DNA content and prognosis in renal cell carcinoma. A comparison between primary tumors and metastases

Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) content was retrospectively determined by single-cell cytophotometry in primary tumors and corresponding metastases from 32 patients with renal cell carcinoma. In 15 of the primary tumors a diploid/near diploid and in 17 an aneuploid DNA content was found. A diploid/near diploid DNA pattern was revealed in 10 metastases and 22 were aneuploid. By comparing the DNA content in the primary tumors with their metastases, 13 of 32 showed a clear divergency, which might illustrate tumor cell heterogeneity of renal cell carcinoma. The DNA pattern showed a close correlation to morphologic grading. A correlation between DNA content in the metastases and survival time was found. Patients, with diploid/near diploid metastases survived significantly longer than those with aneuploid DNA contents (mean, 31.1 and 11.5 months, respectively; P = 0.004). In contrast to this, no correlation was found between DNA content in the primary tumors and survival time.     

Progression of diploid tumor cells in aneuploid head and neck squamous cell carcinomas

The development of aneuploid clones from diploid progenitor cells is a regular characteristic of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma progression. While the significance of aneuploidy formation for the acquisition of invasive and metastatic behavior is well documented, little is known about the contribution of diploid tumor cells after aneuploid clones have emerged. To distinguish diploid cells of epithelial origin from benign cellular components, we applied multiparameter flow cytometry of DNA content and cytokeratin (CK) expression to 36 primary tumors. Twenty-seven carcinomas accommodated aneuploid cell lines that stained positive for CK. All diploid cell populations obtained from aneuploid carcinomas contained CK-positive subpopulations as did all of nine tumors that consisted exclusively of diploid cells. The proportions of CK-positive diploid cells ranged between 6% and 80%, independent of whether they were achieved from entirely diploid or from aneuploid carcinomas. CK-gated diploid and aneuploid cell populations showed largely identical S-phase fractions. These results emphasize that diploid tumor cells regularly persist after the development of aneuploid clones and significantly contribute to local tumor progression. Despite the presence of diploid epithelial cells in aneuploid primary tumors, exclusively the aneuploid clones of eight corresponding lymph node metastases were CK-positive. This provides further evidence of a largely reduced metastatic potential of diploid tumor cells.     

Tumor spread and DNA content in human renal cell carcinoma

Local and distant tumor spread was evaluated and compared with DNA content analyzed by flow cytometry of eight samples from each of 71 renal cell carcinomas. Twenty-six tumors were homogenously diploid while 45 tumors contained at least one aneuploid tumor sample. Diploid tumors generally respected the surrounding tissues and only three of 26 tumors (12%) had evidence of local tumor invasion. In contrast, 33 of 45 patients (73%) with aneuploid tumors had local invasion (p less than 0.001). Local metastases in lymph nodes and adrenal was found only in patients with aneuploid tumors. However, distant metastases appeared in about the same frequency in patients with diploid and aneuploid tumors (35 and 29%, respectively). Patients with diploid tumors had significantly more often solitary metastases and, most interestingly, the occurrence of lung metastases was a characteristic feature for patients with aneuploid tumors (p less than 0.02). The diploid primary tumors with distant metastases generally were devoid of local invasion while all aneuploid tumors with distant metastases had local invasion and mostly also local metastases. Thus, different characteristics of tumor spread were shown for diploid and aneuploid tumors and the pathways for spread with distant metastases might also differ between these tumors.     

Nuclear DNA Distribution in Neuroendocrine Gastroenteropancreatic Tumors Before and During Treatment

The nuclear DNA contents of tumor cells in 73 patients with endocrine gastrointestinal tumors, 19 patients with endocrine pancreatic tumors (EPT) and 54 patients with malignant carcinoid tumors were determined before and after treatment. The DNA profiles were divided into diploid and aneuploid. In untreated patients, 9 out of 10 (90%) primary EPT and all 9 primary malignant carcinoid tumors (100%) were diploid. Tumor cell imprints from liver metastases of patients with untreated EPT showed aneuploidy in 5 of 11 cases, but only in 7 out of 46 DNA records from patients with untreated carcinoid liver metastases. DNA alteration from diploid to aneuploid profiles occurred in 2 patients with endocrine pancreatic tumors who had received chemotherapy. A change from diploid to aneuploid records was also seen in 7/23 (30%) carcinoid tumors after treatment. The DNA patterns before and after treatment did not show any correlation with survival or treatment response.     

Flow-cytometric analysis of colorectal cancer with hepatic metastases and its relationship to metastatic characteristics and prognosis

Studying the DNA ploidy patterns of 52 primary tumors, diploid tumors accounted for 48.1% and aneuploid tumors for 51.9%. Out of 31 patients with liver metastases, 35.5% had diploid tumors and 64.5%, aneuploid tumors. Heterogeneity (difference in DNA ploidy pattern between the primary lesion and liver metastases) was found in 20% of the patients examined. In 28 of the patients, the liver metastases were unresectable, and their prognoses were such that the 1- and 2-year survival rates from the diploid tumors were 42.9 and 14.3%, respectively, while 1-year survivors from aneuploid tumors died within 2 years. In resected cases of hepatic metastases, the DNA ploidy pattern of the metastatic lesions did not correlate with the metastasis period, extent of spread or number of lesions. The recurrence rate of aneuploid tumors in the residual livers was 50%, which was slightly higher than the rate of 36.4% for diploid tumors. The prognoses in patients with diploid tumors were significantly better than those in patients with aneuploid tumors: 5-year survival was 71.1% in diploid tumor patients, compared with 21% in aneuploid tumor patients.     

DNA index and cell cycle analysis of primary breast cancer and synchronous axillary lymph node metastases

The DNA Index (DI) and the percentage of cells in S-phase (S-phase fraction, SPF) were measured by flow cytometry in 80 primary breast carcinomas and in 80 accompanying axillary lymph node metastases. The DI in primary tumors and metastases agreed in 61 cases (76%). Cases with diploid primary tumors revealed more constancy of the DI in comparison to the metastases than the cases with aneuploid primary tumors (91% and 70% respectively). The mean values of the SPF were in close agreement in the primary tumors and in the lymph node metastases (6.1% and 6.0% respectively). Differences between the SPF of the two groups could be detected only by the consideration of case-related data pairs. In 50 cases (62%), the percentage of SPF agreed approximately in primary tumors and in the correspondent metastases. The cases with diploid primary tumors revealed more agreement of the SPF in the primary site and the metastases than did cases with aneuploid primary tumors (78% and 56% respectively). In conclusion, diploid carcinomas and their metastases revealed more constancy of the DI and the percentage of SPF than aneuploid carcinomas. These findings agree well with a better prognosis of diploid mammary carcinomas, as reported in the literature. Comparisons between the DI and the SPF in primary tumors and the corresponding metastases could be a source of valuable information on the biological behaviour and the aggressiveness of mammary carcinomas.     

Deoxyribonucleic acid content in metastatic renal cell carcinoma: clinical implications

Tumor DNA content was analysed in 26 patients with metastatic renal cell carcinoma. The primary tumors were homogenously diploid in ten patients (38%). In 16 patients (62%) an aneuploid DNA content was found in at least one of eight tumor samples analyzed. Patients with diploid tumors survived significantly longer (P less than 0.001) than patients with aneuploid primary tumors (median 32.5 and 6 months, respectively). The DNA content of the metastases seems to give additional prognostic information. The results indicate that DNA content is a useful prognostic predictor in renal cell carcinoma. Patients with homogenously diploid tumors might be treated aggressively with nephrectomy and excision of apparent metastases, particularly solitary, since these patients seem to have a chance for prolonged survival time. Aneuploidy in metastases, solitary and multiple, indicates that nephrectomy is not meaningful.     

Flow cytometric analysis of primary lung carcinomas and their lymph node metastases

Specimens of primary lung carcinomas and lymph node metastases from the same 18 patients were investigated by means of flow cytometry. The number of DNA stemlines, DNA indices, the proportion of diploid cells in the tumors and the distribution of the cell cycle phases were compared. In 10 patients DNA stemlines and DNA indices were identical in primary tumors and metastases. In two cases the DNA indices were doubled in metastases. In 6 cases the primary tumors contained two abnormal DNA stemlines and their metastases contained only one aneuploid stemline. Gross differences between primary tumors and lymph node metastases with regard to the proportion of cell cycle phases could not be found. The large variation between primary tumors and lymph node metastases with regard to DNA stemlines indicates that flow cytometric analysis of lymph nodes gives only limited information about the primary tumors.     

Flow cytometric analysis of DNA and cell proliferation in ovarian tumors

DNA content in tumor cells from 50 patients with ovarian tumors was analysed by flow cytometry (FCM). Solid tissue samples were processed to obtain monodispersed cells. Staining for DNA analysis was achieved with ethidium bromide and mithramycin. Peripheral blood lymphocytes were used as reference diploid cell population. All benign ovarian tumors exhibited only diploid cells. DNA aneuploid cell lines were found 66.6% of serous carcinomas and in 80% of malignant granulosa cell tumors. The S-phase fraction of DNA diploid cells in benign ovarian tumors (S = 2.4 +/- 1.2%) was smaller than those of malignant tumors (S = 8.2 +/- 5.2%). DNA aneuploid cell populations in serous carcinomas display a higher S-phase fraction (S = 19.2 +/- 9.3%) than DNA diploid cells (S = 11.7 +/- 3.2%). No major differences were obtained between primary ovarian tumors and their metastases, as far as degree of aneuploidy and S-phase fraction are concerned. A high degree of correlation was established between the grade of differentiation of ovarian tumors and the DNA ploidy abnormalities.     

Regional DNA content heterogeneity in colonic adenocarcinoma: prognostic significance in patients with liver metastases.

We retrospectively examined by flow cytometry the DNA ploidy pattern in tissue blocks from 25 primary colon adenocarcinomas and their lymph node and liver metastases. Intratumoral heterogeneity was present in 22% of primary tumors and 21% of metastatic liver deposits. Intertumoral heterogeneity, measured between the primary tumor and its lymph node and liver metastases, was 0% and 20%, respectively. Of 24 patients who underwent successful resection of their liver metastases, 8 neoplasms had uniformly diploid DNA content, while 16 tumors had aneuploid DNA pattern in either the primary tumor, the metastases, or both. Five-year survival was better in the diploid group (38% vs. 7%, P = 0.10 by log rank analysis). Three of eight patients in the diploid group remain free of disease, while all 16 patients with aneuploid cell populations have died of recurrent disease.     

Flow cytometric DNA analysis of poorly differentiated adenocarcinoma of the colorectum.

DNA ploidy patterns in 11 poorly differentiated adenocarcinomas of the colorectum were examined by flow cytometry using paraffin-embedded specimens. Measurements of DNA content were made of the superficial (Sup) half and deeper (Deep) half of the primary tumors in all cases, and of lymph node metastases in five cases. All the primary tumors showed invasion beyond the muscularis propria of the colorectum. Aneuploidy or polyploidy in either Sup or Deep of the primary tumor was found in six of the 11 (54.5%) tumors. Out of the six aneuploid tumors, five were in Dukes' stage C with distant metastases at the time of operation, and four died within one year of surgery. Conversely, out of five diploid tumors, none had distant metastases at the time of operation and two survived for longer than three years after surgery. The DNA ploidy pattern of Deep differed from that of Sup in four out of six aneuploid tumors, and two showed aneuploidy in Sup and diploidy in Deep. All the lymph node metastases in the five tumors had a diploid pattern, although three had aneuploid patterns in the primary tumors. The findings suggest the DNA ploidy pattern of a primary tumor to be correlated with the degree of metastasis at the time of operation or prognosis, but the population of tumor cells having different DNA contents may be apt to change between Sup and Deep in aneuploid tumor.     

Nuclear dna Measurements on Thyroid Carcinoma in Young Patients

Nuclear DNA measurements were performed on thyroid carcinomas from 36 patients aged 20 years or less. Histologic material from the tumors were stained according to the Feulgen technique and measured with slide cytophotometry. Thirty-two of the 36 tumors were of papillary type, 3 were medullary carcinoma and 1 was a follicular carcinoma. of the 32 papillary carcinomas, 6 tumors (19%) were aneuploid and 26 (81 %) were diploid, including 2 cases with lung metastases at diagnosis. of the 3 medullary carcinomas, 2 were diploid and 1 aneuploid. the only follicular carcinoma was aneuploid. the patients were followed between 10 and 35 years, and 34 were alive at the end of the study. Two patients died, both had medullary carcinomas. One patient, with a diploid tumor, died during surgery. the other patient, with an aneuploid tumor, died 5 years after diagnosis of metastatic disease. Six patients had recurrences, all within 7 years. All the primary tumors and the corresponding recurrences showed a diploid DNA content. the results show that the majority of thyroid carcinomas in young patients exhibit diploid DNA profiles which is in agreement with the overall good prognosis in this patient category. However, since also patients with aneuploid tumors exhibited a similar good prognosis it seems that DNA measurements do not contribute additional prognostic information in young patients.     

Relationship between DNA ploidy, glandular differentiation, and tumor spread in human prostate cancer

DNA ploidy was evaluated by flow cytometry for 45 human prostate carcinomas (34 prostatectomy specimens and 11 biopsies). Twenty tumors (44.4%) contained a distinct aneuploid stem line. All 11 tumors confined to the prostate gland (pathological Stage B) were diploid. The frequency of aneuploidy increased with advancing stage, and most tumors with distant metastases were aneuploid. The degree of glandular differentiation was characterized by the Gleason score. One-third of tumors with a Gleason score of 5 to 6 were aneuploid, whereas over 70% of poorly differentiated tumors with a Gleason score of 9 to 10 were aneuploid. Among diploid tumors, 45.5% were localized carcinomas (Stage B), 36.4% were characterized by invasion outside the prostate (Stage C), and 18.2% formed pelvic nodal or distant metastases (Stages D1 and D2). In nearly two-thirds of patients with aneuploid tumors, pelvic nodal or distant metastases were found. When tumors were classified according to both DNA ploidy and degree of glandular differentiation, then subgroups of tumors with the highest and lowest degree of malignant potential became apparent. Only 7.1% of diploid tumors with a Gleason score of 5 to 6 formed metastases, but 80% of aneuploid tumors with a higher Gleason score (7 to 10) formed metastases. Diploid tumors with higher Gleason scores and aneuploid tumors with lower Gleason scores had intermediate frequencies of metastases. The presence of an aneuploid stem line in prostate carcinomas indicated that the tumor had spread outside the prostate gland or had metastasized. DNA ploidy may be an important prognostic factor for human prostate cancer. DNA ploidy and the degree of glandular differentiation considered together may improve prognostic evaluation of prostate carcinomas.     

Benign metastasizing giant cell tumors of bone. A DNA flow cytometric study

Approximately 2% of histologically benign giant cell tumors (BGCT) of bone are complicated by lung metastases, which can progress despite their benign histologic appearance. Almost all BGCT studied by DNA flow cytometry (FCM) have been reported to be diploid. However, the very few cases with lung metastases previously analyzed were all aneuploid. To assess the usefulness of DNA FCM in predicting the metastatic potential of BGCT, seven metastasizing BGCT were studied by DNA FCM using paraffin-embedded tissue. Five were purely diploid, one was tetraploid, and one was aneuploid. The primary and the metastasis showed the same DNA distribution in all but the tetraploid case, in which the metastasis was purely diploid. A single patient, who was in the diploid group, had unresectable tumor in the lungs; she remains alive with stable disease at 30 months. The other six patients, who underwent complete resections of their lung metastases, are free of disease. These results suggest that DNA FCM is not a sensitive method for predicting the metastatic potential of BGCT since most metastasizing cases appear to be diploid.     

Nuclear DNA profiles in primary melanomas and their metastases

DNA-aneuploid primary melanomas are said to show a greater propensity to metastasize than those without an aneuploid profile. A higher aneuploid rate has also been reported in metastatic melanomas than in primary lesions. The ploidy profile was determined of 26 primary melanomas and their first subsequent secondaries on Feulgen-stained sections from routinely processed material using a computerized video image-analysis system. In 18 of 26 cases, both primary and secondary tumor showed similar corresponding DNA patterns. These were aneuploid in 13 of 18 of the cases. A hyperdiploid pattern was present in one case in both the primary and its metastasis, and a diploid pattern was seen in four cases. There were only eight cases in which a disparity between the nuclear ploidy profile in the primary and secondary tumor was evident. Although the results suggest that ploidy studies are not useful for predicting the metastatic potential of a primary melanoma, the maintenance of similar DNA profiles in the metastases in most of these cases was interesting in regard to tumor biology.     

The prognostic significance of tumor ploidy and pathology in adenocarcinoma of the esophagogastric junction

Tumor DNA content has been advocated to be an important prognostic indicator in human malignancies. Paraffin-embedded specimens of 75 resected adenocarcinomas (AC) of the esophagogastric junction were studied by flow cytometric DNA analysis to determine whether tumor ploidy was a significant prognostic variable independent of stage and histologic grade of the tumor. Eighty-one percent of the tumors were aneuploid. More patients with aneuploid tumors had lymph node metastases than patients with diploid tumors (P = 0.007). Patients with aneuploid tumors had poorer 18-month disease-free and overall survival than patients with diploid tumors. Cox regression analysis demonstrated that the most important prognostic variables for predicting overall survival were lymph node status, depth of wall invasion, and tumor differentiation. Tumor ploidy was not an independent prognostic variable in predicting recurrent disease or death from AC of the esophagogastric junction. Tumor DNA content is valuable, however, as a marker for patients at increased risk of lymph node metastases, early recurrence, and poorer survival.     

Prognostic value of ploidy of primary tumour and nodal secondaries in colorectal cancers

Tumour ploidy is of prognostic value in colorectal cancer, DNA aneuploid tumours having a worse outlook. Nearly all studies have concentrated on the DNA content of the primary tumour. We have examined the ploidy of the primary tumour and its lymph node metastases in 71 cases of Dukes' stage C disease, to see whether this provides greater prognostic information than the primary alone. Analysis was performed using formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tumour sections. Ploidy of primary and metastases was different in 20 cases (28%), aneuploid nodes being seen with diploid primaries and vice versa. Ploidy of both the primary (χ² = 4.86, P = 0.03) and secondary (χ² = 4.86, P = 0.03) tumours predicted survival in univariate analysis. Combining the ploidy of primary and nodes, three prognostic groups could be defined — diploid primaries with diploid metastases (hazard relative to both aneuploid, 0.36) had significantly better survival than cases where the ploidy of the primary and nodes were mixed (relative hazard 0.47–0.56), which did better than cases with aneuploid primary and nodes. This study demonstrates that ploidy variation between primary and secondary tumours is common, and better prognostic information may be gained by studying both.     

Response of DNA ploidy to chemotherapy in primary and metastatic lesions in human osteosarcomas.

Primary and pulmonary metastatic and pulmonary metastatic tumors (two synchronous and seven metachronous metastases) in nine patients with osteosarcomas were studied by DNA cytofluorometry. All patients were treated with both pre and postoperative chemotherapy. The results showed that all five diploid osteosarcomas and three of the four aneuploid tumors did not markedly change their ploidy pattern after preoperative chemotherapy, and had almost the same ploidy patterns as the pulmonary metastatic lesions. Those eight tumors showed poor histologic response and chemoresistance by the doxorubicin binding assay. Only one aneuploid osteosarcoma showing good histologic response and chemosensitivity changed its ploidy pattern to diploid, with the disappearance of aneuploid tumor cells and its synchronous pulmonary metastatic tumor also showed conversion to a diploid pattern with massive tumor necrosis. It is evident that those tumors showing no change in their ploidy pattern after chemotherapy were resistant to the chemotherapy. Therefore, we conclude that regardless of whether the pulmonary metastatic tumors were synchronous or metachronous, they showed the same change in their ploidy pattern as well as their chemosensitivity as the primary human osteosarcoma from which they were derived.     

Comparison of DNA aneuploidy of primary and metastatic spontaneous canine osteosarcomas

Spontaneous canine osteosarcomas were analyzed for DNA aneuploidy and percentage of S phase cells using flow cytometry. Forty-eight dogs were studied in which both a primary tumor and subsequent metastases were available. The DNA index distributions for the primary tumors and the metastases were quite similar. However, when individual primary tumors and metastases derived from them were compared, many of the cases had different ploidy values. The tumor cells were also analyzed for percentage of S phase. The diploid metastases had less than 17% S phase cells, whereas the aneuploid metastases had up to 40% S phase cells. There was a direct correlation between the DNA index and the percentage of S phase in the metastases.     

Prognostic significance of the DNA content of renal carcinoma

DNA analysis was performed on fresh frozen samples of the primary tumor in 32 patients with renal carcinoma (13 with apparently localized disease and 19 with metastases at presentation). A comparison of ploidy with staging and standard histologic variables was performed. None of the patients who presented without metastases died of disease during the follow-up period. Eleven of 13 patients of this group had a diploid/near diploid pattern, and metastases developed in only one patient. Patients with metastatic disease and a diploid/near diploid DNA content had a significantly better survival rate than those with aneuploid primary tumors. Statistical analysis showed that grade and ploidy contributed significant but independent prognostic information. We concluded that DNA content is a useful prognostic factor in renal carcinoma.