Improving Electrical Discharge Machined Surfaces Using Magnetic Abrasive Finishing

Abstract

A recast layer is invariably present on surfaces produced by electrical discharge machining (EDM). For some metals with high hardness, the recast layer may contain micro-cracks. This damaged layer can affect the service life of the parts produced by this method. This investigation demonstrates that magnetic abrasive finishing (MAF) process using unbonded magnetic abrasives (UMA), can improve the quality of EDM machined surfaces effectively. The UMA used herein is a mechanical mixture of steel grit and SiC abrasive. SKD11 tool steel was used as the workpiece. Experimental results show that the recast layer and micro-cracks on EDM machined surfaces can be completely removed and a new surface of roughness on the order of 0.04 μm Ra can be produced. Additionally, experiments using the Taguchi method and L₁₈ orthogonal array enable the determination of the optimum process conditions for improving the surface finish. Further, the significance of the control factors was identified with the assistance of analysis of variance (ANOVA), and the optimum combination of the process parameters was verified by conducting several confirmatory experiments.     

Improving the surface quality in wire electrical discharge machined specimens by removing the recast layer using magnetic abrasive finishing method

This study explores the feasibility of removing the recast layer formed on aluminum alloy cylindrical specimens machined by wire electrical discharge machining (WEDM) by using magnetic abrasive finishing (MAF). The WEDM is a thermal machining process capable of accurately machining parts with high hardness or complex shapes. The sparks produced during the WEDM process melt the metal’s surface. The molten material undergoes ultra-rapid quenching and forms a layer on the surface defined as recast layer. The recast layer may be full of craters and microcracks which reduce service life of materials tremendously, especially under fatigue loads in corrosive environments. This investigation demonstrates that MAF process, can improve the quality of WEDM machined surfaces effectively by removing the recast layer. The present work studies the effect of some parameters, i.e., linear speed, working gap, abrasive particle size, and finishing time on surface roughness and recast layer thickness using full factorial analysis. Three-level full factorial technique is used as design of experiments for studying the selected factors. In order to indicate the significant factors, the analysis of variance has been used. In addition, an equation based on regression analysis is presented to indicate the relationship between surface roughness and recast layer thickness of cylindrical specimens and finishing parameters. Experimental results show the influence of MAF process on recast layer removal and surface roughness improvement.     

INVESTIGATING THE EFFECTS OF EDM PARAMETERS ON SURFACE INTEGRITY,MRR AND TWR IN MACHINING OF Ti–6Al–4V

Ti–6Al–4V is a kind of difficult-to-cut material with poor machinability by traditional machining methods, while electrical discharge machining (EDM) is suitable for machining titanium alloys. In this paper, three input machining parameters including pulse current, pulse on time and open circuit voltage were changed during EDM tests. To investigate the output characteristics; material removal rate (MRR), tool wear ratio (TWR) and different aspects of surface integrity for Ti–6Al–4V samples such as topography of machined surface, crack formation, white layer (recast layer) thickness and microhardness were considered as performance criteria. The variations of MRR and TWR versus input machining parameters were investigated by means of main and interaction effect plots and also verified by ANOVA results. The effect of pulse energy based on pulse on time and pulse current variations against recast layer thickness and microhardness was studied. The possibility of forming different chemical elements and compounds on the work surface after EDM process was investigated by EDS and XRD analyses. The experimental results revealed that general aspects of surface integrity for machined samples are mostly affected by pulse current and pulse on time. The approximate density of cracks, micro holes and pits on the work surface is intensively dependent on pulse energy variations. Although increase of pulse energy improves the material removal efficiency but leads to increase of average thickness and microhardness of recast layer.     

Surface modification using semi-sintered electrodes on electrical discharge machining

This study investigates how machining characteristics and surface modifications affect low-carbon steel (S15C) during electrical discharge machining (EDM) processes with semi-sintered electrodes. Among the machining characteristics determined, the material removal rate (MRR), surface deposit rate (SDR), and electrode wear rate (EWR) are included. Additionally, exactly how semi-sintered electrodes affect the surface modifications is also evaluated by electron probe microanalyzer (EPMA), micro hardness, and corrosion resistance tests. The experimental results confirmed that the composition of the semi-sintered electrodes is transferred onto the machined surface efficiently and effectively during the EDM process, and that the process is feasible and can easily form a modified layer on the machined surface.     

Effects of finishing processes on the fatigue life improvements of electro-machined surfaces of tool steel

Machining the EN X160CrMoV12 tool steel by electro-discharge machining (EDM) process generates significant modifications of microgeometrical, microstructural and mechanical properties of the upper layers of the machined components. In this paper, the role of these modifications in controlling the stability, under cyclic loading, of the propagation of the crack networks generated by EDM is discussed. High cycle fatigue tests (2?×?10⁶ cycles) show that the presence of these cracks in brittle layers, i.e. white layer, quenched the martensitic layer, and a field of tensile residual stresses (+750?MPa) results in a loss of 34% of endurance limit comparatively with the endurance evaluated for the milled state that generates crack-free surfaces. It is shown, in this work, that the detrimental effect of these crack networks can be controlled by putting in compression the upper layers of the EDM surfaces. Indeed the application of wire brushing to EDM surfaces generates compressive residual stresses (???100?MPa) that stabilise the crack networks propagation and therefore restores to the EDM surfaces their endurance limit value corresponding to the milled state. Moreover, removing the crack networks by polishing generates a stabilised residual stress value of ???130?MPa. This results in an improvement rate of about 70% of the endurance limit comparatively with the EDM state and of 26% in comparison to the milled state. These rates could be further increased by the application of the wire brushing process to the polished surfaces that reached 75% and 30% comparatively to the EDM and milling states respectively. In this case, a stabilised surface residual stress of about ???150?MPa was measured on the specimen surfaces.     

MEASUREMENT OF HYDROGEN CONTENT IN ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE MACHINED COMPONENTS

During electric discharge machining (EDM) process, localized high temperature electric discharges occur in the presence of hydrocarbon dielectric such as kerosene. Hydrogen that can get incorporated into the workpiece during the process can dramatically affect the mechanical properties of the machined workpiece. In the present work the hydrogen content in workpieces machined by EDM and electric discharge abrasive drilling (EDAD) have been measured by a relatively new diagnostic technique called Elastic Recoil Detection (ERD), which utilizes He⁺ ions of mega electron volt energy obtained from a particle accelerator. Workpieces made up of high-speed steel and cemented carbide were machined at different pulse-on-times, and their hydrogen content was measured. From the experiments reported in this paper, it is concluded that hydrogen diffusion takes place in the workpiece surface.     

Surface integrity study of WEDM with various wire electrodes: experiments and analysis

Abstract

Wire electrical discharge machining (WEDM) is always significant for its high-precision machining. However, due to the generation of high discharge energy during machining, machined surfaces are often got distorted. These might be upgraded by choosing the correct tool with proper machining condition. The effects of the electrode materials and process parameters on different responses of WEDM like average surface roughness, recast layer thickness, and surface morphology are systematically examined here to enhance the knowledge of WEDM and its correlation with electrode property. The experiments have been carried out on one of the expensive steel namely Maraging steel 300 due to its applicability in tooling and aerospace industries. Plain brass wire, zinc-coated brass wire (ZCB), and silver-coated brass (SCB) wires are used as a tool electrode for analysis. Comparative experimental studies prove that among BW, ZCB, and SCB, the overall performance of SCB is commendable owing to the high-quality surface considering control parameters in low discharge energy level. However, the second-best performance is shown by ZCB.     

Electrical discharge abrasive drilling of hard materials using a metal matrix composite electrode

The main object of the present work was to develop an electrical discharge abrasive drilling (EDAD) methodology to remove the re-solidified layer through the grinding induced by a metal matrix composite electrode prior to the re-solidification of molten material. A metal matrix composite (Cu/SiC_p) electrode, with an electroless pretreatment of Cu coating on SiC_p to enhance bonding status between Cu and SiC_p, was made with a rotating device and this was employed to study the EDAD technology. The machinability of the mold steel HPM50 and tungsten carbide P20 was investigated by the combined technologies of EDAD. The machined surfaces of these materials were examined by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and their surface roughness measured by a profilemeter. From the experimental results, it was found that the EDAD machining efficiency was three to seven times than that of normal EDM operation for mold steel. However, the efficiency improvement is hardly detectable for tungsten carbide. In addition, the surface roughness of both materials could be improved in comparison with that achieved after EDM.     

Influence of electrical discharge machining on the reciprocating sliding wear response of WC-Co cemented carbides

A number of commercially available WC-Co-based cemented carbides with 6 up to 12 wt.% Co were machined and surface finished by grinding as well as by wire electrical discharge machining (EDM) in demineralised water through a number of consecutive gradually finer EDM regimes. Comparative dry reciprocating sliding wear experiments on both wire-EDM and ground samples against WC-Co pins were conducted, using a pin-on-plate test rig, in order to investigate the influence of the EDM process on the tribological behavior. The worn surfaces of the investigated cemented carbides were scanned topographically and characterised by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The post-mortem obtained wear volumes were compared to the online measured wear in order to determine correlations between wear volume and wear rate on the one hand and sliding distance on the other hand. The experimental results revealed a profound influence of surface finish conditions and distinctive EDM regimes on the wear behavior of WC-Co cemented carbides.     

Influence of parameters and optimization of EDM performance measures on MDN 300 steel using Taguchi method

Maraging steel (MDN 300) exhibits high levels of strength and hardness. Optimization of performance measures is essential for effective machining. In this paper, Taguchi method, used to determine the influence of process parameters and optimization of electrical discharge machining (EDM) performance measures on MDN 300 steel, has been discussed. The process performance criteria such as material removal rate (MRR), tool wear rate (TWR), relative wear ratio (RWR), and surface roughness (SR) were evaluated. Discharge current, pulse on time, and pulse off time have been considered the main factors affecting EDM performance. The results of the present work reveal that the optimal level of the factors for SR and TWR are same but differs from the optimum levels of the factors for MRR and RWR. Further, discharge current, pulse on time, and pulse off time have been found to play a significant role in EDM operations. Detailed analysis of structural features of machined surface was done by using scanning electron microscope (SEM) to understand the influence of parameters. SEM of electrical discharge machining surface indicates that at higher discharge current and longer pulse on duration give rougher surface with more craters, globules of debris, pockmarks or chimneys, and microcracks than that of lower discharge current and lower pulse on duration.     

SPECKLE METHOD EVALUATION OF THE ROUGHNESS OF ELECTRODISCHARGE MACHINED SURFACES

Abstract

This paper describes the applicability of the speckle method to evaluate the roughness of surfaces produced by non-traditional machining processes such as EDM, ECM or USM, where material removal occurs randomly. The method is based on the digital correlation of two speckle images produced by interference phenomena arising when a coherent light beam is incident on a rough surface. The basic principle of the speckle pattern correlation is presented and the theoretical analysis based on a hypothesis concerning the morphology of the machined surface is reported. An experiment has been set-up in order to assess the feasibility of applying the speckle method to evaluate the roughness of machined surfaces. In the experimental tests, two speckle patterns produced from the same rough surface under two different illumination conditions have been correlated. The two different conditions have been obtained by varying the angle of incidence of coherent light on the surface being analysed. The roughness of electrodischarge machined surfaces, as measured by the speckle method, is found to be in good agreement with that of a stylus instrument.     

Performance and surface alloying characteristics of Cu–Cr and Cu–Mo powder metal tool electrodes in electrical discharge machining

The main objective of this study is to investigate the effect of Cu–Cr and Cu–Mo powder metal (PM) tool electrodes on electrical discharge machining (EDM) performance outputs. The EDM performance measures used in the study are material removal rate (MRR), tool electrode wear rate (EWR), average workpiece surface roughness (R_a), machined workpiece surface hardness, abrasive wear resistance, corrosion resistance, and workpiece alloyed layer depth and composition. The EDM performance of Cu–Cr and Cu–Mo PM electrodes produced at three different mixing ratios (15, 25, and 35 wt% Cr or Mo), compacting pressures (P_c = 600, 700, and 800 MPa), and sintering temperatures (T_s = 800, 850, and 900 °C) are compared with those machined with electrolytic Cu and Cu PM electrodes when machining SAE 1040 steel workpiece. Analyses revealed that tool materials were deposited as a layer over the work surface yielding high surface hardness, strong abrasion, and corrosion resistance. Moreover, the mixing ratio, P_c, and T_s affect the MRR, EWR, and R_a values.     

ON THE PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF FLEXIBLE MAGNETIC ABRASIVE BRUSH

ABSTRACT

Magnetic abrasive finishing (MAF) of alloy steel workpiece with unbounded magnetic abrasive particles (UMAPs) indicates that the surface finish in the range of nanometer can be achieved. Important controllable four process parameters have been identified which are as current to the electromagnet, machining gap, abrasive size (mesh number), and number of cycles. Experiments have been planned using design of experiments technique. Based upon the results of response surface methodology and analysis of variance (ANOVA), it is concluded that magnetic flux density that depends on current to the electromagnet and machining gap, is most influencing parameter followed by grain size and number of cycles. The surface roughness profile generated during the MAF process has been discussed. To understand the cutting mechanism of magnetic abrasive finishing process, scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) of the machined surfaces have been carried out. The correlation between surface finish and material removal has also been established.     

A NEW METHOD FOR MACHINING OF ELECTRICALLY NONCONDUCTIVE WORKPIECES USING ELECTRIC DISCHARGE MACHINING TECHNIQUE

In this study, a new method for machining of nonconductive ceramic workpieces in electric discharge machining (EDM) was developed. Machining surfaces of nonconductive workpieces were coated with a conductive layer (CL) and graphite powder was added to dielectric fluid for machining. Al₂O₃, ZrO₂, SiC, B₄C and glass workpiece samples were machined by using the method. Different machining conditions were tested for each sample and optimum machining parameters were determined. Effect of electrical conductivity, thermal conductivity and melting point of workpieces on material removal rate (MRR) was investigated. Optical microscope and SEM (Scanning Electron Microscope) surface photographs of workpieces taken after machining are presented and discussed.     

Investigation of EDM characteristics of nickel-based heat resistant alloy

The EDM processing characteristics of one of the nickel-based heat resistant alloys, Hast-elloy-X, were investigated under the various EDM conditions and analyzed in terms of surface integrity. This alloy is commonly used as a material for the hot gas path component of gas turbines and it is difficult to machine by conventional machining methods. The primary EDM parameter which was varied in this study were the pulse-on time. Since the pulse-on time is one of the main factors that determines the intensity of the electrical discharge energy, it was expected that the machining ratio and the surface integrity of the specimens would be proportionally dependent on the pulse-on duration. However, experimental results showed that MRR (material removal rate) and EWR (electrode wear rate) behaved nonlinearly with respect to the pulse duration, whereas the morphological and metallurgical features showed rather a constant trend of change by the pulse duration. In addition the heat treating process affected the recast layer and HAZ to be recrystallized but softening occurred in recast layer only. A metallurgical evaluation of the microstructure for the altered material zone was also conducted.     

Recast layer removal using ultrafast laser in titanium alloy

Recast layer, which has undesirable effects on the fatigue resistance and service life of components and microstructures, has been observed and analyzed from the points of surface morphology and internal microstructure by three test methods including scanning electron microscopy, metallographic corrosion analysis, and transmission electron microscopy in this study. In order to reduce the harms of these unwanted recast layers, taking ultrafast laser as a post-machining method for recast material removal is proposed based on the advantages of ultrafast laser micromachining technology, which include the wide material applicability and absence of the recast layer during processing. The feasibility of this new recast layer removal method was verified by experiments on Ti-6Al-4V. With a series of optimized processing parameters, horizontally bedded scanning processing was adopted ultimately in final recast layer removal experiment because of its higher material removal rate and better machined surface quality compared with vertically shifting scanning processing. Based on the theoretical analysis and experimental results, ultrafast laser could be widely applied in more fields of microstructures finish machining.     

ON THE PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF FLEXIBLE MAGNETIC ABRASIVE BRUSH

Magnetic abrasive finishing (MAF) of alloy steel workpiece with unbounded magnetic abrasive particles (UMAPs) indicates that the surface finish in the range of nanometer can be achieved. Important controllable four process parameters have been identified which are as current to the electromagnet, machining gap, abrasive size (mesh number), and number of cycles. Experiments have been planned using design of experiments technique. Based upon the results of response surface methodology and analysis of variance (ANOVA), it is concluded that magnetic flux density that depends on current to the electromagnet and machining gap, is most influencing parameter followed by grain size and number of cycles. The surface roughness profile generated during the MAF process has been discussed. To understand the cutting mechanism of magnetic abrasive finishing process, scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) of the machined surfaces have been carried out. The correlation between surface finish and material removal has also been established.     

Advantages of carbon nanotubes in electrical discharge machining

Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) have a small specific gravity and a straight-pin shape, which allow them to continuously float and to uniformly disperse throughout the entire dielectric-filled cavity with little agglomeration during electrical discharge machining (EDM). In the past, powder mixtures of silicon, aluminum, and chrome have been used in the EDM process. However, there are concerns about flushing the controlled gap between the electrode and the workpiece because of their heavy specific gravity and their associated non-uniform dispersion in the dielectric. In this study, the effect of adding CNT powders to the dielectric on the surface integrity and the machining efficiency of the workpiece were investigated. CNTs can avoid the agglomeration problem. The CNTs were fabricated by chemical vapor deposition and added to the dielectric at a concentration of 0.4?g/l. The average surface roughness of 0.09?μm was achieved within 1.2?h, and the material defects of the recast layer and the micro-cracks were considerably reduced. The adopted processing parameters were a negative electrode polarity, a discharge current of 1?A, a pulse duration of 2?μs, an open-circuit voltage of 280?V, and gap voltage of 70?V. This technology improved the surface finish by 70% and the machining time by 66%. The achievement is attributed to the nanoscale characteristics of the CNTs in the dielectrics. The surface force became large and was able to balance the gravity body force of the CNTs. Consequently, the electric arcs were well dispersed and more uniform across the electrode gap, thus significantly enhancing the performance of the electrical discharge. It is expected that carbon nanotubes will be used in many EDM applications.     

An experimental investigation of cylindrical wire electrical discharge turning process

The cylindrical wire electrical discharge turning (CWEDT) process was developed to generate precise cylindrical forms on hard, difficult to machine materials. A precise, flexible, and corrosion-resistant submerged rotary spindle was designed and added to a conventional five-axis CNC wire electrical discharge machine (EDM) to enable the generation of free-form cylindrical geometries. The hardness and strength of the work material are no longer the dominating factors that affect the tool wear and hinder the machining process. In this study, the effect of machining parameters on surface roughness (R _a) and roundness in cylindrical CWEDT of a AISI D3 tool steel is investigated. The selection of this material was made taking into account its wide range of applications in tools, dies, and molds and in industries such as punching, tapping, reaming, and so on in cylindrical forms. Surface roughness and roundness are chosen as two of the machining performances to verify the process. In addition, power, pulse off-time, voltage, and spindle rotational speed are adopted for evaluation by full factorial design of experiments. In this case, a 2²?×?3² mixed full factorial design has been selected considering the number of factors used in the present study. The main effects of factors and interactions were considered in this paper, and regression equations were derived using response surface methodology. Finally, the surfaces of the CWEDT parts were examined using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to identify the macro-ridges and craters on the surface. Cross sections of the EDM parts were examined using the SEM and microhardness tests to quantify the sub-surface recast layers and heat-affected zones under specific process parameters.     

Investigation of the relationship between the white layer thickness and 3D surface texture parameters in the die sinking EDM process

It is a well known fact that the EDM process results in the formation of a hard, brittle recast layer on the component's surface. Several investigations have been carried out in order to assess the nature of the recast layer in terms of its phase structure, the microhardness, presence and the density of cracks, and other surface features. Some researchers [Barash, Delpretti] have reported mathematical relationships between the thickness of the white layer and 2D amplitude surface roughness parameters (such as R_a and R_t). But so far no investigation has been reported which correlates the thickness of the white layer with 3D surface roughness parameters, especially those related to spatial parameters. This paper presents an experimental investigation of the effect of the EDM process factors (current and pulse on-time) on the thickness of the white layer. Empirical equations relating the thickness of the white layer with 3D surface texture amplitude, spatial and volume parameters are presented and their physical basis is discussed. The results of this study show that a better correlation can be obtained between the average thickness of the white layer (AWLT) and the spatial parameter, S_ds as compared to other 3D surface texture parameters. This is believed to be mainly due to the similar effect of the current and pulse on-time on both AWLT and S_ds. The possible effect of surface tension between the solid and liquid phases on the thickness of the white layer during erosion is also discussed.