palladium membrane cost of 9200 €/m², a cost of electricity (COE) of 64 €/MWh and a mitigation cost of 20 €/ton_CO2 were obtained for 90% captured CO₂ and 10% hydrogen recovery. An increase of the hydrogen recovery up to 20% determines a reduction of the COE and of the mitigation cost to 50 €/MWh and 5 €/ton_CO2, respectively. A sensitivity analysis showed that even a 50% increase of cost of the membrane per unit surface could determine a COE increase of only about 10% and a maximum increase of the mitigation cost of further 5 €/ton_CO2.     

Techno-economic analysis of the Ca-Cu process integrated in hydrogen plants with CO2 capture

In this work, a techno-economic analysis of a hydrogen production plant based on the Ca-Cu process has been carried out. The simulation of the whole hydrogen production plant has been performed, including the calculation of the Ca-Cu fixed bed reactors system using a sharp front modelling approach. From the analyses carried out, it has been demonstrated that the optimal operation point from the energy performance point of view is reached when fuel needed for sorbent regeneration is entirely supplied by the off-gas from the PSA hydrogen purification unit, which corresponds to operating the plant with the minimum steam-to-carbon ratio in the reforming step. Moreover, lowering the operating pressure of the Ca-Cu system results beneficial from the hydrogen production efficiency, but the CO₂ emissions and the economics worsen.The Ca-Cu based hydrogen production plant operating at a high pressure has been demonstrated to be cost efficient with respect to a benchmark hydrogen production plant based on conventional fired tubular reformer and CO₂ capture by MDEA absorption. A hydrogen production cost of 0.178 €/Nm³ and a CO₂ avoided cost of 30.96 €/ton have been calculated for this Ca-Cu hydrogen production plant, which are respectively 8% and 52% lower than the corresponding costs of the benchmark.     

Techno-economic analysis of e-waste based chemical looping reformer as hydrogen generator with co-generation of metals,electricity and syngas

Chemical looping reforming (CLR) is an efficient technology to convert hydrocarbon fuels into CO₂ and H₂ using metal oxide based oxygen carriers. The novelty of the present study is to utilize electronic waste such as printed circuit board (PCB) to generate high quality syngas and metallic components for the CLR process. A portion of the syngas generated during e-waste pyrolysis is used with coal and polypropylene for effective combustion. A techno-economic analysis is performed for the production of hydrogen and electricity in the CLR method. The levelized costs for electricity (LCOE), hydrogen (LCOH), syngas (LCOS), and metal (LCOM) production using e-wastes are estimated as 92.28 $/MWh, 3.67 $/kg, 0.0034 $/kWh, and 24.32 $/ton, respectively. The LCOH is found to be the least of 2.90 $/kg under the co-feed conditions of PCB syngas-PP. The integration of the e-waste based CLR with a steam turbine system achieved a net efficiency of 50%.     

A strategy of mid-temperature natural gas based chemical looping reforming for hydrogen production

Steam methane reforming (SMR) needs the reaction heat at a temperature above 800 °C provided by the combustion of natural gas and suffers from adverse environmental impact and the hydrogen separated from other chemicals needs extra energy penalty. In order to avoid the expensive cost and high power consumption caused by capturing CO₂ after combustion in SMR, natural gas Chemical Looping Reforming (CLR) is proposed, where the chemical looping combustion of metal oxides replaced the direct combustion of NG to convert natural gas to hydrogen and carbon dioxide. Although CO₂ can be separated with less energy penalty when combustion, CLR still require higher temperature heat for the hydrogen production and cause the poor sintering of oxygen carriers (OC). Here, we report a high-rate hydrogen production and low-energy penalty of strategy by natural gas chemical-looping process with both metallic oxide reduction and metal oxidation coupled with steam. Fe₃O₄ is employed as an oxygen carrier. Different from the common chemical looping reforming, the double side reactions of both the reduction and oxidization enable to provide the hydrogen in the range of 500–600 °C under the atmospheric pressure. Furthermore, the CO₂ is absorbed and captured with reduction reaction simultaneously.Through the thermodynamic analysis and irreversibility analysis of hydrogen production by natural gas via chemical looping reforming at atmospheric pressure, we provide a possibility of hydrogen production from methane at moderate temperature. The reported results in this paper should be viewed as optimistic due to several idealized assumptions: Considering that the chemical looping reaction is carried out at the equilibrium temperature of 500 °C, and complete CO₂ capture can be achieved. It is assumed that the unreacted methane and hydrogen are completely separated by physical adsorption. This paper may have the potential of saving the natural gas consumption required to produce 1 m³ H₂ and reducing the cost of hydrogen production.     

Environmental evaluation of hydrogen production employing innovative chemical looping technologies – A Romanian case study

A cradle-to-gate life cycle assessment is carried out to evaluate the environmental impact of producing 1 kg of hydrogen implementing innovative chemical looping technologies: chemical looping hydrogen production (CLH), sorption enhanced reforming (SER), and sorption enhanced chemical looping reforming (SECLR). The performance of the looping technologies is compared against conventional hydrogen production without and with CO₂ capture, as well as against green hydrogen production in order to determine the more environmentally-friendly option. Comparing the looping technologies with the reference blue hydrogen production it shows that CLH has a lower environmental burden, presenting smaller values in 9 out of 12 environmental impact indicators. If we confront the looping technologies against each other, CLH shows better performance in 11 out of 12 environmental indicators. As expected, green hydrogen has a much smaller overall environmental impact with the exception of human toxicity, terrestrial ecotoxicity and mineral depletion.     

Chemical looping steam reforming of ethanol without and with in-situ CO2 capture

Chemical looping steam reforming (CLSR) of ethanol using oxygen carriers (OCs) for hydrogen production has been considered a highly efficient technology. In this study, NiO/MgAl₂O₄ oxygen carriers (OCs) were employed for hydrogen production via CLSR with and without CaO sorbent for in-situ CO₂ removal (sorption enhanced chemical looping steam reforming, SE-CLSR). To find optimal reaction conditions of the CLSR process, including reforming temperatures, the catalyst mass, and the NiO loadings on hydrogen production performances were studied. The results reveal that the optimal temperature of OCs for hydrogen production is 650 °C. In addition, 96% hydrogen selectivity and a 'dead time' (the reduced time of OCs) less than 1 minute is obtained with the 1 g 20NiO/MgAl₂O₄ catalysts. The superior catalytic activity of 20NiO/MgAl₂O₄ is due to the maximal quantity of NiO loadings providing the most Ni active surface centers. High purity hydrogen is successfully produced via CLSR coupling with CaO sorbent in-situ CO₂ removal (SE-CLSR), and the breakthrough time of CaO is about 20 minutes under the condition that space velocity was 1.908 h^?1. Stability CLSR experiments found that the hydrogen production and hydrogen selectivity decreased obviously from 207 mmol to 174 mmol and 95%–85% due to the inevitable OCs sintering and carbon deposition. Finally, stable hydrogen production with the purity of 89%～87% and selectivity of 96%～93% was obtained in the modified stability SE-CLSR experiments.     

Hydrogen production from bio-oil: A thermodynamic analysis of sorption-enhanced chemical looping steam reforming

The steam reforming of pyrolysis bio-oil is one proposed route to low carbon hydrogen production, which may be enhanced by combination with advanced steam reforming techniques. The advanced reforming of bio-oil is investigated via a thermodynamic analysis based on the minimisation of Gibbs Energy. Conventional steam reforming (C-SR) is assessed alongside sorption-enhanced steam reforming (SE-SR), chemical looping steam reforming (CLSR) and sorption-enhanced chemical looping steam reforming (SE-CLSR). The selected CO₂ sorbent is CaO(s) and oxygen transfer material (OTM) is Ni/NiO. PEFB bio-oil is modelled as a surrogate mixture and two common model compounds, acetic acid and furfural, are also considered. A process comparison highlights the advantages of sorption-enhancement and chemical looping, including improved purity and yield, and reductions in carbon deposition and process net energy balance.The operating regime of SE-CLSR is evaluated in order to assess the impact of S/C ratio, NiO/C ratio, CaO/C ratio and temperature. Autothermal operation can be achieved for S/C ratios between 1 and 3. In autothermal operation at 30 bar, S/C ratio of 2 gives a yield of 11.8 wt%, and hydrogen purity of 96.9 mol%. Alternatively, if autothermal operation is not a priority, the yield can be improved by reducing the quantity of OTM. The thermodynamic analysis highlights the role of advanced reforming techniques in enhancing the potential of bio-oil as a source of hydrogen.     

Techno-economic assessment of solar steam reforming of methane in a membrane reactor using molten salts as heat transfer fluid

This paper reports the results obtained in a techno-economic analysis of the Steam Methane Reforming (SMR) technology aided with solar heat, developed and demonstrated in the European FCH JU project CoMETHy: a compact membrane reformer heated with molten salt up to 550 °C allowed to simultaneously carry out methane steam reforming, water-gas-shift reaction and hydrogen separation. This reactor can be integrated with new generation Concentrating Solar Thermal (CST) systems to supply the process heat. Experimental validation of the technology has been successfully achieved in a pilot scale plant and the results recently published. In this paper, we introduce a fully-integrated scheme and operation strategies of a plant on the 1500 Nm³/h hydrogen production scale. Then, techno-economic analysis of this new solar-driven process is presented to evaluate its competitiveness. Considering a plant capacity of 1500 Nm³/h (pure hydrogen production) and today's costs for the methane feed and the CST technology, obtained Hydrogen Production Cost (HPC) are in the range of 2.8–3.3 €/kg for a “solar-hybrid” system with high capacity factor (8000 h/year operation) and 4.7 €/kg for a “solar-only” case, while HPC≅1.7 €/kg can be obtained with the conventional route under equivalent assumptions. However, a sensitivity analysis shows that the expected drop of the cost of the CST technology will bring the HPC around 2.4 €/kg for the “solar-hybrid” case and close to 3.4 €/kg for the “solar-only” case, thus making the cost of solar reforming closer to conventional SMR with CO₂ capture and with wind/solar electrolysis in the future. In the “solar-hybrid” case total CO₂ production can be reduced by 13–29% with 58–70% of produced CO₂ recovered as pure stream (at 1.3 bar); in the “solar-only” case total CO₂ production can be reduced by 52% and 100% of produced CO₂ recovered as pure stream (at 1.3 bar). However, compared to the conventional route, CO₂ avoidance costs are still relatively high (≥137 €/ton_CO2) and process optimization measures required. Therefore, optimization measures have been outlined to increase the overall process efficiency and further reduce the HPC.     

Low-carbon hydrogen production via electron beam plasma methane pyrolysis: Techno-economic analysis and carbon footprint assessment

Electron beam plasma methane pyrolysis is a hydrogen production pathway from natural gas without direct CO₂ emissions. In this work, two concepts for a technical implementation of the electron beam plasma pyrolysis in a large-scale hydrogen production plant are presented and evaluated in regards of efficiency, economics and carbon footprint. The potential of this technology is identified by an assessment of the results with the benchmark technologies steam methane reforming, steam methane reforming with carbon capture and storage as well as water electrolysis. The techno-economic analysis shows levelized costs of hydrogen for the plasma pyrolysis between 2.55 €/kg H₂ and 5.00 €/kg H₂ under the current economic framework. Projections for future price developments reveal a significant reduction potential for the hydrogen production costs, which support the profitability of plasma pyrolysis under certain scenarios. In particular, water electrolysis as direct competitor with renewable electricity as energy supply shows a considerably higher specific energy consumption leading to economic advantages of plasma pyrolysis for cost-intensive energy sources and a high degree of utilization. Finally, the carbon footprint assessment indicates the high potential for a reduction of life cycle emissions by electron beam plasma methane pyrolysis (1.9 kg CO₂ eq./kg H₂ – 6.4 kg CO₂ eq./kg H₂, depending on the electricity source) compared to state-of-the-art hydrogen production technology (10.8 kg CO₂ eq./kg H₂).     

Evaluation of power generation schemes based on hydrogen-fuelled combined cycle with carbon capture and storage (CCS)

IGCC is a power generation technology in which the solid feedstock is partially oxidized to produce syngas. In a modified IGCC design for carbon capture, there are several technological options which are evaluated in this paper. The first two options involve pre-combustion arrangements in which syngas is processed, either by shift conversion or chemical looping, to maximise the hydrogen level and to concentrate the carbon species as CO₂. After CO₂ capture by gas-liquid absorption or chemical looping, the hydrogen-rich gas is used for power generation. The third capture option is based on post-combustion arrangement using chemical absorption.Investigated coal-based IGCC case studies produce 400-500 MW net power with more than 90% carbon capture rate. Principal focus of the paper is concentrated on evaluation of key performance indicators for investigated carbon capture options, the influence of various gasifiers on carbon capture process, optimisation of energy efficiency by heat and power integration, quality specification of captured CO₂. The capture option with minimal energy penalty is based on chemical looping, followed by pre-combustion and post-combustion.     

Techno-economic feasibility assessment of sorption enhanced gasification of municipal solid waste for hydrogen production

Waste-to-fuel coupled with carbon capture and storage is forecasted to be an effective way to mitigate the greenhouse gas emissions, reduce the waste sent to landfill and, simultaneously, reduce the dependence of fossil fuels. This study evaluated the techno-economic feasibility of sorption enhanced gasification, which involves in-situ CO₂ capture, and benchmarked it with the conventional steam gasification of municipal solid waste for H₂ production. The impact of a gate fee and tax levied on the fossil CO₂ emissions in economic feasibility was assessed. The results showed that the hydrogen production was enhanced in sorption enhanced gasification, that achieved an optimum H₂ production efficiency of 48.7% (T = 650 °C and SBR = 1.8). This was 1.0% points higher than that of the conventional steam gasification (T = 900 °C and SBR = 1.2). However, the total efficiency, which accounts for H₂ production and net power output, for sorption enhanced gasification was estimated to be 49.3% (T = 650 °C and SBR = 1.8). This was 4.4% points lower than the figure estimated for the conventional gasification (T = 900 °C and SBR = 1.2). The economic performance assessment showed that the sorption enhanced gasification will result in a significantly higher levelised cost of hydrogen (5.0 €/kg) compared to that estimated for conventional steam gasification (2.7 €/kg). The levelised cost of hydrogen can be reduced to 4.5 €/kg on an introduction of the gate fee of 40.0 €/t_MSW. The cost of CO₂ avoided was estimated to be 114.9 €/tCO₂ (no gate fee and tax levied). However, this value can be reduced to 90.1 €/tCO₂ with the introduction of an emission allowance price of 39.6 €/tCO₂. Despite better environmental performance, the capital cost of sorption enhanced gasification needs to be reduced for this technology to become competitive with mature gasification technologies.     

Renewable hydrogen production concepts from bioethanol reforming with carbon capture

This paper is assessing the hydrogen production from bioethanol at industrial scale (100000 Nm³/h hydrogen equivalent to 300 MW thermal) with carbon capture. Three carbon capture designs were investigated, one based on pre-combustion capture using chemical gas–liquid absorption and two based on chemical looping (one based on syngas and one using direct bioethanol looping). The carbon capture options were compared with the similar designs without carbon capture. The designs were simulated to produce mass and energy balances for quantification of key performance indicators. A particular accent is put on assessment of reforming technologies (steam and oxygen-blown autothermal reforming) and chemical looping units, process integration issues of carbon capture step within the plant, modelling and simulation of whole plant, thermal and power integration of various plant sub-systems by pinch analysis. The results for chemical looping designs (either syngas-based or direct bioethanol) show promising energy efficiency coupled with total carbon capture rate.