Signal-to-noise ratio fundamental limitations in the discrete-time domain

Fundamental limitations in feedback control are a well established area of research. In recent years it has been extended to the study of limitations imposed by the consideration of a communication channel in the control loop. Previous results characterised these limitations in terms of a minimal data transmission rate necessary for stabilisation. In this paper a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) approach is used to obtain a tight condition for the linear time invariant output feedback stabilisation of a discrete-time, single-input-single-output (SISO) unstable, non-minimum phase (NMP) plant with arbitrary relative degree over an additive Gaussian coloured noise (ACGN) communication channel with memory. The obtained result gives a guideline in estimating the severity of the fundamental SNR limitation imposed by the plant unstable poles, NMP zeros and relative degree as well as the channel NMP zeros, bandwidth, and noise colouring. We then characterise the output feedback sensitivity function for the infimal SNR solution and follow up by quantifying the extra SNR imposed by suboptimal solutions (for example due to plant modelling errors).     

Fundamental limitations in control over a communication channel

Fundamental limitations in feedback control is a well established area of research. In recent years it has been extended to the study of limitations imposed by the consideration of a communication channel in the control loop. Previous results characterised these limitations in terms of a minimal data transmission rate necessary for stabilisation. In this paper a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) approach is used to obtain a tight condition for the linear time invariant output feedback stabilisation of a continuous-time, unstable, non minimum phase (NMP) plant with time-delay over an additive Gaussian coloured noise communication channel. By working on a linear setting the infimal SNR for stabilisability is defined as the infimal achievable H₂ norm between the channel noise input and the channel signal input. The result gives a guideline in estimating the severity of the fundamental SNR limitation imposed by the plant unstable poles, NMP zeros, time-delay as well as the channel NMP zeros, bandwidth, and channel noise colouring.     

Feedback Stabilization Over Signal-to-Noise Ratio Constrained Channels

There has recently been significant interest in feedback stabilization problems with communication constraints including constraints on the available data rate. Signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) constraints are one way in which data-rate limits arise, and are the focus of this paper. In both continuous and discrete-time settings, we show that there are limitations on the ability to stabilize an unstable plant over a SNR constrained channel using finite-dimensional linear time invariant (LTI) feedback. In the case of state feedback, or output feedback with a delay-free, minimum phase plant, these limitations in fact match precisely those that might have been inferred by considering the associated ideal Shannon capacity data rate over the same channel. In the case of LTI output feedback, additional limitations are shown to apply if the plant is nonminimum phase. In this case, we show that for a continuous-time nonminimum phase plant, a periodic linear time varying feedback scheme with fast sampling may be used to recover the original SNR requirement at the cost of robustness properties. The proposed framework inherently captures channel noise effects in a simple formulation suited to conventional LTI control performance and robustness analysis, and has potential to handle time delays and bandwidth constraints in a variety of control over communication links problems.     

Discrete-time compensators with loop transfer recovery

Loop transfer recovery (LTR) has gained some prominence over the last years. In this paper, the authors briefly overview the main design features of the LQG/LTR controller both at the input and at the output of the plant, using the delta operator formulation developed in Middleton and Goodwin (1990). Two discrete-time compensators with LTR capability are then derived following the LTR design approach proposed in Chen, Saberi, and Sannuti (1991) for the continuous-time case. These compensators are shown to outperform their underlying LQG/LTR controllers from the perspective of recovery error. Of particular importance, they share the same degree of recovery as the continuous time compensators of the above papers when the sampling period goes to zero     

Unconstrained and constrained motion control of a planar two-link structurally flexible robotic manipulator

Unconstrained and constrained motion control of a planar two-link structurally-flexible robotic manipulator are considered in this study. The dynamic model is obtained by using the extended Hamilton's principle and the Galerkin criterion. A method is presented to obtain the linearized equations of motion in Cartesian space for use in designing the control system. The approach to solving the control problem is to use feedforward and feedback control torques. The feedforward torques maneuver the flexible manipulator along a nominal trajectory and the feedback torques minimize any deviations from the nominal trajectory. The feedforward and feedback torques are obtained by solving the inverse dynamics problem for the rigid manipulator and designing linear quadratic Gaussian with loop transfer recovery (LQG/LTR) compensators, respectively. The LQG/LTR design methodology is exploited to design a robust feedback control system that can handle modeling errors and sensor noise, and operate on Cartesian space trajectory errors. Computer simulated results are presented for an example planar, two-link, structurally flexible robotic manipulator. © 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Loop recovery via ℋ︁∞-modified complementary sensitivity recovery for non-minimum phase plants

In order to recovery robust stability of a desirable state feedback system by output feedback, the desirable complementary function is approximated by a modified complementary function of the output feedback system by solving an ??^∞ norm-minimization problem. The modified complementary function is obtained by getting rid of non-minimum phase factors from the complementary function. Numerical examples show the superiority of this method to LQG/LTR method and other methods.     

Robust stabilization of linear multivariable systems: relations to approximation

A simple feedback controller methodology is presented that allows for exact tracking of the sinusoidal input signals and rejection of the sinusoidal disturbances in a closed loop control system. The control method is motivated by a mathematical inequality that expresses the tracking and disturbance rejection requirements for a closed loop system. The exact tracking of the input command at a particular frequency requires an infinite loop gain for the system at the frequency of the in put command. A second order undamped transfer function is cascaded to each input channel to increase the loop transfer function gain at the frequency of the input command. A feedback controller is then designed via the LQG/LTR method to stabilize the system while the loop gain remains large at the frequency of the input. The method is experimentally verified on a single axis servo system and extended to multivariable systems.     

LQG-like control of scalar systems over communication channels: The role of data losses,delays and SNR limitations

In this work we address the problem of feedback control design for scalar systems in the presence of a non-ideal communication channel, which gives rise to tightly coupled limitations in terms of quantization errors, decoding/computational delays and packet loss affecting the closed loop control performance. We restrict our analysis to the context of LQG-like control, where the estimator and controller gains are forced to be constant, subject to SNR limitations, packet loss, and constant delay, and we derive their impact on the optimal design of the controller parameters. In particular, we show that the stability of the closed loop system depends on a tradeoff among SNR, packet loss probability and delay. Through this analysis we are also able to recover, as special cases, several results already available in the literature that have treated packet loss, quantization error and delay separately. We also show that the estimator and controller cannot be designed independently even if the controller has full knowledge of the packet loss sequence and the control inputs to the plant. In fact the optimal control gain, when accounting for the communication constraints is, in general, different from the optimal gain derived under the classical LQG scenario, which is recaptured when the SNR over the channel goes to infinity.     

Performance limitations for single-input LTI plants controlled over SNR constrained channels with feedback

This paper studies control problems for discrete-time single-input linear time-invariant plants when controlled over a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) constrained channel. Our focus is on the performance limitations in an architecture that uses channel feedback. We explicitly characterize the interplay between stabilization, optimal performance, and SNR constraints, highlighting the way in which plant dynamical features affect the best achievable performance. We also apply our results to the study of networked control systems where communication takes place over a power constrained erasure channel. In that scenario, we first show that stabilization problems, and problems involving stationary second-order moments, can be dealt with by focusing on a related SNR constrained networked situation. This observation allows one to obtain results valid in the alternative scenario as corollaries of the results obtained when a single SNR constraint is present.     

侧向飞行控制律设计与仿真

线性二次型高斯/回路传递恢复方法(LQG/LTR)足一种多变量频域鲁棒设计方法,以良好的鲁棒性和解耦特性得到了广泛的应用.阐述了 LQG/LTR方法的基本原理,给出了方法的设汁步骤.针对某型飞机侧向通道的多输入多输出系统,运用LQG/LTR方法对其进行飞行控制律设计与仿真研究,提出在目标反馈回路设计中要注意的回题.最后将仿真结果与传统方法进行比较,结果表明LQG/LTR方法适用于飞机复杂的多变量控制系统,设计的控制系统具有良好的动态品质和鲁棒性.     

Aeroservoelastic model based active control for large civil aircraft

A modeling and control approach for an advanced configured large civil aircraft with aeroservoelasticity via the LQG method and control allocation is presented.Mathematical models and implementation issues for the multi-input/multi-output(MIMO) aeroservoelastic system simulation developed for a flexible wing with multi control surfaces are described.A fuzzy logic based optimization approach is employed to solve the constrained control allocation problem via intelligently adjusting the components of output v...     

Structural Properties,LQG Control and Scheduling of a Networked Control System with Bandwidth Limitations and Transmission Delays

The problem of simultaneous LQG control and scheduling of a Networked Control System (NCS) with constant network induced delays at input and output and bandwidth limitations is investigated. Delays are considered at plant as well as controller side. Sufficient conditions for controllability, stabilizability, reconstructibility and detectability of the underlying networked control system are drawn. The proposed conditions extend previous works on structural properties of NCS by capturing both plant and controller side delays together with bandwidth limitations. A framework for computing the optimal LQG controller for the NCS with a fixed scheduling is provided. The proposed modeling approach facilitates use of LQG as well as other control methods for NCSs with delays and bandwidth limitations. In order to optimize performance, a semi-online scheduling procedure is proposed based on an offline look up table. The look up table assigns an optimal schedule with associated optimal LQG controller to initial conditions. The proposed scheme improves previous results by online deployment of schedule and LQG control with stability guarantees and very low computational overhead. A simulation example with communication delays, packet losses and bandwidth limitations in both sensor and actuator sides is included. Static optimal periodic communication sequence, Optimal Pointer Placement (OPP) approach proposed in previous works, a random access scheduling method representing contention based access policies and the proposed method are simulated and compared.      

Cooperative robust output regulation problem for discrete‐time linear time‐delay multi‐agent systems

In this paper, we study the cooperative robust output regulation problem for discrete‐time linear multi‐agent systems with both communication and input delays by a distributed internal model approach. We first introduce the distributed internal model for discrete‐time multi‐agent systems with both communication and input delays. Then, we define the so‐called auxiliary system and auxiliary augmented system. Finally, we solve our problem by showing, under some standard assumptions, that if a distributed state feedback control or a distributed output feedback control solves the robust output regulation problem of the auxiliary system, then the same control law solves the cooperative robust output regulation problem of the original multi‐agent systems.     

Robust quantization for digital finite communication bandwidth (DFCB) control

The problem of digital finite communication bandwidth (DFCB) control has come to the attention of the research community in connection with a growing interest in the development of distributed and/or networked control systems. In these systems, actuators, sensors, and other components are connected via data-rate constrained links such as wireless radio, etc. In this paper, we consider a scalar model of DFCB control that accommodates time-varying data-rate constraints, such as might occur with intermittent network congestion, and asynchronism of sampling and control actuation. Because of the possibly unpredictable fluctuation of the data-rate, we are interested in feedback control designs that will tolerate significantly constrained data-rates on feedback loops, while providing acceptable performance when such data-rate constraints are not in force. In light of a very basic notion of acceptable performance, we show that control designs with different number of quantization levels tolerate constrained data-rates differently. This leads to the conclusion that binary control represents the most robust control quantization under data-rate constraints imposed by time-varying congestion on the feedback communication channel. The advantage margin of binary control is further investigated numerically with and without the sampling-control asynchronism being considered. We show that the advantage margin is more substantial when the sampling-control asynchronism is significant. A design of quantized (binary) feedback with side channel information is proposed, and stability properties are discussed. We conclude the paper by examining performance limitations of our binary coding in the presence of noise.     

基于混沌粒子群优化的约束状态反馈预测控制算法

提出一种基于混沌粒子群优化的约束状态反馈预测控制算法,用于解决带有输入约束和状态约束的控制问题.将混沌粒子群优化引入到约束状态反馈预测控制的滚动优化过程中,增强了算法在约束范围内的局部搜索和全局搜索能力.通过对一个实际的带有约束的线性离散系统控制优化问题的解决,验证了基于混沌粒子群优化的状态反馈预测控制算法的可行性和有效性,与传统的二次规划算法的比较结果说明了此算法的优越性,证明了状态反馈预测控制系统良好的鲁棒性.     

Coherent quantum LQG control

Based on a recently developed notion of physical realizability for quantum linear stochastic systems, we formulate a quantum LQG optimal control problem for quantum linear stochastic systems where the controller itself may also be a quantum system and the plant output signal can be fully quantum. Such a control scheme is often referred to in the quantum control literature as “coherent feedback control”. It distinguishes the present work from previous works on the quantum LQG problem where measurement is performed on the plant and the measurement signals are used as the input to a fully classical controller with no quantum degrees of freedom. The difference in our formulation is the presence of additional non-linear and linear constraints on the coefficients of the sought after controller, rendering the problem as a type of constrained controller design problem. Due to the presence of these constraints, our problem is inherently computationally hard and this also distinguishes it in an important way from the standard LQG problem. We propose a numerical procedure for solving this problem based on an alternating projections algorithm and, as an initial demonstration of the feasibility of this approach, we provide fully quantum controller design examples in which numerical solutions to the problem were successfully obtained. For comparison, we also consider the case of classical linear controllers that use direct or indirect measurements, and show that there exists a fully quantum linear controller which offers an improvement in performance over the classical ones.     

Discrete-time loop transfer recovery via generalized sampled-data hold functions based compensator

Loop transfer recovery (LTR) techniques are known to enhance the input or output robustness properties of linear quadratic gaussian (LQG) designs. One restriction of the existing discrete-time LQG/LTR methods is that they can obtain arbitrarily good recovery only for minimum-phase plants. A number of researchers have attempted to devise new techniques to cope with non-minimum-phase plants and have achieved some degrees of success.^6-9 Nevertheless, their methods only work for a restricted class of non-minimum-phase systems. Here, we explore the zero placement capability of generalized sampled-data hold functions (GSHF) developed in Reference 14 and show that using the arbitrary zero placement capability of GSHF, the discretized plant can always be made minimum-phase. As a consequence, we are able to achieve discrete-time perfect recovery using a GSHF-based compensator irrespective of whether the underlying continuous-time plant is minimum-phase or not.     

Two-delay robust digital control and its applications-avoiding theproblem on unstable limiting zeros

In the design of linear control systems, the existence of unstable zeros makes it difficult to construct many control systems. When the usual digital control scheme is used, unstable zeros appear in the discrete-time model due to the existence of limiting zeros even though the continuous-time plant is minimal phase. To avoid this unstable zero problem, two new digital control schemes, called two-delay output control and two-delay input control, are proposed. These control systems are proved to have no finite zeros. Asymptotic inverse systems, pole assignable unknown input observers, and output feedback controllers having the LTR (loop transfer recovery) property are developed using the two-delay output control. Zero assignable control systems and model matching control systems are developed using the two-delay input control     

Robust output‐based controller design for enlarging the region of attraction of input saturated linear systems

The aim of this study was to design a constrained robust output feedback control strategy for stabilizing linear systems affected by uncertainties and output perturbations. The input is constrained by a saturation function. A classical Luenberger observer reconstructed the states from output observations. The state feedback control employed the estimated states given by the observer. This work proposed a Barrier Lyapunov Function (BLF) to manage the saturation problem in the control input. Moreover, an extended version of the attractive ellipsoid method (AEM) characterized the zone of convergence due the presence of perturbations in the output. A convex optimization procedure, formulated as a set of matrix inequalities, yielded the control parameters and the region of attraction for the close‐loop system as well as a minimal ultimately bounded set for the system trajectories. Numerical simulations supported the theoretical results formulated in this study.     

Force control of a two-linke planar manipulator with one flexible link

Force control of a two-link planar manipulator with one flexible link is considered in this study. The equations of motion are derived using the extended Hamilton's principle with only structural flexibility effects included in the dynamic model. The linear quadratic Gaussian/loop transfer recovery (LQG/LTR) design methodology is exploited to design a robust feedback control system that can handle modelling errors and sensor noise, and operate on Cartesian space trajectory errors. The LQG/LTR compensator together with a feedforward loop is used to simultaneously control the force exerted by the flexible manipulator normal to the environment and the position of the end-point in a direction tangent to the environment. Simulated results are presented for a numerical example.